Business Entity v. Customer (Contract Breach and Parol Evidence Rule)
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe appellant, a business entity, sued the appellee for breach of contract stemming from the non-payment for goods delivered, with the appellee asserting a defense based on the unenforceability of the contract due to a prior, purportedly superseding oral agreement that modified the terms, specifically concerning the scope of the required performance. The court reasoned that because the written contract contained an integration clause clearly stating it represented the entire agreement between the parties, the parol evidence rule barred the introduction of evidence regarding the alleged prior oral modification that contradicted or varied the clear written terms, thus affirming the judgment in favor of the appellant based on the written agreement.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Business Entity v. Customer (Contract Breach and Parol Evidence Rule): The court reasoned that because the written contract contained an integration clause clearly stating it represented the entire agreement between the parties, the parol evidence rule barred the introduction of evidence regarding the alleged prior oral modification that contradicted or varied the clear written terms, thus affirming the judgment in favor of the appellant based on the written agreement.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive for the imposition of court costs.
Testo completo
#$%&&#'(($ #$)&#'((*
!!+
, !-, . ,! .-
$ / '((*
%0 1 2
3333333333 ! " " #$# % !& &' # (#! &## 4
!
.55- . 6,!7-8-- )* & + ,-./ 01
! " -2,,
5-
,4 "# 5555555555 !#! !6# ( ,)37 %! (!8# 9 01 :# ,)). ;# &%+ ! 1 & ! 1#4
-4 -< :#! ,)). /. !8 ,))< # (!( +( =5555555555 > !! ' ?4 # &% 6# ( ! '# 6@#! & ! 1# &# %(!( ,))A %#!( ( (!( ! #! &% @! !!! !! !#1#!( ,. ,))<4
/4 # !# # &%#&! B#C 0 D E # 1 ( & !!# &% & , !8 ,))< /. !8 ,)))4 > ! & 5555555555 (&#C# & % ( ;; #! &% $( #! 1 &%# !! (# F #' & 8 ( # ! &#(#!# #1 & # & ! '% 1 # ;# &1#! @! ! #4
A4 ,, !8 ,))< % ( &(( 0 & %;;# ! & % C#1#&#!( B#C 0 D E && & !!# &G C #1#&#!( 1#! 9 #!!# ;# ! & 1 ;# !4
<4 & & %H & && % ( 8((;##( &% 8 1!# ! & ! # !6 ;# & ! ( #& & ,7 18 ,))3 ,7 1 # ,))*4 % 0 ! & 9 %# & !6 % ( (!#!
6#' F (! 8# ! 9 4 I! & !6 !
! '%# (!#! &! #!( & ! 1# !#0 &F & 6#4 1#! ;#! 1 &% 8 66! ! &% 1!( ( & ! 1 1 #4 !;# % ( 1#! 8# & 6@ & !6 ;;!( # & 6#4 ## !6 # # 1#! &J @! #! # &% 6# 9 ! 8#4 ! & 6! %1#! (6! 6@( & !6 K5555555555 '%# &1#! # & !#! 8:!4 ;# # (!#! '% # 9 L5555555555 %(!#! &!( # & ;#! '%# &1#! ! & 6!4 "6 ( 8 & !6 ! #&#'( ' % ( (!#! !#8 &%@! 66( !M6 ! N! &#;;#!(4 # I! (&!!# #! #& ! ;# & ! 1 9 % ( ! & 6#6 ! N !M6 !!#4
2,//32-.., /2,,
34 &(## & -* ,))7 % ;( %! # & !!# &% C#1#&#!( 9 %#!( ( 1! (# &! & !4 (!#! ! ' % ( 1#! H !#1#!( & 6#6 ! N & !M +! ! & 6! ! ' !#1#!( (#!#! ; !# (84
*4 -7 1 # ,))7 % ( #! :!( ! !! &(## ! 9 %! # &% ' ! & ! &%#1#&#!(4 !!#! # & 1 ;;!( % ! #! %1# :# ? #& 0! ! 6 ( &&4
74 (1# & * !8 ,))7 % :! & !! ' # (6( ! & ( #! ('#1#! 9 6!!# & ,3GA,A4C ; 4 '# (!#! #84 @ !! 8# & &! & -.O H# &6 ( &%#1#&#!( 8! !!#! 1 ! &% ! &%#1#&#!(4
)4 &(## & * # ,))) ## ! & !#0 &% C#1#&#!( B#C 0 D ##E &# ! ! +( 9 % ( ' ! & ! &%#1#&#!( &0 # & ,))34
,.4 /. J! ,))) % #! :!( & & #! &##! !#; ! !! &(## 0 & #8 ;(&( & ! 9 !# !
9 ;# !# & &(## & -* ,))74
,,4 * !8 ,))) % ( ##! :! & ! 9 # 8((;# &% ; !# !#' !! ' 6## 4
,-4 @! & -7 ;(1 # -... #8 ;(&( & &# ! ( :6! & ##4 #6#! ' 1 #1#&#!( &1#! 06 6(( @! &(! #( &% 0 & # # ' % ( 8! 1! %!!#! 9 !( !! ! & %(1!# & # #! 1 :'% ! & ( & &(##4 %0 1 ; ! ;!!# & # + & 6# &1#! @! (#(4
,/4 # & / !8 -... % ( #; ( % '%# !##! 9 ##! %! # & ;# (& '# %(!#! (!
! #( &1! #8 ;(&( ! ' '!# & 1# %# 1#! & #! 9 ! &%#1#&#!(4
,A4 -/ 1 # -.., % & &(## & ; ! ;# !! '% ! %(!#! #&#'( %0 !#1#!( (!! #8 ' & (#;#' #! (# 4
2,//32-.., A2,,
,<4 &! & -/ # -.., % ( #! :!( ! !! &(## ! 9 %! # & ;#4 1#! '% + %(!#! !#8 & %66 !! ' 6## '%# (!#! 8#6( & ! & 6!4
,34 (1# & ,- !8 -.., % :! & #&#'!
'%# 1#! (!( ! #8 ;(&( ' ! #! 8 & ! 1# !!## !#1#!( ' ; !# !##0 %(!#! (# ! '# (!#! &!( 9 (!! & !(4 '!# & ;# 1#! &(:9 (!( ! #!( ! ;( !! % ' #8 ;(&( & & ! ' (! ! ; # & :!# &1#! @! # 9 F 6 & ! # & !(( #!(4
,*4 A !8 -..- ! ;#! 1# 9 % !#;#! (&# & "5555555555 +F#! '# ;##! (!! &% 66 1!# & (!!
+F#' ! '%# ! 1#! ##!( & !! & ! 1# &# # & !8 -..,4 &&#! 9 1# 8((;## &% ! &%#1#&#!(4
,74 >#! 9 %H & !! && % &(#&( ,3 !8 -../ &%! + ! ! !#0 &%#1#&#!( 9 ! & , !8 -..-4 % (6! !!( ' %H & & #! H ;# (!#! &1 8:!4
,)4 # & -3 !8 -..- % #; ( #8 ! & # & '# ((&#! ! ;# ( '%9 #!#6 &!
C&1! #8 (!#! &1 8:!4
-.4 1#!( 9 #! '%# !&#! & 9 % ( &( ( # & ,/ !8 -../ '%# F#!#! #!# 4 (&#!
!: #!( @! : #&#' 9 '%# #! !!( '%# 1#! & #! !
& &(N! & && 9 %8!!# & & (&!!# ! (' 9 %! # &%#&#!( : #0 4
2,//32-.., <2,,
!.-
,4 # 61# G 6#!# :&### & -- 18 ,)A, B#C 0 E (!( &#;#( ! #8 ! & # (!( #!#!( &0 , J! -../ B;4 !4 , !4 E4 ; (! 9 G !4 / 4 / & &##!# ! #!# & # & ,A 18 -..- &#;#! #! &#! 1! G! ( 1#6 & # (#!( ! &! &1! ## ! & !#0 &G C#1#&#!( ! (!( ! # &G;;# #8 ! & #4 (! & #8 & ( ! &0 (!8# I! & (! #!#64
-4 # ;(&( !# 6(( & & #! & # & 3 !8 -... B#C 0 D E ! ! ( 1#6 , :1# -../ ! I! & 8 &#;#!# & &# & % C#1#&#!(4 &%0 & !!;# (6# &##!# 1#6 :'% /, &(8 -..- (6 & ## ' :6 & # % 9 & #&( !# &#;#!# & & #! & %(!!
& ;#! !( # 9 &! &(! #! & &(## #!#6# B P ,-* A3* #&4 , Q ,-, /73 #&4 ,8 Q ;4 (6! &##!# ! #!# !4 7- 4 , E4 (! #!#6 (' H#( 9 #0 & &##!# & # ;(&( % C#1#&#!( & ,) :# ,)<) B#C 0 E ! & 06! % C#1#&#!( & ,* :1# ,)3, B#C 0 E 1#6 :'% /, &(8 -..-4
/4 (( & ; ! &(# #( # (! ! 18
9 ; 1 ! & !4 3) ! 7A & # ;(&( % C 1## ! 1#1! & -. &(8 ,)A3 B#C 0 >E4
A4 & (& ! (!( # 8((;# &% ! !#0 &%#1#&#!( 9 ! & , !8 -..- &(## & % & ,3 !8 -../4 !!;# &( ( #!# ! '!# & ;# #&( ! '%# (&#! !: #!( @! : #&#' 9 '%# #! !!( '%# 1#! & #! 9 & ! ! & &(N! & &&4 ;;! ! &&#! 9 1# #1 ; !# 1 & &1# # 6 ;# F;; & #4
(! (& ' '!# & &% & ;#4
2,//32-.., 32,,
<4 G 0 G !4 ,* G ( & #! ! & 1 ;# # #1#&#!( & (# ! # #!( & 6# ! ## !!
1 #8 @! 16 &( (# ( & #0 !8 B4 ,E4 ((&!# & @ ;# ! ##( ! B4 -E4 >!
#&( ( ! & ; !# &!#( 9 & ( '# ! 8# # & #1#&#!( 0 F01! &% ; !# ;# ##!# 0 &(8! & %H # &% !#1#!( !#1 ; !# (8 #!# (# #8!
#!( & 6# B !4 3 E4
! : # & !& G8 & & (&!!# & ! ;# '# ! (# ! ;;#! 9 G ( #8##!( & 6# 9 0 ('#1! 9 ' # ;; #! # !#1#!(4 06 6(( G ( G & #! 'GH (# 9 !!#& 8! & (&!!# 1#( # 9 '# #!
# & B P ,-A ,,. #&4 - ! (;( Q > -..- 4 ,.) #&4 -E4
!## G ( ! (!& 9 ; !# &G #1 ( # 9 # & # !#1#!( ; # ! ! 6 1#!( & G#1#&#!( !
! ' ; !# &G #1 ( # ! & !! 9 ;#!
&G #0 !# #!( & ! 1# 9 #1 ;# (1(4 ! # ' # (;( & G#!( ( '! F#H & 6 & ! ! @! # #&( !# #! !!;# : N &(! #! B ,)77 4 -33 #&4 ,E4
>! (!( (# ! #( !! & (&!!# ;# '# ! #8! &# !! 9 ;1 # (&!!# & 1# !#14 G(!& & #! @! &(! #( & #0 8! #! #' ## & # ! & 1# C;# ! ' #! & (&!!# ;# ;&! #1 ##  ! # # ;! G !# H # ! & !4 # '# ! (!& ! # & #1#&#!( & #! 9 ; !# 0! '# ! (# & # #!( & 6# ! ## !! 1 #8 @! 16 &( (# ( & #0 !8 B P ,-A ,,. #&4 -Q > ,))* 4 7< #&4 ,E4
& #! ! ' G ( #! #1#& ( &G #1#&#!( ##! B !4 7 4 , E4 ! (!( #1#& & G !4 ,* # '# G! ;;#! (&!( G!#1#!( !#1 H ( :'C9 G(!! #8! H#6#8 G(!! ' !#!
2,//32-.., *2,,
# & ; ! & 6 1#!( & G!!#! 9 !(4 # ## ;#H( : # & 1 # & #! 9 & ! ! &##!# & #!( & 6# & -. O 1# B P ,-A ,,. #&4 -8 !
(;( E4
34 ! +! (!( ! #! & # & !( &%8& !#1#!( & ? # 1#! &0 &GH# G# ##! &#!# & G !4 ,* 4
; & !! &G & ;# ! !# % ;& ;#! ' G#1#&#!( & ! & (# !4 &(## & -/ 1 # -.., G#!#( ! ' GH # & 8 &G !#1#!( ;# (!#! #8 6 ( G!!#! 9 !( ' & (#;#' #! (# (;( ! ##!
H ! & 9 %# & !6 > #1# % ( ! &%#!(6 !# ;# & 01 & ,7 18 ,))3 ,7 1 # ,))*4
! F 9 G#!#( & G1# ! ! & &#;;#!( ! ( & !#1#!( ( # & 6#4 F#!#! 1# ;; # #8##!( & &1# # 6 ;# F;; & #4
*4 %0 # ;#! & &! ' ;# & ? G! H#6#8 & ! & !4
!H &%#1#&#!( ;#H( #8 ;(&( B! -743 O /3< OE 1 ## ! & #! 9 & ;#4
8 & (&!!# ! #&( ( ' # ! 1#!
H & ! 1H 1 !# &#! +! & ;;! 60 # G (&#! # # #!( & ! 1#4 ! #!# # ' &8! 1#! @! #! & & ( # ! & F 6 ##!( 9 -.C/. M# (1#! &(6 &!# 6 ! 4 ;#! '%#  ! & 6! % ( 1#! (6! !# 6@ & & # # &&! & # & !#! 8:!4 !;# # & (F# & #6 & #&#!( &%&!!# ! &% !#6 # !
#&! &1 ! & !6 ;;!( ! #4
## 9 %# & !6 6# L5555555555 # (!( ! ' ! #! !#8 &%@! 66( !M6 ! N! &#;;#!(4
!6 # # &J @! #! # &% 6# 8# ! 9 4
2,//32-.., 72,,
;# !6 K5555555555 %! (6! 8# &( ( # !6## (!#! 6@( & #!# & !#! F&# # & ! & 6!4
! ' 8 (&!!# ! (6! ! ' % ( %1#! !#!& (# ! & ; !# 1 !F( #'4 > ; !# !#' ! # (!#! 1#684
# % ( 1#! ! 1# & 6#6 ! N ! !M64 #8 & ( !#& %0 !!# 1 ( 1 (# ! #' & 80 ! &% 6# H !#0 ! ! & 6!4
P#! ! & #' # &G8 1!# C &! # # & &#;;( ! ! # C # ! @! #1#4 > 8! 6 (1!# !#' ! !#!# !F( #' & #!( & % ( ! 1#! ! @!! ; 9 #!#'4
!! ' ;# 1#6( ! ; 9 : # & #'% !! #! & 9 G ( #8##!( & 6# 9 0 ('#1! 9 ' # ;; #! # !#1#!( 1# @ ( # # % % !#! H F#;; # & !!#!#'4
;# : # & !#( & #! ! ! 9 % ( &%(!! & &#& ! ' %&##! !# %;; & #1 # %! # ! 9 H#6 1 !#1#!( '# # 1#& #!
#H '% ! & !#; & 1 4
# '%# #! &H ; !# (( % ( BF;; & #& & ! # 6E # ! 1 ! 1 & # & %8 1!# ;#4 ;;! % ( &( ( #C@ H I! & (&!!# 1# # & &#! & !!+6 # & 6# & ! '%# ! H & %#6# H ;# & # 64 # %6#! & %!#1#!( & F;; & #& & !! '% ##' #1# & !F( #' %! &('! %0 1 80 & 6#' &%8! !# ; ?# ! %8 !#'! !! & # # & % (4
74 1 & '# (0& %! 9 :! !#! ' % :!( && & ;# & ! & ! ' (10 #;&(4
)4 ( #! & ,- !8 -.., % ! 9 ' & (! ! ; # & :!# #! # 9 F 6 & ! # & !!#!& !(( # 4
2,//32-.., )2,,
,.4 ! ; # ! &( & % !4 7< 4 - > (# ' ! ! (1# (& # #& ! ## 6 !#!4 % !4 7)R 4 , & # (& &##! !#1 & ,- !8 ,)7< (1#! '! 9 # ' (& ! 6 !#! !#4 (! & :!# ! ; # & (& 1! !!;# @! # 9 F 6 & ! & !(( # #! :!( 9 (60 4 ;;! ## ' #8 ;(&( & % &# #8##!( & ##! 6 !#!( & !(( # #! :!( 9 (60 ! ## 6(( & (& (1 !! 8 F & # B P ,-3 ,<, #&4 A8E4
: # & (#( '% 1( 9 %(F #! @! ##( 9 (!! !0 & (60 !( & !(( #!(4 ;#! '% #! &( 1 & F & 0 ;;#! # # 9 # 9 # ;( ! !0 4 ;!C# '% ((! S #!#'8 S %:! 8:!#1! ! D !# ( &#! 1# !( (& '& 8# @ 1#! ! & ! ! & %!!!# ' % 1#! #8! H#6 &% ' (!#! &( 1 & F & 0 B !#' > ,))7 4 ,)AE4
#8 ;(&( & (6! ( '%# + # & ;# &#;;( ! &% ! !# !#!( # & ; # & (& 9 F 6 &% !# '# 6#! (60 !( & #0 !(( # & % !4 7< 4 - !4 > B!! !4 3, !4 E ! &%! ! & #! H &( % !4 7< 4 - !4 ; > B!! !4 3, !4 6 E & #! '# % (# #!0 &(1( :! & %!# & &( 9 !# 6#! &!# B !#' > -..- 4 3,E4
,,4 %0 # 1#! & &(! # # ! 6# 1 (60 !( !(( #!( :!#;#! H!# ## & 6 !#!( & (& 4
! & (& ' ! #! 6# & #0 !(( # ' #! &J @! #&( ( &( 1 & !! F & 04 ! ;;! :! & !# ' '!# & ;# %1#! ;#! %8:! &% &(## H & ! & % & #8 ;(&( 4
! & &(## ##!# & % !! ' #C# !!#! &%;;# ' !H &%#1#&#!( & % ( &%1# -.O (!#!
#;;#! # 1 # & #! 9 & !!# & % C#1#&#!( !!
(#! ' &6 ( ## '# ! & A.O4 %;;# #!#( %(!#! &
2,//32-.., ,.2,,
H (! ( '!# & ! # (## '! H ;# '#4
! %+! 6# & #0 !(( # (60 # #! @! ;#! H!# ## & 6 !#!( & (& 4
1 & '# (0& (& ! 6 !#!4 ! ; # ! &( & % !4 7< 4 - > (# ' ! ! (1# (& # #& ! ## 6 !#!4 % !4 7)R 4 , & # (& &##! !#1 & ,- !8 ,)7< (1#! '! 9 # ' (& ! 6 !#! !#4 (! & :!# ! ; # & (& 1! !!;# @! # 9 F 6 & ! & !(( # #! :!( 9 (60 4 ;;! ## ' #8 ;(&( & % &# #8##!( & ##! 6 !#!( & !(( # #! :!( 9 (60 ! ## 6(( & (& (1 !! 8 F & # B P ,-3 ,<, #&4 A8E4
2,//32-.., ,,2,,
! .-5 !-, . ,! .-
49 : ; 6< $&' .
9
,4 ( 184
9
-4 :!!4
/4 #! ' (& ! 6 !#!4
A4 ; !# & 'G 1! ; ! (! @!
& &(# & /. : &0 !#;#!# # &( & ( #8 ;(&( & >FT#$ F;'# 3 3..A ! # H# 4 &(# ! @! 6(4 (# &#! D E #&#' H!! 'G &(## ! &(# 8!# # ! & &(## !!'(Q 8E H ' !#; # !# 1# && !! ! &(##Q E ! #6! & (!!4 ># (# !#! ! # ((! (( ( !! E 8E ! E #C& #8 ;(&( & ! !#0 'G# &1 &( # 184 (# & !# + & 1 '# ! :#! ## ' &(## !!'( ! G1 & ' (!( H(&#( ! B !4 ,/- ,.3 ! ,.7 E4
6 ;;#0 D (#&! D
# PP U # > U
(!# C: #! D " # R ""
# ; & (! @! ! !#;#( H !# ## 'G9 G;;# ;(&( & # 6 ;;
2,//32-..,