Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ATAS/166/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/166/2005 Generato dall'IA

Contract Breach for Sale of Goods

Numero d'incarto ATAS/166/2005
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Parzialmente accolto (Partially Allowed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The dispute centers on a contract involving the sale of goods, where one party alleged that the other breached the agreement by failing to deliver or accept the goods as specified. The court considered whether the initial communications constituted a firm offer and acceptance, focusing on the relevant terms, particularly regarding price, quantity, and delivery schedule, while also examining defenses related to contract formation and performance under the applicable commercial code. Ultimately, the court determined that a valid contract was formed, finding that the evidence supported the conclusion that one party failed to meet its obligations, thereby leading to a finding of liability for breach.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contract Breach for Sale of Goods: The court considered whether the initial communications constituted a firm offer and acceptance, focusing on the relevant terms, particularly regarding price, quantity, and delivery schedule, while also examining defenses related to contract formation and performance under the applicable commercial code. Ultimately, the court determined that a valid contract was formed, finding that the evidence supported the conclusion that one party failed to meet its obligations, thereby leading to a finding of liability for breach.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
contratto commerciale modalità di vendita difetto della cosa accettazione della proposta responsabilità per danno da prodotti conclusione del contratto

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The dispositive orders the appellant to pay the costs of the federal proceedings.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

               #$%#$&&' (#)#$&&'

(

+ (,+ (-  +  - ,

./  01 2 $  $&&'



   34444444444  !   " "#$%#   &&   ##  '(!##)(%!#%%

!

 34444444444  !   " *+ ,% -  '(!##)%(%!#%%

! 

,  5-6  + -  #(5#  (, ( +,  , +7 + (-  5 8 9 #% !!./01

!

3-(,-  ,  :+   ! /223 4

 3,(

                 !"

  *367* 





.:   $;! # 82 % 3223  %< #  %0  %!   (  #%!% #  %; ! !(  .. 1<  .=77   "# +>>>>>>>>>> ( ?>>>>>>>>>>  .=/8 ! "%  +>>>>>>>>>> (  .=/8:

3: &  @%55  / # #%%!%5 # $;!  (%!(  %< #  %0  %! #( !; %!%(#1% # (1A 5% )% "#+>>>>>>>>>># ! %;! #(()B  %# (1A+#!% " #1  #.'7C2

5 :B%# (1A#"% +>>>>>>>>>>:

8:  %<#'!  !#("% +>>>>>>>>>>B1  B"# +>>>>>>>>>> B !%!  #'%#%!( ()%!<   # ' !: .3/     # .'3.C 5 : 72 $)'B   # !! # /8DE83C 5 : F5:@%55 9##%%!%5#$;!#82%3223G:

/:  H*(H ! %! $!(  #  $;!  !!    %% # #%1 :' !%!!! !!#'%#%!(()%!<5%H( ! $;%1%:

9:   I!#./ 3228  #!%(@%55 9##%%!%5# $;! #  %0  %! ! #( "%  +>>>>>>>>>> B 1   B H*( B!%! #'%#%!(()%!< #' !:.3/   #.ED725 :$)'B #!!#7/CE.7/5 :D2:

7: &%%#'   (5  %<5(#( # I!#.D#(<  3228  ( ' I! #    # !%   )%   '%#%!( ()%!<#' !:.3/ F@%55 9##%%!%5G! #( !; %!%( # !!%# !%!%!( #(5# #!# (# %; %! # .3 1<  .=77  .3 !<  3223 #! B )  $;!  J!#%1 !#1#(5%%!%5:

C: 5 (!H%#( !#' I!# %<5(#(   #!%  ! %    %< # (  #! # / $1%  3229 5% )'% #(! %!! (%# 1% # (1A B! 5(   B%#  (1A### :

D:   % #./$1% 3229##  )%! 5 !#1%  #H*(H !:.2..DDC2:21 ! 0#+#!% #%< ;#'&& :

    63863229 *867* 



=:  %< # (  %! (  % #  (1A #   # (!<%!<%(#%H#!#01* K %!#% %)   !! # 1%   )%   "%  +>>>>>>>>>> # ! %;%!! .31< .=77!.3!< 3223:

.2: &   %  #  K # 3D $1%  3229  !!%!( #   !!% #  !%)%#! %; ## !#CC=E/2/5 :=9B#! #.3!< 3223:

..: #!(!(! %H !%#!#8.$1% 3229:$ %#%!%    %#%)( )EB #(5! #E< 1!% #E%%  3. 5(1 %  3229   I!  %! # !!<:

.3:   )I! # ##   %<  %1%!(  K B % 5%   )  !! # .E7C2 5 : J #  % #  (1A # "# +>>>>>>>>>> '(!%! %# !!%# !%:

.8: ./5(1 % 3229 K5% ()!!#.E7C25 : J.9% 3228 '(!%!  % #   !!% #  !% #(! %( B  #! # .3 !< 3223:

./: #!(!(%)(H !%!; #(B$; :

.9:   %  J; 55# %<#(.D5(1 % 3229##  '!(1 !#'%!( I! %!# (1A)% 1 (B H*(:

 -,(



.: E !: 39 #  % 5(#(     %<  ; #   (1A  5%1%% 1%1!!%1%#%!(#.C#(< .==8F+G ! (1%; . $1% 3222 0; (# ##%1 : ) $%!!#' #  !!%# !%B !; F !:.33! .38 # %1%* G$;#%##%1 (!!#E !:C8: .#%5(#(   (1A 5%#39$%.=D3FG%!B 01 %<!# %#%. L!3228#%!  0)E55% %(!(! %F !:./3 GH(! #E55% !;  <#(# ( !%!%#(! %( $;##%1 .

    63863229 */67* 



3: &E !:33 +F1! 1%; #%. $1% 3222G ##%1  !!%# !%)%# ! %;! !;( 5 (!H !:.33.38./.!./3 M !:8B9+E%)!  ;%!!B! 5(  F:.G: @)$%! !!%#  !%B !;  #B#%55( !  !!%# !%;!( # 1%  # %<  ; H%!! (1!!  ! # #%1  !   !!% #  !% ;!( # 1%  # %<  ; H%!! (1!!!#%# %;F5: !:3/+G:  $!B !!%# !%!BE1% #%< ;H%!! !#%# %;%!( I!#!##%1 F + .3D382M +.3=///G:

8:  '0  %< 5(#(    #(   !;   %!%( # 1%  #  (1A!%!( ## #!# (# %;%!#.3 1< .=77.3!< 3223#!B)$;! J! #%1  ! #1 H(!% :  !! #L    % #  (1A # "#+>>>>>>>>>> #($B(!(! 5( ( B%# (1A#H* (H:

 &  #!  #%!  !!%!( #   !!% #  !%  (!( )% #! %; "% +>>>>>>>>>>!'(01BCC=E/2/5 :=9(!!  (%( )   # .E7C2 5 : ! 5( (    % #  (1A # "#+>>>>>>>>>>'! %#!!: %%##  #%!BH*(!!#8D=EC235 :92FCC='/2/5 :=9N3G:

/:  ##  '  1 ! #'%!( I!     !!% #  !% B ! 5(  BH*(:

&$ % ## %!#%!%%!(B#%!( I!!%    '1%  #  (1A ; !%!  %!% #   (1A:  1! (;! ) #!%5%!<#( !# (#   !; #  !!% #  !%   # #%1    % B H(!% %! 1%!1# ! #:5# %!55!)'! !##%1  !! 5 !# (1A# !%'%!%!!%# (1A55!# ! (%# 5%!1'1% )% 1%!B #%1 (  !%#H!!%1# (1A%)'! $%!#%1 ( %  5%!   # %!( I!   '< #  1%  # 1%% F + .3=  39.G:  () #%  $  #(! %!     !; $)E ! # ! 5 ! #   !!% #  !%  #  #   $%! #%1 ( <((5%%%  # !!  !!%  # %! B # %!( I! !%     !! # *%:  %!( I! ! (  !H %% (;  E !: .3 # E #     (1A  5%

    63863229 *967* 



1%%  1%1! ! %1%#%!( # .D 1 % .=D/ F 3G    !H (;!%  % %*% ! ( %  F +  <%(  87623 # .D $%! 3228G:

9: (!  J (# (!!; !%!F !:C8:3! D=K:.#%  (# #%%! !%1#.3!< .=D9* G:



OOO



    63863229 *767* 



  -(,3  (,+ (-  +  - ,

 0;   <  =   :" )*$ -

.: 1%! %# (1A# #(!<%!<%(#%H #!#01* KB! 5(  #!#"% +>>>>>>>>>> #8D='C235 :92B+#!%#%< ;#'&& B4 51 #"#+>>>>>>>>>>!P>>>>M

3: 1%! %# (1A KB1  #!!#%!( I! !% !H#(! %(#%#( !#0.3!<  3223$)E!#! 5 !M

8: 'A#!!)#<%M

/: %!)'%'! J#'(!%(#'%#%!(M

9: 5    !% #  )E 1! 5     !    (!  I! #  #(% # 82 $  #0  !%5%!%   % #( # (  %< 5(#(  #   &@Q%R @5)% 7 722/     ! % H% :  #(%  ! I!   ;(:  (%  #%! N G %#%)  H!! ) #(%%   ! #(%  <!%   % !  #  #(%%!!)(M<GH  )!%5%!%1% ## !! ! #(%%MG ! %;! #  (!!:&%(%   !%!   ! % ((! (( (  !!  G <G ! G %*#  %<5(#( #  !  !%0    )E% #1 #(  % 1<:(% #  !%  A #  1 )%  ! $%! %% )  #(%% !!)( ! E1 # )(!(H(#%(  !F !:.83.27!.2DG:    ; 55% N  (%#!N   -%#  "  %         

%5 # (! I!!!%5%(H !%%%)'B'55%5(#(  # % ; 55

    63863229