Statutory Disclosure Requirements and Prior Restraint on Commercial Speech
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAA litigant challenged a statute mandating certain disclosures in advertising, arguing it was unconstitutionally vague and overbroad, encroaching on protected speech and imposing unconstitutional prior restraint through an unduly broad review process. The court held that the disclosure requirements were valid as they regulated commercial speech with the aim of preventing consumer deception, a legitimate state interest, and the required disclosures were reasonably related to achieving that end, thus satisfying intermediate scrutiny. However, the court struck down the prior restraint mechanism as unconstitutional because the required submission for pre-approval of advertising was overly broad and lacked sufficient procedural safeguards against indefinite delays, failing to meet the strict requirements for prior restraints on speech.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Statutory Disclosure Requirements and Prior Restraint on Commercial Speech: The court held that the disclosure requirements were valid as they regulated commercial speech with the aim of preventing consumer deception, a legitimate state interest, and the required disclosures were reasonably related to achieving that end, thus satisfying intermediate scrutiny. However, the court struck down the prior restraint mechanism as unconstitutional because the required submission for pre-approval of advertising was overly broad and lacked sufficient procedural safeguards against indefinite delays, failing to meet the strict requirements for prior restraints on speech.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe final order directs the losing party to pay the costs of the proceedings.
Testo completo
"#$%&"%''# ("%'$"%'')
*(
( + +(+ +
,# %'')
)- .
/0 !"#$% &' & %( )*++**
*'
1 23333333333 4"1 2 5+ 2 (,' 5(+ 16 .117. #8 #%'$ 5+0 4 14 93333333333 :
! -./0
+ 2(
/3 *(( 45555555555 (( ' '6' *&&' $% $/7&/!""3 %+*'8)9+**)6+& +'*# '% *& & : +** +'* &+*'';*'6*%*<69+**)6:,,3
-3 ' '6' *&&' =*' 5555555555# >( ''#8((,)6'%$?&'/!!-@>): ,# =& 5555555555# ''# 8((, ) 6' % $ ? &' /!!- @>): ,# > =*' A5555555555# &''# 8((, ) 6' % -" ,(%''/!!B@>):,3'(%'( 3
03 *(( ( ,,( +'$ '+'*,* )' %'%%A(('*'*&<+'*9A =C +'$ =D$/!""+*'*+'*'(3
?3 '@6&/2*E/!!!# '8+'&$'(+8> *$%+'**(,*((45555555555 3)( ***(((+*(-0,(%''-222#++'F'% 1G+*''(''*$&C,3+$H/?/1 =D3
13 /B,(%''-22/# =*,('**'(+'**&&6: )*' =& 5555555555# =' 5555555555 A5555555555# * '* +' *@*& *'&# +*' &* * A'3/01I2?-3/1#'+'(**+''&+<((&8'/!!7# &# @# +&8' : (&8' /!!"# + * ,' ' +('* )%'/!!!C,3+$HB:"# =D3
B3 -2 &' -22/# =*' A5555555555 ,*'&( *++** +'$ =; 9+*( > * %'& +' ** , /!!7 *' )( /!!" )9+> +' , > *((# ' +('*# '%'+J('(*''3*+*&'*,* '# 6'K : >( (8' >): *, > (&*6 9 &' *((# =*' 5555555555 =& 55555555553 '++ > = % *'*<( : *(( '
./1-".-22/ 0./0
+& 7 %' /!!! >) + )&*'& +'(%*< %'& )*&+ & A'3 7I1223 $ 02 %' /!!!# ** *'3 >) +'**( ,# 45555555555 : '+' )(J(' +& %(3 )*++* (6( %*'# +'$&# ,,(*&8''J'J,%'*((:'+''#.* )'*+'8)++*''*)'''*3 +'+%#)&8(6(('*'-@/!!!%(( +''*% '(+*'*''(++(&'; *'*#8>',()''&$'*(('+' ) ((3 *% &8( 6((' ,E *' *%*>( /B @ /!!!*'>((((),*'&'@6'& *((# > ,E , +' *''' -- @ /!!!3 **# )&''*%*'*&&(666'%*$'>) ''(+*'**&+<(C,3+$H1 =D3
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
./1-".-22/ ?./0
=&5555555555#*J'%=*'A55555555553 = * > *(( '*% + ( '(*''# (6 >) % L' +'*88& '( /!!7 (@:# *' > )&'' (8 )( /!!! +*' '+'' (&'J%%'*((3*$'>'+*8( (,'66(3
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
!3 '*(:)'*#)*'('*''>),, +*',*&+(/!!B:/!!!#*+)( ***>'++*')*'6'(%*',:)9'/!!"3 +$*((E&*&&>(9+'3
./1-".-22/ 1./0
/23 '(+> -7 *%&8' -220# = '++ > ' +&)*+(('+(#'+*&+:%''+*'&*'' )''('(# *(( % '(6' ** *'3 ++*'>*((,E&')>'**( '*83 : % ), +, *(( : 6'*+ ,'O#++'(*'#+,('6&+(%(>),3 )' +'# ' +'*$ %'8 )&8( 9'*'' *(( - @ /!!! (&*' > +'L 8' *( '( (*)L'>3', '((+'(%8#*&+ '((,''(8/!!"*&8'+*'*' *((3
//3 *' +'*('# = ,*'&( )*'( '*' > , %((N'(>)%'O%A'3!I?"23/23)'+'# =& 5555555555 =*' 5555555555 % %'( *&+ +*'*A'3-"I1-03!2# 3;&**&&6(*(> '(:A'3!7I7-!3213
/-3 '$'**#(,',%*'>+$'& +' ),, , *,'& '(( , (6( ' ('&*+'(**3
/03 *''+#%'(6(+'>((&'( *' )'* '* '+'# > 8*# +' '* +'$3
./1-".-22/ B./0
+ (
/3 '(8&# +'(' > * 6%* ' )*'6* @'--*%&8'/!?/CD((&*,(+'*/?*%&8' -22-#>) '8*'*((($/' *E-220#>#*&&'**'%: * ,((' ' )' % '%%# -2 (&8' /!?B C,3 '3/#3'#1B3#J3/D3 *,*'&(&:)'0#(0 +**'*'#+'(#'*%)'(%6' * +'(( + *&&* * '*' &$' )' %'%%#(('&)*,, '8* '*3*&+( '8($*'(8 +*'@6'+'(63
)'+'#*,((''+'6((''*'* B **8' -222 C D '( %6' +'&' @%' -220# 'F&*,**&8'+**(6*& ) # *&& > *' )' 1- * ,((' ' )' % '%% C D3 (*'&# '+*8( )&+*<' '(6( &$' + (( >)+'% : )' 1- #'"/"-'$6&')' %'%% C D*((8'*6(3)+$'(&*'(6+'+** %6' @>) 0/ (&8' -22-# (6' +'+ * > '$6 ++8 * %6' &*& *P , @'>& ('&*+'*C A/-7?B7#*3/D3+**(6 +''*$*'(''3
-3 9'&)' "-#3/ #'*&''(+'*) *&&6+''*'> *&+*,+%*'+' (* '(+'* )( +'$ >) * *&&63 *''&:'+**#)6)*'' )(+('&+*:*('')*,,C A//0/"/Q /!"7#+3 B27# A//-"#*3?Q /!"B#+3?!0D3*'>'*('%) +8*&+'*+(:(+''+*+*6 '(#(++8C,3'"-#(- D3
'8 ,((' ' C A D +*( +'+ >) *&+*R**&&6S+**+'((#: +'' &*& *P * '*F'# < +'L )* >)* '*)')*&++'>#>'*
./1-".-22/ 7./0
+'& + '*%'' **# & +*'' @,' *86*'(+''*&&6C A//B71#*308;//0/"/#*3 -; //- " *3 ?# /1"; /2" 1-# *3 1; /!"0# +3 /2"D3 , ('&**'>))<R'**+''+'*,#' :'8'SC,3A'JMRJ8'86T*U'#-$&(3+3//-D# )*P'(+''( 3
, * **' +' 8* ),# ) + ('& * *&&6 &*& & *P + *' 8 '8* *&+ , (8 +' ),, ,*>'#*::> 'O*(, 83 ,,#>8+',*+'*(' **''%'**&&6 ('L#6(('#* +'> '89# (@: ,,&& * *&&6# &*& *P *** '( *,(# * : *P )( ***)%'*(((+*(+%L'*(3 &*& :# '(' # * %' L' 6(('# &' *F' )( ,# *** '( % +'*88 C,3 A //! !- *30;/2"/!B*30;/!!1#+3/B! /72#*3-; A//B /B/#*3?;//B71#*308Q /!!2#+3?/1D3
'& R '$6 *''S 6, ># +'+# *&+* &' )&' ,,&& )( * *&&6 &*& (+N )( ***3 + *,* > &* * +*8 > +J ('' >*# +' 9&++'>&*,(++'*% 8 &&*8'>)&'*,+,*''* :+'*+*%+'(%8C /!!-#+3-BB#*31;8&'# *&+* > +' : +'*(' '(+'* ) *&&6 * )' 1- # /!!/# +3 ?2BD3 %'&# +' (( + 9+*&# '* '* +(# >('' * (' % (+N )( ***; ) +''*'>)++')&'*,#:)** )&8('('#>)%+*''L''8(9 '(' 3 )9 '* ' + &>)%'M&+'&'*'6&+'*% +'* * *'( +'& + *' ,*' &*%' &@C A//"/!B*308D3
./1-".-22/ "./0
' '# ) ,# : @ '# &*'' (%$' )++'(* '+*8( ) &+*<' V # +' 9*# *'6 ) )6 ) +'* &*' V > ** *&&6 : *&+*)*8'%+#*&*+'(666'%# +''+* C A //? --2 %3D# , &L& &*'' 96:)(6')&'*>*''+** ,*'&)*'+*8(,*(')'31- C A//!!B Q/!!0+3//2D3
)+$#)(***(((+*(+8(A -0,(%'' -2223 *' **# *( >) % 1G ( +'(%8+*''(''*$&C,3+$H/?/1 =; +$H!#*',,,VAD3 ):&*& :> = +''*&+>)8'*8&*&&63
*, * * '(+'* *&&6 : )*' (,' /B,(%''-22/# =6(+('&+*')+'' +')'"-#(/ 3
' ' 6' -2 &' -22/# 'O +' -- &' -22/# (,',*'&(*++**C,3+$H1 =D3*+$*'# (,'+'*&'(+'**&&6-? ,(%''-22/#*'>)*++**(('@(&+3 = '> &%( )*++** /! %' -22/; ) > )*++**>'>L&%(*'%8,*'&C,3' "/#(0#"-#(- D3
03 9 '& )' 1- # )&+*<' * *%'' *&&6 >) ( %* +''+* *& * +' (66 6'%3 '++'>)'1- +**+(C,3 /!"!# +6//7D3
)+$#*&&6*+''(**8+' ='*,*((45555555555 #+*'&* )(% & : A'3 !7I7-!321# *''+* 9 ** +'' &+<(+*'+('*(&8'/!!7#&#@+&8':(&8' /!!"# + * ,' +*' +('* )%' /!!!# ,' ('L &*'*'*&+'3
I'/?#(/ *''(*%'0?% # +''I*86*+*'I&+*<'(''J>'**
./1-".-22/ !./0
'(%'' :*&+*%+'*+'**3 &+*<' *% %*<' 9 # +('*>&# +$ *&+8*''%'(:''(#&$':> **+''+L'(,'I*8@(*3
I*86* +<' ** ,*'' (*&+ # +*' I&+*<'#KJ'*+8+''+'*3 (6'# '8 ,((' ' ('(# : '(('( '+'# > '+*8( I&+*<'I'1- ('*+8C A //-/11#*31; /!"7#+6--2D3I&+*<'>I>+ KJ*&&%**+''+*I'1- # > 'F +*' I*86* '(+'' $'& *&&6 **( C A /// /70# *3 -; /2" /"B# *3 /# /!- *3 -; /!"1#+6B?B#*30D3
A ,,'&(9+'(&>I*86*(6'(+''*&&6 * L' '* > *P *&&6 E : %** * * +' (66 6'%# +' I&+*<'# +''+* '(6 I C /!7"# +6 -1!; /!7-# +6 B"7D3 *&+* > * >I 8 *&&6 +' * *8'%* +''+* + &' > I&+*<' %*( *&*&*+'(666'%#&'*PI9 +I,'*':(6&(**&+*'&*:I8I ,C,3 A -"@/!"-# /!"0#+6/2/D3
*'> I&+*<' +'* &*'# *'6 '(+* *'&# : ' 8'# *&&6 ( +' # *&& > +'* &*' I9 + &*& *P '+*8( 66(C,3*B220'%IA '+'+*** ; A //? 7!# *3 0; //0 -1B# *3 0; /!""# +6 /0B# *30; A////70# /!"1#+6B?!#*3-3D3
'W*'6W#,'*+'*+J<>>'+'(+'* &*' : I9('' * > + 9'' , (% ' *&+*'& C,3*B22?D3*'>II*(( *<&# A I*@*''(,('(:I'71?#/'(#*''(*% I'71!#/'( 3 *,*'&(&:'#*+'* J'6(I&'*#6***'N#'(+*#:I(6' *((# &L& >I%' J> *' * '(' *# *&&6>I'&>*&*+'(66:
./1-".-22/ /2./0
'%*'+'*>'(+*I&L&*&&6* *'&3*'(+(J'6(I&'**6* I' 71B W* & *'6 (* (6( 9+'(& *&& # & (6& +'* > +' ,,%& (*'%*'6#*>&6*+'*+'&* +' +'(+*(' : ,*'&* %**( *((W C A /27 010# *3 1; A //- /!"1 I''L -/ %' /!"" ; A*'&*'# U'JJ 'X*'JU# -$& (3# +6 -2!D3
)+$# (,' ( ' '6' *&&' >( )&'' > *(( ,# 8((, ) 6' %#$-",(%''/!!B#@>):,C,3+$H1-# =D3%8&>()*'6*((,# >)*&'+3
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
./1-".-22/ //./0
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
+'(% , > 9 *' *((# =& 5555555555 =*' 5555555555# )> &( % )&*''+'+(3(,'*$'%*'+'*&' >*&8>()&''%*'6+'(66 6'%;+'#''(+*'*&&68+' =3
13 *&+/!!B/!!7*(((&*',,>)%(66( 8((,#,*'+*'>)*,,( '(*''&+*'+/!!B#>)&+LJ)>'** *:&+3 =E&'*&8'+*':)*' *((&'(*',+'*''3** (&8'/!!7#>>9&*/!!")%'/!!Z*@&(( +<(3
./1-".-22/ /-./0
+ %6' >) &+*<' *&&6 : *&+* %* *& +''+* &$' ) # >'F+*'*86*'(+''+'(@3 *'> )*8'%* +''+* ++'F# % '*# *&&(6&*,%C A/2"/"B*3/8#/!0*3-8; /!"1 +3 B20 *3 -# B?7 *3 0D3 # + ''%' >) '' +&**#)&+*<'+'%:&'*'+'%# +' 9&+ *' ) + ( '(*''3 = , *'# +*' >) *&+*'& *&8 + (''& * *+ )'3 1- #>)*+&'>)&+*<'%#&*&*P+' (*#'*('*8@%+'>)+*'')>' ** ( '*8 C A /2" /""; /!!- +3 -B/ *3?8D3
'8 ( *$' > )( + )*''3 , +'% )* > )* + '*8& ' # (,' ' E *' > *(( *,,' ) &> >( J'*># > ** ''('( % , )*8@ *&8' +*'># **#)J<+*J$>8>*'' +'L ++' + >)(*'3 ' E L' ) + , +&J'6*>*&8'9++&*'(+' &' % E L' (# ** ' )( + '+(3&'%6(#>'+'*((+'6'*+ ,'O# * '(%(( '% ,'3 (,' (6*( %*''%+%,;*,**(+'*'( +&'('#('&) 3 ,#(,' '+'(%*'+&)*&+&*' *((+*'+'3
*&+)&8'*# '8(''> (,'&>(:*%*'63*&&(66 6'%# 66 '+*8( '% *&&6 8 +' &''** +&**3
./1-".-22/ /0./0
(2 ( + +(+ +
41:1 ; 711 1 <= #>%
:1
/3 O* '>L &%( )*++** ,*'&( +' =*' A5555555555:(*'(+'**&&6/B,(%''-22/;
:1
-3 $% )*++** ,*'&( +' (,'# : *'' &* A'3!7I7-!#21;
03 (8*+'***''**;
?3 ,*'& +' >I +% ,*'&' '*' *' +'( ''L ( 02 @*' $ *,* +' + '*&&( '( '8 ,((' '# JX['J*,> B# B22? # '* 9&+'3 ( + L' +'**6(3 &(&*' * M D >' 9& >I (* '*' (' *8' + (*>(;8D9+*'+*'>&*,&+*%*'&' '(*;D+*''6'**'+'(3&(&*' * + '* ((& (&('( * ' D 8D D # '8,((''+*''+''&$'''*'>I %'(''''%83&(&*''*'&*'*'&*< +'%# > '* @*# > (* >( I%*++ >((9+(('*'C'3/0-#/2B/2"D3
6',,'M '(M \ =
*+*,*'&+'(''L*,(9+'>I:I,,,((' '*+'6',,
./1-".-22/