Agency Consideration of Discontinued Proceeding Evidence
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe appellant, challenging an administrative decision, argued that the agency improperly considered evidence presented during a prior, related, but ultimately discontinued administrative proceeding when making its final determination in the current matter. The court reasoned that while agencies possess discretion in evidence consideration, the use of evidence from a prior proceeding, especially one that did not result in a final adjudication on the merits, violated procedural fairness and the established evidentiary rules governing the current action, thereby warranting reversal of the agency's finding due to the inclusion of potentially prejudicial and improperly admitted material.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 68 al. 2 LTF; Agency Consideration of Discontinued Proceeding Evidence: The court reasoned that while agencies possess discretion in evidence consideration, the use of evidence from a prior proceeding, especially one that did not result in a final adjudication on the merits, violated procedural fairness and the established evidentiary rules governing the current action, thereby warranting reversal of the agency's finding due to the inclusion of potentially prejudicial and improperly admitted material.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThis article governs the imposition of court costs, which is specified in order 1.
This article governs the reimbursement of procedural costs, which is specified in order 1.
Testo completo
&'()*&)++* &',(&)++-
##
# " " # "
% )* ./ )++- ,0 12
% 3333333333
44 " "5 " !"# ""! $%&'#()((*+$
!"# $%
/),'/
4
(0 1" 2222222222# "" 34 " ! "5# 3"66 5" 3 !""# 3 !!3# !7"" "3/"0 4 * 3 466" 3 4!"8"/* 93 "/334"3!"" +6+ "3 3 ): ; )&&( )' ; )&&$0 3 """# 4" 43 <==34"+" 34"3/"0
)0 4 3" "6" ! 3" ;" )' ! )&&$ 2222222222# "" "; > ? "6" 5 4 3 3 1" 2222222222/"3"53+@3#""="# 5""+3A0
$0 # 2222222222#! 3"/"34 #3 +"() !" )&&$0 6"! 5 "+" 3 ;B"! 66"+! / "3"5 !"C5+" 7+" 3 4 !!3 ! 3"!0
.0 !36"54""+"!33"@"3!" 6 3 )';)&&$#4 4""3*.!;)&&$*3+"3 ! 3 4 8"/* D1 9 6" 3 ; 6"" 34 ! =E!6"33"0
%0 F+!;)&&$#D1 " !"!"8 9 3 G 3 @ < +" * 3 =E"@ "+"" 7+" 8H933 !34@""#+"=G7"*04" 3+" <(&+!;)&&$0
F0 D3!"65"3 3F+!;)&&$#4 "3"5 >?6A0
'0 3 "" 3 $& C+" )&&.# D1 " < 4 3" < ! #!"654"+"6 4!"5""+" 0
:0 )-6 +")&&.#4 6! !"3 ""0@"5 +" +""!!"3!")&&$34"+373"5" " " (& 6 +" )&&.# 3 3" 5 " " 3"0"#4 7 66"3;*!3@0"5 """77 3 !7 <4" 34!;=343!3";#" 6 6# !"654"3!3 736634" 5"!"+7#=54"+"04 3" "6" ! 3" ;" (F 6 +" )&&.
,(-).,)&&. /$,'/ 2222222222 3 =""" 3 (& (F 6 +" )&&. 3 6" 5" 3+""C54)+")&&.0
-0 3 "" "" 3 (: I )&&.# !" 3 4 6"! 3 "" 3 $& C+" )&&.0 + 5 4;C"6 "" 3 ! !! 3 4" 34 !" !" " 3 +<4 "+" !"<""33! 3 "; < "3 6" 6" 3 " ! 3 !" 3"" "+ < "3 3 "" " < 4+ 34 +3"<4"3!" 0 !""3 54!"3 G " !"; + "" ! 3" )&&$0 + 54"" 3+"3" "6" 3"6"! 3" 3"4 +"5 "33(&6 +")&&.)+")&&.0 <47!54 +" +37#" "7 54" +" E 3 "" 3 4 "" !"6 +; 3 6 !"# 34 5 " 4"3"5"54 " ?6 <37A0 "3 54 +"36 !"6+;5""+" #3"< !" " 0
(&0 "3(%!;)&&.#4 "C 3 ""0 66"! 5 +" 5" " "!"; + 3 3"<4"33"="3=73#""54 "3 22222222220
((0 +" < # 4" ""! # 3 3 : ; )&&.# C 3 0 5 4"+" < 4 4"!"5"3+@35"6"3 22222222226" 56"! 3"6"! 3"@3 C<+ 3"0
()0 73 <C70
($0 6" " "# 5 3 ;"# 3 " ? 3"A3 C7!0
#
(0 "7+"3))+!;(-.(47""C3"""8J )0&%9 !3"6" "" #3*(I)&&$# ";3 " ! 3 "5 C7# 3 "3 +"/ "3# "5 "KC780(0%F 90
,(-).,)&&. /.,'/ D"<4"34 "3C7 ";6 3 8 L9 )'C+")&&.8 L($&(&F9#3 "7+"3 #($6 +"# 3""" "" 7 80 (F) 9 ! D 3 " 7 # < " C7 ""# 3 4 3 4 " 3 +@ C70
)0 6! ! < M0 %F 0 ( 0 =0 : # D N " "5 3 " + < 4" %F "+ < " 6 3 )%C" (-:) 4/=E!7 ;"7" 4"3!" 34"+;"" 8 90D! C7334*3 ;"0
$0 C ! " 3 6! 5"# +; 80 F& 0( 90
.0 !; 3 " ! !" 3 =E!7 6"7 !! 4!" !" 80 ' 0 3 3 " 7+" 3 (( +!;(-:$!"*3=E!78"/*"J))&90
4" ! !"!">
9 @ =E! = 3 4B7 3 " G " 3" @ "3!" 6 3 #
;9 < " ;"3""# @ =E! G " 3" @ "3!"
6 3 5"4+ +"" 33"<4" 3!"#
9 "" 54@ < == 34 !" * +" @ "+" "3 380$-0(3"90
4!"!"66<""3"+"333347!! "6 3 3 ! 3 "; @ "3 6" 3 =E! 80 $- 0 ) 3 " 90 3 " 3 43!""" # 34 ;"! 63" 3 3" ;"# 343!"""!!343!""" 7"6 3 80$-0$ 3"90
; 6""34!"!"#=E!3">
9 +" " 3"@"3!" 6 3 J
;9 " < " 3!" 3 4B7 3 3" < 3 4/+"" +" ; 6"" 34" 3 !"340$-0(0;3"J
,(-).,)&&. /%,'/ 9 +"; 6"" 3476"3 ""#34" 3 !" 34 !" !" 3 5 3 3 E 3 3!3# + 3 O =E!# !! 3 3!3# " < !" 3 " 3!" 3 4B7 33"<34/+""<3 634" 3!"J
39 P!J
9 +" ;" 3 3 "/3 34"3!"" 6 3 3 " 3 3" < 4"3!" 3 3 $( C +" 6 !" +; "7 4" ! # +" 6" 5" P";!@"7 3"+!"+;#+" 3 3 "3"" 6 "!* +" 6" 3 55 !"* 4;"7" 3 6" 3 "7! 3!3 4;"7" 34+"# +" ; 34;" "3I! 4"3!" 3=E!7J
69 +"6"4;C343!" 3!"""+" 34"6" "! @0(&%#(&F#(&'3"6 3 .'.:3 "J
79 ""!33 "!@"!!3$!"3*4 "!33" @"3!" 6 3 #3"7 + 80.)0()3 "90
+" 34"" 6" !" !" =E! 5"6"3!3 "5"!"3""6"@ @0.(#.) ..3"80..0(3*7!34@ "3"!"*3 =E!73$3 !;(-:.#"/**7!34@ "J))&0&(90
=E! 3" 3 !" "!! 3"! 4!" !" 80.%0(3*7!34@ "90 "5"#!"6 "@C"6" # 6 !" !" + 3 40 $- 3 " 4 3"<"""<! +" 3 3" " 80 .% 0 ) 3 *7! 34@ "90 =E! +3"5 !" !" 3 !" 80 .% 0 $ 3 *7! 34@ "90
%0 M*# " 3 3"66 "6" ! 3"@ + 3" 54 !!O4!"!" <4 #"F+!;)&&$# 3" ";34@+"5"!3"3"+" 353"+" 3;B"!@!0 73#"6" 3"4 3"7 2222222222# ""L1H="7" = 3"5 ' !; )&&. 4 ! + "54"
,(-).,)&&. /F,'/ 6"!5"34"" 34663+@33" %+!;)&&$0
" 3 =" 3 =7 3" 4 5 "+" """" < 3G7<4"34!; 3 @ 3 H# !! ;G7 =!"3 3 "6"# +7# 74"! 7"3#3 " 7363 !;""# +7 3 +" 6P# < G !" 3"66 3""; 3 "# +# 0# < !" 3 !;"" 3 33G7<63"!33 ! 7!"# <""!#"!="3 34=G7"* ;"#<!! "5#<3 "6#G =;" "# < + 3 3 =# 0 " " 5 "!!=""" "3" <36" " 3!=" 0
L 3* 3 < 3 ! " 54" 47" ! 34"+" 3 !; < "5 3 ! " 3 ;B"!5"66"+! 3 " <4 5#"#" 6+"!;;54""3"!+370
F0 73 @ "3 " 5" *3# !"6 "+5 4 "P"3 !! "@66"3"4 5<C"54" ""! 46 <" "+" !"0
,(-).,)&&. /','/
# 4 " # " " # "
% 1. 6 7 58 '9) ":
.
(0 +;J
% .
)0 CJ
$0 "5 37"J
.0 6! " 3 54 + 6! P 3 3 " 3 $& C 3* "6"" " !!3 3 "; 6 3 3 # D=Q"K=65" F# F&&. # " @!"0 3 " P 7 0 ! !" 3"> 9 "3"5 @!53 ""3 ";""33 "" 5 J ;9 @ 5 !"6 " "! +" 3!3
3 ""J 9 "7 3 0 D" ! !" " " ! ! 9 ;9 9 "/3# ";6 3 3!"*54" 3+3 "+;0! !"3!"!G 3 +# 5" C"# "" 5 3 "" 5 4+ 3 5 @ 3" 80($)#(&F(&:90 766"*> "3> "LL R"D R
" 6! 3 P "6" @ " "" 54 "
34 <4 !"766
,(-).,)&&.