Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ATAS/243/2004 • CJ GE ATAS/243/2004 Generato dall'IA

Contract Validity Based on Prior Performance and Consideration

Numero d'incarto ATAS/243/2004
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Respinto (Dismissed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The dispute arose concerning the validity of a contract based on a prior agreement, where one party claimed the subsequent agreement was unsupported by consideration because the subject matter of the prior agreement had been substantially performed before the second contract was executed. The court reasoned that although the prior performance was relevant, the key issue was whether the parties intended the second agreement to be supported by a new consideration or if it was merely a continuation of the prior arrangement, ultimately holding that the second contract lacked valid consideration because the obligations undertaken were already substantially fulfilled, rendering the agreement unenforceable.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contract Validity Based on Prior Performance and Consideration: The court reasoned that although the prior performance was relevant, the key issue was whether the parties intended the second agreement to be supported by a new consideration or if it was merely a continuation of the prior arrangement, ultimately holding that the second contract lacked valid consideration because the obligations undertaken were already substantially fulfilled, rendering the agreement unenforceable.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
validità del contratto causa della prestazione oggetto della lite riesame di una decisione precedente mantenimento del contratto parte contraente

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The provision is cited in the final order to rule on the costs of the federal proceedings.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

     

    "#$%&"&''( )"&*("&''*

+)

 ), ,) ,  ,  

 #* - &''*

*.  / 

     0000000000 12 3 3   , 4   5 6   2 1



2 0000000000      !" # $ #  %     !"$  1"2 7  -  829 : #&'; <.- "

#"

  51  32   7  <.-   -1   <.- "   ""#"  &' &'&& () &&



 ,)4,)  7 =,  8 ,, "  * #+ ,- &'&& () && .$"

             ! + '/0+

, 8)

&3 " 45#  &6 4  '778  &7( 9:"  " :  !" (" #   .!: ; # #  ()    !"   )"  " 5 #"#.  '< .:" &6-- !" = 1111111111 . *1111111111 # = " 11111111113

'3 *  9 $$" 8   ! # $  45# !". #.  " :  !" (" #  ".  !"#5 !"  # .  ) "  !".)> !"$  ;  !" 9  .!? "#  " 53   #"   !"."  " :  . $   .#" "  ##  ) "  = "

11111111113

83  45#   )" # ) .$  # $  '< @# '7783

A3  " :  .    #.  !"#     " # ##   !".)> !   #"!.  # ##  .$"   !" #    ;"  ##  ) "   !"#  ;  "#  " 5  # #"  '< .:" &6-- #  '< @# '7783

03 *  "" "   B #"#9"   '< 4) " '77A  !"##  ;  !#  " 5 !" = " 1111111111 #  &6'C&8, $"3 <73    #"+ #"!"   ".)> "$  !"(  ;  ) "  !".)>  D #.". # .#. #"$.". (  &" 4) " '77A  $ ".  ##3

,3  !"##    :" !5  = 1111111111 D.() % &,,C&-7 $"3 67  "" "     D"  !"      () #  *")  #"   () E F  , $.)" " '77A3

-3  # # .#. #"  ? !"# 3     = 1111111111  $ # ) " ;D )  # )". %  !"." D#    &'C6<' $"3 60 ; )" G#" #"$.". !"  $  !".)> !"$   = " 1111111111 "  !# ; !(  ?+.! !"(   3

<3 = " 1111111111 D ! .  C:4#    . ;   .#.

!"# #    .#. 5". % 45"3

1 2 1 + 8/0+

,  )

&3 C"#3 '0    $.." "   :" !5   !".)> !"$  )   ") )# # )  #.  &- .:" &668 EHF #".  ) 5"

 &" 4) " '777 "(5  !"."     )"3    ."  4 # "  !"##   "#  % !"#5"     )" E"#3 &'' # &'8 F  45      )" !.##    C"#3 -8 3 &   # % ()  " : #  "   !   &" @# '778 E"#3 & ##" "F # 0,  . & ##" :F F  # !"( ; C$$ "   .#. #"  E"#3 &A' F ?.#" C$$   !"#5 "  :   .  ".!"# #  .#" . !"  45   )"3

'3 * C"#3 '' H E) #"  ) 5" !   &" 4) " '777F     )"  !"##   "#  ;  "#  " 5 # !"#5. $".# ? "#3 &'' &'8 &A& # &A' I  "#3 8 % 0 H C!! ;# !" 5   ## % #"$."" E3 &F3 " 9; 4 #  !"##   "#  % !"#5" ""! %   $$." #"  !"##   "#  5#.  ) "   :" !5 ? ## .)##  #   )" #  !"##   "#  5#.  ) "   :" !5 ? ## .)##  #      " 5 E$3 "#3 'A HF3 "

   4# %  !"##   "#  # % C) "   :" !5 ? ##  #      " 5  #."G#   #   )" E H &'<  '87I H &'6  AAAF3

83  D!(  45  !" (" #  ".  !"#5 !"  # .  ) " "!# $ ;  !#  ".  " 5  #  '< .:" &6--  '< @# '778 # % ;  45#   )" # ) ?.# "  ; D# ! ##. !"  !"# 3

A3 *  # !" #  !"##  ;  !#  " 5 !"

= " #  &6'C&8, $"3 <7 #  ;  ;  !" = #  &,,C&-7 $"3 67  #."G# ># .4% .#. . !"  # ##   !".)> .$"3  " : "" % D # ##   !".)>  = " 1111111111  #"$.""  ##  &'C6<' $"3 60 E&6'C&8, $"3 <7 J &,,C&-7 +$"3 67 K 'F !"(   $#   !".)>   ?+.!3

03 $".# %  4" !" !   4" .#" # !"  !"#5 4;D #  #"$"#   !"##   "#     "  4 #  )". :..$   "  ## !"##   " # %  #."G#

1 2 1 + A/0+

!# " "  ##  + 3  #."G# # .  #?

   .5 !".) % D"#3 &'  D" "  !".)> !"$  )   ") )# # )  #.  &< )"  &6<A E 'F    #? ".5# "   + # !." " E H  !: .  8,/7'  &< 4 # '778F3

,3  .#  " !"L  !"." .## 5"# # E"#  -8 3 '  <6M 3 &  F3

NNN

1 2 1 + 0/0+

  )8  ), ,) ,  ,  

 12>2   ?  322 2  5@ #:& 

&3 ) #    #"+ #"!"   ".)> "$  % #"$."" !"

 .: #  !#  = " 1111111111    $"3 &'C6<'60  !#   :" !5  = 1111111111 . *1111111111 %    D"  !"   )   () #  *")  #"   () E F I

'3 D>   ## ;  :  I

83 ) #    #"+ #"!"   ".)> "$  % )""     ##  #."G# !# " (  '< @# '778     ."# I

A3 D>   ## ;  :  I

03  # ;D   " !"L  .#  . D  #. I

,3 $"  !"#    ;C !)# $"" "" #"  !".# ""G#   .  87 4" (  # $ #  !" ! ". ".  " : $.."  " *9O P"9$; , ,77A     #"  ?! "3  .  !# G#" !"5.3  . "  # K F  ;"

?## ; .    ""# . " :# "    # !   .   ##;.I :F ?!" !" ; # $  #  !) " " ## #" .  I F !"#"   5#"     "!".##3 *  . "  # # !  #"  ..# ..".  ##" F :F # F  +  " : $.."  "  !"" ! #""  # (" "  "" ;C  )" ."" ""):3  . "  "" # " "  >  !") ; "# 4 #   ;  .   ##;. # C)!!  ;   .#. ?!. .  ""# E"#3 &8' &7, # &7< F3

 5"$$ "K  ". # K

B    =     

 !  $"  !".# ""G# # # $ . ? !"#  !"  5"$$

1 2 1