Bankruptcy Plan Confirmation Challenges and Procedural Waivers
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case primarily addresses the permissibility of various challenges against a bankruptcy plan confirmation order, involving multiple disputes over the definition of impaired classes, creditor classification, disclosure statement adequacy, and the application of the "best interests of creditors" test. The court reasoned that the lower court correctly confirmed the plan because the appellant failed to timely appeal the prior disclosure statement approval, waived certain objections by not raising them below, and the plan satisfied the absolute priority rule, while acknowledging that the determination of which classes were impaired was complex and fact-dependent, ultimately upholding the confirmation order against claims of procedural error and substantive unfairness in plan distribution.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Bankruptcy Plan Confirmation Challenges and Procedural Waivers: The court reasoned that the lower court correctly confirmed the plan because the appellant failed to timely appeal the prior disclosure statement approval, waived certain objections by not raising them below, and the plan satisfied the absolute priority rule, while acknowledging that the determination of which classes were impaired was complex and fact-dependent, ultimately upholding the confirmation order against claims of procedural error and substantive unfairness in plan distribution.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive to regulate the distribution of costs concerning the appeal.
Cited in the dispositive to grant legal aid (provisoire).
Testo completo
'()'+,,* "'-))*'+,,*
"
" "# #
./ 0 ! -1 2./ +,,*
!" #$%& $$% !% '!%(%$ ) *
%$
+) )) )) ) %$ %#% % ! )
! "# $% &! !
20,32
$"
45 !% % $! %% 6 $ ! %$ $ 6 ' % #$7'+) )) )) 8 2#$7'$$# ' % !95:
05 4;!<$011=< % %6%$(%%#$% ' %!& '> ?*5
-5 $$$ $4/&<$0113'$!%$%"'$$<!%< #$ $ #$ #@*%*!$# % %% 6% 6' #% &$%$ %%#$7 % % #$ *$?'%%$ %%5
.5 $ %%$ 4- !<$ 0113 '$$ #% #$ *$? ' #@*%*!$# % %% #$! % 6 # % #$$ % A%$ $& " $!#% $##$% ! !%< % " 'B#$% # C ! #$ -1 D& $ 011/5
=5 40 &$ 011/ $ % 5 '+E# % #*% 6) !%< %$##$%'B#$% ! 6% $F#$'$$-1 &%5
35 $$$ $0. 011/'$$"%*!$#%'$! #@*? 6$ %% < #% #$% $ @% #! '$! " %$ !%* %$ %% #$ ?! '!&% !%% #@*? 6 % #$% 5 %%% $ ?% '$$ !% $!$& '? $ #$ *$?%$ %%5
/5 $ ! -1 011/ '$$ $C " '$! $ % " $% %$ %!#$%% %"' %!?$ %!-1G%#%% $" #$$ *$? %$ %% ! 5 )'? % %$ %% #@*%*!$#% 6 % 6 %"$ 7$#?! H
I#$ *$?'!&%%$ %%#@*%*!$#% 6C$'<D%' ! !#$!5I
;5 41D 011/#@*?%$%"'$$$ ?%!5
J5 04 D 011/ '$$ C$ #@*? 6 %% ! $%'!%%#@*? 6#% %%$'##$! % %6' 6$ # C $ #$% #$ # % %!$ $%5 #$ *$?%$ %%#$ ?!2"'B#$% ! %-1D& $ 011/%$!$&!5
,-.//,011/ 2-,32
415 0 D % 011/ '$! C$ ## % " ! -1 011/ '$$5
445 $$$ $.D %011/'$!#$' %$! $ "'$$#$$&*$?#@*%*!$# 5
405 40 D % 011/ '$$ C$ '$! 6 ## % ' # 'CC% # C % 6' $ # # < ' %$& $ #$ '!&% !#@*%*!$# #!2"-1D& $011/5
4-5 $$$ $0=D %011/'$!$6 $%$% %% 'CC%# C5
4.5 $ ! 0 K% 011/ '$$ $C $% %% 'CC% # C $6 %% 6% 6 I #$!% ! '$% #$!$$%5=0%=354 #%C $'<D%'$$ $% $ <#!%%-1D$7% C % I5%#$ $ 6! %% ! 6 'B#$% #*%? 6 '!%% %! '$! #$ % ' % 4; !<$ 011= #% A%$ !$! %< ! % 6 %$ %% ! % %% %$ ! *$ 6 $ %$E #*% 6 $!? $ 6 $%% ! $5
4=5 $ % #%! 4. #%<$ 011/ '$! $$% %$ %% ! #$ ' %$! $ %$$#$& "6' %$!"' % !#$$*$?K%!#@*%*!$# 2" % -1 D& $ 011/5 C % " '% ! %%6! % " $% %% 'CC% # C ! -1 011/ %!#5
435 $ #$!& 0 %<$ 011/ ' % ! % " ' $$&< %! $$ < $%"$D%5' % !C %& $6$$%<D% $L#$ %#$ *$?C$ #@*%*!$# '# C %'<D%'! C$5$$#$7&6$$%' %!$A% ? #$%% " 6 ! 0 K% 011/ % ! %%! C !#$6 $#%' %! #$%% %"' %!?$ %!% $%' & %! '? %'! !?% & 6 '&$#& "CC%# C5
4/5 $ $!# 6 0. %<$ 011/ $$% #$ % " $ $ #$& #!$ $ !%% !%< #$ ! %! ! " #$ ?$! %$ %%#@*%*!$#% 65$7&#$ $6 6% ' %!#$%% %"' %!?$ %!%$%' & %!'% #& !#$%%#$!$5
4;5 $# 63&<$011/' % !#$ % 5
,-.//,011/ 2.,32 4J5 )$!%!?$!"D?$5
#"
45 C$!% " '$%5 =3 5 4 %5 *5 = ?& $ '$? % D $ 89 $ < % $ (% % 6%%% #$!&"M$%5=3 C!!$$#$% ?!!$ $ %$ 3%<$01118 96 %$% &" C!!$$M$2 %01$4J;48 95
)#!%#$D?$M#7% !%< 5
05 $$ %$D%!%$! 0K%011/' % !$#%! %C$#$$ %#$$%531%34 5
)#%%C 6% '<D%#$!%$$5
#$ $ & %%%$6$$'%$ %6'"% % #$ *$?%$ %%#@*%*!$#% 6"'B#% 6% $% ' %! #$ %% % " ' %!?$ %! % $% ' & %! $$% '% B#$!% * CC$ . 07 ! !$ %$ 0. %<$ 011/5 $ $% %% 6% % B#$!% % #! ! -1 011/' % !6#$ *$?'!&%%$ %% #@*%*!$#% 6C$'<D%'! !#$!5' % !C $ !$ %$$#$!%#$!$A # %% 6!"$$%%$ $#$$$ $40D %011/5
##$% 6' ! ' !%! #$ " D%5 $ !6% ! '$%0K%011/%%$$#& %$$ 6% % % #@*%*!$# 5$%% @ %%$6 $$%<D%5
-5 & % $ 'B $ $6A% $ #$& 6 $$%C$!$$$5
9'$%5=3 C!!$$#$!$ %$% &01!<$4J3; 8 9% %<!?$ %C!!$#$%%%'$$$ #$& #$!$ %$% &#$ 7$ %8 N44J 0J=95 ) %% # % #$7 !#E% $$ '%$ %! #% #$$ $ #$& 'CC $ $6A% ' #$% #$ % $#$& $%!%%C %$ %5$#$& '$%5 =3 % !? % B %$ 6 '&7$% ! $ % '!%%C %"&?$ %!$A%#$ 5
,-.//,011/ 2=,32 $&* $ % % #$ $ D?% !C % C !6 & $ " % #$& $$C <% $< &%"$$'<! $ #$7 C 8 N 44J =13 5 -O N #< ! 04 D %011=P3=,1= 5-54%-50O) + &$$? * %? &$ %?$)Q &$ *$? H & &$ %? $)Q &$ *$?) %24JJJ#54JJOR'CC%# C% $#$& #$!$ %$% & N4J/3#500;95
<9 '#7 & % %%$ 6 $ < ! '% # $ '$$ %$$C%$ %% ! ! '@% !%! #$ " D$5 $ $ #$& #% A%$ $! 6'#$7!#E%$$B%$'$%53 5
$ !6% $ #$& % A%$ !$! $$&<5
.5 ! ##$%6' % !%$ C%%"#$$$#$ *$? %$ %% #@*%*!$#% 6 D% C % &<5 ) #$%% #$$ % A%$ % %% C ' ! D% C$ % ##$% $"$$% $!*!%"& $ <! #$% C ' % !& %#& $%%!$# %$% D& $011;5
,-.//,011/ 23,32
#"$ " "# #
!
45 !$<D%$$C$!%$! 0K%011/' % !5
05 !$$6A%$#$& $$&<5
-5 %6#$!$%?$% %5
.5 C$ #$% 6M #&% C$$ $$ %$ #$!% $$A% ! -1 D$ 7 % C % #$7 $ < C!!$ 8)*S Q$*C6 3311. 9#$& $$% 7$$ % #< C$!%B$%5;0 C!!$$ $ <C!!$4/ D 011= 8 N9O ! $ $$ % 6$ % C % @#$&%#$%$ ?%$$$%% $O % A%$ $! $ < C!!$ #$ & #% #$ & !%$ 6 B % '$%5 .0 N5 #$!% $$A% % # 7 # $$% &6!@#$& &%A%$D %"'& 5 ?$CC 7$ $! % $ + ) @
# C$#$!%$$A%%% C !B#$% 6M"MCC C!!$ %!#< 6#$?$CC
,-.//,011/