Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ATAS/1341/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/1341/2007 Generato dall'IA

Contract Breach and Warranty Dispute Affirmation

Numero d'incarto ATAS/1341/2007
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Respinto (Dismissed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The dispute centers on a contract dispute where one party alleged a breach due to material failure concerning work performed under a specific agreement dating back to 2018, and sought damages accordingly, with the case involving multiple appeals and retrials concerning differing interpretations of warranty provisions and applicable standards of performance. The court reasoned that the evidence presented failed to conclusively establish that the identified failures constituted a breach of the contract's explicit warranty or that the claimed damages were directly attributable to the defendant's work under the governing terms, ultimately affirming the lower court's findings where the plaintiff did not meet the requisite burden of proof regarding the breach and causation under the contract terms.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contract Breach and Warranty Dispute Affirmation: The court reasoned that the evidence presented failed to conclusively establish that the identified failures constituted a breach of the contract's explicit warranty or that the claimed damages were directly attributable to the defendant's work under the governing terms, ultimately affirming the lower court's findings where the plaintiff did not meet the requisite burden of proof regarding the breach and causation under the contract terms.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
interpretazione del contratto garanzia per i difetti della cosa grado della prova contratto di servizio violazione del dovere verifica da parte dell'amministrazione aggiudicatrice

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied for the allocation of costs to the respondent.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo



           ()+(),,- "(+*.+(),,-

"

 "# "   #

!/0  + & )-  /0  ),,-        !"#!$$ $$ %#!$$&!'(  $ $)    !     *  ) $#6$ +## *  * ),$  ) $*!$-.)/012   3    *    * ) $!! $ !$, +) !244.).1005 (  

         !  "#"$   %& & '

  072  

 1#"

/9  :+! $ 0- :" 0118)  //; <, $ , $ ; ! #$"$$)#)#  !,/=8/)!)#:!/=>.)#$!$ // !,/==09

09 *  <66 8 $ :+! #!#)  , $ ; !  $# !?# ?$++!$ !+ !#"$ #"@ 6A $!+9

49 :+!$$"!$"$#6!6>0118!#!#!$%66  ,$#/2:0118 ?#!$ !+9

29  , $ #  !# $ $$   $  !!! $ #"@)   ! # B   ! $  A  !!$"A$!+)!!// !,/==0 !>01189

-9 *$0=!,0118$  * *)  ;$A$$#!!66#$/:!/==84/0111) !! $ , + $ 0-%1>- 69 >1  #!# !6##  / : 0111 C         *   * 9 !! !!!) +##   *   * ) , $ +  )  $A#   $ /4 :! 0118) A  "  #   $$!$2*3)-, 4 ' 5, !!)!#D!>0118 9 ## A  "  //  !, /==0) !#D!  >  0118  ) %#"!C+,3),6 4 ' 6,9

>9  $$  #!# "!# C "   ! $ , + ! C  A$# ,$#9%! 6!#9

89  $! ! #!# ! ? !  $! $ /> ", 01189  :$!$A#A%C$#6!$%,"!$%0>",0118) D!!$!!,9

.9 %,$%,:!$$#6?#)#!#+$#C:+9

 #"

/9 %!90-$6#$#, +$ #"@ 6) ")""!!"$!#$/8$#,/==4E3F)!#"+

    7044/70118 472  

/:"0111);+ #$$$"9A:!! $G$ !!$!C !+E!9/00!/04 $ "B F) :+$$$" #!!$%!9849/$6#$# #"@ 6 $ 0- : /=.0 EF) ! C ;"  , !$$ /H!0114)$!) ;A%66  #!#!E!9/20 F)?#!$%66 !+,$ #$ # !!$#!# :+$$"9

09 *%!9003E"!"+$ /:"0111F) $ $")  !! $ ! A $!  + ! !+# 6#! ?!9/00)/04)/2/!/20 I!94C- 3% A! +!!C!6#E9/F9<A:!) !!$ !C !+ $C$66#! !!$!)+!# $ " $ , + ?!! #"!!  ! $ $") !  !!$!)+!#$"$, +?!!#"!! !$$+E69!9023F9):! C  !! $ ! ! C %" $ , + ?!!  ! $   $ +  !#D! $  ! $ $" E 3 /0.  041I 3/0=222F9

 G ;)  :+ $ ; !  $#  !+  !# $ !! $ ! A $!  +   $$9  $! !!!)$G !)$+)// !,/==0)$G! ! >0118)$!CA:+!$$"!$"?#!9

49 *  $! $!)  !! A $!  +   $$ !$-*3,7, 4 ' 7,E2*3)-, 4 ' 5, $ +,3),6 4 ' 6,8)!#D!@! $#:C #!# #   !!! $ #"@ $#6$9   $$$!BC?B# !!$*735*, 4 ' *, 9-*3,7, 4 ' 7, )8'

29 6#! C  : $) $   : $#!!   !+ :A%!$!6!$ !!$!$$):! $"#,##6$!! !!$!C$!#D! ! !!$B9 !#D!!#!?#+%!9/0 $%$ #"@ 6")""!!"$!# $ /. " /=.2 E 0F    !? #+!)  B !  # E 3/0=0--$94F9

-9  #!   J)  #$ #!! +!! E!9 84 9 0  ! .=(9/$ #$$!!"$/0 !,/=.-F9



    7044/70118 272  

  :"#1  "# "   #

/9 "!    *  * )+## *  * ),$+  )C!6#$ ! $)$*735*, 4 ' *,) !C" 6" $ $ ) #)  ; $  3     *    * ) $!!$ !$, + C5<)A$!#D! !$$#!)$;> 0118:A%!$!6!9

09 G@$!!A$,9

49 !A #$!+!!9

29 6  ! $  AG "! 6  !  #! D! $  $# $ 41 : $;  !6!  ; $ , 6#$# E*<KL<6A>)>112  F) "$!;$$! ,)6#!?!9.0$6#$# ,6#$#$/8 : 011- E 3FI  # $  $! $A  ) !6 ! @$ "! !+!$!$$!I$! D! $#  , 6#$#  " !   " #!A ? $! $ %!9 20  39  #! D! !  ;   $ !)"A#@$ ")$"!D!:!C%"9

 +66;  #$!M     B 5 N    6$ #!D!!!6#? !AGCG666#$# $ +66

    7044/70118