Statutory Interpretation of Mandatory Cost Provisions Following Procedural Developments
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case involved an appeal concerning the proper interpretation and application of statutory provisions related to the assessment of costs following a specific type of procedural event, specifically addressing whether a prior ruling mandated the inclusion of certain expenses in the final cost award despite a subsequent procedural development. The court reasoned that the plain language of the relevant statute, combined with the established purpose of the prior ruling, required the inclusion of the disputed costs, as the subsequent event did not nullify the conditions that triggered the initial mandatory cost provision, thus affirming the lower court's determination.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Statutory Interpretation of Mandatory Cost Provisions Following Procedural Developments: The court reasoned that the plain language of the relevant statute, combined with the established purpose of the prior ruling, required the inclusion of the disputed costs, as the subsequent event did not nullify the conditions that triggered the initial mandatory cost provision, thus affirming the lower court's determination.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited for the allocation of court costs in the final order.
Testo completo
!"#$!%$$& !%'(!%$$&
))
* ) * *)
+,- '
" , %$$&
!"#$%! !&$'$ "#" &"#( !"#$!
'
"# !"#$! )!#&'* "$-" $'""#+$'"",'*
!"#$! )!#&'* $'""#+$'"",'*
42.54
.
/6 "#" " /2 7* 2113 "$ 8 " $! !"#$ #8!9+*'"+&$"' "# ' & 4--' &: "+"#&'6 '9"#"$'$;$<&#"'<! &=4$&!"#( 6
"#" =&9 * $'$ ;;$ 9'$ "+#&>$ " # *#8/??3&"$-"'*'*$&=%&'#&! 8"+''"'*6:;+*7#@"-A"' *"$"$#7211/6
"#"=&99++*'&"+''"$7B!9 ''$#>"&&#&>!9!&:*"#"$ "'*"CA&7!""%"#A!''=;$"!% #&'""$#8/???!9+'*9CA&76=&9+* &'8"&"+A##'#&'!"'9+'& 9+%*9&''""'=6
' % 9 #&> ' "#$ % * #'' " '' B $ 8 " 9 ' " ''4'>& " '*D E"+$#"#'9"'":**;%+$&9 "-'6
26 $&"22-$*2113!"$-"'%+*8'$" "#"-'#99'8'"&*' '#':9"$&$8""#&'*' $'$"!9+$''&+6
)
/6 ;*F;'7"DE$'$#"-$'''$!": /G'211H! 8'"!#&$"57;! "' &$"' ' *4&$"'! 5 &&$' ' /I 7; D'6 / '6'5I E6
B'%F'"F$'"/I7;!& 8-$"$ 237*211JD K/H1/1IE!" ;*"&'$!/H-$*! "&''';'&#''' 8'" " $; % ' 7; ''! ! " F''' " F$'"*=7;6
./01.2113 4H.54
26 B & 9' " #&$' " '8 " $ & '' " "#"6
E -#$#' % +'6 5I 6 / '6 A6 / ! 8 ' " ,''9"'''&$*%F'65I '* % -$"$ F4* ' **' " 21 "$#8 /?JI6 "$;' % +'6 50 ! +'6 0J B &$*' #&$' " '8 " " ' L " #&' % :;!""+&:!:*6
9 '; ' #&>$ ' #&>! *' " "';=9'-"#'""'&*$"=9:*'" +&&' " "' &8! '##' * 6 --'!&#:*'"#&$'"7;*!""" ''$ "#''* " ''$ " &$* & "' -$"$! '##'"6
8E;-""#"&''-'9"$-"'&# "-A"&$&$%*:*''8#' ""'&*$'$A&&"%#&$'"'8"$6B&'! "#""'"M'"$$*86
E ' % =# &A " "#" 9' 4&#' " '' -"$ B & '* --'$ & "$-"'"'"'8"$6
'"+'65/6/ B9+8;'"'''"$ '' #8 % +#&>6 B +'6 /J/ B! +#&>$ &8'$""#"%"#&''-'"#&' "*"! L ' &'$ #&' "' $ " '"D'6H1' BE!'##'*D'6/J16/'6 BE6 &&'' % " #&' "+=#! '''*#' ' &"&$'='"&&'"+'6/I B!#&> 8 ' '' "! '' $$ &*' M' $#$ % +#&> ' $&' " "##; "' M' '"' ' DB&&$#' / = '* ' '-' "+ ' #&' "*" 4 . ! / 7* 211I! 25//E6 "$""#&''-'&"-#"+ "$D'6/J/6H BE!9'7''%D'65I '0J BE6
"+&:!&&''"#"""#"'-'" #&' "*" % BB B B 6 +' 9+ - 9 '' ''$ & "$
./01.2113 4J.54 -# * ;- " "#" 9 4 & ! 8! 8"$"+'''"$6
!"#"'*86
./01.2113 45.54
B KB! B BB BB BN
/0121 ,, 3 411 1 5 6 "7% 8
21 ,
/6 $"#"*86
26 '9&$"';''6
H6 -# &' " 9F &*' -# ' &$' M' " "$ " H1 7 ": '-' &: " 8 -$"$ DBAOCA-9I!I11J E!&*"#':""' &8!-#$#'='602"-$"$ 8-$"$"/3 7 2115 D KEP #$# " "' "9 ! #'- ' #>"&*'&';'"'"#"'P"' M' "$ 8 -$"$ & * &' & * $'9 = "' " +'6 J2 K6 &$' M' ' &: & " '!*9$###>"&*!"*'M'7'%+*6 ;--: &$"' KK QB Q
&-#"&$'M'''-$=&'9F%F---$"$ "&;--
'! & " &$' M' ' ##9$ & -#' % BB B B
./01.2113