Tax Valuation Dispute Over Asset Value
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe litigant challenged a determination regarding the calculation of the value of an asset for taxation purposes, asserting that the assigned value was excessive due to the court's failure to properly consider evidence concerning comparable sales and the property's diminished utility. The court reasoned that the factual findings regarding the comparable sales were supported by substantial evidence and were not clearly erroneous, and that while the property had specific deficiencies, the trial court was within its discretion to weigh the various valuation factors, including expert testimony, and conclude that the assigned value was appropriate despite the litigant's objections to the method and weight given to certain evidence.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Tax Valuation Dispute Over Asset Value: The court reasoned that the factual findings regarding the comparable sales were supported by substantial evidence and were not clearly erroneous, and that while the property had specific deficiencies, the trial court was within its discretion to weigh the various valuation factors, including expert testimony, and conclude that the assigned value was appropriate despite the litigant's objections to the method and weight given to certain evidence.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThis provision was cited in the final order regarding the costs of the federal appeal.
Testo completo
"#$%&"%''# ("%'&"%''&
)(
(* *( * *
+# %''& &, -
. ////////// 0 0 1 23 4 .5 653 #7 #%'8 9*: ; 3 . 2<
== *( * >*?*:( !"#$%$$ $& ''()
! *%+$,*
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
+$-%.+%,,$ *&+$,*
D'#;)4)%-4$!!&))3%59(4$!!& )'' :DD' )3' :*'9'') @ B : : )9'# (3 : 3 ))'' :) ):):3(=('9'/ ' $ D)9' $!!.# '9') F')) C 3 F49' 3D' 3 L 3' 3 ' A 3' / 5/ $< ( $!!.# :) )3) 9 ( 3' ''ED(3D'/ '9 )'' 3D' 3 )= )) ) $!!.# (' ' )E) :4 : == )9' EM F'))33E '==(3(/(( 33)4'%&D)9'$!!.3 K=:)(='(38( ('9'C3'9')3D'/ "/ 33 ()' $, (' $!!.# 2222222222# ()' '# '() = 39' J ')) (( 4'') =F' 4'' '3') 9' $,,N 3D' (>/ I)G O 3' 9' J (' C F # I =F' 3' 3 '9')3D'))F)3'P/ 2222222222# ;# $, 9(4 $!!.# ''=) = FA( DD) @ 0B 9' 3(' F49 (') 9' ' (' D 3' ' A# '' =F ''4''D''D(*)3'/ =49'D''9';'F)'3 C(3 (;'=)'3F'))/ :A3')')( $$9(4$!!.# 2222222222# 3)'' 3 E''*3 EE)3' Q0K# '))=:'9)3'3D'9'(;)J )=::)E#': ''3 E''=: /1'#'*'9'J)#39'J=4 49' (''/ 3)') = : 3' 9 ';'# 39' ' 3E4*4'= '; )(3' C3')9'33 E;'=/ </ # 3 )'' $! I' $!!- 9 )D'''9 :4 :33''#C:)'(''3');'%-N @' ('=B ' ) 9 DD $ 9(4 $!!. :'9'')3CA#('D='9';'#:) )'C(J(:A'9'));8'DD):''#C
+$-%.+%,,$ *.+$,*
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
+$-%.+%,,$ *-+$,*
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
+$-%.+%,,$ *5+$,*
%%/ ))(3''3'=4' 3'O'P3)J/
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
+$-%.+%,,$ *"+$,*
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
+$-%.+%,,$ *<+$,*
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
+$-%.+%,,$ *!+$,*
"/ =' D' 9A );) 3 9 3)'( C )'' . 3(4 %,,$# '' = 3'8 ';' )4' )'( C )'' ''(')# ' ' J 3'')'3)3)('89:3) )9''=: A('/ </ 9')''*#(D)#'JI)/
+$-%.+%,,$ *$,+$,*
(= (* *( * *
@2.A. B 0.. . ;< #C% D
A.
$/ )94T
A.
%/ IT &/ '=3);'T ./ D( 3' =: 39 D( 3) J )' &, I 8 'D'' 3 3' (() ) '4 D)) # 1EU'MED=' 5# 5,,. # ' A(3'/ )' 3 J 3;)/ ()(' ' G B ''= A(=)'')'4''3)'' =)T 4B A3 3 = ('D ' '( 39' ( )''T B 3 '; 3)/ 1' ()(' ' 3 ' ))( )()) B 4B B '*# '4D))33('8=:' 9)'94/()('('( 39# =' I'# '' = )'' =) :933 =))A3)')@/$&%#$,5$,<B/
;DD'G )'G V' 0 '
)'*I'G A 3)J(('=)3'D''A3'3;DD
+$-%.+%,,$