Liability Affirmation for Foreseeable Harm
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court affirmed a finding of liability against an entity for damages arising from an incident where the entity's actions allegedly caused harm, rejecting the defense that the alleged harm was not foreseeable or was too remote. The court reasoned that the evidence sufficiently established a direct causal link between the entity's actions and the resulting injury, noting that the injury was a reasonably foreseeable consequence of the proven conduct, and thus the entity bore responsibility under established legal principles.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Liability Affirmation for Foreseeable Harm: The court reasoned that the evidence sufficiently established a direct causal link between the entity's actions and the resulting injury, noting that the injury was a reasonably foreseeable consequence of the proven conduct, and thus the entity bore responsibility under established legal principles.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited for the obligation to pay the procedural costs of the Federal Supreme Court.
Testo completo
!!"
#$$$%& '&(&# &
# $) %$ $) & #$%& % )&
* + "
,+ %-+
./ * 0000000000 !" ! # #$ % !!" &" '(") )* (" )
"!
1 % & $ $)& & &$ % 2%% &$ "( )" +, " -$"""! . / !
0 1230
&$ 3
.7 #! 8888888888 90 !+ !!": ( .;6< " !=! ) ) > )'!""7 " / ""! !( "! )" / % %% %%% % ' 90 !+ % :7 )" ) .5 &! 1554 ! *' !"" ) '( " "!&" ! "!""! ("!) !?) ! &"! !*( " ("( ! *' "!&"
/ "!! !&*" "!" ! !!" * '("" $( ! &!
) * !"!"7 % ! $!,7
17 % ! !" ) ! 8888888888 (" -#@ "0!$0!>,, "
$!!, !&0= ) < "?! 1554 !!" ==! ! "
)' $+ ?"(!A !()" / ,$ " )'$> !?"( ?!"7
47 !!" '" "!&( "( "" ) "!& )+ 16 &?! 15547 % ! !" () ) ! 8888888888 ) .1 ! 155B ' "( "" ) "!& !)!7 'A ) ! "> " !A ) )A C"( " / '),! " " !A ) )A C"(7 '"0( "* " !)" ) )"! !(&+" "!( !&( / )!" " "!( !" / ,$7 '),! " "" ! "0( " !)" ) )"! !"" !"!?( / ,$7 !!" !! )! A (* ) "!" "* )" ("( &"7 '"&"( != )&!" D"! ! ! ! )" ?7
B7 ! )( ) .. E 155B % !=( ) !)! $!, "" !"" !"& / ' "( ) "!& "= * 0 '("" !" ) "( ! !?? & ')" ) .5 &! 15547
67 %" / ' " ) !!" % =!( )( )" ) .< ! 15567 E" * *" !"& ) "( "! "
!"! &!" *' " '> ) "( )(*"7 ')" "
*=( ) >" ,!& ) !" * "!? >$* ) !!"
)&" D"! A( E! !) ) !? =()(! ) ! 90 !+ - : ..6 .44 )" )" " !((7 !(=+! / '& ) ()0 "0!$0!>,, ) 15 F" 155B * !" '$> !?"( ?!" * !+& )' !?+ )' !?("* >$"!*7
G7 !! ) 1. E 1556 !!" " / '" ) "" )( " / *' " )" * % )" !!" "" !""
21.3421556
0 4230
) =()(! ! '!0)" ) 15 ! .;<. 9 : ) .5 &! 1554 & " ) )( 7 %?)!" " / '!) )' A !" ()7 +, *' "!" "* A" ? " ? ! !" ,! $* ) ! 8888888888 *" )" )!7 !(=+! (," / ! !" ) '$C " " ) -!?!, ) 3 )(?! 155B * " / A ) " ) ! $+ "
'"(! ?!" ("" ! " "!" "*7
37 !( ) 45 F" 1556 % " !E" ) !!7 !(=+! ! '" " ) )( ! "7
<7 !? !)( !" ! ) !" * '" " )" ) 16 "?! 15567 !+ &! )(!" / )) ) !? '(&+" ) .5 &! 1554 !!" A *( *' !+ 0 &" ! ! "!& '"")" / * ("" '(! !(,+!" ! * '" "!! * '" !)" ) !" * )+ '" 1554 '" "!&( !!D" ) "!&7 ! !("" ) % ! ( * ", !"" *" ! )"( E!+! " =! ()A "(!! ) E 155B % >" ! $!, E*'/ "" (!)7 "!" (!" ! !? ) ( ("( !(& !+ ) ! 8888888888 / +& "
8888888888 ) '$C " " ) -!?!, A = ) &! ' > ) ( / ) !& ?E"&? ) '==!"& ( ,(+!" $+ '$> !?"( ?!" )A7 "A" !"! !"= / '," )' ! ) ) > )'!"" '"0 /0)! !+ )')" )&" D"! A *( A () * )&"
(," )("!! ! *" ) &! '("" ) "( ("" / E! "?( " * ("" ($(" (*7
;7 ! !!! ) G )(?! 1556 !"( ! 8888888888 ! '$"!* " '+ " " !( ) ?" " A *" ) !? H
0 '> ("$) !""" )'?E"&! ) ( ) !& )"& ) '! "! ) &&" )' !7 )==(! ""( ) "!( ) "0( "* "! )A ! !!" D"! ( / )"!" !" ) ( A"! (* ) "!" "* ) .5 &! 15547
0 %'," ) "" "( ) "!& !" ) / ')""! ! !!" '" =!"" A ( ?!" " ! *
21.3421556
0 B230
"!&" ) ')"! ?I""7 '("" ) "( !" "?( / E!7 A !" >$"!* !" " & ' !" ) " !"& / '"(! ?!" ! ! !" A !("" ) A7
! !!! ) ; E&! 155G ! 8888888888 () )E" ) * "0!$0!>,, ) '$C " " ) -!?!, !( ) *' '> ) ( ?E"&? / ) !& & ! !" ) A =="(7 $+ ?"(!A " '$> !?"( ?!" " ! !" )!" & "!" "* ? '," ) ( ?E"&? *"=?7 ' "( ) "!& " D"! E"=( ) != =!"" A ( ?!"7 '("" ) "( " "?( / E! (* "
" ) " ) & )"= / <555 @J & )"= (&( / 45 ) $+ &)" " '$> !?"( ?!"7
.57 & !" ! ) !" 4. E&! 155G7 "" !" " )(!( D"! )'!) * !? !) A !" >$"!* ) !!"7 )( 1< =(&!! ("( =A( A !" ! )! )A )'A !" *' " ) *"7
..7 ! !!! ) ; =(&!! 155G % )*( !! / "" ="(7
.17 ! !!! ) 1< =(&!! 155G !!" ! ( )'A !" !
!! 8888888888 *' " ) *" * ! !" ! ! "(!!"7
&$ #
.7 !? "" !(?" *K " ("" "+! 9!"7 6G 7 . " $7 6 : " * !! " !&? / =! 9!"7 6G / G5 "
.5G :7
17 % E! !) " )"! K"!"( )"!"& E, )&"
)(!! =" !&( * !*K " & ) !("( 9L! !)! ) M& !J!$" B+ ()" ! .;<B 7 .4G N >, )&!O",!$" =, 1+ ()" 7 13< $7 6:7 ) ) ! E, =) )( = ) " "!! ) ! =" * =" )KD"! ("? ) +! !!(="? !" &!?? K"0/0)! * !("" ),!( ) &!?
21.3421556
0 6230
!( )(!"7 ==" ) *K =" D"! )(!( "
$> "$+ ?7 ! " ((" ) =" (,( &,? E, )" ($(" !"! A * !" !?? 9 - .1G 4G5 )7 6 "7 ? N .16 .;6 )7 $7 1 " !(=(!:7 KA"0"0 )!" ) ! ! * K)"!" E, )&!" ""! ) )" =&! ) K!( 9 - .1G 411 )7 6 "7 :7
47 ' + !P" *' '> )'A () )'> * !"" )'("?! 'A" ) ( ?E"&? ) '! "!7 " ) !!" " ! ! "!( ! !?("* ) '$> !?"( ?!"7 0 " !" & '("" >$* ) !!" '" !&( " () "(7 *" / !()! " ) ) &! '$> !?"( &)" )" ==! E!)'$ !!" " ) / "!? >$* ( ! '(&+" ) .5 &! 1554 ) "( & )!!7 B7 ! (*" A !" >$"!* ) !!" E"= * !" " ! ! )7 !" " ?((=( ) ="( !(& ! !"7 4< " ) ! !()! )"!"& 9 :7 ! 8888888888 =!( ! "(( $ ) ,!== *' !!" "! )" )'A !" " !()! / 0 ) ) )( !?7 ! (*" !(" A !" ! =(7
21.3421556
0 G230
# %& . 3 )& # $) %$ $) & #$%& % )& * 55/+
.7 !) A !" >$"!* ) #! 88888888887
17 = ! 8888888888 (" >$"! " >$"$(! B. ! ) %>,, .15B +&7
47 6* + / *7 H
!)! ) '"(,!"( ) )! () ) !!" A! )!! '"!! (! )'"! & =" !)! ! !"
)'A !" (!" " "!"! " &" H .7 +7
17 ( ?E"& ) ! 9)! " ) ":7
47 """ ?E"&7 B7 ,"9: & = ! "( ) "!&7
67 !(" ) 7 G7 ( A *" (=* &" H 7 9: "!?9: >$*9: ),"*(9: "0 / '!, ) '$> !?"( ?!"7 ?7 9: "!?9: >$*9: ),"*(9: "0 ) "( & '(&+" ) .5 &! 1554 ) =Q ? !?? !"R 7 % "!? >$* " !(A"" ')" ) .! &! 1554 0"0 ,,!&(R )7 " "" ) / '""" / "(7 7 ,!( ) "( !() S ) '"&"( !"& A!( 9," ) ) > )'!"":R =7 "( ) "!& "0 D"! ($(" (!( ! ) ! ()7 ,7 "( ) "!& "0 D"! (!( ! ) ! )'!)! !=7
21.3421556
0 3230
$7 "! !"7
37 !* " "! ) 'A !"7
B7 &" KA !" / )( ! !? ) ( / ! & ! !" )A A ! " " )'$!!7
67 (!& =)7
G7 =! !" ) *K &" =!! !! "! !(" !!D"
) )( ) .5 E! )+ "=" ! !)( )!( !? =()(! ) ! %$OJ!$=* G G55B "! A !7 )( " D"! !,(7 (! )" H : )*!
A"" * )( !!" )(! ?"! " ) )( ""*(N ?: A ! ! * "= " &! ))! "" "! )(N : !"! ,"! ) ! !(""7 % (! "" "! ((" ((!( ""! : ?: " : 0) !? =()(! ) ! !! "!! "+! ! !! *K )&! )(!! !!&?7 (! ) !! "! ! > ) !& * !" E" * )( ""*( " K& ) * ("( A ()( !!" 9!"7 .41 .5G " .5< :7
,!==! !()"
!! % ? %
=! ) !(" !!D" " "=( A !" *'/ '== =()(! ) ! ! ,!==
21.3421556