Negligence Action Affirming Liability for Vehicular Collision
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAA plaintiff sought damages for injuries sustained in an accident involving a vehicle driven by a defendant, asserting the defendant's negligence due to excessive speed and lookout failures; the court affirmed a judgment for the plaintiff, reasoning that sufficient evidence supported the jury's finding that the defendant's operation of the vehicle was the proximate cause of the collision and resulting damages, despite arguments regarding comparative fault and the extent of the injuries.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 93 LTF; Negligence Action Affirming Liability for Vehicular Collision: A plaintiff sought damages for injuries sustained in an accident involving a vehicle driven by a defendant, asserting the defendant's negligence due to excessive speed and lookout failures; the court affirmed a judgment for the plaintiff, reasoning that sufficient evidence supported the jury's finding that the defendant's operation of the vehicle was the proximate cause of the collision and resulting damages, despite arguments regarding comparative fault and the extent of the injuries.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive for ordering costs.
Cited in the dispositive to declare the appeal inadmissible.
Testo completo
%&'()%*++, -%.&/)%*++,
!-
- - ! ! !
0 * $ ' 10 *++,
!"#$"%% " &$"%%'" (
"
(( & )) * " $ %+,-
! " #$ $
*2.40*
! 2 -
45 6*!78"9$:4,;1 $"!7% <"=""#$ >!&"!?%4,@2A 4,,;!$"$ !+$ "! %B%2C" 4,,,/4:#233;5)%:%"#$"$42:#233/" %$""%-,&0/3=55
25 %" % 2, :# 233/ " %$!$ !7 % &(( & )) * 6*!78 9 % % % !"" "%" A &" %& " ! D % !! =$#23345
/5 !!" ! & % 44 =$# 233/ % <%DE%F ? ) ) 6* !78F9"<>"""!" G2332!$ %E"$!!"$%"#%!"D/* 05 " " < &"#"$ B$ :<& $"" BEG % "%% "5
05 $% """ % !!" % 40 =$# 233/ A & "" %E" #%$!!"$% "#+% #"$G G<&"<E<" "; %" # D % " "$ $5 !"$ % "# $"" %! 4/ :# 233/ " ! %$ %$" $5 ) G % %# !!"B$ $%"""B!"<"=="%% %! 4,,; 6 %B"*#B D+!% %!"D ;*)495 4; =$# 2334 #" % % % G$" " #" " G<% G%"%: G%"5#"#$ %E" %&"" % ; %" ! "$ % $ " !$ %& D%5"=="":% G"%: G %" !!"" ! % E !" %G" " $#" =$< ""5&"#"$%"&$""!BEG"!"$% "# % !" !#" ! H" $$5 &B %& " "#"$ &$""!BEG% <%= "%G"%& !G"$ A "%!" G$!E$5
;5 : 233/ "E$ ! $% % I ))) %!"%E%& !+!"$%"# $%%" $%"""%<"<&!"%==% ! % ! % "# % # !=5 " $"" #! <%DE<! ""%% %F6""%20:233/% 95
./01,.233- */.40*
15 <%DE="!#A& $ $%&G#" %4;C"233/$"GA"%&$:%"%4442C"233/ <&""%/%$ G233/% 5 $" % % " < " A G $+ !"$ < &#""'$!"$%"#5 """D$!"*%&#" DE$ % + !" "E % % G %== # %" !%*%AED!<&A%"5)%!" G233/ #+" %$E$$ % %$$ /*0 ! !$ 0*; J %$$;*)4 !%5"!""": " ! G" < E" !" "5 "#" DE" "#E$#"= "$"$B""#" $"$ %$ A & % % ! ! DE E " ! % # % &%!"" % "+ % # " %& # !=5
-5 % 0 =$# 2330 %$ "<&&$""!!G!"%!% !%"5#DB""A#!"$%"# $% % ! ! $E <& !!"" " %&B!" ! !% " !G ! B ! A "# " != % &#%"$5
@5 # $% % 2, # G 2330 "D!$%" (F%) 6*!78)9!!" %#&#%"%&% ""!"$%"#%433K % "#"$ %!"$ B "" =" 6! % !" % DE !$AD"L"%!"%G".!%!"*A*=B %"9%!=$#23305
,5 ( !$" (F $% " " % D " $% % &""" % !$#+ % & !+ % " "" % !!" % /4 233; A & %E" % G*"<0*;%"D%5M#!"$%"# !#" ! H" $$ ! % $% " % !=&$""!%<$5%B %0:#233; #" "$ "7 !"" +% #"$G !E" % "G E< " # % " % = $ A N# 7E % %7 03 %E$5 !" " % %==$" $$ " < #" $"$ !"$ A ! $% """ " ! < % DE &+ #" ! % &""% A $" <5 &"#"$B$:<&""#"$&$""BEG % & !" =" : % #"$G G " % G=$%"5
./01,.233- *0.40*
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
445 =%!#$#%"A%!""%&*#%"$& "$% & ()) 6*!78 9 B % !""% % " A $%!"" != " % !"$%"#5
425 !!" %&"" != % 4@ # G 233; $"G !7 "E % <" A !G"$ % $%!" "%"#"$$E7 !"!"<!#$E"!" #!G"$%&"!""=$E7 "<<!% &! % "#5 "#B " <&# A &$"G %" " $E "E%&$$ " !"$E!#"#"% %" %$" % " BEG $"" % -3 K ! " !5 E$ % !"$ %&!!"E ==" " % G !"$ %&"$E"!="$""#%!!#A !%"#"$<!#"B!<&"""%%$ ""##$! '" % $%!""5 % " #" =$
./01,.233- *;.40* "$E< " !!" % '" %&==" $#" "E "!5 " $"" % "" % "" "" " % %$%" " #*A*# % !D7 % "# " !!"# % "!"!=" "5
4/5 %%E$%&#%"$%2,# G233;& &"=%$ &<H"""%6*!78))92330"G 4O ""###%"$%0;&;//=5G"" "%2;K<& ##%"$%-,&@//=5"B%&#%"$%"$""%0/K5
405 %$ % ; 2331 & G % % "B "G$$=%&<"%"A!"%:#23305
4;5 )"""&!!"= $!"& !%$%4/:" 233-= $%$%; 23315G"& " $ G%"""% <&!!"#% "$"" # % &"""% %$ "$ ! "5 %" A &" % != &$"" ! !5 " "B %&#%"$ # % ) G" G#" % "E 5 &B %& "#"$%"$E7$""BEGA433K!!"%&B < %22:233;<="'"!#!G"5DB % "G 4%))2330$""%:"=$# G"" "% 2;K % &QE % =" < "#"$ $E7 $"" !G < % ""="5
415 " !"$ 4/ !" G 233- " ":"$ " %$!!"%4/:"233-5"!! "A&" % %$ ""<$ " A =B" %& "B %&#%"$ % 433 K %7 4 :#2330G% "A=B"%&"B%&#%"$%-;K%74 :#2330"!$% %$%!""!=#" %%$!5G""!DA& %!#!$%$A <H" $ < " % &H" =%$ < " &))5 !%" %B #$"% $%"""<%(5)""G" !" " % """ A "$ !D+< % G "" ="%&G""%= "!="% E"< < % QE " " H" #% A 433 K5 ""$"" H G%!!"% =%"" <% " BEG" B %-3K%"#"$%!"$"B<%#"H" $%" % 23 K % "7 "$5 !!<" "B %&"#"$%;3K%E$%&#%"$"%12K<%%"A"* <" % "5 = % R &" ! %&B ! % > % " %" A % %&"" != % "5 %" %& = % % $%!"""!$$5
./01,.233- *1.40* 4-5 %"%4;"G233-& :"%$=$"A "#"%%$!!"5"=B%!$"%<" &" = " != E"<5 = &" A G %" < % $%!"" " $"$ =$ % R " =$ "" "E "! " =" !# %& S <% "#"S5
4@5 %"%4@"G233- G%$= $!"< $""E%$:E$5
! -
45 = $ " A &"5 ;1 5 4 "5 D5 2 % E# &E" :% 69 G " % '" " < % """ !$# A T" ;1 % =$%$ !" E$$ % %" % % 1 "G 2333 6 9 < " "#A=$%$T*#%"$%4,:4,;,6 95
) !$"!:E%%T!7"$"G5
25 %$"E+"$"$%%"%4/:"233-"""" $"" % =" :%< " %$" " "" A &$ 233/ !$" "E B $ A 7 % # %!" % "$ #E4:#233/"% %="% $"#A07 $#%"""$#E4:#2330% % !"6 (4/3//2%5252"25/95
! =$%$ % 41 %$ G 233; %=" =$%$ &*#%"$ " !!G !< $"$ = $ !7 4 :"23316D5"5%%!""""#A %="% 41%$ G233;95
/5 ":"$%= "%$!$#!"#G6"5;1A 13 "!!%%$%%4;:"4;C"233- "5/@50"5G 95
05 "E!"&$#"%"B%&#%"$%"%&!"" %"A&"% %$%!""!=%&"!"5
;5 ""!$G#"%#<&B" %&"5@54"/ " $!"$ #%"$ T!"$ % E "" !" < " !$ $ ! " % E %$5 T""" A "$ T" % ! A %$" ""!%$"<% R"'
./01,.233- *-.40* !"$%"#+"%=="!"$%E%T$6+* %E"J UG % #%#DE ID 4,,- !5 @95 " $!"$!"$%"#""!"""!"%T!""%%T$ A ! % != % %T"#"$ "# < !" H" G " H" BE$ % "" !" $" % "$ !D+< "5 %T!"$ % "# % E %$ T"#"$ < !" H" BE$ % !" # %T " != %T " % %T"#"$ 6"5 1 95 " $!"$ !"$ % E "" % " % T G %T !" % !G"$ % E % T$ D$ % "#$<G$<"%$"""% "$"%T""" A "$ !D+< " " <T !" !7 "" " " %$%!""BEG6"5- 95
+%!$<:!%"%&#%"$% %"%""$ <" $%O" $<$ <G:"#%&!"$="<& !" %&$# 6 ( 443 2-; %5 0 43; 23- %5 295 <& % &"#"$%&$%$$ <="%$="+%=% %$ %&% $% % R ! """ %&$# !"$%"#%&"$$%%"#"$G "BEG6 ( 44;4//%5243;4;@%54O ( !G$%4,#2332 ;;0.3495
= =" ! !% % # < &GE" ! &$ % % % E"!!E$$%%"%6 (42,01/ %505242/2//%5/44-2-@%52G033"H""$95 :E!"!=% ! ""#<&$=&" * H !G%=%!%$G"%!"$%"#! $#"<""""$%&=A!="%E$%#%"$
6 (431@1%52!5@-95
15 $""!!#%E$%&#%"$&% ""6:E & + 9 G % % " <& $% $#" " %&"!$"%#"=5"QD% $%"A!" :E " &$"" % "$ " A %< % < " ! < "#"$ &$ " A "= !G % "#5 " %$ $% """ $$ " " ! %$" < "#B !" G "BE%&$6 (42;214%5044;4/0 %5 2 440 /40 %5 / 43; 4;@ %5 495 %$ $% ! """E$$ "!!$"G:"#%5& !"" """ < !#" H" =" A & %& "E %&G#" != < " !"G %&H" =$ ! % $$ " G:"=$ !" "%&$!%""E6 ( !G$%1 233/-12.3295
./01,.233- *@.40* 7E$$%&B %#!G"%&!!" $% < " %$" " &" < !" "EB " =" &G:" %& $"% "$ < !!" =% % B !" <& ! $E "%$"!"B! $!!B $<& "$"$$"G!%& 7<%!"%"B" $% " &!!$" % "" $% " " = < % &B!" " %C " "#$5 % " &$$ " %$" " ! # !G" &" &E % + % !# %$E" !!" B!" G"G"6 ( 42;/;2%5/422413%54"$=$95
)&E" % # !G" % !!" $"G ! $% """ :E!""%"" !"%="<&B!$ $%"""" E$$ "%%"A!%!"!!""% "%=<&"A%5 :!%%! %!%B"""="!!$"<&A&!!$"%&!"$ %"#! $%%= 6 (42;/;/%5/G."$=$ 4,,;!500O 4,@@!5;30%5295
= ! < " ! !"7 " % !!" $%B $"G ! ) & " # <& !#" ! H" H !% < B %& B!" % " %&G#" $% % & 6 9 E= ""=!<&%%#E%&!" $%%)" $%""""$% ""##B!"5 # !G" % !!" $%B % " % " %" G !"V" &!!$E%%"7B!$*%6 ( !G$%20C" 2331,/@.3;%5/5295
-5 &!7 !!" ) % 2- : 233; $ %& !$" D "E " #H" ! # !G"5 ==" !" "EB !"""="&G:"%&$"%=$!!"=%&G#" < !% %$" !" B! $ $"$ $"G ! % % 6 7 ! = " !=9 EG%E"!$!" $%<"B $" """G "#$!"7 "<"% &"#"$ < % G " BEG5 ) !" &# % :"B%% <%DE %F"%5&#%(&"!%"A "" <" """5 ==" """ % #"$G"% G=$%"B<="$=$"!% " A B !G"$ %&B "" "#"$5 ( " %& == "= % "" % 42 2331 !%"!"R "<&SB" "#%"$% =" < &" ! ! & < %#" &H"S A # !
./01,.233- *,.40* &""" % !$#+5 ! $% """ 6%" """ %#" H" !!$$ # "9 $=7 A % "7 < " ! !"" % !" % # % &*#%"$ A "% 6 < % = " % G9 < " ! !" % "+! %&"#"$ %!"$ 6& !G"$ % " % !" G$ !E$95 & " == "= <" A &B % "" !"$ % "# $% % "" % 20 : 2330 5 ="!!$<&&+!%=%"#<" &" * H !G%=%!%$G"%!"$%"#5
" '"%$%!""% "" $<% "%" $""$%"A-3KA%"%!"$6!!") %4@# G233;95 !%"!!<= " %& "E %&G#" ! " <& " " !!" &#%C " "#$%& $%A<!!""! D=%!" :E " &$"" % "$ % &$ " %&%< % < " ! <"#"$*"!G%"#$D$"<"#B" !"G "BE%6 (42;214%5044;4/0 %52440/40%5/43;4;@%5495""$""% " $ G#$ %" "E "" " 22 " 2,K " &B!<" !!" % ! < % %+ " % "#" % " < S&"!%%+ <%$"= $<&"%&%$< """ " "" ! """ ! % "#S 6!!" !$"$ !5 419"!!&"""A"$5
%$="#&"A:"""<& "<"" %&B A 433K "#"$ %" $E7 %!"$ A "" ="5
@5 $"" #" % #$= % "B %&#%"$ < !$%$ & $"""$<&%$="#%$" "%##%"$ """$!"5
$G "!!$<&#"%&"52@54 6%# #E%74:#23309&$%"A""7&"#%A -3K A"*<"%"&"#%A13K A% * "&"#%A;3K A<"%"&"#%A03K 5)&"52,54"5G %"A"!%! "V"A%"A<&$!$"$ +!"$%"#% 03K !%"$"!""G6"51 95
DJ $ "= %E$ %&#%"$ %" H" $#$ G %& ! % # !>" " % % %" A " 6 ( 42, 22/ %5 05495 # < &$ " !
./01,.233- *43.40* G" & &$"" ! #% " !$ # <& !" G" B>"&"#"$<!"G "H"BE$%!7"" " " %$%!"" D$%"#$<G$5 ! % # &==" 7E % D==" B" " < !G ""%%B#"=""&#&" %==$ ! """ % "B %&#%"$ 6 $"D% E$$ % !%#O (4/3/0@%5/5042@/3%54430 4/1 %5 2 " 2GO % 4 :# /4 %$ G 233/8 "5 4 5 4 $" # &"5 41 O %! 4 :# 23308 "5 2@ 5 2 $"#&"541 95
# % ! #% %$" $"G" %E$ % # G!$!%$"<&"=="# "!$ " %$" " $"" G "$ 6 ( 42, 220 %5 05/54 " $=$95 %" H" $#$ % 7 7" < !G G <& #" 7E E$$ % $=$ % < &$ G" #"&"""A"$5
) &$$#$!<&&!!%&"#"$%! #%"$% &B!&"#"$<&!"G " BE % # %&#% !" H" $#$ G % %$ """<""%&<H"""%6 (421 -1 %5 /G. 44- 4@95 $=7 A """< % G" "%%$=%"": $%#"6 (420 /2495
= % < "" % """< %#" H" $%"%$!%%& G%"!"!=% !" 6 "" $ D%! QE $ % # ""$."$E %&"" % $: " "B %&!"9 " $" %& $#" % " % !# %&!!$"5 %$%" EG B %2;K"""<! "%" !"%%==$" $$ "<!#"=#%& "#"$"#6 (421-, %5;G.*O)2332!5-35%50G95
,5 &!7"$"G<!"$%"#%""""% "#"$ %!"$ ! """ %&" %B = ! D !" " !"%G"B"%#$E7 "%DEB$%";L" %!"$E7 "!%B$%"42L<"""#!"*A* =B ""< !E$ % "5 &" ! ""$ < ! % #%"&=="2330" "%%$G"%"&"52, 5 "5G <&="" ##%"$< ""$$% !+%"#"$%" A#-,&@//=5 " "A<!$"%"!%$"
./01,.233- *44.40* # %&#% & & ! A ==" <H" $ < !A!"$%&$ !" &="=%&))5 &%$=$"<!#"!$"%D =="" % "#"$ ! " $!$""# 6# % <=" 09 % " !#$ % !%" A # ;@&2/1 =5 6)) 2330 495 G""%%$"" !"%&D%"#%03D" %$ DG% % =$ A + % "! 2330604-DO$ <42*233;!5,0,529 ""%"H" !"$A13&-44=5 $!%BG:" %"#"%" <& E% % E $#" %&"#"$ ! " $!$""# < # " % !%" G E="= % "#"$ " $E7 " %!"$ A D%!5 """< < $"$ ! %$" " %!$""=%<!"EE" !""%& D$ $<G$%"#6%&"52@52 41 9 """A!=" !!"$%"#%"#"$%!"$5
$""&QEE!$%%&"#"$"="<""% $ %"+!%&"#"$<&!"B%D%!"""% "=%$%"%"""<5#D&+!% ""$ A""$B$%#5""$""& "%$%" B % 2;K " G"" " !$ A % 23K !!$ ! "5 !!#"%!!<=="%2;K"# :"="<<""%&$"%$"$E%" " A QE B $ % # A ""$ A "$E %&"" % $: A "B %&!" # A $ % E A $"" %&"" %&!DG$" 6 ( % 24 =$# 233/ /4-.32 %5 ;5/529< G!H"&!75 $""& %!% % %&E!#%&!!$"%"<:E%"=!# %"<&" $A#$=G*=%$%&"!!$"6 ( 421-;%51!5@442/4;3%52"$=$!54;2957 G % $ & "% A $%" !$$ ! & #" ""="7E$$B5
"B %&#%"$ % " " % 0/K B # %$" *% < % %" A <" % "5 %$ ""<$= $!"5
435 " A %$" " %" B % $%!"" %&% != !" &"" != " !=<&% %A""G%5
""!$G#"%!!<$#% $%T #%"$ ""%"B %$%!""$<"% "A$"GA "A $!"$%E!"$
./01,.233- *42.40* %T !"#BDG"<T"B$"#"$"# !$G6"5@54 95 B" %&"5@5/"G % $%!"" !" % %T% != " &"" != 6"5 4; 9 " != 6"5 4- 9 " #%! "6"54@ 95
7EE$$&$&%"<&B $!!A""% G" % $%!"" #$ ! A < " % 6 (420443%52"$=$O)2332!543,%5295 !" &$ !" !$"% A = " %& # !$ A %"#"$=""E#"$%&#%"$"" < = " %& # !$ ! " % "" A !=" %& 7 !" !"$ % "# A # != ! $#$5 " < !$=$ % &"$$ <" DB % E % "%#"H"!%$""""=: V %$" " 6 4,@@ !5 211 %5 495 )" $!"$ $ " !!!$ "" % $%!"" != < "G" %" "A=#$%!""%#"#6 (420443%5 2O)4,,-!5@;%495
445 &!7"B%&#%"$%0/K"!$B<<23K!$#! :!%!#%"A %$%!""!= 6=5 ( !G$%22%$ G233/@3-.32%525195
$"" " " % %=="$ A "# % "# &" !%$""%"$ " "%="<#% ""!"$%"#&"!%$ D%5==" %!%"%= "$! """%"# ! ! % % % !%" " <&# A &$"G %" "$E "E%&$$ " !"$E5 &:" <!"$%"#%"""7%"#"$%!"$< !!&G%&%"<&"A H %"#! !! +$D$"#&%%E%&*DV E ! %!"$ A $"" % "$ 6) 2333 !5 -3 %5 2G -4 %5 95 % %&% != = %&"" != % " != %&% ! " $#7" ! $%:!%!!$*%6=5 ( !G$% 23:#233;4/@.30%5;5/95
#D # QE "" =" %$" " %$ % &!"$%"#!"H"BE$%"<&B $%" " "#"$A433K H %!"$5)G%G#"="%"E 6G !""% !$" B!"G % &G % "#"A!%"#"$!=9 G%7<&"
./01,.233- *4/.40* $% """G$$=%&"E%$"' "A&==" < # %& % % ! "5 =" # ""= A &" % & <"&"!!$A"" !="=$ "E "!5 $<" " %$ < % % "#$5
425 #%<!$7%:"$"$ "%233=5 ADE%"= "$%&"51,54G 5
./01,.233- *40.40*
! - 2 ! - - ! ! !
$
340
45 $#G5
$ 34
25 :""5
/5 "<& #"$A ""!"E%$"' "A&==" % % "#$%"5
05 &+% ""<%G5
;5 "$ "%233=5ADE%"5
15 = !" % <T !#" = " !$" H" % %$ % /3 : %7 "=" !7 % G =$%$ 6)DWJD=<11330 9!#% "7%%" !G= $ "B"5@2%=$%$ G=$%$%4- : 233; 6 (9O $ % %" %< "= " +%!#"!"E"%"% %"O%" H" %$ G =$%$ ! # !" ! # $"< B %" % &"5 02 (5 !$" H" " !7 ! % "#<$ +%!#%#"H":"A E== !$%" G) $"*:"8 #
!= %!$"H"""=$B!"<TAT===$%$ %!E==
./01,.233-