Contract Breach Over Performance Benchmarks
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe situation involves a dispute over the terms of a contract, with one party alleging that the other breached the agreement by failing to meet specified performance benchmarks or timelines related to complex construction or operational tasks. The court reasoned that the contract's language clearly established non-negotiable performance standards and associated remedies for failure to meet them; thus, because the evidence demonstrated that the required performance levels were demonstrably not achieved by the specified deadline, the breaching party was liable for the damages stipulated within the contract's default provisions.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contract Breach Over Performance Benchmarks: The court reasoned that the contract's language clearly established non-negotiable performance standards and associated remedies for failure to meet them; thus, because the evidence demonstrated that the required performance levels were demonstrably not achieved by the specified deadline, the breaching party was liable for the damages stipulated within the contract's default provisions.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive for the allocation of costs.
Testo completo
$%&'($)''* $%()$)''&
!!
+ !,+ - +! -,
./ 01 2 3 )''&
4444444444 !" ! # $% && !!" '("))*(")
"!
-55, - !- 6 !" ) +, -. "( /0//1%
! "#
602/06
5,
/7 #) &8888888888 ( /954 )'!: : !( )( ( 0 ;(%!!/99.))) !"" ("!;()(!""< '!6% !%%" " %)"( =6 !1 > " ? !1 ) ';;") !@:(=6 !1' ?= 1/"A;!! ?7
07 &':" ) !% " )( '!( )*( ,"! B((; )' !" ) '! %)"( ) /! C" /944 )' "" ) -94 ;!7 & ( A !%" ! ! ! B!" ) .D-33 ;!7 " ()" ;!" ) 0D449 ;!7 ! E! '(%" < 9D.43 ;!7 " ! "")'!6) !1)!6)! "%("" )0D-55;!7= 1/"A;!! ?7
57 !)()0-!/99." !!!!A ";)F%!/99.' "!E( ) !"" ("! " < '!6%)"( =6 !1 ? )' "" ) ..F ;!7 "" !;" '"! ) !"" ("!;()(!=6 !1 >?7 ""%"("(( !B))(;! !'!(= 1-"F;!! ?7
.7 ! ! )( "!% +* ( ) "" )" ' +*;"!E(<'!() )1/!G%!/99F)B) )'!6))F33;!7)""""%!(;) ;" ) +:" "!% ) !! " )( ) '"(!(=;7)( H./5-3..I533--F9.0F"F35F45 19</F ;!! ?7
-7 !!!!)/3C"0333'!(;!(' ) !) !" ! ( !!")'!%"!%%"= &?)' "")I-.;!7)1/!C"0333= 1/I;!! ?7
F7 !)()/. "B!0333" !!!!A ";),G!' "!E() )'"")/..;!7")B) )'!6))F4F;!7)1/!C"03337!)()5G%!033/ !"!E() )00-;!7")B))'!6)) I/F ;!7 )1 /! G%! 033/ 9 ;(%!! 033/ !";( "" ) !""%!()1/!G%!0333=;7)( HF.4/I-FI-I9/" F9I05F 1/4<00;!! ?7
I7 !)()-;(%!!0330"!!!A ";)//;(%!!0330' !( !""%!()1/!!0330'!( %" B((;!"A+:""!%)"";1!") ( A7 )!!%"("(B((;)'!" )/D/F-
2/-3420335 652/06 ;!7 )1 /! G%! 033/ )( ) ';; " ) '!6 %)"( = ? ) 0/ "B! 033/ " %" )()( ) ! !" ) "" ) 54-D/I4 ;!7 .- ) )A1 ! " 033D33/ ;!7 ) "! "!" )'!6% = !(%E B! ! 5B? !1 ) & 2&J&& > 7 ' "!!*G";";) !%)'( A)/!G%!/99I5/)(B!033/!%()" %! B! "A "" " " "(!," ) 5/ )(B! /99F 5/ )(B! 033/ * '%" B ;A" E! " +!:) /99I;) !()!<<G!))!)'!(=;7 )( HII4FF3 105"A" 10."0-;!! ?7
47 04 ;(%!! 0330 '!( ;" !%! < ' ! G";"; ))("'""""!)( A !'(033/)*"* )!! %" !K ! ) .DI-3 ;!7 " ("" ) " ) '( A !1) &&& =6 !1 &?5/)(B!/999=;!" ) -D/35;!7F-?0333 =;!")ID49. ;!7I3?"033/=;!")/5D5I4;!7/-? = 10F"A?7
97 0FG0330!%!*,")' )//G0330! ;" !%! ("" ) " !1 ) =6 !1 ? 5/ )(B! /99F =;!" ) 0 ;!7 /-? 5/ )(B!/994=;!")/;!7/-?5/)(B!/999=;!")0I;!743? 5/ )(B! 0333 =;!" ) 0DI40 ;!7 .-? " 5/ )(B! 033/ =;!" ) /D5I0;!7/3?7 (:"G"("") ")( A !1) & 5/ )(B! /99F =;!" ) 5D40F ;!7 F3? 5/ )(B! /99I =;!" ) 0D300;!70-?"5/)(B!/994=5D./-;!7--?= 10I"04;!! ?7
/37 /4G"0330' ""( !1%!"!!:(!:"!)!" *'!(%" !K!" )/D33-;!7)/!;(%!!/99. 5/ G" 0333 !" & ) II5 ;!7 ) /! C" 0333 5/ )(B! 0333! "%")/D/-5;!7)1/!G%!033/= 15/;!! ?7
//7 ! )A )( ) /4 G" 0330 " ! !!! A "; ) /9 G" 0330 ' !";("")"!E(<'!(""!) " )B))'!6))1/!C"/99I"))(!""" ) !""%!("! ) "")"""")..D-4.;!7F3 =50D350 ;!7 F3 ) B) )'!6) )" 0/D/5F ;!7 F3 %!( ! !% ) '!6) 6 !1 & # L /0D--0 ;!7 ) ?7 "B(;!")5'453;!7)1/!C"/99I)0'30F;!7/994) 5'./4;!7/999).'/50;!70333)/3DFI4;!7033/")599D953;!7 03307(:"" ")'!" )/D33-;!7)1/!C"/99I )'!" &)II5;!7)1/!C"0333")/D/-5;!7)1/!G%! 033/ * ) !" ) '( A ) /D/F- ;!7 )1 /! G%! 033/7 ! ! : ) '"%"( !"% ) '( A "! /! C" /99I " 5/
2/-3420335 6.2/06 )(B!0333("( ;A(<-.D33/;!7 +* ().ID.95;!7"* "B( !%" =;7 )( H 4/.09I < 4/.53F 1 50 " A ;!! ?7
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
/57 ! !!! ) 09 C" 0330 '!( !"( ** !:" ("!<)))!7 ;!(* ")01 !)( A%"("( ()!6%*! !"" !" ) /D433 ;!7 "" !(" * ) ) " " 033D33/;!7 %" ("( ( ) "! "!" )'!6% = !(%E B! !5B? !1) & 2&J&&> !%"<(+( 5/G%!033I03/3"03/5= 15."A;!! ?7
/.7 ! )( ) 0/ "B! 0330 ' !;( ! ) !""" ) !"" %!( )(!" * '!( ' ! " )" )1!*''%" :)B;7!%(*'%"< "*(%"")!" !K'%"%( )+:""!%)"";1!7 '%" !! :!!B:")!:!)!M !(%E"!" "*"!)A!!!)' %""G!("(G"+*( A )( !) )" !(" * "" +:" ) ""(* !)%","!("*"":""
2/-3420335 6-2/06 )" ) !% ) )( "!N" < G! ) !"" %" )! < %!" !("!"; < )) ) !B!"7 ' ! A *( * )A1 )" " )+!:"! !)'("" ! ))'!()1 ! *)!" (!)M %" !K) !"")' "! %"!K)%!"!("!";)) ""*) ""!;!" '%"B%!"7 "!") !""" ( A ) " )' ;!" B1! ) 599D953 ;!7 * %" !""! !B!" ) "" !(( !""" = 1 5F;!! ?7
/-7 ! !!! ) /I %B! 0330 '!( ;!( " < "" )( ! '"! )' !" (:" '%! G : "!!" < B ;7 !%( *' %" (!" < ' /. C" 0333 ! :!*'B((;!")'!" &" )'!" "*' %")1!! "(B:")!:!7!*'%"!K!" 0333%!"A"!!)!)0FD59I;!7""!("!";)C;"*' '%" ("( " " ) ) !" ) "" : %" " ( *' ':" ) " *" !K ! (!) " * ' %" ("( " !"7!""!1;!K'%" !*""'("" ( " * ("" )( )" ) "!7 & B ; %" )'!("()("!( !;"*'%"()""!:(' ! !K ! ( A !%" ) 01 ! ! +!7 '!( ! !%( * "" )" !""" ("" ))( )( "!:" "!("!"%*'%"B"" ! (!)(")= 15I;!! ?7
/F7 ! )( ! " ) 0. ! 0335 ' !G"( ' " " ;!()()0/"B!0330!;"!7'":!) !" !(;(!( A !:" )(G< )(% ( !%" * '!( %*" ,!:" !(()")"(!))))!= 159 ;!! ?7
/I7 ! (!"! ) 0. %! 0335 '!( "!G"( !! "! "" )( !1) ")!!"1! &2 2 =6 !1 ? !'"!)%" !(B"< '"!)')()"!"G!;)"!)!)"(:!"(" ! " < '" ) )( ! " " < ! ) ))(!"""7 !%(*'%"))(!) !" 0- ;(%!! /999 !1 ) ) " !*' '("" !K * "" : '%" ("( ! " ) ) "" ) !"7 '("" * 0. ! 0333 * )!1!%";;"%"("(!( !"! ")""
2/-3420335 6F2/06 : "*'%" !K"") 0FD59I ;!7 !("!";)!"7 '"!%%""G!)(!(""A")!" 7 %""!;!(' ));")!" !" & C"03337!!*!")")+!:"! !) ' %"(*':")""))A1 !)'( A %" ("( ( ;! )'!6% " * '( A %" ) ! B!"7 '!( ! ; ""( ) "" !(")" %!( < "!" !" ! * B ! " ;;"( !' 7
/47 ! !(% ) 0I G 0335 ' ! ( !G" ) !! " ;!"))(! "7"")'B!) !((*)( !""" ) /9 G" 0330 '%" ;" 'BG" )' " ) )( (: ) "!" G! )1 ";" B *' ("" "!( ;!7 %" ,"!""() )!) !()!* !"" *" ! !; ) )) ) ! ) '!( ! "" < !""!)..D-4.;!7F37 *!"!' !%E(< !(()" )( !(" * ':" ) B ; ) '!( %";;"%"!K !1!)()!" &)"()4C" 0333*)()!" "!E(<'( A7#%"< '%)"( ) ( A ) )! ) '(+: ) !! ) * %"%'!('%":(*"")!"!! )" < * %" ("( ! " ) ) !""7 1 ! )")B;'("" ! ))' 17
/97 ! !( * ) /4 %B! 0335 '!( "(:!" !"( ) "" !*(!" )" ; ) )("!! ; ) B ;7 ! A *( * ':" ) )( ) /9 C" 0330 "")!1!%";"'BG")'"""B");!)") /9 C"0330"*B*""""""A%""( )) ) ! ;" )(!! (:" !(" ) !" * )" )( '("" < G! "G! "!( ;!7 ! ! ! ! !(()"!:"7
037 ! ) * ) /0 )(B! 0335 ' (:" !"( ) 7 !%( * )) ) ! )( ( /9 C" 0333 ! '!(;;!")'"! !("""*'6")"" !("7'%")'!(%")'! !(())!! !(;(!" A !(" A !" ) !( * !(:" A%")))!")( O")'!("7 "! ! ( ) !( " ) /9 "B! 0330 )!( ) '!( ' %" ( !( " ) )) ) ! " '%" !(: "! ! !%" * (!"! )%" (:" ,"! ! !("7)()!""")/9G"0330("")1!
2/-3420335 6I2/06 "!(;!;")!("")!"":*") ! ) !"" )C" %!(7 &':" ) !:" !" B ; ) '!( ' E )!+; !( ) ) , 1! * !(()" !%" * '!( '%" ! "( B:" ) !:!7
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
007 !(!"! !1*,")09%B!033.'!(" " !(" * "!!" < *'%" ;;!( ! !("" ) ' ! ) ') ! ) ( A '%" G :"( " ("" )!( ) F/DI-3 ;!7 ! (7 )!+; A *( * ( A %" ) ! B!" ) "" ) )A1 !7 " < % :( *' '%" :( %!" ) !("!"; !K ! *' " * ' %" ("( ;!( )';; ! ) "7!!'A !"*);;";!K"
2/-3420335 642/06 ;;!" )' )( ! "(!! < '( 0333 ' ,+" ) !)! ) (( , P 7 !)" !";" ) E+: #)88888888)"()0/"B!033."""");"7
057 ! (!"! !1*,")/3G%!033-' (:"" " !%" * '!( '%" ;!( ) ;" !" "";1!"!!"<*'%""G! !(")7!! !1!:" ! !1) & 2&J&&> "! !6% "!"( ! '( A ) '!( ("" !+"B %" ! (+(B*)!! %")1!) !""" 7
0.7 !! ;""(:( !"") !"!"! !""* )B) !"Q)!"R6 !17
!-,
/7 :%!'!:"G)!=?("();("""()1 /!C"0335 !B")! ()-G: )" !()""%6 !()"- (""/FG:!=!"7/"7 !"-F ?7
&"<'")'(")/FG:! ! !B;()(! 0IG%!033.= >/53/3F?!) :%) "(/5;(%!! ) ""!"!!:" !""" !B")! ) (:! ! < "! G: ""! ) '""" ) '(")%AG:!7
07 ;!("<'!"7575)) ""!"!));" ! '!:" G)! ) /. %B! 0330 "!)" %" '"!( %:! ) " )" )%" " ) !! " ("( "! )';; !B " ) ! """ " * ! """ "1! ) !"" ("! ;()(! " " =;7!"7 -F ?7 & (" ! G:!))' 1"("B7
57 '"(!( * '" (( ! )( ! !(" = "? ) ' " "!G"! !! ! (!" " ) "!" G! * %" ";"))(! "=!"7-F-9"F3 "!"7.5) ! !""" ("!<'!6%"!%%" " <'!6%)"()0-"B!/9F4S T?7 "!G"())(" ;! !!"!!")1!!%B7
.7 &!;) !B)(!1%*)(":E"("(!) )")0.!0335"""!("");"G!)*")("!" !""<0330 !("":!A(<1!)) ")
2/-3420335 692/06 " ) !1:" %:! G*'< "" )"7 ) " (: !")1!"()!"!7
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
'")1!%*'""G!)'+;;"( !' ))()/4G"0330)!1!("""!(;!;") !(")"!"G!;!("<'!"7.0 7
!B ) ( !1%! ( * ' '" )(!( )'!) ) !()! "" ))( !""" "" B) )'!6)%!(/9990333"033/ !"")0/D/5F;!7F3 * !""")":<05D..4;!7)..D-4.;!7F3 !(()" !(( =;7 !16%!B ) !" ! ) !" ) F "B! 033.?7
F7 & )! ) ": *" ) !""" )' "" ) 05D..4;!7
? &'!"70.7/ ' ""!( B((;!<< +(!"! * '" "( !B!" ) "" !"" E( )C"7 "; B((;!*("") B;'""< !""" "" !" * ) ! M !" ) ;" ) "");;=70?7 A"!)'!"7/.)!1:")' ") ! !""" ("!<' &2 = ?!* !"<!""")'!"0.)("")B;"
2/-3420335 6/32/06 * !""" ""!" ! +!: "! !) !( !""" " ;! 'BG" )' ! "" !"7 +!: " )(!("! !)!*'"(!(B((;"G!) !"" )"))))!""""*' 1);!" !%)'"%"(!"%=70?7
! ! '!"7 // B((;! ! !("" (: )" )(!!<';;"";"%)"!<"!N!);")"" ) !""*"(! !7
& G! !) "" D:! ! D!( ) ;" *D D%" )!"A !""%!(;;" !)""!*D("")B;7 ;" B "O" * B((;! ) !"" " !) B " )D "" )D (:: :!%7 D" * B ; "" * )" ) ! " A )DB( !* ;" * )" < DB:" ) !""! =%" ) )%! )D!)!:!?" "B< !"");< (:::!%7 !%+D!( "%*!B;!*D" D ;"; """ *D %" (:1! ) DB:" )D! ) !:! = > //0 /35 )7 0 //3 /43 )7 5?7 E (:: :!% *) E" )!" ;! < * " !B" ,"! A:( )D ! B ) )!" ) "")"*"),!"= >//3/4/)75)?7
B? ' 1D;;!!"(:::!% )(!" < " ;" * "" ) !" !! )" <A;;"%"!K)!"*B;!" ,"! !"(:( " DB:" * " ;" ) !""! !"" )C" !K ) ! !7 O"( '!( 1: ! D" %! *' )%" %! ' ) "" !K !("!"; ) !M "*""(""("!"*) ;"' )%","!!"7 "!;"%!*)( " A6)( !% )" ;;! ) G%! 0333 ' ,+ ) !)! )((,P 7 ""%!(:::!% " )1! * B ; (!" )D,"! !"(:(7 >" ! ! %! !(!"( ) "" (* " < ! ) DB:" ) !""! !"")C" !K7
>!" )")""!* ")%!","!%7
;;"*'!%(<G"""!'"('!( %" :!! B:" ) *! "" +:" ) "" ;1! < ' 7 +* ( % )( )'"! ) !"" ';; ;" !%! A !( )A !!! )* !!" !" * ""
2/-3420335 6//2/06 :"")")!%))( "!N"<G! ) !"" %")!<%!"!("!";<))) !B!"7 " !" !:!""B * '!( % ) @: " ) )");"()<)"!""*"" ("" ( "! " * )1 ! ' %" ("( !" ) )(!+7')! *'' !"" *();! !%! )'"! !:" " * +:" ) !" !" &C"0333!"!")( A)""))A1 ! 033/7")'"" !(+B*''" %(' ) %!" )' "" !("!"; ) 0FD59I ;!7 ! 03337 % ) G! !) !("(B; ","!!7
!"!!"(:::!%71!* B ; " ,"! !" DE )DA! "!%!" ) "" (* !(! ) !""" ) !"" )C" !K7
*!("";1! !B)(!1%! ! * !6% )' "" "" ) 033D330 ;!7 !%" ) )A1 ! ) ( A " ;;"%" !+"B "" " ':" ) " ) "!1 ! ) "E B " !(%E B! " (7 >! " ) ""! * '!( ! ! ) '*""!) !""!K"! )'"")05D..4;!7
!"";!!!!G"(")(! ")' )0.!0335;!(""*' !"!!""")'"") 05D..4;!7
2/-3420335 6/02/06
! -,5 !,+ - +! -,
07 8 9 :# %;) -
7
/7 (!!!)0.%!0335!%BU
7
07 !G""U
57 ;! )( ) !; ) ! ) ' ) 0. ! 0335 < !!)'"")05D..4;!7) !"" ("!" )C" !KU
.7 "*'("! !K)')"((7
:!;;!V !()"V J) # !("!6G!"V >!#
;!) !("!!,""";(A !" !:!;;
2/-3420335