Expert Testimony and Punitive Damages for Fraudulent Inducement and Breach of Contract
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAA dispute arose concerning an appeal where the appellant challenged the trial court's admission of expert testimony and the sufficiency of the evidence for punitive damages related to fraudulent inducement and breach of contract. The court reasoned that the expert testimony was properly admitted because the expert was qualified and the testimony assisted the trier of fact, and furthermore, the evidence presented, including internal documents and testimony about misrepresentations made during contract negotiations, was sufficient for a reasonable jury to find the elements of fraudulent inducement and breach, thereby supporting the award of punitive damages.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Expert Testimony and Punitive Damages for Fraudulent Inducement and Breach of Contract: The court reasoned that the expert testimony was properly admitted because the expert was qualified and the testimony assisted the trier of fact, and furthermore, the evidence presented, including internal documents and testimony about misrepresentations made during contract negotiations, was sufficient for a reasonable jury to find the elements of fraudulent inducement and breach, thereby supporting the award of punitive damages.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive regarding the costs of the federal appeal.
Cited in the dispositive regarding the granting of legal aid.
Testo completo
!" #
$ #%$ & & $ #&
' ( )
*)+
! "#$ %! # #&' ( ' $' " "# ) '" " *' + , -- ,
'
. / ,, ,! 0# " # 11! '#$ &' 2234! 1556 , ! #&' ( $' " "# )$'" " *' 7 " , /. 8
7 691:7
,#
1< 3 "$#= 6555! ! $ ' 70% &>' ? )0@' , .,! '' " %A" &B B $'' "$&$ " &>'< '' ( CA! ) & ( B &B 0'' &' " %A" '! B) '' ? (!
&' "' 0'$ (##' &B< '@' ' " " ? )$& "'! # '$ ? '( D&C $ E7&C F & G 6 '
14 &< 3H<
6< ") '#$%' 'C " "& 65 %$( 6551! '$ 61 %$( 6551 ! &$' #$" A$$! B ''$ I"C# #&'' " A" &' "'< #$" %' &$" #J# K ? $0A&0 " # B #'$ &' &' 'C $ " %= " A" &' ( " &' L' $ ? 0$#'# ' $'' &' " %= # #' " '' &'< &' " & B " #' ' '''$ &'$ " '( " 155M "C 66 %$( 6551 # &==#' KB) 15 # 6551 D&C . / E7&C F & G 1! 4 ' ;H<
4< 6N %$( 6551! )#&O $ )"' " 3 "$#= 6555 ?
. / ,, , D7&C F . /H D 6H<
;< '! &A$ ? & & )&'$ " '( KB) 15 # 6551 < " $'' $AC#' &$'!
# )#&J0' & )'('$ &% D 3 ' :! 14 &< 3H<
3< 1P "$#= 6556! (' 0A '(! )$ ' )& ") 0 '' AA(' " " $ ? #&' %' " )$& ' ? )&&' ") I"C# " # "' ( O< '$ 0@&'L " $# ? 077 "' #$" ' '''$ ( &'$ " '( ? 155M D 16Q P ' 14 &< 3H<
:< &&' " : %$( 6554! ! 0A " ##= &$ ' " #! ''$ A " 0" %'#' &'% ( A"#' =" " # "'< "A'B$ ( ( ' $(' O"# '$B $ D 14H<
2< 1: ( 6554! " " &' " 0A! " %" " L'$#'$ ( #&' &' " ##= &$ "'! )$ '$ ! &$' 0A (! B ''$ # "' %" ' ($ B " #I( " 0" ' ") "
9653;9655;
7 491:7
&'( " %R ='$< "B$ B &'' &A' " "O'0$ "' "' " '' =' ' B "A&0 (' #'$ )= " @' ( " #%#' $("'< "A'B$ O"# " "$%$ '07=0 ? "'< &$$ " '' ' & '! (' $'' " "! "$#& " "$%$ '07=0 ( $' " C '$ B " &#C @' D NH<
N< )'0A&07 &'B$ 16 # 6554 #'$ " $'' #L! = (='$ " A" B " &'' &' ' %#$ #& L'CB A%'( " 7(C " ' &L# D PH<
P< " )$0 " $$"' # ' " $'' " = '0A&0B #'' ? % O"# " "$%$ '07=0 ' " $B '"! &'B$! 1: K 6554! $'# '$ "' ' $' " &'' &' "' D 2! N ' PH<
15< &C #$' '' "' ' #! )I"C# " # "' B O ' $&& ' " " )$& "' ' A#'$< '' $"( " O#&'#'A K'%$! P &'#= 6554! $' &' " &#C @' "' & #J# &$' B $A#' &'B$ $' &A( ") %= ' L$C " =" %=7 'A D 2 ' N! 14 &< 3H<
11< . / # I( L&'< ' %%'! #"'$ ,,,! 0A '0&$"B< " L# " 6N '= 6554! )L&' # $(" "C' 0O&'&0 "'S" "'! " "%% ? &&' T &' )$'"' ( ) ' KB) =" L' " )#&'! #'' " " )$& "' '' '& D145UH ' ="' DP5UH! &$ ") O "C' ? #"$$ O#$'B L # ' %" " "L L'$#'$< $A#' ''$ &'('$ " @'$ A0 " '' " " ' " < &&' " 6N '= 6554! )L&' "A'B$ '' "L '
"L # &C ' " )$& "' ( "$0 &' " ('
L' " # A" &'! O"# '7$B ='$ D'0' O"#H! '' B' # &C $'# '$ '
$' " &'' &' "'! '' # &C $' " &#C @' "'< &$$ B! " @'$ "'! &'' &$'' '$ " )'C 7(C! " &' &L# ' ( ' &#C @'< '#$ B )$($#' " 3 "$#= 6555 (' &(B$ O"# "L '= " 'O& I"C# O! B &#'''
")(A ? )A " &0$#C "$#&' ( "'
9653;9655;
7 ;91:7
A" &C " $ " A" &'< L&B$ B) "$#&' ( "' A" &C " $ " A" &' &(' & J' ' "( L# (' #'$ #& &L# $A 7(C< $A#' K'$ A '#'B " ?
)0$#'# " A" &' L# %%'$ 6554 )(' & # $(" ' #& &&$#' " )L (< "$%'(!
"$$ B O"# " "$%$ '0B $'' &'0A 7 K' B #=' ( $'$ $($$ & )$($#' " 3 "$#= 6556 D' 6555H< B) ' " '$ ' ' $($#' ' '= ''$ $'' '' & &=! ( L D 14 &< ;H<
16< &&' " 6; (#= 6554! "B$ B "L # &C "LC# '('! )L'' & ")I"C#! B ' " )L'$#'$ $'' # ' B O"# "L (' "& D 2H<
14< 4 (#= 6554! . / ##B$ ? )$ " )L&' ' &$$ B &='$ ") &&' " '$ )$'' & %%' & %" "' L &'' " )7"' =A'< $B! %$ '' &'' & 0' " 1P "$#= 6556 D 13H<
1;< &&' #$" " 12 "$#= 6554 ? )''' " )(' " '! '#$ B) ( " $ &$'$ & &''! ' " '$ ' )"' " 3 "$#= 6555 ' '= ''$ " '' " 1: ( 6554 ' " ) " 16 # 6554 &' '< L&B$ B! )! L'' " #"%' '#B " '#'# &&' ( O"# B " "$%$ '07=0< %! K'$ B $ #7'" '#'B &' ")A ' &$'$ & &'' $'' ? )A " )AA(' ") O"# " "$%$ '07=0 D 1PH<
13< 66 "$#= 6554! ' )' &' &C " . / ") #B &'' ")=K'('$ " " )L# " 6N '= 6554< &&$ B) (' %' &' ? . / " #&'#' " )L&' "# " )L&'! ' 6P '= 6554! ' B )&' " ' (' "$$ B )$'' & &#C % B) '"' " 0 &< '#$ B! " "'! ('
") )L&' ' " #"' ( L&' # ('< %!
"#"$ ? . / " ( "$ = " &&' " " 2 "$#= 6554 K' ? D 1:H<
9653;9655;
7 391:7
1:< . / # ? #$"7! . !
0A7'0&$"'< &&' " 1 # 655;! ( " $'' " )'0A&07 " 16 # 6554! &$' %#$ A$ $B " "$0 " A" &'< K'$ B) (O' & " ' " '$ ' $ # A$ $B ' "$#& '" ' " "L '' B )(' & $'$ $$ & )$($#'
"'< %#$ B )L' ") " '$ )$'' B &= & " '$ V V<
12< "$ " P # 655;! . / "$$ B &&' ")L&' #&' "' $ & *' ( &=' '
B $(' #B =K'( " )L&' #"%' )&&$' % " 7< "$%'(! #' &' D 12H<
1N< N ( 655;! )$ %#$ &&' ' '' "$< $'$$ #B B' ? )=K'('$ " )L&' ' ' B #&'#' " " (' %$ $'' " )L&' '' B) (' %$ " ' #&' =K'(#' " $''< ''$ )= " " '$< K' ? &&' '''' "'$ " 45 # 655; $#' " B )(' #&A$ 0T )L&' ' B %#' #&'#' #&& " )L&' D 1; ' 1NH<
1P< ,. ! ' &' " A " #"! # I( L&' B) %$ / ! "A< 64 ( 655;!
)L&' L#$ )$ B &A' " &' ") #=' $"' " )$& "'! ") $&&' " " " 0A " = "' B ") #&'' O ' ")"C# " # "'< &&' ")L&' " 6N ( 655;! / "B$ B) $0A&0 %%'$ 1; ( 655; (' &# " "A'B '0#= ' < "$$ B '' ' " '0#= ( "('
#'' )"' ## $'A " O#&'#'A B $''
&& = (' &#C '(' 0A "$%$ '< %!
($ B '= ' '$7(L (' $'$ B#'
A$ " )L&' & #&' " )7"' " ' B ' ' )"' " 3 "$#= 6555 ' O#&'#'A &= " )&'$ ' " '( #$'' ")J' $'"' ( D 15H<
65< 6: ( 655;! . / "#"$ ,,, " &" &' &0 %#$ & )$< #&$#' ")L&' " #J# K! '##' ''$ ( &$'" B )$ $'' #' &%' ' B) )A' B ") '&$'' " &''< &! "$$ B &&' "
9653;9655;
7 :91:7
" 12 "$#= 6554 '' A#' '#7 &'0AB &=' $'=' ' ' )$($#' " 3 "$#= 6555 ' "A' " ( 7(< &&$ B ) " 16 # 6554 (' &($ A$ $B " "$0 " A" &' ' &$$ B #& L'CB " )'C 7(C )(' ' ( "$0 " A" &' D 65H<
61< . / $A#' # ? " #$"7! / ! 0A< &&' " 6P ( 655;! &$' L&B$ B) O"# " "$%$ '0B &(' '' '#& &(B '' B #== ? &$'$ & )$ ' #J# )%%'
") & L'$< $B! "# B) " '$ ' O#&'#'A " O"# " "$%$ '0B ' )"' $'' '' & &=! # B) $'' & (#== B O#&'#'A $'' #&'= ? '' &$7'#'B< %#$ " )L&' B " . ' "# B '' B $'' ''' ( L # &C )"'<
66< "$ &&' " 6 K' 655;! . / K'$ )&&'< "$$ B )L&' ' "L #$"7 $''
# ? "#'' B $ "' (' A$ #&C'#' " ' B) )L'' & " " '$ ' )"' ' '= " '$ && 1P "$#= 6556< "# B &&' ")L&' (' & ( &=' ' B )L&' )$'' & &$( "C B &&'
"$#'' O =K'(! A ' $ D 1PH<
64< 63 W' 655;! )$ '$ )'$ ")('A' #=' " B " #$" " /@&'L (' " C( D7&C F /H %! '##'! ")=' "LC# ( #$" ' " '$ ' )"' " 3 "$#= 6555 ' "A' " O"# " "$%$ '0B< " L#! ' %< , '
''$ # "' %" ' O$! "&' " & " ?
A0 " #I( ") "! #=' " " 0 ( " '' ? "'! #'' " #=' " )$& "' ="'7$$('< &&' " 6P &'#= 655;! ' B %< , ' &$ "A' " O"# " "$%$ '0B "'! " O"# &'7'0#='B &== " ##= &$ "' '' &'7'0#= " ( 7 (C "'! " '' &' '#'# & 0 "' % '$ " )$& "' #&B$ & &' &' " # A" &' "'
( 0$#'#! " '' &' &$' " O"# " "$%$ '0B "' ?
"L &< ' "B$ B O"# " "$%$ '0B ='$ L''
9653;9655;
7 291:7
&==#' "$K? (' )"' " 3 "$#= 6555 # $'' O#&'#'B< ' K'$ B ' "' (' (#==#' &(B$ " '= ''B #&'' D( ( '' $'' " &#C @' ? "'H '
B) $'' &= B #"%' ''B ' A"$ #& & #B$ " ( " "'< ' L&B$ B! ''$'! $'' %$B' B) O"# " "$%$ '0B ' $ ? '#'#< ' "$$ B O#&'@# "$' & )$ $'' '#' ")A #'%' DO"# " "$%$ '0B ='$ &$L'' "$#&$ & '#'# @'$ "' ' #&B$ & '0#= ( 7 (C "' ( &== O"# &'7'0#='BQ 16H<
6;< ' " ; '= 655;! )$ ' "$ &&' "
6 K' 655; &C " = ' " < ' ? # I( ") ( L&' ' ? & 0A & )'#$ " $B $ ' " 3 "$#= 6555! ' " % ' "$&< )&& " ! (B (' " )'"' " )=' '' B )'#$ )' =$ L&' &' ' "$$ " '' =K'('$< ! L&B B) " '$ ' ' "# & & # " L #$"! ? ( ! !
/ ! , ! ' "' &&' ' & ( &='! & B O " &$%$ (! " )L&' )$'' B)$<
63< )'#$ "#"$ - ! 0A '0&$"B B " # ' #$"7! " &" &' (L &&' #$"L &"' & '< &&' " 66 '= 655;! - "B$ B " '0C / )L&B' & )&&' '"$ " O#&'#'A! B %< , '' & #' " '$ &== ' '0#= &$L'' ")A #'%' ' )$($#' "'< ? )L' &= ") " '$ ' ' '0#= ( 7(C "' ' )"'
" 3 "$#= 6555 $A" ? ='$'$ " O"# " "$%$ '0B ' ?
)&&' '"( " O"# &'7'0#='B<
6:< $& " 6; (#= 655;! )'#$ K' " < "$$ B ( " ('$ ") L&' )$'' & 'C & &&$ K' " B! "#'! #&' "' &#''' " *' & ( &='< ($ B! &# ' #$" 'A$! "#''' &&' " '$ &$&"$' ' )"' ' '= " '$ ' " '< %! &"' &&' " - <
9653;9655;
7 N91:7
62< $&B " 2 K( 6553! ' #' < ! L&B$ B) )$'' "K' ( " & )#&A " )L&' ' A' "' ")J' '"< ''$ B / ' #$" " / )' & "# " '$ ' )"' ' O"# &$'$<
6N< "&B " 1: %$( 6553! )'#$ #' < &&$ B "$' " "(' J' L#$ ( ' "C B) $'' #$"7''' " '<
6P< $' " 1; # 6553! ' L&B$ B) )$'' %'
#&A & ! )(' B #O & &( ''' ") $(' "' (' " )L&'< '#$ B )&& " &$(' " )L&' $'' $'=< $A#' "$$ B ' " )( " )L' ") " '$ ' ''" ? K' &#''' & " ' ? =" " <
45< " 64 # 6553! )'#$ ($ B) 'C# $0A ")$' )$'' & &$( & " &$" "#''( ' B "C =(' " ' "(' J' '$ " "< &! "#"$ B) "$ ' %L$ & "$& " =('<
41< 63 ( 6553! ' &"' &&' " %< , "'$ "
61 ( 6553 &$' B) $'' 'C &== B )"' ' &$&"$' " O#&'#'A $'' "$ B)( 35M " O#&'#'B " "$%$ '0B (' ' ? '#'# ' B 1M &&' "$0'<
46< P K 6553! )'#$ &"' #&$#' ")L&' " "'$ " 4 K 6553 "$'' )$'" #$" B =' , & #'( &'< L&B$ B '' $'" $(B' ' #= " #$# &(' A" &$&' O"# " "$%$ '0B! ? ( " '' " ( %= " #' C (' &C '#'# ! " '#'# " &' # " B! " # A$' " #' %# " =" %=< " '! )L&' $ B) O ' '#'# $'' ") ' ($' A%'(< ! "$$ B '0$ ") #"%' ''B " #' " C &' L(! ( #&==! ' #"%' ''B )'
& J' B & A%'( '! (' $'$ &$'! ' "& &C $' " # C '$< '#$ B )$($#' " "$#=
9653;9655;
7 P91:7
6555 (' $($$ &=C# '#B &$L''! ? ( '' $'' " ( ( &#C @' B $'' ? )A " #& L'CB " 7(C< % ($ B )A " '0#= ( 7 (C $'' L&B$ ' B) )(' & $'$ "A'B$ " )$07 && %%'$ $'$ 6554! # = &C "LC# '(' 0A< "$$ ## 'C &== B "' '0#= ' ' ( "$%' '#B '7( ' %#$ '<
44< 13 K 6553! ' &"' " N K 6553 $#' ") L&'$ " ' %' $'' ") ''#' #$A#' '
&L B ") #&'#' 'C & =K'% & ' L&'<
4;< 1: W' 6553! ( $'$ ('$ ? &! ' $"A$ $' " B '#$ B 0 = 3 "$#= 6555 $'' ") ' ($' A%'(< &! &"' ( &C "'$ " 63 K 6553 $'=' B! " " )' L&'$ " !
)'#$ ' &'$ " #'' I( ( L&'<
43< 1P W' 6553! = " $ "$ ? )'#$ "$ & % &'
" =('<
4:< $' " 6: W' 6553! )'#$ ($ B! " )' '$ & '! )(' #' # B'$ '%B " &&'
")L&' " ! # L&'#' ' & " #'% ")&&''$! (' &'$ ")(A ( L&'<
42< 14 %$( 655:! = " $ %#$ &' " '' " % #"' ")L&' ? &B #$" (' ? < '! %L$ "$ 6; %$( 655: & ##B $(' B' #&$#'<
4N< , )'#$ '$ "$ "#"'! & " 6; %$( 655:! %#' "%%$' " B' 3! :! 2 ' P<
4P< 1 # 655:! = " $ ##B$ '' $' '<
9653;9655;
7 1591:7
#
1< A( XA' K" DH $'$ #"%$ ' ''$! "C 1 W' 6554! = ' " ! #&$ " 3 KA!
"' &$"' ' (7&$"'! 3 &&$' ' 1: KA D'< 1 '< ' 3: H<
,' ? X' " X$' " 1: KA ! & = %$"$
62 K( 655; D Y 145 15:H! " A( "&'$! 14 %$(!
"&' '' A' &#''' = ' " " $A ? ' KA ''! ! " X''' " X$' " (L KA <
6< %#$#' ? )'< 3: < 1 '< 0< 3 ! = ' " *' ' B " ''' &$( ? X'< 3:
'( ? %$"$ X7"' " 65 # 1PN1 D H< , #&$' & KA " "X&C ' $'=<
4< ' '$ (A 1 K( 6554 '*' #"%' " #= "&' $A " "# " < , & #'$! &' " ( B "' )&&B "' J' '0$ ? #C " && B CA &&= ' (A ##' Z %' K"B#' "$'#' ' &"' D Y 145 645 "< 1<1!
443 "< 1<6! 16P ; "< 1<6! 162 ;:2 "< 1! 16: 14: "< ;= '
$%$H<
X&C! &$' "' ? " &'' "C 1P "$#= 6556! ? ( ? "' '$ ? X'$ (A " < $B! & #'$! &$' ' $A & $A' (A KBX 41 "$#= 6556< ' L CA " &$"! '
&&=! % "&' '' '! ? ' "C )'$ (A " D Y 141 41; "< 4<4! 112 P4 "< :=!
116 4:5 "< ;Q 1PPN - 42 &< 41: "< 4=H<
;< , X'< :5 < 1 ! "$ " ' " '' K< '%! "$A' ? ! X'< 15: &$(' "$ " " ' #< '' "$ B "$ &&' "' " ("" 6 K' 655;! B) $'$ R & '@' " 3 K' 655; ' B "$ ' &" " 13 K' 13 W' (#' D'< 4N < ; '< = H! $'$ %#$ '#& ' 1; W' 655; " "$ ' " : K' 655; N (#= 655;< 'K'$ " %# ' "$ &$( & ! ' (=!
(' " '< 3: ' <
9653;9655;
7 1191:7
3< 'A &' &' " ( ) L' " '$ ' O#&'#'A " O"# " "$%$ '0B "' %% ' '
)"' $ " 3 "$#= 6555<
:< (' " #L# ")%%! )"#'' ' KA "(' ( ")%% ?
)$'=#' L' ' #&' " %' &''< ,' &'' ' %' "' )L' &' % ") #C ") ' KA#' '% ? &$''< %#$#' && B' B $A' &$" " "# " ! ''$ "#''( ' KA " "(' &$" ? " ('A' &&$#' " B) O %%##' " & %! $A" L A% (B$ & &' L " $'' " "< &(' A " A% &'' (B$ & &' & #& B) )'
& $'$ &($ D, 391PP;! 665 "< ;H< &'! "(' #'' I( L&' B) &*' $ " % &' #$"L " D Y 112 6N4 "< ;Q 1PN3 &< 6;5 "< ;H< B KA "C B %' ' & %%##' $"$! &' (O ? X"#'' & #&$#' "X'' &$" 7#J# ? ' '' #&$#' D 1PP4 &< 14:H<
2< H , && " = &&$' " &(! B X&&B = &$" "#''( BX &$" " " "' "#''% D'< ;5 Y $' ( X'< 1P Q '< P3 < 6 ( '< 114 ' 146 H! X"#'' KA &&$ =#' &(! J' $ & " CA %#! &$"' ? &&$' #&C' ' A " &(< C ! KA "' L# " #C =K'( ' #O " &(! B BX ' &(! & "$" "#' ?
"&' &#''' " &' KA#' (= "' 'AL< B &&' #$"L ' '"'! KA &' '0 )%% "B & B %" & #$" ' & '< ' $A"! )$$#' "$'#' )' )A! "$A' " #O " &( ## &&' L&'! # '< #&' B &' 'AL #&'' ' %' )=K' ") $'" %$! B &&' %" " L# #&'! B) & $A#' "$' &' L&#$! B) ' $'$ $'= & " " D#CH! B "&' " '%$ #$" ' '! %! B " )L&' ' = #'($ D Y 163 436 "< 4H<
=H , #'' && " = &&$' " &(! = %$"$ " &$ " A "' B #C ")&&$ ' 'O& ")L&' " &&' #$"L< !
B! '" " &$" "#''(! L&' %$ ? #$"
9653;9655;
7 1691:7
"$&"' ' $'= & &$' ! = ")=(' &&%" ' ")('A' #&C'! B) & " "! ' B )L&' ='' ? " $'' ('! KA ' $' A'#& B) " ' &#'' " "' " =7 %"$ D Y 163 431 "< 4=9==H< KA &' " & ( &=' L &&' ' L&' $'= & #$" ") A'#& B L7 ='' ? " $'' ('! B ' $#' #'($! B ( '' & " '"' ' B) " ' &#'' " #'' =7 %"$< #& %' B #$" '$ ' $ ? ) & &&' " '( &#' & " "' " )=K'('$ " &&$' " &R &$(' ? )$A" " )$< )' B) &$ " ' &'C B "' K' " )#&''$ ") &&$' &(' J' "$$ ## =K'(#' %"$< '' "$ )#&' %$$ L &&' #$"L " "' " !
O ''% " & " LA $(C B' ? )#&''$ " )L&'
D Y 163 431 "< 4=9H< L&' &$'$ & &' ) & #J# ( B " L&' # ( & '= & )"#'' %#$#' L CA " &$" &&=< (' " && $$ & K&" ' )&&$' " &(! KA ' ''% ' ")L# ' && ? #'' "'! &' 'AL #&''! )& " )L&' #"'$ & '= & )"#'' D Y 163 431 "< 4H< ! B &&' $'= & #$" '''! KA &' ' "' ' #&' " %' B! )L&$! #$" ''' ' A$$#' ! " "'! ? &" &' & &'' " ' " % B )' ? " D Y 163 431 "< 4=9== ' H<
N< &&' ")L&' " 6N '= 6554! "A'B$ '' &C ' " )$& "' ( "$0 &' " (' L' " # A" &'! O"# '7$B ='$ D'0 ' O"#H! '' &C $'# '$ ' $' " &'' &' "'! '' &C $' " &#C @' "'< K' " " '$ ' O"# " "$%$ '0B ' )"' " 3 "$#= 6555! '#$ B) $'' '' & &=! ( L< (' " &" '' ! )L&' (A$ "( 0O&'0C D$$#' &'0AB LR' #&! %' '#'BH L&B' )&&' " O#&'#'A '( O"# " "$%$ '0B ' "'$ )( ' " &$' B &$ " T ")#= &#''' ")=' ? " A#' '< K'$ A '#'B & #'% B! ) )$'' A ") "$#&' (
9653;9655;
7 1491:7
A" $'( ? )"' " 3 "$#= 6555! ' $'$ $ &C " $ " A" &'! B "( L# (' #'$ #& ? ' '! ' $A 7(C< $A#'
$'$ ' A (A' )0O&'0C ") #& " )L ( &(B$ & )0$#'# " A" &'! L# $$ "$=' 6554 )(' & &# " %# ' 0O&'0C< %! ($ B '#'# (' $ A" &' " &' "'! B )'(' " 1: K 6554 (' '$ $' " &'' &'!
' ' '<
"$%'(! &&' ")L&' " " 6N '= 6554 %" " L# B #&' ' &" "$' &' L&#$ & '< $'$ $'= & " )#C '
" " #$"< "&' " '' #$" ' &&$' '
< )L&' )' L&#$ )$(' " )$'' " '$ "& "$=' " )&'$ " '( B " '$ ' )"' ' O#&'#'A " O"# " "$%$ '0B! % "W#' #'($ &' " (< )' B &&' ")L&' #&' '' "' K&"' &#''' " *' & % &='<
P< ' ? L# " '' " $$#' ' " ' ? #'' =7%"$ " " <
&&' " #$" " / " 6P &'#= 655; ' ? A #'%' " '= " ' &(B$ '' & O"# " "$%$ '0B ='$ &$L'' %# O#&'#'B ' "$#&$ & '#'# " @'$ "' B & '0#= ( 7(C "' ( &== O"# &'7'0#='B< '! #$" "C'
#' ## &= B '= ''B #&'' &(B$ & )"' " 3 "$#= 6555 ' A"$ #& & #B$ " ( " "'< ! $(B' $A#' #& &='$ ") & %='B B ' "W '#'# ' L '(' 0A< %! &$' B) ' '(#' %$B' B) O"# " "$%$ '0B ' $ ? '#'#<
&&' #&$#' " 61 ( 6553! %< , "B B! #J# ) &' & L &$"&' 7K' " ' ?
)&&' "$0' " O#&'#'A " "$%$ '0B! '# ## 'C &== B )"' ' &$&"$' " O#&'#'A! ! ''$'! 35M " O#&'#'B " "$%$ '0B (' ' ? '#'# ' #' 1M &&*' "$0'<
9653;9655;
7 1;91:7
#'' B " 35M " ! O#&'#'A " "$%$ '0B #%' ? ' ") '#'#! &&' " %< , K'' "' =7%"$ " " < '' "$ B) )L&B & &B #$" " / ' #"%$ &&$' ' 6P &'#= 655; ' 61 ( 6553! )' & &= " '' = " ''' ' " #$" " /<
15< $B! ( " K&" #'$! O ")" '' #&$#' %# ") L&' #$" &"& D'0&$"! A ' AAH B %$ ? &B #$" (' ? <
---
9653;9655;
7 1391:7
. #, & #%$ & & $ #&
' / / 0 )
1< " '7L&' &"& D'0&$"! A '
AAH & L&' " &B #$" (' ? !
' ")L&' #$"! B ' & # "XL# '
"X'" ! &C XJ' '$ " ' $$#' ' ' &C ( & " " " . / B " " " &$' &$"Q
6< 0A L&' " $&" L B' (' F 1< #C 6< ' 4< ''' =K'( ;< A'DH 3< )"' " 3 "$#= 6555 7'7 &(B$ " '= ''B #&''! " #C '! (#== #' &= [ , ! B [ :< '#'# " 3 "$#= 6555 7'7 "$0$ O#&'#'A " "$%$ '0B " #C '!
(#== #' &= [ 2< , ! '' B '7 (#==#' ''' ' "& B" [ N< ' & (#== " "$0#' " O#&'#'A " "$%$ '0B 0T [ P< '= "' %% '#' &'' '7 $B '"( " )"' " 3 "$#= 6555 " #C '!
(#== #' &= [ 2< ' #B ' ' &&' " XL&'
4< ##' ? % &B #$" (' ? <
9653;9655;
7 1:91:7
;< (' L&' ? "$& &&' "L L#& A%% " = " $ ") ( 1' <
3< $( %"<
2< %# &' " BX &(' %# ' &$' J'
" "$ " 15 K "C '%' & & ##"$ "$ = %$"$ " ! ,0\T0%B :! :55; ! ' L#&< "$ &' J' &A$< #$# "' F H "B L'#' B "$ ' "$ =' ' & " "$ ''B$Q =H L& & B #'% '# &( "#" '' ' "$Q H &' A' " &$''< , #$# '' ' $$#' $#$$ '' H =H ' H 7"! = %$"$ " & & ' #'C BX "( "$ (=< #$# " #' #O " &(! B ' K'! B "$ ''B$ ' X(&& " B $'$ L&$"$ ' D'< 146! 15: ' 15N H<
A%%C $"'
YY - , -
$'7K' F 0&& +
& %# " &$' " ' '%$ L &' B)? )%% %$"$ " & A%%
9653;9655;