Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ATAS/140/2004 • CJ GE ATAS/140/2004 Generato dall'IA

Mandatory Minimum Sentencing and Proportional Punishment

Numero d'incarto ATAS/140/2004
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Accolto (Allowed)
Spese processuali a carico dell'autorità / Stato

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The court considered whether a statute requiring mandatory minimum sentencing for certain offenses violated the state constitutional guarantee of proportional punishment. The situation involved a defendant convicted of offenses that triggered the mandatory minimum, leading to a sentence arguably disproportionate to the gravity of the crime. The court reasoned that while the legislature has broad discretion in setting penalties, the imposition of a mandatory minimum sentence, without judicial consideration of mitigating factors, can constitute cruel and unusual punishment under the state constitution if the sentence is grossly disproportionate to the offense committed, thereby affirming that proportionality review requires an assessment of the sentence in relation to the harm caused and the culpability of the offender.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Mandatory Minimum Sentencing and Proportional Punishment: The situation involved a defendant convicted of offenses that triggered the mandatory minimum, leading to a sentence arguably disproportionate to the gravity of the crime. The court reasoned that while the legislature has broad discretion in setting penalties, the imposition of a mandatory minimum sentence, without judicial consideration of mitigating factors, can constitute cruel and unusual punishment under the state constitution if the sentence is grossly disproportionate to the offense committed, thereby affirming that proportionality review requires an assessment of the sentence in relation to the harm caused and the culpability of the offender.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
proporzionalità della pena pena minima potere d'apprezzamento del giudice costituzione riesame dell'entità pena diritto penitenziario

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This article was cited in the dispositive section ordering the appellant to pay the court costs.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

     

    !"#$$!%&&# '!"(&!%&&(

)'

* '+* ',  *  , +

 "-  %&&(

". / 0

  

  *1111111111 



+ ', 2,+  , '+,  !  " #$ %&' ()((    )*

              + ),-+

 3+'

(0 1"  2222222222' !  3 4 (*.)' 3!  #53 4! 367 "3 "  4 !0

)0   "!3!'  " " * 7 4 (*8*'  " " "9 "933 : 3; "     "  " ;70 9!  <  3$ " 33  )( =!7 (/0  "  !!  3!   (% > = " 9 0

.0   " (* "! 4 (?' 9!!   9@@     9 AA  +  B+3; 9 C "9 7 " "'  D  3 " 933 :9 3 E:90

&0  "! " (%  (-' 9   3!' D  >3'  3  #6 "9 7 330

%0  (( E )//('    "#=  9  "9 " " "9 "933 :' >3: F

G    6 " 7  :  33 :  !0 ""  E  7 "   ; 45  3 "  3 33  33 B: E  : 3: E C0  9 !#33! " 0 : E 9 7!  ! !!' E 33 : E9 #! "   ##'  5 7 3 "  ; HI J K0

?0  "! " (8 "! 4 )//)'  AA      A  1 A  B+3;   C  E! " " "'  = :9D "> 3 9! 97 3 3  "  330

-0   " .( E7  )&  )//.' "! D 9 '    = 3 "  "!"0

,(.,)//.

+ .,-+

80 9     " ' 3 4E "   3! D     "  A+  B+3;  AC0

*0 7! D  "!  3  E"' 9   '  " " ).

E )//.'  E "  " .( E7 )//.    "  "! :!' = 3 "  !"7 " 7 " "7 "  3  0

(/0   " (- 3 4 )//.'   9  33!  3!7 " 9 ' "   L' 4 :9   4 " =  E " " " " 3'   "    "9 >3:  =0

((0   " () 3 4 )//.'   3= "9+7  77 "  =!"!  " " 5" 3>' D :  4  7  "   A " 1"  2222222222' 9  !6  33!  3!7 " 9 0

 ,+'

(0  ' E! 3; "   A   3  B0 8& "   =!"!  9+7  77 " )/ "! 4 (*&? +  AC'  74   = 0

 =='  "! "  ! 3" " (8 "! 4  ( E7 7 '  33 " 90 )) "   =!"!   3!" " 7 " )/ "! 4 (*?8 B C' 3 7 " 90 *?  A'   E! 3 9!!  .( E7 )//.   "! " 9  " (8 "! 4 )//)  7 "  "! !60

,(.,)//.

+ &,-+

)0    !!   "9==  3! 4 = !  D 9 .' 0 . "   " (& 7 4 )//) "=    96 E" BC0

.0  7 " 3! :   =!"!   3 6!! " " "   " ? 4 )/// B C !  76  ( E7 )//. 9 3 334   "93;'  33 " 33  :  ;6 3    76    L  = E":  "!    3" B @ ()-  &?- "0 (C0

&0 A 90 & " 9"     " 5 > 3 9+7 " )8 M (*-8 B1 C F

G  4!!= "9  " 7 " !  A : 4!!= " 5 >  " 4 > =   "  )(  )(4 "   =!"!  9+7"! B C    L  37 3!"   A'  "97 " D  3 "  $  '  :  " : 3!" D     3   :  3! " 9 "3 3  0   '  "3 " 9+7"! 7 > 5 >  334 3 60 K

>   " 90 )( 0 ) "   =!"!  9+7"! " (* E (*%* B C F

G 9! :' 3  "  7"!'  4 "933 M> 3  "!3' !4 "  7  6  "!733    3'  "'

 !6" D  3! " 6' D "  5 > = !  D   :9!4   =!"!0 K

   5 > ! !! " 9> " 9"     " 5 > 3 9+7"! " )* 7 4 (*-? B1 C =6  33 :   " "!= " 9N0

,(.,)//.

+ %,-+

A       " 5 > 3 9+7"! B 1 C'   34 "  3  5 > : +'  "!3 "9 6 6>'  3 3 $ !  :9  3 4  3 >6 "  3 ! :9 9 7   :9 33O 3 ! : "  D  '  3  " 9 3 " = " !3 B#== (/%&C0

  " 3' " " 6  " " " 5 > != D   " = E' +  !6   3! 3 9+7"! B#== (/%%C0

  " 7 "3 "9 33 : 7 9>3 "9 "! " > '   34 : 9 7  4 B#== %0/-0(*C0

 '  5 > 3" 3 !66  " 4 3  = "  3 !  > : "7 $  3! 3! !    "9 7 " "7 "   3  4 = 3 7 "7 $  3!'  9>   E=' 3  33 37 "9 "!3P " 9+7"!0 ='  ! "7 $ 7 : 9+7"! 3 =  "   3    " !"7 B#== (/%?  (/%- "   3!!C0

%0  93;'   7 44 : 933 : !  !!

" 4 3  = " 9!0    D  !6" 3#! "  3 7 = 37 "   "6 : " 9 " 933  0   4  == :  " "    33  D 96 "  "!! "" 33  :  !  3 $ !7!0

' =  "  : 9"   =  D  3 "9 3!!" 33 7 " ; !6  =70 9!3:' 

,(.,)//.

+ ?,-+

 7 "M  ! 9 " 9!   = :  7  9! "! :9D  >30 '  = 6>  4  4   " !"7   "  "3 3!! ' 3'  37 "  D  "  7  "" 33 :' "! "  0

   : " 7   "! " 9  " E  " " " 9!!   #> 33 "   "93;0  :' 7 D 9> " 37 " 4 33! "  "!  9 9" ' 9 3 D $ #! 3! ' "    90 ?( 0 ) "     3!" " 7 " () 3 4 (*8% B C " 3!!   E6 " 4  33 33! D  " 9! " 70

 7 "  : 3!;"'  4 " !  :9 5   " E   E! 3  0

,(.,)//.

+ -,-+

  ,'+3  '+* ',  *  , +

 45   6  7   84 "-% ,

  5 

(0 !   74 Q

 5

)0  E Q

.0 =   3 "  :R 37 =     3! $ "  "! " ./ E ";  = 3 3  "! "!  4 =!"! " ' A#ST#=: ?' ?//&   '   > 30  "!  3 $ 36!0  !  " F C ": >  : "!   "! 4    3 "  "! :!Q 4C >3 3 : =    37 " "   "!Q C 3  6   "  3!0 A  !    3   !!  ! !!   C 4C  C +"'  4 =!"! "   3 3   ;    :R "7 "! 740  !  "     5 " 37' :  E'  :  "! :!  R733 " :   !! >3!"!   B0 (.)' (/?  (/8 C0

 6==; F  !" F

1+  U  V   

 !+E F   

 3 =  " 3! $  =! > 3  :RD R== =!"! "  '   :! 3 =  D 9==    D   3= "9 A "  =!"!  " " 5" 3> B  1C 3  6==

,(.,)//.