Estate Distribution and Statutory Interpretation of Advancements
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe dispute concerned the proper construction of statutory provisions regarding the distribution of an estate's residual assets following the satisfaction of specific bequests, specifically challenging whether certain prior distributions to beneficiaries counted as advancements against their respective shares. The court reasoned that the relevant statute clearly indicated that distributions made without explicit direction or written acknowledgment that they were intended as advancements should not be treated as such; therefore, the trial court erred in reducing the residuary shares of certain beneficiaries based on earlier, uncharacterized payments, requiring a remand for redistribution consistent with the finding that the payments were not advancements.
Regesto Legislator
Ufficiale; LOI FÉDÉRALE SUR LA PRÉVOYANCE PROFESSIONNELLE ; PRÉVOYANCE PROFESSIONNELLE SELON LA LPP ; PRINCIPE DE LA CONFIANCE(INTERPRÉTATION DU CONTRAT) ; DROIT CONSTITUTIONNEL À LA PROTECTION DE LA BONNE FOI ; BONNE FOI SUBJECTIVE ; INTERPRÉTATION(SENS GÉNÉRAL) ; RÈGLEMENT DE LA FONDATION ; CONVERSION(CALCUL) ; RETRAITE ANTICIPÉE
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAApplied to allocate court costs for the federal proceedings.
Testo completo
%&'()%&' +%&*%&,
!+
+ + ! ! !
- & $ (. /0 &,
!"#$ % &
&
' '( ''' % '') * !" &!" + , - ./,'&012340 %
! " #$ $
71+87
! 1 +
09 :7;<= ! > &," && ?@!;$" ' % '') * &<-&#*A9
19 "&& BB" # '' ' ' % ' ') * :7;<=> &<-&# 9
69 144CA&&; &&&;"60&D1445 ! &" -!&;&";-&& ,?&,"#;& 0,!D14459
39 3&02!144C ?" ! ?;& ";-60&D1445#,#@E- C0&C!& 565@182 B9 & & , 3@22C B9 D @ &F , 593024G9 F " -" ! !&& ? @&,&?@#&&B!&B&? "B&BH &&"&& ","9 ;"& ? "&& BB&" D <-!& 0H,1442:7;<=<-!&1442> &B&! B& !&","9
29 0H,1445&&",-,<-!& ;&" ; B &:7;<=<-!&1445>9
C9 15B",1445B!" ! ?@60&D 1445 & &&;&";-& 565@II2B952&& , 3@325 B9 ; ! D @ &F , 5913C5G ", ! B&H?@# & &&9
59 12,1445 ! B&,#?@&&&&F , " ? ,& J& BF" D <-!& 1442 ;&&& <-!&14459
89 && 8H1445F;" ! ?D &F , "&& &, ; & " & ?@ <-!&& &&"&&;",;F?"&&"0I38,&9 B & "&& & ? && ! B& D-& & " # , ; ,!@"&&--"#-&"&"#-&! 9'", ! B&H?@# & &&60&D 1445;&";- ! & 565@I28B9&&! , &F , 5913C5G 3@325 B9 6@414 B9 ;< ;!& @;& 165@I38B9
I9 ";"04H&1445-BB ! D & 9F;?&F 3
+1506+1445 76+87 &0C!144C,& " " ; &&&;"915B",1445 ?" ? &F , "&& ; D ? ;& && <-!& 1445 !&& ? &F 60 "!D 144C & -&9 ; & & && ;"&" F & <-!& 1442 ?@ ! B&;!;&& <-!&14459
049 "; 64K&1445H& ! , & B & ";9 D& <, ? @&&& ! &H "&" &&" B& ? -!& "&& B # && &B ", "B&B & && ",& ! B& <-!&9 ;!@,&"&"B& ! H& !& &F , 59302G & <-!& ,& "&" ! B" D & B!; B &9B&"B"#J& D B" " 0C!1445015+429
009 6;&!D1445 D "!!?" ! "; &; @J&;"&"@,&&# "&!9
019 && 13 ;&!D 1445 ! ?" D ?@ !&& ! 9 ' @&9 13 9 3 <-!& 1445 & , ,& J& " L, !!! &F , ? & "&" ;;?"L 60 "!D 144C9 &F ,& J& ;" ;?@ & ?&& !; 60 &D 1445 & ;$ && # H?@# && &9 "B&, &F , ,& J& 593024G <-!& 1442 ;;D ; , @&9 13 9 6 <-!&14459
069 & 0C &D & 01 ,!D 1445 ;& & ;&" ;&,9
039 & 06 ,!D 1445 & "&" B!" B& ? "&& - "#H-9
! +
09 B!"!& # @&9 2C 9 0 &9 D -, @-& H :> D & M& & ? &&& &, # ;",$ ;B ;;& &&& ;",$!;$&$& &$!; , ?NF ;"&& ;D&" :& 660 # 660 D-&. & 21 2C " 0 & & 56 B" " ;",$ ;B , ,,& & , &" 12 H 0I81. &031 ,>9
+1506+1445 73+87 '!;"&;H- N;<&"&D9
19 'N&95696B &&&"!""#@&95690& <- ! "B NF;&& ? N" "&" --"9 @;< ;& ;"& ; ! F"&,&"#<,9 !D,!DD;?@$ "&& !":B9# ">9 ?@& !O && ?& @& ; ," ; !;"& & D " !9
69 N,& N& ;", # N& 56 " 0 N& ! !! &#ND,& N ":' &&F B" " & ;" & H; AE& I83 ;90I. ' %) * %7% % A&;B- A ! '*'0I86;9081>9
&& ! 04 H& 1445 && & ;!&9BB&"& ,"&?@& "B&,? & !"#,& ,"&F , 593024G9 ! !;& & B! @&9 8I90&1 9
! &,D9
39 &-;&?& ,?&F ,@;;? ! ? &" D""B @ && &;" 60 &D14459& 593024G ! & 5913C5G9 "B&, ! &&@&;"&&?B& @&9139 6 <-!&1445 @;&&;"& ;,;", @ &?& @;! @&;&9
29 "D!& ,& ;; ? @&9 03 9 0 & , & " ;7& N, , ? ; N" !!& O 7 &&& NE- ,& & # & :&F ,>9 @&9 03 9 1 ;" ? &F , !! N"<, # C8 G # NE- && C2;A!!&B!!:&!& C3 ; B!!>9 & @&9 24 9 0 &&& ;",$ & AD&" # "&D ;& ;&& N-& N !&& & B!& &P ? ;;& , !;$ " & $& &9 ;& ;,&B- N&&&&B &&& <-!&:&924 9 1 >9 ;& ;!& ;& "&D ; N&&& ;",$9:&92496>9;& "-&#N&9 06 9 0 ;& "-!& ;,& ;", ? & F
+1506+1445 72+87 ;&& ,; <HON&,&"&,; B9 &F , &:&903> ;&""?9
@;< @&9 069C <-!& 1445 " ;,& ;, ;&& ," &;&P&?,&@E- && :BF" # C6 ", @&9 0690>9 ;&& & "B& ;& ;D!!& &&&;"& B& , ?" &D @F9
;&&&&;",;"$&&&&@E- 28 ",60 "!D144C=;&&&"- @"L& , # && & " , !!! &F , ? & "&" ;;?"#&& &<-!&,-L:&91396 <-!& 1445>9
C9 ;! ! &&?@F&! @&91396 <-!& 1445 & K ;;? # &F & & D""B" 60 &D1445;;& <-!&14429
H& , ? ! ;",$ ; "& : && & , ; F!; Q 011 032 9 3D> @" & " # @&&& ;",$;&&!!":-> & ;",$ &<-!& ;",$&&&&;"B!", & -"" F? @" !& F;"!& ; & &9 @&;"&& <-!& & < B <- -"" ? &;;D;&;"&&&: Q015645 96011032 93D&"B". Q01I032 9690>&;! &&: Q 01H,144362+41 9690>9
59 @;<B&@&&F& ;&&&?&9 &&F?&"&";;?"<-!&1442# & 60 "!D144C#,? ! "&&E-" C4&8!& 5913C5G :5901G # C4 & 5960G # C0 >9 @&9 13 9 6 <-!& ;!& ; ; !;& &F 59302G # , ? & "&" ;;?" ! &D1445&#@E- C0&C!@F <-!&@,&;"&"! B":5960G#C0&5921G#C1>9&# &?@F <-!&1445&F ,& 295G :29C3G#C0&295CG#C1>9,$"F";!& ; @&;"& BB"!!& ;& && !J! & & !;"? &F&"-!&9B&F"&& <-!& &B!!!!;",;:&903>9
89 F<!,& @F! ! ;&;", & ?:&91190 <-!&1445>9
+1506+1445 7C+87 !< -"" &&& ;",$ & D @!"- "-! ;",$;"& !& @&93I91ABB0# 1C & !! &&& :& & @D& "-&" &&!& & ;;&&">9 ;",$ ; "& @D-& ;& ; ;& <-!& ? & ;,! B: Q 0IH,144581+4C 9190&191. Q016 145 96D00C0I5 93.B9"-!& Q01I032 9691>9
'H; ! B& <-!& &&& @&&& ;",$ & !D ; && ?@ @,< ; D& # "-&" &&!& & "9 & # -& &?;&F? "& ;&"-!;"&, & & ; , "? && & J& ;,"9 "&" @& F& ? & -& & !; F& ? &&& & ; &EA BF9 7 ;& , ?&" & ? ? ?! B& "-!&&@&;&":'1444R 01;925&"B".,"-!& Q0641I 9696&86 9 69192. Q 00,1442II+46 9390>9
;&<!& D B" " @ ;" ? @" &!;&,",&D!& &F , &;" D&& ,& ";& # && & !J! ; &!; ,& && &;": Q06615I 9696>9
@ @&9 11 9 0 <-!& 1445 : , 1442 @ ; "&" ! B";&> ;?<-!&;&J&! B"&&&!;; B &", ,- &?9" ,&J&B!" ! B&:&91196 <-!&>9
@F <-!&:?"!<&F ,B& @E-> "&"! B",BB&0H,1445 &"&"&"B!"9 ;&&F"&"D" 5901G#2921G;A!!E-" C4 5960G#29C3G;A!!E-" C0& 5921G#295CG; A!!E-" C19
I9 @;<@&;&&"?<-!& "&"! B"; B &B!"!&#;" ;",9'H; ;;" 7 &F , &A ; # @F& ! # @!; &F;&&9 B& !&&?&F , ;;D&,- "D& &#&#,0,!D 1445&? ! ;&;", @ &?#,;;? &F ,,-144C9
049 B & # "&! ! ;& ;", @ ;! !&&F ,"&& <-!&14429
+1506+1445 75+87 & "- ,& ;; ? & # ;&& D B " & @&9 3 &9 & F;"!& " # @&9 I &9 ' H; @ & ? & &H ,D : Q 015 6C 9601C 685 96. 1444R(01C;9116R(066;9 1I0 9 1 R ( 050 ;9 180 9 6D> ;!& &$ @F- ? @&&" ;& ;! & ?@ ",& & 9 -!& "";,&D-@ !&&#& # !&" ,&- & # & !&, ,& & " = B& ? @&&" & &, && <&#@"- ; "&!".?@&-&",- !& !;"&. ? @ !&" @& ; !;& !!" &!& @F&& -!& D&. ?@ & B " 7 ; ; ;& ?@ & ! B D ;"H .?@&;A-" ;!!&O-!&"&" ": Q010CC 91&"B">9
009 @ & !&< ;&& D B @ !&"&!B&!&;""9;&@B ! -!& " ?? ;! ? ;!&&& @F- @?@ #BB"&"D &F ,,-144C9BB&&& 3&02!144C && ", :!J! ;& "; ? F &"&"" -"! ? ! & !"#<,>= -!&"&& "#&& &B&", @#B !!& &&9"&&F;"!&;""?"&&BB&" D <-!&1442&?&&! B& 7"&&","9 "? @& # && ? ! ;"& , ; ;& D ;!B&144C;9
019 ! ",<!B "& ,J&H&"9
? B ;" @&9 56 9 1 ; ? & ,&;",;" !;; &;;-&&9@&9 8I% 9 0 ;" !&&, 01 ;&!D 0I82 : > ;",&?;" &-&&;;&9?& "; F?D&&- ,&H & ;!< &@&; &# !&" ";B &"!" &H&"#"-<;@"? !;F&" &- & && @ ?@ ; , @ ,& "; &. ,& "-!& ; & !&< ;",$ ;B: Q01C03I 93.04C016 96.'1+1441;9C4>9 @;< A$;&A<@&"" &??@ @; B@; &# ";9
+1506+1445 78+87
! + 1 ! + + ! ! !
$
23-
09 " ! ,D9
$ 23
19 H&&9
69 &?;" &-&&9
39 B! ;& ?N ;,& B! & ;"& J& " 64 H < &B& ;< D B" " :'A/SAB?CC443 >;, !&< & ;DB!"!&F&981 B" " DB" " 05 H 1442 : Q>. !"! & ? !&B & !$ ;,&;&-& & ! &. & J& " D B" " ; , ;& ; , "&? F & @&9 31 Q9 ;"& J& & ;< ; &,?"!!!$ ;, ,&J&H&#@,9 -BB< ;" & TU * D' "&7H&= ,
;B! ;"&J&&&B"F;&?N#NBBB" " ;-BB
+1506+1445