Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ATAS/1447/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/1447/2007 Generato dall'IA

Bankruptcy Plan Confirmation Challenges and Procedural Waivers

Numero d'incarto ATAS/1447/2007
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Parzialmente accolto (Partially Allowed)
Spese processuali a carico dell'autorità / Stato

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The case primarily addresses the permissibility of various challenges against a bankruptcy plan confirmation order, involving multiple disputes over the definition of impaired classes, creditor classification, disclosure statement adequacy, and the application of the "best interests of creditors" test. The court reasoned that the lower court correctly confirmed the plan because the appellant failed to timely appeal the prior disclosure statement approval, waived certain objections by not raising them below, and the plan satisfied the absolute priority rule, while acknowledging that the determination of which classes were impaired was complex and fact-dependent, ultimately upholding the confirmation order against claims of procedural error and substantive unfairness in plan distribution.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Bankruptcy Plan Confirmation Challenges and Procedural Waivers: The court reasoned that the lower court correctly confirmed the plan because the appellant failed to timely appeal the prior disclosure statement approval, waived certain objections by not raising them below, and the plan satisfied the absolute priority rule, while acknowledging that the determination of which classes were impaired was complex and fact-dependent, ultimately upholding the confirmation order against claims of procedural error and substantive unfairness in plan distribution.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
credito nel fallimento censure procedurali rinuncia alla motivazione motivazione nel merito opposizione tardiva nomina dell'amministratore fallimentare

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive to regulate the distribution of costs concerning the appeal.

Art. 64 LTF

Cited in the dispositive to grant legal aid (provisoire).

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo



           '()'+,,* "'-))*'+,,*

"

 " "#    # 

./ 0 ! -1 2./ +,,* 



   !" #$%& $$% !%   '!%(%$ ) *





%$

+)  )) )) )  %$ %#% % !  ) 



           ! "# $%  &! !

   20,32  

 $"

45   !% % $!  %% 6 $ ! %$  $ 6 ' % #$7'+)  )) )) 8 2#$7'$$# ' % !95:

05 4;!<$011=< % %6%$(%%#$% ' %!& '> ?*5

-5 $$$ $4/&<$0113'$!%$%"'$$<!%< #$  $  #$  #@*%*!$#   %  %%   6% 6' #% &$%$ %%#$7 % % #$ *$?'%%$ %%5

.5 $ %%$  4- !<$ 0113 '$$ #%  #$   *$? ' #@*%*!$#   %  %%  #$! % 6  # %  #$$ % A%$ $& " $!#%   $##$% !  !%<   % " 'B#$%  # C ! #$  -1 D& $ 011/5

=5  40 &$  011/  $  % 5   '+E# % #*% 6)  !%< %$##$%'B#$% ! 6% $F#$'$$-1 &%5

35 $$$ $0. 011/'$$"%*!$#%'$!  #@*?     6$ %%  <  #% #$%  $  @% #! '$! "  %$  !%*  %$ %% #$ ?! '!&%    !%% #@*? 6 %   #$% 5  %%%  $ ?% '$$ !%  $!$& '? $  #$   *$?%$ %%5

/5 $ !    -1   011/ '$$ $C " '$!  $ % "  $%   %$   %!#$%% %"' %!?$ %!-1G%#%% $" #$$  *$?  %$ %% ! 5 )'? %  %$ %% #@*%*!$#% 6 % 6  %"$ 7$#?!  H

I#$ *$?'!&%%$ %%#@*%*!$#% 6C$'<D%' !  !#$!5I

;5 41D 011/#@*?%$%"'$$$ ?%!5

J5  04 D  011/ '$$ C$  #@*? 6   %%  !  $%'!%%#@*? 6#% %%$'##$! % %6'  6$ #    C $ #$%   #$   # %  %!$ $%5  #$   *$?%$ %%#$ ?!2"'B#$% !  %-1D& $ 011/%$!$&!5



,-.//,011/  2-,32  

415  0 D % 011/ '$! C$ ## %  "  !    -1   011/  '$$5

445 $$$ $.D %011/'$!#$' %$!  $  "'$$#$$&*$?#@*%*!$# 5

405  40 D % 011/ '$$ C$ '$! 6  ## %  ' # 'CC% # C % 6'     $  # # < ' %$& $ #$ '!&% !#@*%*!$#  #!2"-1D& $011/5

4-5 $$$ $0=D %011/'$!$6 $%$% %% 'CC%# C5

4.5 $ !    0 K% 011/ '$$ $C  $% %%   'CC% # C $6  %%   6% 6 I #$!% !   '$%   #$!$$%5=0%=354 #%C $'<D%'$$ $%  $ <#!%%-1D$7% C % I5%#$ $  6!  %% !   6  'B#$%  #*%? 6 '!%%  %!  '$! #$    %  ' %  4; !<$ 011= #% A%$  !$!  %<  ! % 6  %$ %% !  % %% %$ ! *$    6  $  %$E #*% 6 $!? $ 6  $%% ! $5

4=5 $ % #%!  4. #%<$ 011/ '$! $$% %$ %% !   #$ ' %$!  $ %$$#$&  "6'   %$!"' % !#$$*$?K%!#@*%*!$#  2"   %  -1 D& $ 011/5  C  % " '%    !   %%6! % "  $% %%   'CC% # C   !    -1   011/ %!#5

435 $ #$!&   0 %<$ 011/ ' % ! % " ' $$&<  %!  $$ <   $%"$D%5' % !C %& $6$$%<D% $L#$ %#$ *$?C$ #@*%*!$# '# C %'<D%'!  C$5$$#$7&6$$%'  %!$A%  ?  #$%%  "  6  !    0 K% 011/  % ! %%! C !#$6 $#%'  %! #$%% %"' %!?$ %!% $%' &  %! '? %'!  !?% & 6 '&$#& "CC%# C5

4/5 $ $!# 6  0. %<$ 011/  $$% #$ % " $  $ #$&    #!$    $ !%% !%<  #$  ! %! !  "   #$ ?$! %$ %%#@*%*!$#% 65$7&#$ $6  6% '  %!#$%% %"' %!?$ %!%$%' &  %!'% #& !#$%%#$!$5

4;5 $# 63&<$011/' % !#$ % 5



,-.//,011/  2.,32   4J5 )$!%!?$!"D?$5

 #"

45 C$!% " '$%5 =3 5 4 %5  *5 =     ?&  $ '$? %  D   $ 89  $ < %  $   (%  %  6%%% #$!&"M$%5=3 C!!$$#$% ?!!$ $ %$ 3%<$01118 96 %$% &"  C!!$$M$2 %01$4J;48 95

)#!%#$D?$M#7%  !%< 5

05 $$ %$D%!%$!  0K%011/' % !$#%!  %C$#$$ %#$$%531%34 5

)#%%C 6% '<D%#$!%$$5

#$ $  & %%%$6$$'%$ %6'"% %  #$ *$?%$ %%#@*%*!$#% 6"'B#% 6%  $% '  %! #$ %% % " ' %!?$ %! %  $% ' &  %!   $$% '% B#$!%  * CC$ . 07  !   !$ %$  0. %<$ 011/5 $ $% %% 6%   % B#$!% % #!   !  -1 011/' % !6#$ *$?'!&%%$ %% #@*%*!$#% 6C$'<D%'!  !#$!5' % !C $ !$ %$$#$!%#$!$A  #  %%  6!"$$%%$ $#$$$ $40D %011/5

 ##$%    6' !   ' !%! #$  "  D%5 $ !6%  !  '$%0K%011/%%$$#& %$$ 6% % % #@*%*!$# 5$%% @ %%$6 $$%<D%5

-5  & % $ 'B $  $6A%  $ #$&   6  $$%C$!$$$5

9'$%5=3 C!!$$#$!$  %$% &01!<$4J3; 8 9% %<!?$ %C!!$#$%%%'$$$ #$&  #$!$  %$% &#$ 7$ %8 N44J  0J=95 ) %%  # %  #$7  !#E%  $$ '%$ %!    #% #$$  $ #$&   'CC   $ $6A% ' #$%  #$  % $#$&  $%!%%C %$ %5$#$&     '$%5 =3    % !? %  B %$     6    '&7$% ! $ % '!%%C %"&?$ %!$A%#$ 5



,-.//,011/  2=,32    $&*   $ % %  #$ $  D?% !C  % C   !6 & $ " % #$&  $$C <% $< &%"$$'<!  $  #$7  C 8 N 44J  =13  5 -O N   #< !  04 D %011=P3=,1= 5-54%-50O) +  &$$? * %? &$ %?$)Q &$ *$? H &  &$ %? $)Q &$ *$?) %24JJJ#54JJOR'CC%# C% $#$&  #$!$  %$% & N4J/3#500;95

<9  '#7  & %  %%$ 6  $ <  ! '% # $   '$$ %$$C%$ %% !  !   '@% !%! #$  "  D$5 $  $ #$&    #% A%$ $! 6'#$7!#E%$$B%$'$%53 5

$ !6%    $ #$&    % A%$ !$! $$&<5

.5 !  ##$%6' % !%$ C%%"#$$$#$   *$?  %$ %% #@*%*!$#% 6  D% C %  &<5 ) #$%% #$$ %    A%$ % %% C ' !   D%  C$ %  ##$% $"$$%  $!*!%"& $ <! #$% C ' % !& %#& $%%!$# %$%  D& $011;5



,-.//,011/  23,32  

  #"$  " "#    # 

!

45 !$<D%$$C$!%$!  0K%011/' % !5

05 !$$6A%$#$&   $$&<5

-5  %6#$!$%?$% %5

.5 C$  #$%    6M #&% C$$ $$ %$  #$!% $$A%   !   -1 D$ 7  % C %  #$7  $ < C!!$ 8)*S Q$*C6 3311.  9#$& $$% 7$$ % #< C$!%B$%5;0 C!!$$ $ <C!!$4/ D  011= 8 N9O  ! $  $$  %  6$    % C % @#$&%#$%$ ?%$$$%% $O  % A%$ $!  $ < C!!$ #$ &  #%  #$ &  !%$ 6 B  %   '$%5 .0  N5  #$!% $$A% %  # 7  #   $$% &6!@#$& &%A%$D %"'& 5  ?$CC 7$  $! %          $ +  ) @       

# C$#$!%$$A%%% C !B#$%   6M"MCC C!!$ %!#< 6#$?$CC



,-.//,011/