Valuation Standard Mandate Dispute
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe dispute concerned the proper calculation of the market value of certain assets, specifically involving the application of valuation standards and methodologies, with a central issue being whether a particular standard was mandatory or discretionary under the relevant regulations for the date in question. The court reasoned that based on the regulatory language and its previous interpretations, the specific valuation standard was indeed mandatory for the relevant period, thereby rejecting the methodology used by one party and affirming the valuation derived using the required standard, which significantly impacted the final monetary determination.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Valuation Standard Mandate Dispute: The court reasoned that based on the regulatory language and its previous interpretations, the specific valuation standard was indeed mandatory for the relevant period, thereby rejecting the methodology used by one party and affirming the valuation derived using the required standard, which significantly impacted the final monetary determination.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThis provision was cited in the dispositive for adjudicating costs (costs of the appeal).
Testo completo
"#$#%"&$"#" "'("#&&)
+ * ,+- - +* -
#. /0 '' 1 #&&)
2222222222 ! " #$ % $ &' (()'" (""$
33 - -4+*5 - ( " "' *+,-.%
!
30/13
+ 3
('"" ( 0 4 0221$ &55 & ## 3 6"3. 7$ (""' (&"%"(" ' %"-!( 88888888886"3. 7 "'&99 "9- '% " ":
(" " " $ "9($ -)&99 "9" " ':
('""""( " "(;,%40221$& 9' ( " &99 "9 '%'9(:
((0+%40221$ - " "( &99 "9%" ((':
&"%)"" <(.(9($ " "9"".("99"":
((=('40221$ "4"%" '& -'( $ "9">'('"9"02('40221:
'" (;,('40221$& ? ()@ $ %"-" "(&3"( "")&-&@ (;0%40221 ( "4 ( ' ( ( ( " "A 3-:
' 'A('-?A ) "$" ('(' '%':
* *
"A%"&A" "?("""67' '("9"' " " '$ (. ; B 022C$ "4 ( "$ ' ( D ?A$ ( '"( %"3'"( $ D ' ;E ?A 6 F; F DE 7:
" - & " ( &' " ( ;E ?A $ "4 9'('0,?%"02216 5;C2;2E7$( "A%"( '$ ;C 9'%"$("" " " "A "4 ( " ( "'A - " ?A " "$ $ ( & (&' "(%>?A:
/010,/21 3C/13 9' - G F DE F ; F <F0 $ "4 ( "H ( " "%-&3"%"(" '(0D 4;+E=:
' ?A((&. ""' 4":
" 9'(' " A'' ( (" ( " ( E 4 02226 7 ' %"A ; ?%" 022C$ H ("9" " ( 4 ("" " 'A ( (" ( "F # '"$ " ( %" ) (" G") (" @ <' - ". ( "" ) .A "4 %"A I9" ?"(") (' " (" 6 5 ;0,1E,"(F;$;0E;CE"(F14 '9'7F %<$ )"'($ -('9 (.A " " "$% (" G") '% (. ? ( ' %"A6 5 ;;, +C "(FE4$;;0CE2"(F1: ! ;++=JC,FC;E"(FC47:
"4&.:
& F DD ( " 9'(' '( ("" "% 6"3. 7$ "%-&99 "9($'%" )"" K L;
99 "9F #9" "'""$('""(& " '"9'" '%" )& '% & (&99 "9: & " ' ( $'"( &"&A" (&.A$@(" .('M ( F C & " '('"( " &99 "9- ) & " ' "9'" &%" "': (( ( " " ( &99 "9 " '('"FN:
& $& FEE("A%"'(("" "%'%" )"" K L;
#9 ("" " 'A "$ 99 "9 - " ) & " ' )" " ('"" )' &" (' &>' " 4 F 9"$ )& " '@ 4" "%' '(' &* $ ?"(" " ( $ (( ( " ( " '@ A% '$ " " &99 "9FNF
& (" )& " " ( ?"( ( "4 9'(' ( "%-& FDD $&99 "9(" @ 9'""$"* ") ) " %'$ '<' - $ " @
/010,/21 31/13 %'$ ) ( " "A " "$ ) ( &" '@ ( &("" ""&" '@ (? ""469F 5;;+D2, ;2E;=7:
&')A ( (% @ ? 'F
OOO
* 3 - * ,+- - +* -
/
6/7 8 9 4! ':# -;<
;F '%4F
0F ? ((( " "(&99 "9F
CF '%" ('(F
1F 9 " ( )& % 9 ' @ ( ('" ( ;2 ? (. "9" " " (' (' "4 9'(' ( $ #<P"Q<9)" E$ E221 $ " >"F ('" @ A'F '" (" K 7 "(") > )('"" ('"4 "" (('"" )': 47 > ) "9 " " %" (( ('"": 7 "A ( ' F #" '" " " '' ''' 7 47 7 "3($ "4 9'(' ( ". )&" (% (' "%4F '" ( " * ( %$)" ?" $"")('"" )' &%() ' '>'("' 6 F;C0$;2E ;2=7F
A99"K '"( K "" 44"
"9(' @ "9"'> """)&-&99"9'(' ("A99
/010,/21