Statutory Interpretation of Overpayment Calculation Dates
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case concerns a dispute over the proper calculation of an alleged overpayment, where the parties disagreed on which version of a specific statutory provision applied during the relevant period, given intervening amendments. The court reasoned that the version of the statute in effect at the time of the relevant transactions or events governs the determination of the overpayment amount, and therefore, the calculation must employ the statutory language as it existed prior to the subsequent amendment that the opposing party relied upon.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Statutory Interpretation of Overpayment Calculation Dates: The court reasoned that the version of the statute in effect at the time of the relevant transactions or events governs the determination of the overpayment amount, and therefore, the calculation must employ the statutory language as it existed prior to the subsequent amendment that the opposing party relied upon.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAProvision cited for the order regarding court costs.
Testo completo
"#$%&"'&&$ "#$("'&&)
+
*, ,, *,
#% '&&)
)- .
//////////
,, 0,1 ,, ! "#$ %&
''()
! * +,-*
, 2
.2 3( 45555555555$ ) 6 .7/#$ 6))8' 9 4 :' . &(6 .77-2 +1 &(6 .77-$ 9')) ):) ( :' : (; <''' 9 4$ &' = :' > :)'? (2 (('' .# @&' .770$ 988' A'*:% 9 B ' ) (; <''' '')$ = 0" C :'< 9 2 9) 6))8'') &( (; <''' )(6 .77D :(6 +11.2
+2 +D 8)&' +11+$ 9) '') :' > 9 & :' :)'?$ ('8 ? :('% ?! )' '& ?? @ :% -+ )&2
/2 )'' # )(6 +11+$ ' >&' (:' A'*:% 'B 8) ( :' ):) : 9)$ ('8 ? (; <''' 9 4 :& ! &'?) ? < $ 8 ' ()' @'8' & :)'? ( & 9<:'' )'2
#2 / @&' +11/$ 9) ) )'' :% 9 '$ @'> :' '8' ()'< )6' : 5555555555 55555555552 988' (' = (('' ('% 9 4 (( 6@ (:)2
"2 :)&' +0 ( +11/$ 9 <: ? 9) ()
'(:''( ? 9 ' ::'' ' 9* '&'')2 $ 9) 6 '6' = 9 :)'? ::'' ':'' 42 &' 88 ' 9E> )> ' +/ 6 .77- &' ):) ( +1 )(6 .77-2 )?$ &( :)'? ' ! ') ::'' ':'' ' 9*&'' &'& ?' :)&' &( (<'(( < $ = (' ? ' ()' @'8' &( '':)$ ? ()' :)' F3G ' '8'2 9)$ 9 : ? 9 @ 2
,./01,+11/ * /,-*
-2 ' # @' +11/$ 9) ('' ($ )> ? :' '' = )8( ? 6' ' & :2 ''' 9! 2
02 '6 )$ ? )) (' 988'$ :)) = 9'' 9)2 )) = ' ? ( ):) H +11+ &'' = 9' '6' :)'? : 9) +111$ ?9 9&' @(' 2
D2 '% '$ 9 :' @ $ :: ?9' &' :' >$ .D :(6 +11.$ ?' )) '&) = 9) 9)) +11+2 9 ' & '6' : :)' ? 9) 9 : 8' 8' ?9 :)'? 9 )) 8')2
72 :$ '& ))( ) ' :'$ ? 6'$ :' ' '*:%2
, *
.B )6($ ' ; ' :)' ? ' >&' 9>'' @''' A + 1"B )) ('8') : ' .# &(6 +11+ ?9 '6 ' )) '') % . H +11/$ ' '?$ (( ' '& = '
8)) 9*&'' &'&$ +1 )(6 .7#- A82 ' .$ 2 "- & 2 . 2 2 . B2 4 92 /$ 2 / ':'' ''$ '' & 9) &'> ' :)') : & (('' ('% 9* &'' &'& )) (' 988' '6 *'2 (:) '6 ) % )6' : @> :) ''>2
9 :$ ' 8)) :' >)) ' - 6 +111 A B ) &'> . @&' +11/$ I ('8'' (6 ':'' )> (' 9 42 9:% )(' )>' : ':'' &'> @?9 /.
)(6 +11+$ )> :'': ? %> ::'6
,./01,+11/ * #,-*
&'> (( J 8' @''?( )(' :' A F .+0 #-0 '2 .B2
6B @) )' )> /1 @ % '8'' )'' ''>'$ :) &6 A82 2 D# 2 . 4B2
+2 96@ ''> ' = )(' ' 9) : 6' &( :)'?$ : ? )@= 6 :'$ ::'' ':'' 9*&'' &'&2
4 92 #/ 2 . 4$ ' 8)) 8'< '' <? 6))8''' &'' ?' ('' )' 6' 4' ' = (; <'''2 '' )')
9 (' (; <''' : 9* &'' +D H .70D A3 K 4 D/.2./"2.B$ 92 + 2 . :)' ? 6))8''' 9 &'' ?' (''') 4' ?' 6' 9 (; <''' : (:' &< 6'$ ):$ )6' & > )&:: (' :$ ' = :' 9$ ' <)2 ' )8'' < '&( > 9(: :' 88) = ? (; <'''2
9 : ) 9:% ? ' = :)'? 8()( '88 #2". . :>: 9< = 93 $ &'> % . @&' +11. ( ? :)'? ( :' > ?9 :) ''&'( = 8( = 8' : >'? :' ?9 (: ::' :)'?2
/2 4 '88 #2". +%( :>: 9< = 93 $ :' 9 : ! &'?) (<'(( < $ = (' ? ' ()' @'8' & :)'? ( & 9<:'' )'2
9$ ' ) :'% ' ? 9*&'' &'& :' >$ .D :(6 +11.$ &( 8' 9?''' :)'? ($ : ( GF +L011$71 : 0" C :'< &' .1 :(6 +11.
(' M5555555555 A82 :'% N .1 B2
,./01,+11/ * ",-*
= <(' % ' :&' 6' +11+ &( :)'?$ & 9<:'' )' < 2 )>$ '88 #2".2# '' (; <''' 9*&'' &'& A'*:% 3 B :)' ?9 & '6' : ! ;) & 9<:'' < ?9 ()' :)' F3G @'8' &( '':)2
9::' ($ :' < '8' ()'< )6' : 5555555555$ .- @&' +11/ : 5555555555 .0 )(6 +11+ A82 :'% N / # B2 $ 8 ? 5555555555 8' ? '8' I '& :' : ()' :' .0 ( .77+ ?L ) 8% ?' ' :' ( 8' 9 )&' )8&6 88' :>'?2 5555555555$ ' 6 = ) ? :' )) '>) : 5555555555 :('% 8' /1 :(6 .77# ? 6 9 6' '>'? +D 6 .77-$ : 6' ( )) 8'2 ()' : ? = )') &( :)'? & 9<:'' )' < 2
'' & '6 )$ )) ?9 )') ( ):) (' 9H +11+ &'' = 9' L '6' = L :)'? : 9) +111$ ?9 9&' @(' 2 $ '' ? (? 9''()$ ' ('% '6' : :)' ? 9) 9 : 8' 8' ?9 :' :)'? 9 )) 8')2
>( ( 8)$ ? ' ! @)2 :) ) >'$ ' :O )((2
,./01,+11/ * -,-*
* 2 *, ,, *,
3454 6 744 4 89 #:'
54
.2 ) &6 K
54
.2 @ K
+2 ' ? :) >' ?L )(( :O K
/2 8( :' ?L :& 8( :) ! )' /1 @ % '8'' : :' (() ) '6 8)) $ 4 P'Q 8?' -$ -11# $ ' <(:'2 )' : ! :>)2 ()(' ' R B ''? <( ?L )'' )' 6' ' : )'' ?)K 6B <: : ? ('8 ' '( :&' ( )''K B : '> :)2 4' ()(' ' : ' ))( )()) B 6B B '*$ '6 8)) : : ('% ?L' & ) '&62 ()(' (' (; :&$ ?' @'$ '' ? )'' ?) L&:: ? )) <:)') A2 ./+$ .1- .1D B2
>88' R )' R
S' 3 '
:' 8( :) ! '8') < :' '' ?L= L88' 8)) ' : >88
,./01,+11/