Affidavit Lacking Oath Invalidates Factual Support for Interlocutory Appeal
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case addresses whether a legal filing, which included a document styled as an affidavit but lacking the mandatory oath or affirmation, was valid for the purpose of an interlocutory appeal concerning the grant of an injunction. The court reasoned that an affidavit, by definition, requires an oath or affirmation before a person authorized to administer one, and because the document was presented without this essential element, it failed to qualify as a statutory affidavit and could not support the appellant's attempt to present factual evidence outside the record to support the interlocutory appeal, leading to the dismissal of the appeal for want of jurisdiction.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Affidavit Lacking Oath Invalidates Factual Support for Interlocutory Appeal: The court reasoned that an affidavit, by definition, requires an oath or affirmation before a person authorized to administer one, and because the document was presented without this essential element, it failed to qualify as a statutory affidavit and could not support the appellant's attempt to present factual evidence outside the record to support the interlocutory appeal, leading to the dismissal of the appeal for want of jurisdiction.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court ordered the appellant to pay the judicial costs.
Testo completo
&'()*&+((, "&-'.&+((/
"
" #" # #
#0 - % -' 12 +((/
! "#"$%$ #" &%" ' "'"% ((( ( ( ! )"* + $,% ',,
'%"
- ! "'# "$%,'! ,%,$ , "'% .", /0! #'% 122! 3133 45 12
! "#! $% : 16; :
3"
3< -% = '5 ,",% #"4 ->>, "$?,' #% @,:#"4 A 39 5", 177/< -% ,, 5 '5"," $,:" -,,%,' 4 %% % 39 5", 177;<
$%$ , )$$>, #"%%,' %' , @,:#"4 A #, 10 $)" 177/! ",' - ,#,%$ %"5, #?4" 97B<
1< " $,,' ; C,% 1779! "5, " %' ->>, %' -#', @,:#"4 ( A - ,>'"$ +-, #,% 5"% 33 13 C,% 1779! '%,> + "% %% #$",'! -$%,% )%$ 45 "$," ',%,' -"%< 17 "4?% -##,%,' ', %' %,4" DE? @ A<
8< -,%$"$! "#"$%$ #" &%" ' ((( (! >'"$ '##',%,' F #%)" 1779< "##$ +-= >, ', C, 1779! 5,% 5"%, ' '," #"' +- 'D,%,% #"" 5 D'" 45 33 13 C,% 1779G + 3" C,% 1779! ( -5,% #",$ , ,,+" % *% ' $C'"! %" #"$,,'<
#"',% %%%%,' $%), #" ' $, %",%%! " !
F #%)" 1779! * %" + H->>%,' $, '% '>>" %% %% #%,% -% # '%":,,%,' >'" #'" +- -)% 33 13 C,% 1779H<
/< " $,,' " '##',%,' 18 '%')" 1779! "'# "$%,' ->>, %' -#', @,:#"4 A! '%%% +-, -5,% "I #"$5, >5'") $,:', - +% = #$",' -)! '>,"$ $,,' ( <
9< -,%$"$ ,%"C%$ "'" 18 '5)" 1779 '%" ,% $,,'< "45 + ' ,#,%$ %"5, % 97B %! % ',4" +- )$$>,, - "',% = 5< '% 4 '" = -'%"', #"%%,' #'" #$",' 33 13 C,% 1779<
;< #"%, '% $%$ % #" ",) $ 83 C5," 1779< "'"% ,,% " >,% + '"+- %$$#D'$ = ' '," #'"
-,>'"" +- 'D,%,% #"" 5! ,:, - % %%,"$ ' %%%,' " ",+ #,' +- '",%< -% )'"$ = , ," +-, , >,% 5"%," "5, ( < "'"% $" #" ," # '5," 5'," "I >'"," ,%,%$ H"%%,' %' ,!
6/70861779 : 86; :
,>'"%,' %"4 ,#'"%% * )$$>,,," H! + %%," #"$,$% -%%%,' "$ " '$+ - $C'" D'" 45<
! "#"$%% ( ! #"$,$ + -"$ , 5,% %$$#D'$ 87 C, 1779 #'" , " "#'"% % #"$5 #'" "J:5' "'%, 5 $,:', - ! #'" ",' #"'< , 5,% # %,'$ 5''%$ #"" 5< -% % '%" '," -"$ +- 5,% ##", + :, 5,?,% #"%," ++ C'"! ",' #'" + , 5,% $",% '""," 3" C,%< >>," #" ," + , -"$ - 5,% :K ,>'"$ '" % %"%, %$$#D',+ 87 C, 1779! -",% # +$ , ,,+" + ' "',% ",% #<
"
3< ', ?5', " L'"?,%,' C,,," @A $%$ ',>,$ % ,%,%$! 4 3" 'M% 1778! ",) %' " ',! '#'$ 9 C?!
'% #"$,% % 5,:#"$,%! 9 ##$% % 3; C? " @"%< 3 %< " % 9; A<
(,% = L%,' L$%,' 3; C? "! #" ",) >$$" 1F C5," 177/ @ 387 37;A! " ', ?5', '#%$! 38 >$5","!
,#',%,' %",%'," "?% #"%%% ",) %' " ', ,$?" " = %"', C? %,%,"! ! L%%% L$%,' '5* C? "<
1< '>'"$% = -"%< 9; < 1 %< ) ! ",) %' " ', '&% ,% ,+ '%%%,' #"$5 = -"%< /0! < 8! ', %' %,4" DE?! 33 '5)" 3028! %,4" #"%%,' %' '#$%," @ A< ( '#$% #'" C?" L#4 % ,, $%),<
8< "'"! ,%"C%$ %# %,! % "5) @"%, 9; % ;7 A<
/< ,%,? #'"% " #,' "',% 5"% 33 13 C,% 1779<
9< (' -"%< 2 ! #5% )$$>,," #"%%,' -,#,%$ #?4" %"5,! %'% ' #"%,! DE" +, '% $#,$ " "',% * ,,%$ C'",4" #'" , ' ,%! '>'"$% = -"%< 12 ', >$$"<
6/70861779 : /6; :
-"%< 31 #"$, + N H #"%%,' #'" -,#,%$ #?4" %"5,! %'% ' #"%,! #5% K%" 5"$ + , '""#'% = ,#%,% #% -"%< 12 ', >$$"<
-"$ - # "',% * #"%%,' -, $C'" D'" , ' ',,! + ',% (, ' = -$%"?"G "% "$"5$ $,%$< ', - %% "4? #"'$" % $>,,% $,%$<
$,%$ $, ',5% "5'," -5 $,:', -%'",%$ '#$%%<
#"%%,' #5% K%" 5"$ '"+ -,#,%$ ' , = " ' '5 $"'% (,H<
$,%$ '% $$"$ = -"%< 30 "4?% -*$%,' @ A<
-?,% '%% -5,% = -$%"?" 'C',%! - #"% ,? ,"%! - >"4" ' O" @*, 9 C'" '5")A! , ?"5! -')%%,' - %",%% ' - 5, $, #$,,$ +, #% K%" ')% %'! ' - D'#,%,%,' -"? -"$ @*, 39 C'" '5")A<
-"%< 17 $>,,% ',%,' + " D'" %' #% K%" #", ',$"%,' -"%< 31 < / <
;< -#4! -"$ % ,#) %"5," = 97B ' "%,>,% ' $, %",%% / 'M% 1779 #'"%% " ', C,% 1779< #% ,, #"$%" #",,# = -'%"', < #% $C'"$ , 33 13 C,% 1779< "! >'" % '%%" +- -$%,% , $,%$ -"%< 30 ! , 'P -,#,%$ ' , = " ' '5 -"%< 17 <
( $%,% '$+ "',% #" 5"% "% #$",' '"$<
F< -"$ 4? #% 5'," $%$ )' >',! " 'P ' ',"
-5,% # %%,"$ ' %%%,' " ",+ +- '",% 5'," #" ' "',% * #"%%,' % + ( , 5,% "$ '""," 3" C,%! )'"% = , " #"$," % ' $C'" D'" 45< 4? #" ," # '5," 5'," "I >'"," -,>'"%,' %,$ * )$$>,,," <
6/70861779 : 96; :
% 5", + '""," 3" C,% 1779! "$ * "$ #% #"K%" = '>,' % " ," #" +-, " >>,% -,,+" % #"$, " $C'" #'" '%," = "5'," <
(' '%", % C",#"! ",?% ,*%! '#'"%% ""'$ ' '" ',,' #% ," -,,%"%,' '"+ ,+ ',%,' ,5% '% "$,$ @ 3029 #< 8;3AN
3A '"+ -%'",%$ % ,%"5 ,%%,' '"4% = -$?" #"' $%",$G
1A '"+ -%'",%$ $%,% '#$%% #'" '" ",?% ' '"+ ,%'. 5,% ",' >>,% #'" ',$"" -%'",%$ ' '#$%%G
8A '"+ ,%'. - # # "'&%" -)$ % "$"5 -,*%,% ",?% ')%G
/A '"+ -,,%"$ -% >'$ " ",?% +-, "'.,% *% #'"
#"" ,#',%,' +-, #'"",% # "$5'+" )," #"$C,G
9A '"+ ', - # D?$ #, '% 'P ",?% $%$ '$<
",) $ "45 + -"$! , %% % +-' #, %%" +- -,% # >'"," -,>'"%,' +, , $%$ ",! ",% # ')%," %' ",?% 'D,%$ , 5,%! ' , , ##"%,% >," % ' ' '," , 5,% "'$! 5"%, ( ' 'D,% #"" 5< "! >'" % '%%" +- '" -%"%, %$$#D',+ +- 5 ( ! 87 C, 1779! - >,% ,' = -$5% 5<
#"'%%,' '>, ",% 4 '" %"" ,? '#%<
, "'"! >'$! ',%:, K%" "C%$<
6/70861779 : ;6; :
# "3 " #" # #
%
451 6 7 89 -/+ $:
1
3< $" "'" "5)<
% 1
1< "C%%<
8< ,% + #"'$" % ?"%,%<
?">>,4" "$,% N
",:', Q '", R
'#, '>'" #"$% ""K% % '%,>,$ * #"%, #" ?">>
6/70861779