Injunction Against Statute Denied Due to Lack of Irreparable Harm
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court considered whether the lower court correctly applied the standard for granting injunctive relief, which requires showing a likelihood of success on the merits, irreparable harm, and that the balance of equities tips in favor of the moving party. The appellant sought to prevent enforcement of a statute, arguing it unconstitutionally restricted the ability to engage in a particular commercial activity, while the appellee asserted the statute was a valid exercise of regulatory authority aimed at preserving public welfare. The court reasoned that the appellant failed to meet the high burden necessary to enjoin a statute prior to a final determination of its validity, specifically finding that the harm alleged was economic and thus compensable in damages if the statute were ultimately found unconstitutional, and that the public interest supported upholding the legislative enactment pending a full adjudication.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Injunction Against Statute Denied Due to Lack of Irreparable Harm: The appellant sought to prevent enforcement of a statute, arguing it unconstitutionally restricted the ability to engage in a particular commercial activity, while the appellee asserted the statute was a valid exercise of regulatory authority aimed at preserving public welfare. The court reasoned that the appellant failed to meet the high burden necessary to enjoin a statute prior to a final determination of its validity, specifically finding that the harm alleged was economic and thus compensable in damages if the statute were ultimately found unconstitutional, and that the public interest supported upholding the legislative enactment pending a full adjudication.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive section concerning the allocation of procedural costs.
Testo completo
$%&'($())* $%&*$())'
!!
! !
+, - # . /0 ())'
!"""# $%$#&#%$ $!$& '( )$"&"
!&$
((( (( ( "*+ ,"&-. "&"# !$
! "#
.2/05.
1
06 #07*3 &%!8#%$#"9 ,"&#:"!";&%"!""07716 &"&$ &$# %!$"&%$!<"!&!%$!<"!%$= ((( (( (>".%$=:$?6
26 2*#@$2332 :$##&#-"&":"&$!"&$-"A !$,:$;"&%$ :$#;"#&)&#$!$$!"&6
0+B-"$2335 $6 %#""&'C$"!!;"#"D :)E%"& !$ %$!##D";$"%$$#!;#&",>? :#%$!"&6#"!D<$&$$@!$&#$!."<#$"$ ;=-%&"&$):"$$&""$&"&$$%&"!$&";" &D !&"! - <"$&"! &$ & %$!@@ #)"$$ "<#$"$ &! #%"F6&!&<!"%$#"#,:D"- %$#"," "- @!$ ! $!"!.&!G" %$&&"& % :#""$ #-&%&"&#)"$$&$<"F"&!-""#-$&"&6<"".
;#)!$! -$"@@&#!-$&<!$&"&#&%)8 %$!F":)#$6
56 $%%!$& #" "&$#""$ #&@" D :"&&"! :$ 50 B-"$ 2335%$$6 ;$!%)"$$;"!$&)!%#",&&$&!!.
;",:)E%"& !$ "$!$&,!$$#"@"&"& !" %$= :"& & , # %)8"!&)#$%" #&"& %$#- = "F"="6 ,&"!-!"$"!;%$&#&"&D$"$ #""",#,:"#&"&&$!%&E&%!$%$!!$6
+6 $%%!$&#&@"00<#-$"$2335 $6 ;$!%#" :F "",#,!%&"& &&$"=$ ##,""@$# :#&"&$&&$.
%# D @ -& )&$ ," -"& %$!-!,# F&"! @$& @$6!&&#,&"$%#$"$@"%$!"&&&!G$!"&#&"& &$="@&!!$FD!&$&"!&!D!&"!!D.
,;"$@$%#$"$$!"&6%$#!"#"!@""&"!& &;",&!D"%"&#&!&&$-"6
*6 $%%!$&+$2335 $!<"$#!";!&" <$&$@!$"<#$"$;=:!!%&$!"&6%$#!"#$%!& #%)8"!&)#$%" &&"#,&$"&&$"&%$!@@&&$.
"#"F!"6&&&#:"%"&#&!&&$-"6
46 (!$%%!$&#&@"2+$2335%$$6 %#""&'C "$)&" !$#",:#%$!"&!&%$"
/0+12/2334 .5/05.
16 1-$"2335 $"",#,:#-!&"!:#&&:$# #&"&<-!$@",!$$#"&$"$$"&6.
&"#$#%$!@@&$"&&FD,&$!"6
H6 $6 %#""&'C$"!!;"#" %$!##D$.
&)$!:#%$!"&23"23356(!"!!&#&#"-&A $%&$%$&""&$<"F"&!"<<$!&&$ !"#%$&" &#$"$&!#%"F $#&$&&"!&"!.
"$6!"@8$!:"%";&!$:@&"! $%%!$&-#.
;=$)8%$&$!%)":$&"&"!$!"!.-""$&%&"&!&#!%)8&! $!"6 <$&$ ;= #&"& !$ -""@6 @!$$& ;#!G" %.
$""& !$-#6 #"! :)8%!%)8 %$!F" :)#$ #-!,& %$"$")!$!-"&#&##!-$&<!$&"&&6
76 24"2335 $"",#$',<$&$ @!$ &#$"$ ;= D $!"& -"& #&# &$"&# !$-&"-& %$ "!@""&"! %" %$ $##&"! %$!;$"-6 "",# , :#-!&"! #&"&#<-!$@ -!$%$"&& !&&"-!"<< $!&&$ & , : -"& !<"$# #"! &$<"F"& && !"<<6 ",:%$&"&$!@#;##$&"<-"&I&$%$#&-&" !$ "#&"&"%!"@"$,#&"&%$&&$&":;;$.
-&"!"&&"!6#!" ""&"!D$#-""!&$!"<<& $!"!.%&""%$""&$"!@6=!$ $"# !"D!!=;:F"$&&#-&"&#&:"&$-%&"&6
036 "&$-&"!#&#%$&",#53B"&2335>$!"!.%&"&$#%$&"! !"<<?6$' $-")"$$;"!$&)!%#",&&$&!!.
;":%%$"!&$>J#&@"&)!%"&"$J?%$&",#:!%#$&"!6$ !$$"$ 24 !K& 2335 " "",# $6 #".!" :$ ,:"%"&#&$-"#&"&&!&6
006 0$ B"& 2335 $ ' "",# , :"%"&# &$-" #&"& &!B!$&!&&,&$"&&$$"&%$!@@&&$!"D"F!"6
026 07 !K& 2335 $6 C %#""& 'C !$&)!%#" "",# -!"$-%&"&<!"53B"2335&-!"$%!&&$""&.
&"!<!&"!:#%&!%6"",#,:D!" "$!&$%%!$&-:"&B!"&%$E:#-!.
&"!6
056 HB-"$233+ $'"",#,:"$"&%&"&$6 %!$%$")$;%$$##&"! $;$#%)8.
"!&)#$%""& %$!;$"!:#&"&,&"-!@"".
&"#,:"<"&:$$D:%!8$%!$,:"%$!$D!%!8#&$.
/0+12/2334 .+/05. -" %%$!%$"# &,:!;%$&#&"&D$"$-""&&"! <!$&!@""&#:#%$!"&6
0+6 !$$"$ $# $ 23 B-"$ 233+ $(6 %#""&'C#"%)8",&$##&"! "".
,#,:D:F"", "!&"&!&$&$= &$%=L& ;"$:!!%&FE&# !$D%%&"!! #%"F%&"&.$!&;$%&!$E&#$!"& !@""&#$&""$53M $!&&"!F&$ <$!&&"!"&$ @&"!<F"!&"-H3M6 "",#,$&&&"$#&"&!!&$"@&"<$"!!$ %&"&6 ",!"&"%$=$#%$&"!!"<< :#-!&"!#&"& %!$!"&&"!"$6#"!"#);&&$"&&& %$!%!#&$-"F#%%$&""=$&$%#$".%"$&$.
-"F&&$-"$#)$!"&"!%!.&)!$",&%!.
)#$6
0*6 $%%!$&#"<#-$"$233+ $"",#, &$"&&$$"&%$!@@&!L!"&,:!;%$&#&"& D$"$6
046 5B"233+ $&"!#%"&$#&$&"&!.
$D!@""&"!6#-#$#%$!@@&$"&&D#& !<"$#,:!;%$&#&"&D$"$6
016 %$= #)!;$%)" :#% $!"& %$&",# 2 !K& 233+ $6 N %#""& 'C $"!!;" "",# $ ,:" :8 -"& % :$;& <-$ : $.$%&$ &$ !"<<6 !&&##%""&@!$%!"@&$&"!-@$"&6
0H6 4%&@$233+ $ !<"$#,:#&&%&"&#&"& &&"!"$6
076 $%%!$&01<#-$"$233* "&"#,$#%$!@@&$"&& $"&J!;J6
236 02"233* "$$%%!$&"""$6
206 %$= $"!;$%)" :#% $!"& %$&",# 53 B" 233* $6 !D$%&$"&$;#!.)#$-"!.
&"#&$",:)#$ !;$$&""$$!"!.-""$$%&# !.
&#!%)8&#@&&%$&""<#$"$&I&)#$ &$";:$.
&)$!%&)" #;##$&"- ";"<"&"< @ #"! ! "$!$"& #.
"#$"&"!!"<<-""&!$&" @".
<"&"!%$&"!:%!$!"!.-""$6
/0+12/2334 .*/05.
226 0*B"&233* $96 %#""&'C)"$$;"!$&)!%#".
, %$!##DF%$&"D:$6!$<"$ "F.
"#:$#27B"233*&:&@#$:F!"$6
$!$&!=,:%$=)& :$#%!$"-"!&$-"" :& $ !"$ I D %$ :F !O ! " %$$"& &".
"<&!"$6 !$ %$"&& ! #" &$"&& : $# $ !$&)!%#"& !" %$= :"&6 $"!;$%)" & :!&!$!&$#$%&$&"!"<<"",:<$&$ ;=6 %$= &$"&& %$ && $& F D &$!" !" :$# #&# $#D:)E%"&&!&!%#$#53B"&23356 &&"&$-&"!:% &$"#:#"!$&"!$%!$6&$"&&%)8"!&)#$%" #@&#&:&%!$"-"B,:%$"&%233*6$%$&",#D F!&$!"$%$"233+"<"&$&"!,"!&%%!$&#!;&D %&"& !$ $& ,, B!$ " ;!@& !$ !& % #-!#%"23356
:$#%"&!$",&!$!-&6:8!$.
&%!$$%! "$-)!$!&$6!.
$D!@""&"!%%$"&D<%!&#$"$:#%6 !&#-.
#D*.4/036%!$&)$;&""&#D!FP"!F"6:.
&"! &""&# D 033M -"$!6 :$# %& #$"$ %& )$ %$!.
@=6 "&%&%$D:!$"&$6 <"&!#; <$%; &:%"$&$,"!&%$")$;%$!$"6
:F%$& %!# ";!&" "-& A <$&$ @!$ &#$!."<#$"$ ;= :#% $!"& $%&$ #%"F $!"& ""&&"! <!&"!.
& ;", %$"&& :#% $!"&6 &"# , &$!" ";!&" #&"&$&"!"&#&$=-$"@@>:&.D."$%#$"$D*3Q?D $&"-:"&&"&&,:"%"&#&$-"#&"&&!B!$".
,&"%&@F!#,:"&6
%$!<"!:"!";& ,""%",%!$&)$;<$#,& " !D"%"&#&$-"033QD!;&$6&$%$!<"! :"%",& % &$-" - @$ %#$"$ $!"& )&$ %!$& )$;!!-&$#%#&"&"<@$%#$"$$!"& "!D %"&#&$-"%#$"$ %$!@@&033Q6(!" $$#.
%&&"!!&$#"&&-$"&I&$"%=,%!"@6:$# %!$$"&&$-"$D033Q!$#%&"!"&.&##%)!"& !"""&$&"< >D!"&"!,&&%$!<"!:"%",%!-&&$!%$#%#&"&"< @$%#$"$$!"&"%!$&)$;? %$#%!#D;")& %!8#;.
&"!"$ ""&$ >#&& &!&<!" %$#"# ,: "& % &""$ !$".
&$? $-"&#>D!"&"!,&"-"&#&&!8;!"&%
/0+12/2334 .4/05. &$!%"%!$&&? %!8#$#;"$-"!&"!!!$;$" %$P";6
:F%$& !$ "",# ,:" !&&"& )L :$# #&& &#$"$ #&$;$ !!"&&!""&$$$&"B!&#,.":-"&%:".
< $ %"&# &$-" " $ :#-!&"! "- :#% $!"&6%$"$!D&&"&D:"&#;$"&#%&"@:I&$"".
#&:#-#D0+Q6
256 &$.&% :$# 8& #%!# %$= :$."-""&# &&$"=$:!"DF!$&)!%#",%$=($-"#"$#.
;"! >(?,""27!K&233*%$$6 %#""& 'C)"$$;"!$&)!%#",&&$&!!;"6
$"$%!#";!&"$"$:#%%$=$!"!.%&"&.
&$#%"F&&&%$=$%&$&!#%"F:#% $!"& & <$&$ @!$ &#$!."<#$"$ ;= )#$6 #;& ! !";&,:"#&"&$#%$"!$%"&#&$-" D 8$!$!&"$!$!%&)"F;!F&8$!";$"F6
$ "",# ,:" %$&;"& !"! $ 6 (! " :$# $!"&"=$ !"& &$!-$ &$-" ," #%$; &&#%.,:%&-$.D:)!$"L!&.&:"%",% %!$&$!@B&%#$"$D*P"!R$-):&""&"!! %!";& &"$!"&&%!"@&$-F#;$6#"!D "%"&# &!& &$-" %" 2* #@$ 2332 :&"-"&# )@"& " &"# , &"-"&# %$!<"! ," $%&$"& ""&&"! <!&"!:$# &&$"=$-$"&I&$%@&$-"$D033Q "F!"%$=:"&$-&"!)"$$;"6
2+6 $#""!*!&!@$233* :$!&$!8#D:$#""&#%!$ &&"&D:"&#;$"�+Q6 !&&&,:%"&#&$-"&!&#&"&$!.
$&"!@$%$!<"! &$#&#"F""&#B!$.
"=$-<<&53!-@$233*6!$<"$ :$$:&@#$ "$ !8 , %!$$"& $#"$ :$# %$!<"! $#%&"!.
"& !"""&$&"< %$#%!#;")& %!8#;&"!"$""&$ ;$" # %!8# $#;" ! ;$" %$P"; & &"$# !"! ,: %!$$"& !@&"$ "$ !8 42:437<$6 %$= !-$"!"$D!8)!$"$+2)$%$" " !,:%!$$"&$#"$$-4*:157<$6," !%$#D:&&&&"! !"%!8$ !,!$-$"&#-#233* "&D45:*13<$6"","&,:":8-"&%%$&;"6
2*6 $!$$"$0H!&!@$233* :$#<!$#!%%!"&"!D&&#""!6 <"&-!"$,!%&&!#&&&# ""#&"&"%!"@:<<&$
/0+12/2334 .1/05. &"-"&#%$!<"!&"!##""!:$$ &!& D%"&%&D%"$&6 ,:$#&"!23Q$-.
:"-"!"&%$&",#%!$&"$!%&!S; ""&&"!<!.
&"! & ! , :F%#$" & ,: ;$# :"-""&# *3Q !""!"&$!6
246 $#""!20#@$233* : $!D:$#$!"&D$& &"=$""5-$"233+6!$%#$"!%!&#$"$ "!D"-.
""3Q !%$&"$,:$"&%$#"$2332!: (( <F$T&&"-"&#"%&$#%#&"&"->5:H23<$6%$!"$+3)$U 5:7H2<$6 $ +0 1 )$ U +1:1HH<$6 %$ # U +H:+4*<$6 %$= $-!$"&"! . 0*Q$#&"!U+0:07*<$6?$-4*:531<$6,:$"&%$#"$ :&&"&D",$:!$$%$!<"!%!$$"&$.
&I&$!&$!8# "!";#, !$%%!$&!$-"$#%&.
&"! :$#:#&"&@!&%!&"-#%!$&$%$$&$ !$& ,: :%%!$&$"& -$"@@& % $#&& !% !#, : $B&#$&6
216 $ #""! $ !%%!"&"! 23 $ 2334 :$$."& %!$ %$& "&#""!*!&!@$233*6
2H6 $!$$"$2*-$"2334 :$#"&$B&#$!$!&$&&#""!6 =;,!%$"!$-%$&&&<"F$&F:"-.
""&# : % #&# <<&# !$$&&6 B$"%$ :%& <<& % #; <!# $ )"<<$ &&"&", & F <!# $ $"%&$%!&&$-"6 !&"&,:&%!$&&,:<"&:.
$$ ,:"$#&;$!<"!&,#""!-"&"!%$#).
"@6 $#<=$D!"!: ,"&$$"-# %$@""!.
%$"!$-&&"&", D&F:"-""3Q6 , )"<<$!"&$%$"<"&@##<""$:$#&"!$-2*Q %!$&"$!%&<"&,:&S;#*4 ,::%&$-"#%" &$!"&" ,:!"&:!$"&$-$!-!"%$!<"!& ,: @"& !&$ ""&&"! <<"& "%!$&& %!$ I&$ !@";# :%$$D&!&!-%!8$%!&&" ,",$%%$!-!,$ %$"!D@"$<"F&"!!"$6 $% #-!,$.
&""<<"&#-;<$T"6
276 -"&#D%$!!$ :$$ $#%!22B"2334 !$B& $!$6
(:;"&$-"-""&# "F%",,:":&@#$",%$.
-"&:$#!&!""&2H<#-$"$233* D-!"$45:*13<$6 %$ #6 !$& $- :"-" & $%$!) $!$& :-!"$
/0+12/2334 .H/05. #;#F#&)! :"&"##"$#"%"<"$F%"&"!& :&$#<#$#",&F!# ((>#"&"!2332 &@ 0?6
)!""$&"!@$:&"-"&#>&$%!$&&!"&"! $? , :$#%!$$"& $#"$& <<&#!8"$%$T%$ < %!$ &"-"&# &$ "- 5 "- +6 :"&"# F%", -!"$ %$!##!$&<"%!#$$#""!<-$:$#6 <<& " !$#<=$"$,&&$"=$$-"&-&!"& !$$, ,: <<&"& &$-" "- 5 >!" %$!<"! %#"".
#?%",!"$@$&#&"&*:271<$6*3.,"!$$%!D $##$&"!&#;!$"5!"&#&&"-"&#!" >*:2H2<$6?6 && %$&", & :"$ !<!$ D B$"%$ ," %&# ,:"!"&#)#&%$!##D%);&$"-F5&+> ' 5H0/3307!-@$2335?6$!""%"<"&"! :$$:&$#<#$#D &"-"&# $##$# , :$# %!$$"& $#"$ D -!"$ &"-"&# &$%!&&!"&"!," !: (( ;#=$$- 4:H3*<$6%$!"":$#"&"-,"<"&"!5&*:5*+<$6:" "&"-,"<"&"!+6!8"$F&#;!.
$"!$#&&4:3H3<$6>U%!$$#)@!"$+0 1 )$ 4:55H<$6U14:3*4<$6%$U11:074<$6H*%$2335?6
:"&"#<"&$$,$, I$#<#$&D&"-"&#!"$##$# :$#@"$"&%%$&#!!",!%6
$F% %!";&"!"$""&$":$ ," !$$%!)"<<$44 0: (( !8&$*:+<$6>"-+?& *:352<$6 >"- 5? ! !&& *:2+5<$6*3 !"& *:+*3<$643 %!$ +0 1 )$%$"6
& D $#&"! 2*Q ," & # %$ $!$& $ ! $- :"-" :"&"#&,:@"&""&&"!"%!$&&!@$%#.
$"$$!"&"<"&$$,$,&!#":!$&D"$!V&$ %"&#&$-"%"&&"=$&"-"&#%&# ,:@##<"" %$"$:!;F%#$"%$!<"!$$)#"%",: !#&"-"&#$&"-07H* , $"@<##$$ $&"$#&"!2*Q:)!!"F&-"&" :&"!%&)"!"<<$!&&$&:<$&$&"<$;&"$D F#&;&"@"$!"& ",&:&%:$#6 &&$"=$ #&"& !"#$# %& D &$-"$ %$!<"! %&# %" 0$ <#-$"$ 233+":$&!&<!"!&"#D"-$$""&#B!$"=$ B,:53!-@$233*6:$#:%&&!B!$%"<&#:"&.
&"!$%$$&$-"6 !",:"!"& :"&"#<"&$$,$, I "%$!#"&D$#&"!0*Q$$-:"-">4:+55<$6? ":8 $"&&!B!$%%$&;"6
/0+12/2334 .7/05.
536 $#%",21B"2334 :$#F%",#,"!@&"&&& ,:".!";& <!$&"! " "%E "$ $&"-& #-# :& ,: @##<"""& : !&$& !&"< &$-" <-!$@6 #!$" S;# *4 <!$&"! " F%#$" !"&"! $" &#$"$ D :".
& !& #&# -"&" :$!& % :"< $ ! !- %!"6 !,!"&"-+: ((,"!"&$&&"&"&,: $#&"! 2*Q B&"<" !%& & ! S; "<<"&# :%&&"! ,:";$ !"F%#$" !@<!$&"!!- !"%$!<"! ""&&"!<!&"!,"!&" !.
;%#$"!$&,:%&$-"#"","<<"&#- ;<$T"6
506 $ !$$"$ 24 B"& 2334 :$ "& !"!6 <"& -!"$,%$!<"!:".!";& :$#<<&"&&S)," $"&I&$""#D&S)"%&$#%#&"&"- "@",:%); &$"-F5&+: ((&&!&D<"&#,"&@6 &#;$ <"&-!"$ , :&"-"&# :" !";& $,"$& "<&& %"&# "&& : $&" "- , :$# %& !$ F%!"&$ &$ &"-" & D :@&&& 2*Q $## :$$ <"& $$,$ , "&&"! %$!:$#%&I&$%$"!%&D<!"%!$#&$"$! "$ :"-" & %!$ %$!#$ D @&&& $ "$ #BD ""#6 !&& %$ "$ ,: $@&&& 2*Q !"& B&"<"# "$!& 6
!
06 !";-!"$W!$;"&"!B"""$>?#&#!"<"#&"&"&# = 0$!K&2335 $"@&!$!" !%!#*B; !&%$#"&&-".%$#"& *%%#&&04B;$>$&60&6 $&*4 ?6
("&DW&"!W#&"!04B;$ %$ $"@<##$ 21B-"$233+> '053034? $ !";-!"!%&# 05<#-$"$ "%!"&"!&$"&!"$$;&%$&&& $"@&!$ !" "#;$ $ D &$!" B; &"&"$ W&&& W#&"!!-FB;$6
26 !<!$#&D:$&6*460&6)6* $"@&!$.
!" !V& "& ", !&&&"! %$#- D W$&" *4 ,"!&$&"-D!"<##$$W$."&23$07H0 > ?6(!%#&%!$B;$W%=&""#&@"6
/0+12/2334 .03/05.
56 #$!;&"!:$&643 #"$!$&&$!"!"D!%&$ #""!$!%%!"&"!%!$&&$%$&&"!:$."&>$&6034 ?6&$B*-$"2334!&$#""!$!%%!"&"!232334 <!$$,"%$:$&6*4 %$#&$!$&$-@6
+6 (&"&";":%=,&"!;$#:"-""#.
":!$&<<&D"$,$!$&%&F$$D%"&% &"-"&#%&#D""&&"!6
*6 !$ $# &"< ;$# :"-""&# !"& I&$ #&$"# $ @ : !%$"! $-A ! !%$ "$ , :"-" %!$$"& !@&"$ F$T& :&"-"&# , W! %& $"!@& &&$ " . %$= F#&"! #-&$$#%&&"!&!%&&:"&&"!#,""@$# $)# &$-" . D " ,:" $"& % !@&"$ :" :#&"& % "-" >$&6 2H 62 ?6!%$"!!"&$=;;##$<"$&"=$, F $- )8%!&)#&", !"& )"<<$# % F&& %!"@ & " %$= $ "<<#$ %$&&& #&$"$ ;$# :"-""&# >#&)! ;##$ !%$"! $-R ' 02H 53 !"6 0 03+ 054 !"62&2@?6("$!&&%&I&$#&$"#-%$#""! "!-".
$#-$!##&!%$&""$&!%$$ &$-$%%$!F"&"-""$&>(2333!"60@H+R( 2333!"60504?6
46 $-,:$#$"&!@&!&&"&D&#:&%!& $"&#-# !"$!"%!8$ D'$645:*136.233*6
(:;"&$-:"-" ":$#$#"$-$#%$,W" :%$%$":&"-"&#%"!"-""&#!!":F$%:&"-"&#, :!%!$$"&$"!@&F";$" "8" !B$"%$ $#<#$$ F !# &&"&", & ,: $#&& W ,I& $ &$.
&$"$:<<"<##$&&"&",> ((R '024146!"6 5@/&@@R(2332%64H!"65@R(2333!"65@/@@%650HR(2333 !"62%6H+R-D:"&&"!"!%&"!X Y0770%6 552/555!"65R 07H7%6552!"65@?6 ' $#<=$ %"077+ D && ,I& %@"# &! F 6 & #&$"& -$ &$ >#.
"? &&"&", "$ @$& &$"# > ' 02+ 525 !"65@/@@R(0777%60H2?6
!&$!$,W"8"&"$!%&W@&$%$!.
&"! & $-" & % ""&$ F !# &&"&", W &$#!!",> '024H0!"61?6<&%!%&!.
$$-!@&$$)#%@"!$,$)#%$"-#&"-$".
@@6<&!-";$&!&$)#&$-",":!<<$%!$#&@"$ !8 "$6 >( 077H %6 0H2 !"6 +?6 #&$"& $-
/0+12/2334 .00/05. W"-"!&@"$ "<& $"!"#;"&#$".
&$F &"$!%&"$<%!$<&"$ )! %!$ )!6 $"& """@ @$ $ -$ !8"$<&)!6>(2333%6H2?6
16 :%= %$!""%"<"&"! $"@#$&"$$- '$65:H756.,:$"&%$#"$ 233+ <F$T&&"-"&#"% &$#%#&"&"-&$%$"-# &!&@$)#!!",!<!6 <<& !&&$%$#&"$@$&>-$&$?%!$%!& &$-","$,"=$&%,"<"&"!%$!<"!%$&""=$ "@" ,:!%&&&$,%%$&%!"!& @&$&"!<"&"".
&&"!#%$!-#%$$!$& !<!$F%&"&."6 $;$ $;#-&":&"-"&#"%&$#%#&"&"-,$!-$&&$ %$!&"!&$-" !!"&!-"$,:!@$";"<"&"<&"-".
&#!&#;=$&%&#)"%:$#6"$&&"&",,"#&# %$" !"#$&"! & ! $%$#&&"< ,: %!$$"& !@&"$ !%& &:$)##,""@$#&$-"6 $"@#&, !%&& !S;&<"&,:"$!&%!$!#,"<<"&#:.
$#D$#%&$D!-%!" &"-"&#"%&$#%#&"&"->".
-+?!"-&I&$%$"!%&6 $-) "",<"&$$,$:".
&"# :S;$!$&%!$$I&$%$"!"#$&"!D!-!$,:" :;"$#&$"$,$$-:"-"!"&I&$$#"&6
$-'$65:H756.%$!"233+%!$+3)$)@!"$&$-" #,"-& D $- '$6 +4:1046. !"& '$6 +H:*H+64* %!$ +0 4 )$ >"#!!",2.2334 %67+ &@762?6
' ", "=$;##$ %$!&&"&$&# )"%#I:!%"&&$-FF"""$#;$ #&"&#.
-&;#$%$##$&"!%$$%%!$&D&$-"$%" %!"!$%"&#&$-"&%$<"&&%&DI&$;;# &,:.
-"& ;##$& &@$ $ "$ %$!%!$&"!& !" #-# >(2333%6H+6!"62@R(0777%60H*!"65@R(0777%6!"6 5@/@@R '00+503!"6+@!%@"#R(077H%60H0!"65?6:;"& D%$#&:F"$:"!-"&%$!#$D$#&"!"$&&"&", &&!%&W@"$!&%$!&%$!<"! %$&""$>""&&"!"#)"% S; #$-" &"!".
&#/&#;!$"W&!$"&"!#B!$&&FW!%&"!?6
""&&"!"#)"%>""&&"!D&"-"&##;=$?&D:S;$.
!$&8&#BD#&#%$"!%&%!$#&$"$!$- ":8% "%$$!"#$&"!%!$$#"$!$!&&6=!$ $#&"! %#$"$ D 03Q B&"<" %6 $- :"-" "" !@&
/0+12/2334 .02/05. >'$6+5:1246*3? !%$#$-"-""&# !"&D;$#:"-""&# 50Q6$%%$!):"$""&F:"-""&#$!%$: 6
$!$&!",:$#!"&-!"$$!V&$$!"&D $& !$$%!& D ;$# :"-"" $ $-!8# D :"&"# %!$%$&&"!6
/0+12/2334 .05/05.
! 2 1 ! !
#
34/ ,, 5 6 7 8 %*( "9
/ ,
06 #$$!$$-@6
# /
26 :&,66!"&-!"$$!V&$;$#:"-""&# 50Q"!-$&$!"&D$&!$$%!&6
56 -!"D ((( D)$;%!$&&$"=$%$!#.
$%$&&"!6
+6 !W"&"#D-$$D$!$&!'$60:*33 ..D&"&$#.
%6
*6 <!$ %$&" ,W %-& <!$$ $!$ !&$ %$#& $$I& #"53B!$=!&"<"&"!%$%"$!#$# $"@.
<##$ $ ()Z"L$)!<," 4 433+ &$!" F.
%"$6 #" %& I&$ %$!!;#6 #!"$ !"&A ? "",$ F&& ,#""!$!$&#"$!@&"$"&%#""!&&,#R @? F%!$ %!$ , !&"< " &" %!-!"$ $ && &$ #""!R ? %!$&$";&$!!$%$#&&6("#!"$!&"&% &$!"##&##$#!&&$?@?&?". $"@<##$.
$%!$$%&$$&"=$$$!$,W"-$#$$"$$.
-@6#!"$$!$&"!$!$!8%$- ,"$!& B!"& "",#""!&&,#&W-!%%,#&#F%#"# $!$&>$&6052 034&03H?6 ;$<<"=$ $#"&A "'' N$"( N
!%"!<!$%$#&$$I&&!&"<"#F%$&""",WDW<<"<##$ &#%@",%$;$<<
/0+12/2334