Trust Instrument Validity and Extrinsic Agreements
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe appellant sought to overturn a ruling concerning the validity of certain clauses in a trust instrument, specifically concerning the allocation of assets and the appointment of fiduciaries, asserting that prior agreements and the settlor's intent were violated. The court reasoned that the trust instrument, as executed, unambiguously dictated the distribution scheme and fiduciary appointments, and absent clear evidence of fraud, mistake, or duress, the written document controlled over extrinsic agreements or asserted subjective intent regarding asset disposition and succession of management roles, thereby affirming the lower court's decision upholding the trust's terms.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Trust Instrument Validity and Extrinsic Agreements: The court reasoned that the trust instrument, as executed, unambiguously dictated the distribution scheme and fiduciary appointments, and absent clear evidence of fraud, mistake, or duress, the written document controlled over extrinsic agreements or asserted subjective intent regarding asset disposition and succession of management roles, thereby affirming the lower court's decision upholding the trust's terms.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive for ruling on procedural costs.
Testo completo
&'()*&+,,* &++-&+,,-
##
# " " # "
. '
%+ +,,-
!"###$%&' ("()
")(
* * !' "+ #)#$ ,(-.!/")0-11!-2-- 2.
!"# $%
+237+
/
-8 ("#) % () '## /(# # -( ")"9(-4448
28 ))$/":!(#)"(";;(")#)#"<$-447+ ;#=$/($##"+%,)(2<7->;(8668
08 ( $##" 26 ;$'(#( 2116! * * ?#+ /(& #@ "$ % <($ :< '#) <#))#" "/( ($ ")#)#" ' ()! % (#" -61;(8 /( "#! & -('(#21168
58 ( "((#( -1 ( 2116! <($ ;"($ "//"#)#" % )) $##" ;#)'"#(:"2<7->;(866#'#)A#$)$($$') 01 "B) 2115 ) : # <'#) $)$! <(#) 9# $'#) /C$ /#:< $)#) "( #D) ($$($ /( # E F"(G ) <) ($ A:< 21128 )#$ : <$)#) % # <( (/"9##)$):$#:#<$)#)$"$/#-447<$)#)/(#"98 "#D$:('!;"()")!<"9#D)%(<# ;) # 9# : (9"() :# # ) $ ))(#) #))#";##&(/($#(8
68 ($##"("//"#)#"2>")"9(2116!#";#($$##" 26;$'(#(21168 "))$:<")"H("#)%()'## <($'#)/(##!-(")"9(-444!")#)#" ";;( <$ -447 <$)#) / "( ))#) /( /((#/)#"8 /( #( ('$:")#)#"")$)$/(#"/)#)():#! % $;)! (#) ($'$$ "# $'$8 ( #( # (//$ : "/)#"<)##9:("H<)/9"# '#)=9$$;###(()8 )$D(!"))$:!(9 #;"()#" ;"(# /( <($! () -61;(8 /"()(#) /))#)%##'#)8
78 ("((#(>"'9(2116!<($#)(A)$("(")())$##"8 ")) / : (' $/) 445;(8 ## '#) # "#D :< ) $A% /()#) % ,(D ;)! : (' ;;#) / % "'(#( )) ;# (")) % <$ 2115 ) <$') % 611;(8 /( "#! :<# # ;) $D) /C( /(# " ( #! " "C(! " 9") 9 )8 "' ;"#!(&':<)#:#"#(((-447):#"# '#)($$))"/)I)!(#)/<:#))(/("9&"( : " /#) D( A"(<,# /"( #;;#)$ ;##&(8 )#":<)%#/(((/"9##)$8
3045632116 +037+ >8 '#)$%/(""(!#!($/"2$9(2116!" (A) ("(8 =/#: : <($ C) ($##$ <( ;))#' *+ /($()#"24;$'(#(-447!$)#))'((")#)#" A:< 0- $9( )) J $ ) : # '#) $)$ /($#$ % <$/":/("((#(-.'(#!25#)27A#-4478
.8 ( "((#( 2 A'#( 2117! <($ ;#) '"#( : # "9#$ # ($("")#)#";;$()%<$-447"(:<;#)'"#( ("#) -4448 (&' :<') -447! /(" ,(D " "#( '#)$A%"#/(#&((((()#'"9(<$")#)#") "#D : #! -444! " # '#) ")("C$ () "# $'$ :# <(#) /)"/)")#)#":#()#)%($D(!<C(#)/"//"$8 ;#)'"#(:#"#)($$!");):#/#(")( )/()#)%(,(D8
48 )#"$ /( (#9 $! ("() ##:$! /( "((#( 0- A'#(2117!:""C()($D$/(;#8
-18 -6;$'(#(2117!#('$:!"A(#/(!")) "C(;;)#')/C$/($9#)(")/(#"/) ##'#)):<</&!#<C'#)"/#/(("C( ("()"#$()#"8
--8 ( "((#( 2> ;$'(#( 2117! ("()! :) % ! #) " (D))#"8
#
-8 "#D'"#(K"(D#)#"A###(?@$)$"#;#$)#)#)$!& -("B)2110! (#9)"("#!"/"$6AD! ") /($#) ) '#+/($#)! 6 //$) ) -7 AD ( ?()8 - )8()67 @8
*#)%K)#"K$)#"-7AD(!/( (#9;$$( 2>A'#(2115? L-01-17@!( "#D'"#"/)$!-0;$'(#(! #/"#)#")(#)"#((D)/())) (#9)"( "# #$D( ( % )("# AD )#)#(! ! K))) K$)#""'=AD(8
28 ";"($) % <()8 67 ! * "M) #) #: ")) ")))#"/($'%K()867"#;$$((/()#D$$(("#) ("#? @()#'%"#;$$(21$9(-457(
3045632116 +537+ K(+'## ) ('#') ? *N ()8 67 8 - )8 ,8 - @8 * "/$)/"(AD(K/&)"$)9#8
08 ) )($ '#D( -( A'#( 2110! )(M) "#;#)#" "9(#/"#)#"$D"#("#8/"#) ' )/"(! ") /(##/ //#9 (&D ("#) '#D( ") "H ;#) A(##:) $)(#) ") /("#) ) AD ("#;"/(##/!/"(//($#(!(<$));#) ($#$%)$)(#)$##"("//"#)#"#)#D#? L-24-! "#8-N L-2>57>!"#8-)($;$(@8
58 (#9 $ ")) : ("(! #)(A)$ )/ )# ?()8 71 8- @)('9;"(8
68 :)#" '"#( : ") #/"#)#" //#9 )#&( /((#/)#" </&! ' <9 ("#) )(#)"#(! /) (( "'() ("H)(<()8-7 *)($J!9)! ::#$)#)'#D(")#($#8 *" <()8 -7 8 - ) 2 *! $# /((#/)#" ("#) ("'(( ($")#)#")/(##/#:8 ");"#!#<($'"#)<"'(#( ("#)%()()$#/((#/)#"/"(#)")#)#"! ($ /) : () /) J)( "/$ ' ")#)#" " /((#)<)/##)$!'()<()8-782 *(#&(/,(?;8 $D) " 5100! 516- % 5160 #()#' ( /(/)#" ")#)#" < *+ + @8 ))#/((#/)#9##)$<=/#:")/(;#): () :# ) "( ('# $)$ $ )) "/) ")#)#" :# (#)BJ)('($8/(##/"/)#")/($'%<()82182 )8 *!:#(/$<()82180 *:('"#<()8-782 "#8
78 *" A(#/(! "/)#" ")#)#" /(" ' ()/)/);#(:("H$)#":#;;) ()/"()/))#)##'#)("/(("#) /"(#)8"(:('<($$/)/##'#)! "/)#" ) =8 (',! # (' ")#) $/) ##'#)!"/)"/$(("/)#"#&(%/)",(%#+ #8 "(:"/)#"")))")<)//"#9;"#! " <;;)( /( ")) /()# ($/()# ( :: "# ? -441 /821>)($;8#)$@8")#"##'#)):#("()#)("#) /"(#));##)?O-14-4%-1421#()#'"()() < *+ N ;8 $D) "( <###9##)$ /"( <$ 2116 N 0 71815@8
3045632116 +637+ >8 </& ("#) % () '## ("() /(# # (
- ")"9(-4448 )))!")#)#"";;(<$-447!;#=$ /( $##" -6 ;$'(#( -447! <$)#) / "( ))#) /( /((#/)#"! (#"/"(:#)""(/"#9/("$(%"/)#" " ";;(! 2<7->;(66! ' () <#)$($! % "#)#" )");"#:))"/)#"<)/9"#'#)=8
.8 *( 9##)#")/#& ;"(#/(<($ "() #))#" ;##&(!#"))$:<()-61;(8/"()(#)/ ))#)%"##'#)("H('<$&')%2<6->;(8/( "#8 *# " ")(#) ")) 9 /"( /(" ?-<-11;(8@)/(#<(+#?520;(8@+:#$:#')%)") $/-<620;(8+!""9)#)#;;$(('445;(8
*<D#)#/I)!#=/#:$:<#/"'#)J)(/(#"/) ##'#)'(),/#)(0"(<###9##)$ /"(<$2116%&'8
) "C(! # /) ;;) J)( ) "/) ( "H ("()#:<#))")$))/C$/(;)8
;#!##:<('$<#)#$!#<))"/);(#<9") 9 : /"( /(" =(P) )#'#)$ ()#' )) : $/ ##/9 % <=(# ( /(";#" ) '() ,/#)( 285 "(<###9##)$/"(<$2116%&'8
48 $D( = "#$()#" :# /($&)! ;"( ) "))( : () "/$($ /( <#)#$ <) / ## '#) ("()! : "))<#(/8 "$:!("(/)J)(:(A)$8
3045632116 +737+
# / " # " " # "
%
012 3 4 56 7-+ "$8
2
-8 $(("(('98
% 2
28 (A))8
08 #):/("$()D()#)8
58 ;"( /()# :K /') ;"(( ("( ")( /($) ((J) $# 01 A"( & ")#;#)#" /( /# ("$ ($ (#9 ;$$( (! *,E#Q(,";:# 7! 7115 ! )("# =/#(8 $# /) J)( /(""D$8 $"#( "#)R @ ##:( =)):$##"("()$#("9)#(#)/$##" )):$N 9@ =/"( /"( : ")#; # )# /"'"#( ( )) )( $##"N @ /"()( #D)( " " (/($))8 *# $"#( ")#) / )("# $$) $$($ " ))( @ 9@ ) @ #+! (#9;$$((/"((/)(()#&((("(:K# '($((#(('98$"#(("()#"("("C /('! :# (") A"#)! ## : $##" )):$ ) K'"// :$)$=/$#$("()?()8-02!-17)-1.@8 D(;;#&( /($#) #LL (#*
"/#";"(/($)((J))")#;#$=/()###:K%K;;#;$$( ("#/(D(;;
3045632116