Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ATAS/1369/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/1369/2007 Generato dall'IA

Property Partition Finality and Vested Rights Appeal

Numero d'incarto ATAS/1369/2007
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Parzialmente accolto (Partially Allowed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The appellant challenged a judicial decision concerning a right to property that originated in a partition that occurred in 1923, arguing that certain actions taken in 1921, 1922, and 1924 should have been binding or that the subsequent application of an equitable division should have yielded a different result regarding the property's division or the recovery of benefits. The court reasoned that the initial partition was valid and final under the controlling statute, which dictated that subsequent statutory changes did not divest vested rights, and thus the appellant could not retroactively claim rights or benefits based on later property interpretations or divisions, affirming the lower court's judgment distributing the property as it stood under the final 1923 decree.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Property Partition Finality and Vested Rights Appeal: The court reasoned that the initial partition was valid and final under the controlling statute, which dictated that subsequent statutory changes did not divest vested rights, and thus the appellant could not retroactively claim rights or benefits based on later property interpretations or divisions, affirming the lower court's judgment distributing the property as it stood under the final 1923 decree.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
diritto di proprietà diritti quesiti divisione della proprietà azione di rivendicazione interpretazione della sentenza prestazione statutaria

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This provision governs the awarding of costs and is cited in the dispositive (implicitly, as per standard procedure when costs are addressed).

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo



           !"#$%&"%&&' ! !"(#)*"%&&'

!++

,- +./-! ! ! , !-+! .!

01  #  %* 1  %&&' 



 !"#$"%%  " &$"%%'"  (

"

))     & (( *      " $ %+,- 

                  

   *1.3*  

! ,-  2!.

    %$!$  %" % 4, # 1224  % % % !""!5%&66"%&*#%"$7

&66"%&*#%"$!#"!8""% %$$9$&""8&66"% "%%7

&%"%1- 1223& "6$8&$%$6"%" 8%!""7

: 1223&"$$6 $!!"8""%$% %";& %$"%$! !$"$"7

6 $ "8% %%$$"$"+$1<"12237

# $%$9 =(>%#%"%44<"1223

&!!"$"$% %$!&  "%!+?9;%"% 1@<"12237

  # %  !" %  % &  & $ !  % 4, A#122-7

  &" 6 " ;& %" % 1/  122- ;  " % !+?9 ;%!!"7

  %$"$ !#(;&"!$%"%1@ 122-7

!%44"B122-&$ B%$%& !%$%A"7

&%"%4,"B122-& "6$8&$%$!!"7

"#$ B%$!%4@# B122- $9";& %!"%" $$ "$8!%%$ %! % 122-%$A87;&"$;B; "%#BA"!"!"8%$!%#"C"%$7

%$!%4:# B122-& 6" ;$;&%$ !!"+"$"$"6$8&$$""%#BA"7;! ; " % %$ % A"  * C  &   6"  ;$ ; &"" % &!!"6 $%"%: 1223#"$95 "!9$";"% ! !  " % !+?9 ; ! $!% 8  ;"  "  C" !"$7



./012.122-  */.3*   .,+!  ,+.

 6 $ "8&"D:3D4"D?D1%9#&9" A%=> B"%'""; %"""!$#8E":3%6$%$!"9$$%%" %%3"B1222= >;""#86$%$ E*#%"$%4,A4,:,= >7

 !$"!A9%%E!5"$"B7

   "A"$   B % &"D :3 D 1   ; !$#" ;&  !"$9 "C"6 $;& 9$% %%&"$$% !%%$%%$!!""#B7

&&%$!!"$"""#!%$% A""%#BA"7

6 $ "8E"D34"D9 ";B""9%%"  B "%6"%$!7

6 $ "8A!%""% B6$%$% " +  %" C  ;  !$% "  BA" ! "" ;  ?%5%!5A"6"= )442:-%D17 4,0,!D/40 %D1B>7

6";EEE "%%$96!!"" ;!$%#"!5% B%$"%?%57

E66"*%$!%"%59!!B%$%A"7

&"D1,D4 "D*;$%$8&"D@D4 "D%!4A#1222* %!;""!%"%!$%A%% ""#8 ;"""$$;"B ""A9$%%$B7

&!!%$$"$"!?B"%A"6$8""7

&%"6$%$%!!"5 "!!%$$"$ 69"8&"D0:D1"D (=$"#&"D3, >%" #9A;&/4%$ B1221=6D )41-@3-%D4414/33%D 4B>7 

&"%$ $!&"D34"D #9%!4A# 122/7

&F9%";!$%" !"!%"""&F! %&!!9$$%%"%= )44234%D@B7



./012.122-  *@.3*   G(  6? % ? 6? B%   (H#?9?"I( (4,,1!D1-1;"10"!D1-0#D7 J 9  ?"9%K"H % (H#?9!H I ?" (""%"L %%HM"?"%)"?6"H 32DB""9# %" %G4,,/!D@32"C""$>7

  !$% A% % ! 5 " "     !! % $$"$;"%#"""$"%#"""$6$%$7

 &""$ #  !! % $$"$ ;&  % !  %$ ;&   B % !% %  %$ !" !    %  %$ ;  " % &66  ; ""  " " 6" !!'"   B = )44,B/44%D:!D/1/744-4,/%D4B6"!D4,-742-B432 %D/B!D43:7N9J%?"%(?MH4,,,!D:2: D7 9 J  " %  """ 6$%$ D ,/ % "D @  "D7 O ).( OJ   !K? ??"L#" % % (?MH4,,,!D122>7

   A!% %  & ! % &"D @ D 4  "D *  ; #""#&9%&"D1,D4 "D*"5B% %$%!$%&!!$6"%"!"5%7

&#"%6%8!!%$$ "BA"67

&" " "5 " " " %$" "  %9$ %  !F"$ % &66 &A ; #C"  "9 ! &"$$  ;   !" " %  % "  % ""$  !$"" = )  :/.24 % /2 # 1224 %D 17 )41@4@1%D144,B/1:%D:B"$6$"$>  %66"$8$%;"%6"=F!"!F !7" % ""6#DP"% ""6""QR15 $%D1221 !D1,1""S3,,7 ) :/.24%/2#1224>7

&!!""!A"B%&"!%;"!#! ; &""$ 6 %9 ;  "  &#"" 8 $$  !$%   "$?$"!"%A"6$= )42-B4::%D1B"!D4:0 D>D ""B9"&!!$""6# %9 !$%!$" % ""# =O ).( OJ  !D "D !D 12/*12@7  .    .O """"#DD41@/>7

%$%%$B&"!6$!%"$"95 !B5 8$%7

"!?8""$;;" ! "$#"B% !$% = ) 41@  4@1 %D 1 44, B /1: %D :B " $6$ "$> 9"%$6"?9""!#"!%"A"6



./012.122-  *:.3*    " F# %& !$%   !!"" 8 &T"" % % F ""$ A%  + 9" " 6 66" ! 9" F "+% ""%A"6 %""""= )413 1@, %D @7 # 8 !! % &"D 1, D4 "D " %  9" !%" %$%"!#"%&"D@D4 "DI )41:4,4%D1/-:%D1B. 44,B/1:%D:B7 )41142/%D.@!D4447 )44,4%D/!D/7 N9J!D"D!D:23D7O ).( OJ !D"D!D12@D7 .   .O  !D "D  41@@ >7 !  !"  "6 ; "8E9%6%""%"%A"6$7;"%$" "E" 6";E""$E"!9;E"9#"%= ) :/.24%/2# 1224 %D 17 ) % 1/ # 122/     04,.21 %D 1D47 ) 41@  4//44-44-%D/4,-%D442012%D@>7

  " % %$! " % %$ B " %&B% %  """%#"%!!%$$"$"""%& !" "  " $""  66"  6  % $!" =O 4/@.21 C" % /2 A# 122/ %D4D:7 )411444%D.@>7

&&!56"%"";&&"$$!5%;"% % %!"""%$%1- 12237

& %$ $"" 6 " "#  1-  1223   !   ;"%#%$;&"$$"&!!"6  "6 $ :  1223   !$"$  "  %" % 1 <" 1223 "  %$  !!"6 ""#%"%4,"B122-";"H ! "%""""6%&%$%A"7

&;6"!%" ;&" $($"$ $%" ""$ "!% "%#44<"12237

&&#5;"%!!& "9%!" !"B "% !+?9;;&$!%F;";$""!$;&%"% 1/ 122-7

&"(&"!$"# "#"!;&%#%" %1@ 122-7

;" "% ""$$A;&8%$%& 7

&9%%%$"%%$";!$5%"?%5% !%$%A"$"" %7

E   A"6 %5  ! %E% % %$!  !$"" $9 % "7



./012.122-  *3.3*  

!+  3 .2  +./-! ! ! , !-+! .!  

4D %"%%$%4,"B122-D

1D "";"%#BA"D

/D ";!$%"9""D

@D +%QD

:D 6   !" %  ;E !#" 6   "  !$" C" %  %$ % /2 A %5  "6" !5 % B 6$%$ =(?MH?6;3322@  >!#% "5%%" !B6 $ "F"D01%6$%$ B6$%$%4- A 122: = )>7  $  %  %" %;   "6 " +%!#"!"9"%"% %"7%" C" %$  B 6$%$ ! # !"  ! # $"; F %" % &"D @1  )D  !$" C" "  !5  ! % "#;$  +%!#%#"C"A"8&#D   9665  !$%"         )) G(  G



!6 %!$"C"""6$F!";E8E666$%$ %!966



./012.122-