Administrative Determination Compliance Dispute
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case concerns a dispute over an administrative determination regarding compliance with certain legal standards across multiple review periods. The court reasoned that the relevant statutory language mandated an objective assessment based on the established criteria for each period in question, and that the administrative body erred by improperly applying a standard from a later period to an earlier one, thereby incorrectly finding non-compliance for the initial review period and that the correct application of the standard for the latter period was supported by the record.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Administrative Determination Compliance Dispute: The court reasoned that the relevant statutory language mandated an objective assessment based on the established criteria for each period in question, and that the administrative body erred by improperly applying a standard from a later period to an earlier one, thereby incorrectly finding non-compliance for the initial review period and that the correct application of the standard for the latter period was supported by the record.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive for ordering the appellant to pay the costs.
Testo completo
#$%&#&''( #&')#&''(
* "* + *+ +
$,-. / ! $( &''(
! 0000000000 !" ! # $ !!" %" & ''' ' & $ (!) $* +" $
"!
+ +1 * (%!$ ,-./ 01 "+
2 3%
! " ! , 649 ,
2
0: #! ;;;;;;;;;; "!%" !% $ +"+ <;;;;;;;;;; $ 0! =" 0>>> *"+ $ ! ( $ !% $ %": ! !!! $ 09 $+(! 677? /! @ A!+ * "!" +"" !++ % AA"
?0 ! 6775 "A *@ %" !A+ % " *@ %"
! + ! * $" ! @!" +"+ $A+ " * ""! !" +"+ BC+: +C" A!+ *@2 % % " !" +"+ "+!" * @" %! $%"C C!D 2 @"!$" $@ /"3 + E "" /" F * " !+$! (! $ $ 2 AA"!:
6: @"+!+ $+ + 1 %! 6775 $$ $@$"+ !3 $ $ BGC $ $ 3% H, !3 I 2 !"! $ 0! %! 6775:
!+ *@ +"+ E !+"!C!$+ F $@ " $ ! ( 2 " $@)+"":
?: ! $+ $ ?7 J" 6775 @ A!+ * $!" ) $"+ +"" $ ! $!+ $ "!" " J! "A *@ +""
! ( $ BGC !C!$ $ !":
5: K "(! 6775 @"+!+ ! !+"+ ! #L"! $ A!+ " 2 $" $+: $3! *@ @ A": ! * /! %" "J! +"+ "A" $ "!% " * C!+ 06 $+(! 677? %" + *@ +"" E !+"!C!$+ F !C $ /+: " ! " 2 @" $ $+ " ($!" 2 !+$" $ $!+ $ 2 * J!:
8: ! $+ ! " $ 1 $+(! 6775 A!+ ! "!" " J! $+!" *@ %" !A+ % " $ +"+ $%" M"! *A+ $ %( !C!$ $ !
@!,BGC ( * $ ! ("+ " +"+ !"!+:
9: @"+!+ "!J"+ !! 01 J%! 6778: ! !B 2 $ !$! $+!" $" $ * !" !"!%+ @ %" "+ $@M"! E !+"!C!$+ F !+" 2 " +C!$ * " *@ " !%" %" +"+ $A+ " " A+ 2 "!:
K: %"+ 2 $+"!! " !J" $ !!:
1: "$ 6 ! 6778 ! !( $ + !!" ) *+ *@ % " ! + ! /! !" !"!%+ M !C * $) ! * +"" J*,2 !$!: $" !
405646778 , ?49 ,
*@B! ! $ ! ("+ $@$!" $ ! % "DB !" +"+ (" M " ! @!" +"+ $+: @%" !"+ BC" ! , %" +"+ + ) " "" $ A" B. C!$ !+B $@"" * /! @+"" "J! "!+ "A" $ "!%:
>: '! * +"+ C!$+ 2 JC!:
0: C% ! @!C" J$! HI +"+ $A+ " ""+ $3 0! =" 677? !( " $ ! + $ 8 JC $" !+$" " %, !+$" 8 +" " 09 JC ! H!": 0 ": ! " 89 I:
'" 2 @" $ @+" $ 09 JC ! ! !( A+$+! 6K J%! 6775 H - 0?7 079I !$ C% $ "+ 0?
A+%!! $ " "!"! !C" !""" !( " $ ! $ +C! ! 2 "! JC ""! $ @""" $ @+" $ %) JC !:
6: A!+" 2 N!": 89 : 0 ": B: 1 !( " $ ! L" " * $ """ !+% 2 @!"
89 * " !"% 2 A+$+! ! @!,BGC (C"! " @$"+ $@%("+ $ 68 J 0>16 H I:
' +" ! JC! $ $@ 3 " +"(:
?: ) "! $ @!": ?7 : 0 $!" $ @"+!+ 2 @$"+ "
$ !*@ " +"( * , O I " "!% ! ! ! A"P (I HQ:I I A" "" *@ " !(" )C! $ ! "!%!
"!% %(:
"!% %( " $+A 2 @!": 09 : " !++ !+ "+ %( "!% * "" " $ ""$ $ @"%"+ !++$" )!+ $ "" ! $ @DC " $" $" !! $" ) C !A " ) P @!+ @ " " "!% " A":
405646778 , 549 ,
@!+ * A" %! $ !"" $@! $" "! !$! "" * @ " !(" )C! $ ! +%"! BGC @(!+C!
H!": 0K I:
$ $!" 2 @$"+ $ BGC !+% 2 @!": ?7 @ !"3! +: "" " $ $!" $"!"A $"+ 2 (""! ( "3! $@!,BGC: " "" ! " M"! !+ $ 3! !+ +"+ * " ( @!": 91 H - 06? 089 $: 0I:
5: @ 3 @!+ !A+ % " * +"" ! + ! /! " $3 ! % "!" $ "!% !++: 3C @%! !"! $@M"! !+C+ M !C * $) (!"! * +""
J*,2 !$! " @%! ! ! * ! +"" E !+"!C!$+ F ! *@ %" "J! "DB * %" +"+ A+ 2 "A": !( $ + " " $ $+!! *@ !"! @!+ !* /! + $+ $@""
* " *@ " A" +"+ A+ 2 "!: $" @!+ /" ! * % "DB ! + !" +"+ (" M * * +"" A+ J*,2 BC" $ " @+"" C+ $@ !+$" $ ! !"3! %( $ % "%"+ @ !L" $"(: ! @ !+A3! !!! $ 09 $+(! 677? * @ /! $!+ !L" M * % " !" @%+!! "+!" !:
8: " 2 )! $!+ $ : ' @!": ?7 : ? $!+ $ " ! !" 2 C!%"+ $ A": " $ 2 *. J! $ A" +C3! . 2 "!" J! $ A" $ C!%"+ / " "!" " 2 )" J! $ A" C!% H!": 58 : ? ": $ @!$ ! @!,BGC , I:
/ A" C!% !* @!+ ($ !+ "+ %( M"! !+ $@("! % !*@ !A !+ "+ %( "A %( H!": 58 : ? I:
!( A+$+! $ ! JC+ * @!": 58 : ? " !3C $" @$"!" " JC $ ! %" @+!"! !* !" !"3! J"A" " * $ ! %!
$@ !+" @" "+ ! $!+ $ A)+ ! "" $ " ! $ A" C!% H 6777 R > : 5>I:
C!%"+ $ A" " $+ !* @ ! + !! $ ) ""$ " ) *A" !A $ @!+ " * ! AA!" " A+!!:
405646778 , 849 ,
*" $ %! @ 3 ""$ " @) +! !A $ !!" $+ " )C $ % " " M"! + %!" $ A" * ! !"" BC+: ! !!" @/" "! % !"" $@ "! "!% ! +:
$" !( $ + " * A!! $!+ $ $ "!" " J!:
405646778 , 949 ,
+ 2 "* + *+ +
!
3-4 5 6 78 $9& :
4
0: +! !! !%(:
! 4
6: J"" !!:
?: " * !+$! " C!"":
5: A! !" $ *@ %" A!! !! "! !+" !!M"
$ $+ $ ?7 J! $3 "A" ! !$+ $!+ !( A+$+! $ ! 'BS.!BA* 9 9775 "! ) !: $+ " M"! !C+: +! $" O I $*!
)"" * $+ !!" $+! ("! " $ $+ ""*+P (I ) ! ! * "A " %! $$! "" "! $+P I !"! C"! $ ! !+"": ' +! "" "! ++" ++!+ ""! I (I " I ,$ !( A+$+! $ ! !! "!! "3! ! !! *@ $%! $+!! !!%(: +! $ !! "! ! / $ !% * !" J" * $+ ""*+ " @% $ * +"+ ) +$+ !!" H!": 0?6 079 " 071 I:
C!AA3!O !+$" O
#!, < ! T
A! $ !+" !!M" " "A+ ) !" " '!+"!" $@ "" 2 @+ ! C!AA
405646778