Contractual Liability and Breach of Agreement
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAA dispute arose concerning liability after a complex series of transactions and agreements involving multiple parties, ultimately leading to a claim for monetary damages and specific performance. The court examined the contractual relationships, the performance obligations under those agreements, and the alleged breaches or failures to perform by the involved entities. The court reasoned that the plain language of the governing contract dictated the responsibilities of the parties, and upon interpreting the terms, found that the evidence supported a finding that the claimant had established a breach of contract, justifying the award of damages and enforcement of the agreed-upon terms against the liable party.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 68 LTF; Contractual Liability and Breach of Agreement: The court examined the contractual relationships, the performance obligations under those agreements, and the alleged breaches or failures to perform by the involved entities. The court reasoned that the plain language of the governing contract dictated the responsibilities of the parties, and upon interpreting the terms, found that the evidence supported a finding that the claimant had established a breach of contract, justifying the award of damages and enforcement of the agreed-upon terms against the liable party.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in order 2 for the decision regarding costs.
Cited in order 2 regarding the allocation of court fees.
Testo completo
%&'()%*++* ,%-%*++.
,
, /, / /
*0 12 " ' 3 *++.
/4444444444 !"# $% 1" &'( &)*((
)
55 / /, 6 /7 8 ,& +),-./..01.2
!" #"$
7/3..7
5 ,
.8 "&* 9999999999 :( .,46 *( *0 & &% ; 1( ' )+&< ( =9999999999# &.6) )$ .,,>2.*(.,,-?()&/@:)>:)*(8 ( ) ( @)( .,,- ( & .> ;8 >> AB 522 CD ) ( <1( ?5E65>;8->8
/8 0 .,,> < );; &< &(1)7%(% ' F & )*$$((( ()&)) & 1(1< ( 2.*(.,,-8
28 ,*.,,,&)&*&& ()&<7(1(&( 0 & <;;( ) & <7(1(&( A(70 < D )(( <) )(&< 8
G8 /4 1( .,,, &) 9999999999 (( +@( ( +@) @( *&( ( &<&(H) ?< ()& < &'(&(H) ('()&&(;%(%&) <( ( )(( H0 *)+ & <)$( ( ))(* @)(' & 1(H( )*$H(8 %(' ' <( 1( & @$( & ))(' &( <IH & .6 ' &(0 1( H* ) & <*(H () #( .,5- :'< 1H ( 1 *( .,,>8 <( (1( ( * *&(* % +@) @(&(:( .,,> ) & &*( ($ &<*() ()8 <(( & 1( ( ) &(.G) )$.,,-8
>8 /2 * /66. & ' ()( 1 ? & *( &< <( 1 '< ( % (1( ? ( * ( < ( )*$*&)&();((08
48 /1(/66.&) 9999999999&(H) )** () )$ +@(' & ' ( ) &(H) ( &<()& &(; *)+ &( .,,> ) ( (( $(( & 1 (H & H)($)))@H( &*%& J 8< ( & )$&)( 8 (( )*) * & )( ) ;*(( (;K( H0* <;; () &) );;( ( '( ( & &<*H < ( ) (1? & 1* & 1( &18 *&( (* <(( & 1( & <?-6C8
-8 /6 )1*$ /66. <'J ( *& < ;( &<;; 'J ))*('*H&(H) ( ?<'J ( &)*((&</2) )$/66.8 ) '<'()(
3.45-3/66/ 723..7 <(*) &< (1( (1'<( ( %( <1( *& 7( < ( 0 ( & )8 (&('( ;)( '< ( 1( ) 1 )( .6 @ *( & )+H ( '< 1(( *)( ? *(7 * ;( '< ( 1( ? .66 C '< ( 1)+ ; ? (8 ( (( &(;;(( & &;(( ) 1 (()8 <'J ( ( &( & ( *J@* & ? <(1(&( )& &)* %@*&< (1( ;) ()& *?)*( &(1 I@*H08 %&<(1(&( &*H<1( ?./>C8
58 &(()&/21(/66/< '<( 1(? * (A/>CD)1 ))?->C% I@*H08 #) %&<(1(&( <1( ?.66C&< (1( (1 )<'J ))*('*H?./>C&<)*(* & I@*H0 '( ) ( ) % &<(1(&( H)$ ? 2> C8 % <)1( &)( ? ())'&*&& () ( : 8
,8 ( &.G*(/66/<( : )) &(() < *(&))() %&<(1(&( &2>C ' < 8 0 1)( )(( &( * ( ) )* ) ) %(' ' ( ;( ( 0 *& '( 1( ( )( ) () 0 ( (( ' & )( * :'<?<IH&&%())'<1( 1( '<? /> C ) + <( () & & *)( ? *(7 * &0 ' )($8 ) H* ) < (* () ) $ & < ' ? ( (& &<;; 1% & *H8 ) ? <) )(&< (0;)&&H&<(1(&( &<*)(444C ? < ()&&(() '8
.68 ( )** ( & 4 :( /66/ < 1 ' );() ' %&< (1( '<( %(<1( *&)1( & <'J ( '( <1( )*( ' & <(& ) ( )@( 1( ? * ( *( ' @)(% ( ( & .66 C ? & $)( ;((8 ) %(' ' )() & <'J ))*(' *H * ( &<@& ( ?;; I@*H0&0)'<);;( &<;; () +@(' ) @+(' ' < ( *) (1 () <H( & *( I@'((;(( &; 8 %&./>C H ()(( ( ()*@($ <$ & ) (* () @(;; & & <'J (8 ) &*( ( (& & 26 C & <)*(* & I@ *H0 ; ) *&( & )*&( ( )?'<)()( %&<(1(&( H)$ &-6C8
3.45-3/66/ 7G3..7 ..8 1( & 2 :( /66/ < )) : & ) %(' '<1( ):) 1(? * (&(*(*@& <*)( <1( :*((&<*)(?( *'(&( )$$ H () ' ;( '< ( ) *)( ? ( * ( <1( *&8 ) <1) ()&*&(&;() ( ( * (&(* &()F &) (1? .66 C8 ? <1 () & *J@* ) & & *H <( <1( ;( ' $ ( ) ( () ? & <'J (H* &;K)( )1( ())' ( < &)()&) &<'J 8
./8 ('&.>)L /66/) 1':'<.,,>1( );; &<))(*'(<1( *J@& 1(H(0* ? * )* 8 ( ;( ( 2)L .,,G 1( );; &<)*( )H( '( 1( ( & )( () )(&$8 ( ()&1( J ()* < )<1 ()&) 8 ) '()( %&<(1(&( &<)*(* & I@ *H0H* '<1( ;( 1)(&)( &) &<'J & '( 1( *( 1 <'J ( 7*J* ( )' * &( ()8
.28 ($ )&) )* () ) & ( '( E .. )1*$ /6628 < %(' '<0 <J *( 1( ;( & *H''@*( )(&&$%('<( ( )*$( &);( <1( 1(:'<.,,/)M 1( ) 1(&%@NO9999999999?()&&%@ &*( :)8#;( ( .,,G 1( 1(&26) )$.,,>2. *( .,,- ? () & &% @ :) (' :) *( @N =99999999998 E(&E&( ($&)&)?< )& ()&<) &&) 9999999999 &<1((*&( & <7(1(&( A(70 #"D ) ( & 1( & ) & (1( *H08
.G8 & & G ;1( /66G < )&( ) *&( & &) 9999999999 & > &*$ /662 ' ()( )** ( ) )$+@('*(*J* ((& &5&*$/662(( '<1(&#"&.6:1(/66G8&) 9999999999)*J* &(H) ('& (*'< & &) ( ()( <1) () & < &(; ;( & & ( *( 1 &)*( & ()& )M ( 1J ( ( ( *)+8 *() <( ;(( ( ) )+H ( (& )*( );(&.48@ ( ;; ) ) ;*( *&(8 *&( (*( ' <(( & 1( ) I@ *H0 ( & >6 C8 *&(7)( & #" ( < $) ?
3.45-3/66/ 7>3..7 1'<$) (&H ( ;; '@&()1( &)$0*@+('A)*$H(D'(H&( @$( * @&( &/6?/>C8 ; ?1(< '<'J (1( ( )(& ()*J@* &<)&&/6C) I@(* ( & 26 C ) < ( & )H* ' )( )1 &) 9999999999 H& ? & *H 1( %*( ( )(& () 7(8 ) <( () & *&( ( ()*0 (7( + * (&(' I@ ' < )1( )*( * () & @&( ( 1 <% () &< (1( ((08 <(& & **$ & ;*( 1 (( ;(( ( ( & * %(H($ & < & ) )H ) &(*( &)H H&< ( ? 8< )* ()') $( &) 9999999999 % J** ( *(( )&( () *((* ) :(& ;& ) $;(( &< (1)$ 8
.>8 /4 ;1( /66G ) ) 1 )$ & <'J ))*(' *H 1 ' &(0 )&( % %(H):(&* (0&*)M<'J ( <1( &)1 ()@(;; '<<1( (H8 ) & % &<(1(&( H)$ & <% ? <'J (&('( (** 2>C0'&(H* )( &)' % ) (( ) ;; &( 8 <( () *&()7 @)(' ( ((&)*( 8
,
.8 )( H1)( <)H( () :&((( & // )1*$ .,G. AD *)&(;( ( ( &0 . )L /662 ($ ) & )(8 );)** ? < 8 2 8 2 & &()( () ( )( ( )&( 1 < 1(H & )( & &1 )(() ) & ) * (0 &<7(1(&( ) *( &<);;( ($ ) & )( ( (' ) () * (0 &<7(1(&( ) A;8 8 >4 D8 )* & ($& (( $():H&&<08
/8 )(;& (H&&)( &)(&4) )$ /666 A D 1(H . :1( /662 F & )*$ *)&(;( ()&&)*(&<7(1(&( 8&<0&* ) ;)(H(&()( ()1(H:'<2.&*$/66/H& (( ) ' :H & )( < ? & )(& () *)&(;( () & &)( ) & < & ;( ) ( ? &
3.45-3/66/ 743..7 & *( & &(() ( (H( A ! ./- G4- )(&8. ./. 254 )(&8.$P;8H* &()( () ( )( 85/8. D8 ( (H )' %*( ? *(0 & &()( () & )( <7(1(&( & ., :( .,>, A D & ) 0H* & .- :1( .,4.A D1(H:'<2.&*$/66/8&()( ()H) &0)( &( 8
28 : &;)* &(H%) 1$A 84, 5G &)(;&<71(( 1(1 &/6&*$.,G4 A #DD8
G8 < 8G8. ('<(1(&( &(*( ()&( &H( * * ) & )H & '( &< ( ? @+(')* )1 &<(;(*( )H( &<*&()&< (& 8 ) '< (1(&( )( ) ( ( & @' '<&(H) (*&( ( )( )(( ')( *( 1(&&(*( ()(*) &( & 1(A &H(DA !./- /,,D8 I@&*&()( ?) :H* E & ? (&(' & ' * ) ' (1( E ($ & 1(8 ) &) *&( ) ( * ( ) & *(' 1%) )()$* %(H&EA ! ./>/4.)(&8G..>.2G)(&8/..G2.G)(&82.6>.>5)(&8 .D8
< 8/58. 1)( 'E&)( ? E( (1(&?G6) *)(8 &<' (< (1(&( &G6) &< &*( ) (1(&( & >6 ) *)( (0 &0 44 /32C *)( &<(1(&( 8 < 8 /5 8 / 1)( ) ' ) <1 () & <(1(&( 1 & 1( ' <(1(& )( )$ ( %K < (1( ' <) ()$* & & ( 0 % () 1 &*@& 1( )*1'<(( )$ (<( < ( (1(&8< 8/582 1)( ' )(;&&(*( 1 & 1( ? )(& &( & ( () )** ( <1 ()&<(1(&( ) @N'(<1( &< (1( (1)'(;(( (H)& &1 &<J (1(&8
< 8 /- ( (( ' <(1(&( & '( <%K( &< (1( (1 & < 8 > 8 . 1 ;) () & <*J@* &<)*( 1%@$( 8#)< 8/-8/ 1%@$( & 1( &*H) &< (1( & *H <& () & ; 8 1 & < 8 /-$( 8 . <(1(&( & '( <% ' (* (1( (1 ) 1 ) < 8 /5 8 / 8 #<( ) ) ? 1% @$( & < 8 > 8 . <(1(&( ;(% )
3.45-3/66/ 7-3..7 < 8 /- ) (1( 8 ( ;& & *( (1 & < (1( (1 & <)*(* & 1% @$( %&<(1(&( &<0@&(&) < ;; & &% (1( ' () A* @)& *(% &<1 () & <(1(&( D8 (( ( ; 1 &< <(1(&( & 1% @$( )*()& (1( A 8/- D &< <(1(&( & (1( (1 )*() & 1 A 8 /5 8 / DP ) ) ) & *( <(1(&( H)$ &<0 * ) ? &% @* &< (1( 8 & < (1( );() & <*$ & 1% & < & *()* <@)(& 1(&);() ' () <@)( )*( < 1(&P ) &) ) ) &%18 & 1%@$( ) ( & ) HA !.6G.24)(&8/P .,,/8.24)(&8.$D8
@)(% & E & )( * @)& A* @)& H & )*() & 1 * @)& *(% * @)& (;('D && & & $;((( ) (& Q%K (1( (1? *)* %K (1( (1 ? * ( ) (;8 &(& ' E ( ? E ) E & )( H)( ;) () & 'E( ( ;( 7() ( *J*7(E ( ? E ( 18 (' ) (& )* & E1) () & ( ():'E))&&(()&*(( (1( (H(&* ( @+) @ (' &E (1( (1 ( ) )*0 ( 1 ( &H & 1(*$ )& A ! ./> .>6 )(&8/..-.,G)(&82$ ;D8
#) :(& &E A) %K (1( (1? *)* ? * () (1( (1D&& & E (1( 'E &)+( 1 ) *(HP ;( ) ( 'E (&(8 1@&((1 &E (1( 'E%( &() *(H 1 & E ( ? A (1( (1 ) I@ *H0D8 ; &) %*( ( E 1(& ( ) E ( & ) (1( ? ) *H ) ? ) () (1 0 ) *(H ? *(0 & ( () ) ;*(( )( );()8 (( ) & *( 1)( ()( @* &E (1( )$$ & E ( ( &* 1(& ) (& )* &E* '( ();((0&*HE& ()&; EIH&E '(;( () );() ;)* () (( ' ;;(( )A !..-.,>)(&82$P#.,,48/6,)(&8.D8
>8 <0( (H) &H&<(1(&( &) ' * @)&&<1 ()&(7(8
3.45-3/66/ 753..7 >8 *((<);;(( (*)(&'(<<1( *& ( )(1( ) (1( ? * ( ? () & &% @ *((':)*()( ?/>C8((&H&<(1(&( ( () & * @)& &<1 () *(% 8 ? ) %(''<( 1(?( *( (1( *( ' ( <1( ;( < ( ('* () & ( & ) *(; (?&<(;(*( )H( &) );;)&%(0* ; '(<1( ) ( ?&*?&)*(()<)8 )( &1 J (1(8
;; &()(1#(< <:*(% (1( & )+ ? ( * *( ):) 1( ? * ( :'<? (&)*(; (('<<7*J*%('&(& )* () ) .. )1*$ /6628 ( ( (1( ( A26 CD .,,/ :'<? ( & ;( )L .,,G ( 1( &0 ) )$ .,,> ? /> C8 F &) ' ( () & ) < * *)&(;(?( &(&; '<< )%)( ?<& ()&%7((('<? & ) *H ) (*) & ) *8 &0 ) 1(*$$ ' (1(&( ) ( )(1( ) (1( ? /> C ) ) ) ? ) *H ; ;)* '( *$( ( )1(8(&<*)(?( *)*J*' %<:*( (<F 1(*$$&&<08
< (( ? : ( ' <;;( ( (* &H &<(1(&( & ) ( () & * @)& &<1 () *(% (1&/>C)< (1( (1 &->C)<)*(* & 1%@$( &*H8
>$8 % &<(1(&( & .66 C < & < (1( (1 < ( (H(% ( ? %*( % &<(1(&( & ) & 1%@$( ;(%?./>C< ?>6C) 8
) ) )() & <'J ))*(' *H ;; /2) )$/66.?)&)*(( 01' &(0*( )&( ();(%:(&* (0)1)()F (1)$ 8 (*(' 'J ( J (( ) *)+ & 1 & * )M & )$ +@('()1( &< @&*(0)& ?<1(*&( &&(1H &<'J ))*(' ) () *&(8 ? < ( 1 ' <'J ))*(' < ( ( ('$)') *&(<1( (1)$ '( )( <( () & <(( & ) & <)*(* & I@*H08
3.45-3/66/ 7,3..7 ) 1 E(1(&( & 1( & *H E&*(( () )0& ? 'J (1( *H0 ;(% E*J@* & @ & (1( @$( );)** * . % &( (1 ) E(1(&( E(*) & E;;( ;& & )( AP(* @8/.//D1(H&.:1(.,,22.&*$/666 A&0 . :1( /66. @8 26,> & (( ) E(1(&( E(*) & E7(1(&( R SD8 ($ ;& & A ! D&:?E)()&E&* );)*( % 8>8. /-8. / & ('&*(( (1AJ &,1(/66.4>G366 ! )$(&//)L /666.6/366 &.>)1*$.,,, 22.3,,D8 %)&( ()):(&A !./5,2D 'J 1)$ 8
! &<$)& (* ' E'J (1( *H0 E ( *)+ & 1 &' )' E*J@* ( & )$ &E)& +@(' 1 ' ' ()( 1 ? ;(% E(1(&( & 1( &*H ( )K&*(0?1@&(&) &E ( ? @+(' E ( &) ) ? E1 () & (*( () ( ? & )$ +@('8 & ( :(&&J )$(&//&*$/662)M(%(' '< & )$ & &(1H & <'J ))*('*H ) ()&<)&*&( (1? ( &<)*( 1% @$( 7( 1( 0H H & )(& ' <'J 8 ) ;)& )() *&( ( ; ' ) *&( ( 1 )$ & :(& ? 1)( ) ')( ( (H(%( ;( <)$: &< &() (' ) ;)& & %* )* ' )() & <% )( &L* *) (1A;8#/66.8.>,)(&82& ! )$(&4 *(/66/>/436. &,)1*$.,5-/--35- ) (()&:(& ! )$(&//&*$/662 2..362)(&8>82D8
<0)()&<'J ))*('*H) )&( ? ( (1(&( & ./> C & <)*(* H)$ & (1( @$( A;8 ) & ./ )1*$ /66. ;( % ? <'J ))*('*HD8)T &) 9999999999%('' <(1(&( &) &<)*(* & I@*H0 ( & >6C(&(' '<)1( )1( ;(( ') )+H ( (&)*( );(&.4A) &>&*$/662D8
&(0 ( () (;( & % ( 0 :(& ( (7&8 ;; (( ;(% ? >6 C ) (( *( H* (%( ()8&( $& ;(( ((
3.45-3/66/ 7.63..7 ' )+H 1 <(& & ) *( & ) ;(8 ) &) ()* (;;( ) *J* ' < 1( ( (( &)* *( &<J ( )($8 ( )() & <'J J * ;?( ('&*)M<'J ( &( 1 (() ( ? )*( &(1 I@ *H0 )* &<)& ()) &@*&< (1( 8 H& ) *J@* &/6C'()( <(* ()1 ' < )1( ;( ) ;( $) &<;;) 1( &1( (('1 +1( *J@* &26C& < (&)H* 8
;( ')& ()& (1( *H0 )1&;(% ? <'J ))*(' *H ;;( ? * 7( &*)M&( 'J )*0 ( < @?&(1 (() ( (( ) & <)*(* &&(1 1%@$( 8
)() <;;( ( ;)& ; % & <'J ? &)*(( ? ;(% ? ./ > C % &<(1(&( & 1% @$( '( ) ( %H)$&<(1(&( ?2>C8
1&* )&)( J : &(()&< &/2 1(/66/);(*8
UUUUU
/ , 5 , /, / /
"
91: ; < 6$ &'* !=
:
.8 1$ ) ( : & & .G *( /66/ "&* 9999999999?<) &&(()&< &/21(/66/P
" :
/8 : P
3.45-3/66/ 7..3..7
28 );(*&(()&< &/21(/66/P
G8 ( ')& H ( P
>8 ;)* ( & '< 1 ;)* ) ) J & &( & 26 :) &0 ) (;( () ( )& & ($ ;& & #@V(N@);'( 4 466G )( %*(8 &( J ))H8 **)( &)( Q D (&(' % * '&(()) &()$ (( &&(() 'P $D %) ) ' *) (; ( (* )1)( &*& &(()P D ) (H ) & ) 8 #( **)( ) ( )( * * ) D $D D (7& ($;&&) * (0)'<( &1&(1$8**)(&)* ())*)+ & 1 '( ) :)( (( ' &(() ' <1) & ' %&() A 8.2/.64 .65D8 H;;(Q (& Q ( # $# (7:( Q !)"
)();)*& J ) (;(% ((('<?<;;(;& &)(H;;
3.45-3/66/