Late Witness Disclosure and Abuse of Discretion
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe lower court erred in allowing testimony from a witness whose identity was disclosed shortly before trial, as this prejudiced the opposing party who was denied adequate time for preparation and investigation; while the rules allow for some flexibility in discovery deadlines, the substantial surprise caused by the late disclosure of a key witness, coupled with the trial court's failure to impose remedial measures like granting a continuance, constituted an abuse of discretion that likely affected the outcome of the trial.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Late Witness Disclosure and Abuse of Discretion: The lower court erred in allowing testimony from a witness whose identity was disclosed shortly before trial, as this prejudiced the opposing party who was denied adequate time for preparation and investigation; while the rules allow for some flexibility in discovery deadlines, the substantial surprise caused by the late disclosure of a key witness, coupled with the trial court's failure to impose remedial measures like granting a continuance, constituted an abuse of discretion that likely affected the outcome of the trial.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAApplied for ordering the appellant to pay the costs of the appeal proceedings.
Testo completo
$%&'($'))* $%++$')),
!!
- !.- / -! /.
+0 12 3 %4 56 ')),
77777777777
. / 8/. 9/ ##-. !"#$%&''()*'+,'
! "#
1'/21
:.
*3 !#444444444445 .&-"*(((6 8 " .,&& --## 9## 6# 5##+ # #,#-3 6:# 9# -- ; < =6# .. -##1&.# ..9. , #9 #,> : *%&-"*((()%?#'%%% -## ..9. , #9 #, > : )% ?# '%%% '% ?# '%%) -## ,#1&.# ..9. , #9 #, > : '% ?# '%%) )*-'%%$&# -##,#1&.# ,#9#,> : + )* - '%%$3 6 > ?3 .9- -## , #9 #, > : !##,# 44444444444 ; &# '%?#'%%*<3!#44444444444##-- -##&.# #,#9#,> : &#'%?#'%%)3
'3 ##. , 55 )* .-" '%%) !# 44444444444 6 ## &+ 655# 6-&# ;#1&+ < ##. ,- 6# -#. @A-9>-& *?,#'%%$3
)3 .## *(5.,#'%%$6 ?. - -#5=6#.## & " =#. 6-&B 6-&B. =6# .# & .= #-&#" #5# =6# ,# .- & -&# = # .5###, #,#. 6&#& # 6#.. , #+ &# # &- "..5## 6 # -#.3
$3 6. 5-. .-# .## *( - '%%$3 :&#=. ,# & A #.. - '%%' &+ 9-#  .# .-#='%C # -##D5# &., #.E ##F3 .9. ,# .. ##. & # 6&# ##+- -## !# 44444444444 = A -?#. &# #.. ,# -"@6 -#!#844444444444#& 6.3 #.,#-# &,# .## #...9. & #= 6-&B. .9- ##,# ..##. ,#"..5##. 6# -#. @A-93
G3 6 #,#. 6. > 5# #, - -- 9# ## #..&# &+1," 6-".9.. ## 5# . ##- 699- !#8444444444443
03 6. .& & -9 .#= G ?# '%%$ =6 =6 -## ..9.#&,#& .## -
/*('0/'%%$ 1)/21 9# ##3 .-# 5#-. D @ =6# A# # #- # # #- & '%C &# #.. =6# 6,# &,# .## ,. 6## -?##F3 869# ##- # &.#. = # ,# .. .# . & & 6-". ## -# -#+ #. & !#444444444443
23 -9 *' ?# '%%$ 6. &.#. = 6 -## ?#5## & 5# =6# .# > 6#9# #.. =6# @## &., 6#-9 #+ -&# &+ &.# #55##3# #=.=#=6# .#&.#6-" &#-# =6 -## # # D> ,# -##-- 9#- 6## -?##F "# = # 5+ &,# .##3
H3 .##&&## *0?#'%%$&.-#5#-. .## *(5.,#'%%$3,.=6..#?,#1&.# -## #..,#9#,> :=6# .#'%C &# #..=#55##?#& > -=6#: #5 .##3 .. ,. = 6. ,# 6# -# =6# # -## 5# &., #.E ##3 #-=6#6,# &-&#,#.. # > # -#.#..#.35#..#9.=6-.# &#" , 6 -&B. ## #.. @= # > 6# -#..:-#.# #,# -5# @3
(3 # *G&-"'%%$6.#?. .##3 #-& = "#&E--# ##-"" > # -# # = 6 & 3 && 5# ==-&B. #..&&,=##-. .=#,=3 & # ,# &#"##. 6#5 ,. 6&# -#+ .-#3 & # # I44444444444 #= #-. #.-& & #.. # (J)0(53)%)% .-"'%%'38##,@& .. ,. '%%)3 .9- ?# &# 6:# -& # #,# ;.*'?#'%%$<3= ##,... *$'J$GH53&6.'%%'3
*%3 ,#. > & 6#. ##-. .& " '%%$ ? 3 && = 69# --" # 6 -### # 6 & .# .-# +- &"##. =6# : # #.. &#=6# #& : 9 6 &,# .-#3 -## ## -" .9#3 & 6#. ##-. 5# -= =
/*('0/'%%$ 1$/21 -&# & & ## #, > &.# ## -K#6&.-&L #K-#-&- .. -&"##. -- .3 = .#1 ## *?,#'%%')* .-"'%%)6.6@.#=?=6 -# ,-"'%%'# M-#3
!/.
*3 #9,# '',-"*($*69##? ###;N 'G< .. - #5#. ##. + * O '%%) #" #3-&. #=?9 &.# ,#1&.# #=&&.#M?9;3*3G0 <3
8#>6# 6.# ?9& #"5. .; 7< '2?,#'%%$; 7*)%*%0< #9,# &.*)5.,# #&## ## 9 ;3 *0' < &- 8 #.9 > # ?9 ## 6 6.# ,: ?93
'3 5-.- > J3 G0 3 * 3 @3 H 8 P # #= # &., > 6# G0 #, > # 5. . 'G?# *(H' 61@A-9 "#9# 6# -#. 6#,"##.; <38-&.&?9 6&+ ."#3
)3 ##9&&# ,##-&# ## #>J# -#. @A-9;3H3 <3
$3 8J3)*3)3 J& #>J# -#. . # J@# ,#&=#5#: .##=& J-&B1 &, #5 # ."- 1 =#. J#. --" J 9 ##9 J&# . J&####+ > J&#N # , -E- ?# & =# &. J
G3 E !3 $ &-" *((2 &"#. : 7 *') ')$ #"
5. . :&##. -#5 5 J&&## 9#= +9>J# J# -#. @A-93
J&+ ?#& ,#=#?# J##&5# -&"> J-&BJ& #>J# -#. @A-9= "#=##.5--&&### 5#: .## J-&B > #5 1# -#+ .-#3 #55 .#&"## J #&##J# -#.
/*('0/'%%$ 1G/21 @A-9.9-#-#+ J# -#. . # J@# ,#&##J3)*3)3 3
## ,@ #55. = #. , &## #-#" > J -&B =# .5###,- J&# # 5- 1#N &# # & J -&-,#>. #3, -E-= J&## J:# -# = #. & # .### -& .5###,-#,#..3-- JJ#.. & &##& &. # -#. @A-9 ; 7 *') ')H # 32"/""N8'%%* Q*$&&3$*1$'# 3'N '%%)Q''&3'$* # 3'<3
5# " &,#?# J&##9> J-&B,- # -#. @A-9>& # ,#..=#J-&B#&&P#9:# J&+35.-#&& ,-#5=#&.# .> :#93J9#, &-A & ,# - J-&#=#6 ##-# #>J# -#. @A-9 ;53 3 H 3 * 3 " <3 # A 5#- :." J9# J -&B. =# & ,# #1 = &#- # J , & -E- & & 5# ##9 =# "# = 5-- ##. &#, #,#. & -& #.. = ,##3 & &## &##+ & &, 55 : #5 & ,# =J "# =# ?- @A-9 #55##- A"; 7*')')(# 32"/""N '%%)Q''&3'$'# 3$<3
6 # -.# 69 ##9 =# .-# 6 5L 9#=63)*3)3 =#,#>-"" -&# "?#53 &## =6# 69# .-# = &#"##. 55#, 6 ##9 6#5 & .## 6 &##,# & -&&&#:#  ."# 6. &,# .## 5# #+; *((2/*((0&3''2<3
:&# > &##& & 7 --" # 6 -### # #& : 9 ;3 2*0 2*0 " < 6 &,# .-# 63 )* 3 ) 3 3 --" # 6 -### # : &# & E : =6# # .# .-# & +- &"##. =6# : # #..; 7*'''2)N 7 )/%) '$-'%%$<3 7 #-.=& ,#6.#&A"#.. ,# &,# . #.. &,# @@ > "#
/*('0/'%%$ 10/21 # -#. 5# -## ,# #.. & &.# .-#=- #55##& ##- #-.=6#6,#& #>6# -#. . # 6@# ,#3
7 .--6# &.#=6&6",..-- = # ?#& & " # -# "# #= 6" = &. .?> ,- 6# -#. > ,# ?# 6##-&"> 6-&B; '%%)&3'$%<3
88.# 6 >6.-#;8 <+99..#,# # . & =# # #9 # #,# &##&# 6.+,>'%C&--&:L #5 .## 6-&B;##R %*/('&3$Q*0<3
03 6&+5 =-,.'%C #-#=6#& -.9S -##,#1 &.# 1 #.. =# 6-&B# , -E- & D&., #.E ##F3 # 6,# &.#,6&#N-E-6# .5 &,#B:A &.& . # P # #- , ## # #53 6B 6&55#-- 6..-&- 6. &.-&#=6#&#B,#" -K:9 #& -B 6#55-# ,. #..=# 6##.3
23 .9 :# .#=#&.+ ?.3
/*('0/'%%$ 12/21
! /.: !.- / -! /.
;15 < = ># %(' /?
5
*3 .,"N
5
'3 ?N
)3 #=&. 9#N
$3 5- &# =6 &, 5- &. E .# )% ? + #5## & &# -- . . #" 5. . 8@T#M@5=# 0 0%%$ # :- .# & E &9.3 -.-# #U < # #= :-= .## .#"##& .## =.N "< :& & = -#5 # #- &,# - .##N < & #9 &.3 8# -.-# # & # ..- .-.. < "< < #1 #"5. . &&-#+=6# , .#,"3-.-# -#-B &, =# ?# ## = .## =. 6,&& =..:&. #.;3*)'*%0*%H<3 955#+U .# U #77 V#8 V
- &. E#5#.:.# 6 > 6.-#&955
/*('0/'%%$