Contractual Consent Requirement vs. Involuntary Judicial Transfer of Assets
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe dispute centered on whether a contractual provision requiring a party to obtain the other's consent before assigning its rights applied to an involuntary transfer resulting from a judicial proceeding, specifically a levy and sale of assets. The court reasoned that the contractual prohibition against assignment, which included language about "assignment by operation of law," did not unambiguously cover an involuntary transfer executed by a third-party creditor under judicial order, concluding that such a restriction on asset alienation requires clear and explicit language to be enforceable in that context, and thus the involuntary transfer did not violate the contract.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 108 al. 1 let. a LTF; Contractual Consent Requirement vs. Involuntary Judicial Transfer of Assets: The court reasoned that the contractual prohibition against assignment, which included language about "assignment by operation of law," did not unambiguously cover an involuntary transfer executed by a third-party creditor under judicial order, concluding that such a restriction on asset alienation requires clear and explicit language to be enforceable in that context, and thus the involuntary transfer did not violate the contract.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThis provision governs the imposition of court costs and was cited in the dispositive regarding the allocation of costs for the appellant.
This procedural rule was cited in the final order to declare the appeal inadmissible.
Testo completo
#$%&'#&(() #$*+#&((,
-. --. - .
)/ 01 ! $' &((,
2! 3333333333
4-. - 4-. ! "# $%&'(
##)*
!"
.$+&.
- 5
/ -0#$%%$1#2222222222#3*( 4 #**! 5)!5!)##6(! 47 4 4 / 4 )## ## (# ! 0!##8593# )):# ,0#$%%$5!*#!*)#*5#;#! $,6/ %/
$/ 4 !< #6# ! 2222222222 !* ! $ 0# 5#() ! = 0# $%%$ >#** ** ) #5? ! (# ! @ $@ 0# 5#! =0#$%%$/
-/ # ! -% 0(# $%%- >#** 6# (# A 4 B># # !*)5 ! 5# )!# *?# 5 44 4C # 6# )B B># 33# ?# 5 (# B )!>#!)#*B##(#***D $$6/@@50EB 55!*)5))!F,%6/ %!(##G(*/
&/ # ! H $%%- >* ## #? ! # !> !)! 5#) 44 4 *3 B ) B# # !H # G (* # A )!# >(#5 **B>#>(#55:!><5###6#A 0/
=/ #! ,!*)?$%%- 44 46#(#B >3#!>#(5!3#5#(* #?! # >*# 5 )5*/ 6! # ** *3* B >*(#**#!)#*6)*)<#!##!*55 !> )# B ! (*#6## *# 5' ! 5 !*)###!)#*(*5!#A!)##/
I/ G##!!$$0#$%%& #?!*>!**)5* 5J!*(*6!!##3/ G*6/
,/ #!$@5)?$%%& 44 4#!#B*B> (# ** * ! 6)# !> )!# )5# 5 4 B ) ! >#!)## (# ** 3)* *BA @%I6/F%;#66B#!#56#)(#6)* 5 !)!/ ** 5*#* B> ) ! =$F 6/ ** (* !)!)#!)$%%&/
+ &$,+$%%- .-+&. @/ (#* A !< 5# A 6# 5(# !*)## #? ! * !)!>5*5!!B**3!*A03 6*(# $%%=/
-
/ (?##* ! ## B )5* ! #? ! * !*0A **!)#5G!$$0#$%%&5*/
$/ !)! *) )?) ! 5 ! 3# ?# # A )!#! @$@0#5#! =0#$%%$B#5*5*#! ! I 0/ 6# (# B # ;# >*(# A $, 6/ % A # ! 6;50/
#>('B>5!3#*B>)59!>#** 66#() ))# )5# 6)# !> ! )!##6#*B#(#5*!*)56# !> # ;# ! $, 6/ % !> 5# ! &= ; 5 )# D6/# ! 44 4 A 4 A >* ! $%0(#$%%&E/ B#5G56A##B6#55J ! ! =$F 6/ 6( ! >*/ ) # ** (* @)$%%&/
)5 ! B# 5*'! #? ! * 5 B B >*?5#!#/
-/ !)!!(?09*!K/
+ &$,+$%%- .&+&.
5 . -. --. - .
!
60272 8 922 2 :" $;& .<=
/ !!5#)5 44 4!"/=$F/.A1# 2222222222L
$/ B!)!!*5*51#2222222222!'!( ?0L
-/ 9!K/ 366#'C *#!C #"" M#4 M *#.0#C 1#N 11
5#6)!5*G#6#*<5#5366
+ &$,+$%%-