Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ATAS/228/2006 • CJ GE ATAS/228/2006 Generato dall'IA

Breach of Settlement Agreement Based on Non-Material Prior Breach

Numero d'incarto ATAS/228/2006
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Accolto (Allowed)
Spese processuali a carico dell'autorità / Stato

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

A party challenged the validity of a settlement agreement, alleging that the opposing party breached the agreement by failing to make required payments, which the opposing party claimed was excused by the challenging party's own prior material breach. The court determined that the challenging party's alleged breach was not material under the circumstances, as it did not substantially deprive the opposing party of the benefit of the bargain, and therefore, the opposing party was not excused from its obligations under the settlement, concluding that the opposing party was liable for breach of the settlement agreement.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Breach of Settlement Agreement Based on Non-Material Prior Breach: The court determined that the challenging party's alleged breach was not material under the circumstances, as it did not substantially deprive the opposing party of the benefit of the bargain, and therefore, the opposing party was not excused from its obligations under the settlement, concluding that the opposing party was liable for breach of the settlement agreement.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
gestione del sinistro violazione positiva del contratto validità della clausola arbitrale esistenza e validità sostanziale pagamento delle prestazioni vertenza non amministrativa

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This article is cited in the dispositive concerning the allocation of judicial costs for the appeal.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

                



  !"# "$"#  " $ #

% & '

()   

 !"""#$ % &

!"& !"""#$  

!'&

((   ((( )'''&*+ !',)  #,& -./-0 1

2  %   2    (  ( ((   ( 3(  4 (  (5!        

1  ( 16  & !&&'&"77 78./   

       

  85/  

" * 

7: & ;<'   8..*   7=& )>&  &">  ?&"=& "' @ A  ?&!!#  "B!&     #     ' !"&  #    C" D#'"'&"#'7+-9:

8:  )",,& -  ;<' ?&#"'#   &">  ?&"=& "'  !&!#  ?&'<?&!"'"#B!"&?&#B!E?&!,"!C"?&) #?!F&'&"<:

G: ;<'"B!&'B#,""'",8..9'#'#'&" D!,,"  &"> '!  & !"  89 ;B"& 8..9 ?!& F#'"!?&'<:

/:  &">#!""'#?&'"!&"'"''"!?&#B!E  ?""'&?#"'"''"!#,&?&"'"!"C& !''  B!"&   ?&'" C" &'  &"<  !"' '&  7+-9'8..9:

*:  &!&'!&&"& 2  %    2    (   ( ((   ( 3(  4 (  (  8. ,#B&"& 8..9  C  ?&''"! C" ?'  &"< ?&  &D#=B$2&:8*D-/+:-*:

9: '$& '2&:77.D.*H:!!&&"& ((    (((7&,#B&"&8..9:

H:  !' !' #'# '&" F ?&'"  '  88 ,#B&"& 8..9:  ;&""'"!&""C#CD$#,'D!>&B'"!#""?&'" &&I' &"'&&''>:

-: D>D!>;'"!#","F# #'#<&#$;<&:

" $ 

7: D&':8*!",##&&">&?<?&#B!E?&!,"!  B"" &B"B''"B""'#7H#>&7++G@2A '&#B"<& 7&;B"&8... &=<?&!#&"B!&:!&C!;!"'!' ?J!&&?&''"!!&'"$?&'<&@&':788'78G ! "B"3 A  ;<""B!&!?#''D&':HG:7!",##&& ?&#B!E ?&!,"!  8* ;" 7+-8 @A  !"' $ =B  &">

    58*-58..9 G5/  

'!&!"?"7&!K'8..G !"' ?&=CD,,"&"  #'#'&"@&':7/8 A F#'&D!,,"?&'<&> # &#?&'"'"!#'&"#?&;<"B!&:

8: (!D&':882@!B'&B"<&?"7&;B"&8...A   "B!&   ?&''"!  !&'" C" &'  &"< !' ?&'<# !,!&#' F&':788 78G 7/7'7/8 L&':G$* 2D??"C' ?&!<"!''$'&,#&&@:7A:!&)C!;!"' ?&''"! !&'"$?&'<&!&&?!$",,#&'&?&''"!!&'" <'#  B!"&  ">& ?< F"'' #B''  !'  "B!&  '  ?&''"!!&'" <'#B!"&">&?<F"''#B'' !'!"!&"<@,:&':8/2A:!& !;!' $  ?&''"!  !&'" ' $ DB!"&  ">& ?< F"''  !'   !"!  &"<  "'#&I'   !'  "B!& @ 2 78-  8G.L 278+///A:

 J?=   ;<  ?&"=& "'  !&!#  ?&'< ?& !"'"#  ?&''"!  !&'" C" &'  &"< ?&  &:  ' ?&'"'!' J?&' &"< 7+-9 J'&?&' 8..9 '$C;<'"B!&'BF#'!"&:

G: (!  !' ?&!"'   ?&''"! C" ?'  &"< ?&  &'2&:77.D.*H:'"CC"?&&'  2&: 8*D-/+:-*   "'#&I' E' #;$ #'# # ?&  "'"''"!  ?&#B!E#,&: ""&!"'$!F3#?!!'' 2&:D.8-:-. '"CD"!"'2&:78D+8/:+*!&'CJ'#,""'"B &C"!"'$!F3#?!!''2&:/8D7.G:+.:

/: !,!&#' $  ;&"?&  ?"  ;!& #'&"' ?!&  ?&'< ;CD!''&,&'?&''"!!&'"!& !;!"' "B!&#>##,"""&''?&''"!&!"'$"'#&I'!?'!"&& !''3": "'#&I'!'#'F""#<!D&':78 D!&!&?&#B!E?&!,"!B"" &B"B''"B""'#  7- B&" 7+-/ @ 8A ! !  'F &#<'"&  " "3" ' ?#&"& @ 2!?>"#G95.87-;"'8..GA

*:  #!'  & ?&M   ?&!#& #'' <&'"' @&': HG : 8  ' -+1:7!"&?&!#&""'&'"B78?'>&7+-*A:



    58*-58..9 /5/  

  $ * #  !"# "$"#  " $ #

(

+,-.-   / 0 1-- -  023 4 #$56

7: B"' ((   ((($'&,#&& !?'!"&    !  2&: /8D7.G:+. $  2    %    2     (   (  ((   (  3(  4  (  ( 5!           1  ( 16  ,B&:

8: B"' ((   ((($B&& ?!''  "'#&I'!?'!"&!"#&' =8..9;CD !''&,&':

G: JE!''C>!":

/: "'C?&!#&'<&'"':

*: ,!&  ?&'"   CD ?B' ,!&& &!& !'&  ?&#' &&I'   #"  G. ;!& =  !'","'"! ?& ?" &!# &#  &"> ,##&  &  ()N"O&)!,C" 9  9../     '&!" F?"&:  #"  ?' I'& ?&!!<#:  #!"& !"' P A ""C& F'' C #""!  &!&' #"& !>'"&  " ' ?   #""!''C#L>AF?!&?!&C!'","'"?!B!"&&'' '&#""!LA?!&'&"<'&!!&?&#'':("#!"&  !'"' ?  '&!" ##' ##&# ! ''& A >A ' A "3   &">,##&&?!&&?'&&'"=&&&!&CD" B&#&&"&&B>:#!"&&!&'"!&!&!E  ?&B  C" &!' ;!"'  "" C  #""! ''C# ' DB!??  C#'#F?#"#&!&'@&':7G8 7.9'7.-A: <&,,"=&  &#"'P       "22 Q&"( Q 

!?"!,!&?&#'&&I''!'","#F?&'"""CJ$J,,",##& &!"?&<&,,

    58*-58..9