Contractual Assignment Validity and Notice Dispute
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case concerns a dispute over the validity of an instrument establishing a contractual relationship, specifically involving successive assignments of rights under that agreement and related claims of breach and termination. The court reasoned that while the initial contractual relationship was valid, subsequent assignments were ineffective due to a lack of proper notice to the original obligor, which rendered the assigning party still responsible for performance and precluded them from successfully asserting rights based on the other party's alleged breaches of the assigned obligations. Furthermore, the court found that the termination of the underlying agreement was ineffective against a party that had validly acquired rights prior to the alleged termination notice, as that party had not received proper notice, leading to the conclusion that the initial party remained liable for damages flowing from the breach.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contractual Assignment Validity and Notice Dispute: The court reasoned that while the initial contractual relationship was valid, subsequent assignments were ineffective due to a lack of proper notice to the original obligor, which rendered the assigning party still responsible for performance and precluded them from successfully asserting rights based on the other party's alleged breaches of the assigned obligations. Furthermore, the court found that the termination of the underlying agreement was ineffective against a party that had validly acquired rights prior to the alleged termination notice, as that party had not received proper notice, leading to the conclusion that the initial party remained liable for damages flowing from the breach.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive to regulate the costs of the proceedings.
Testo completo
%&'()%*++, -%&.&%*++)
-
! -! /-" !/ "/
/0 ( *, #1 *++)
"
!"# $"%&'%! !! ( %)%" !
%"
* #+ ,%"-..#/..0 ':" *
1 * *21 #!& ,'3%"-4$ %#-..- *
1 * * #!!%"%! $%!5"$64$ %/778#8.009 +
!" #$
0;<
2 + #1 %! %!&0?$!!" 9@"!,#&!0.#-..- *
;-</=;0..> 7;<
2-
-A "B6%-<"0..>#/?,5" "!5$"!?"!% $" '! %! "!6 %"%'->B!-C87DBE "%6F $" #'0-'5"-C=/#% !"# '0="-C=/A
0A * ,!::" C !$ !%!: B6% $"'!%'# "!5 $"!?" !% " '$"%6$" !%!'& !"$"'& G$" :! H!$",'$ I"%"!6A
7A B6% !& " % & ':!!%!: / ! 0..> % '%' %"! ( ::! "!5'07!0..>$ "I'%! $"%6A
/A "!5 ' !!%' $"%! " !%!%%! $"'& GA"(B!"'$ I!B %! "!5A
>A " !H'"!6%"H!% "!5' !%"$' !%!%%! ':" $"!% ! !H" %%& !"H!$""!""%"!6#$ "$'"! ->B!-C87/!0..>A
=A *(6!% & !" $"'& G "# (!%"%! ::%' $" "!5$"!('%5!":!%!&%J
• * ""!"*21 0=$%5"0..>#"$ ? $ ! !5" $6 A <.../A $"%%! "%! ( '%' H! %"!6%$"%%! D$"%6"('?&D8(878:"A/ !0..>A
• * * !: "' "!5 H " '%' "' $"? 1 %! %!& $ " $"'& G $" :! 5!6% !"# %"% A>.;..7>C/K "6 !"!"* -"B&!"-CCC 7. &"! 0...A $"%%! "%!# %!?"% H! $% "!6# !%0(70.:"A7.'%'%":'"'>B&!"0..-$"?(%!%%! $$'%!& D 9"!,A %% "!?" :!"' & !" "L %%# "% H$"%%! !5"$6"('?&D0(/-8:"A0>/! 0..>A
• * * # # "
"!$ (& !"$"'& G'- &5"0... 7- ! 0..># 0.(C7- :"A $"%%! H! % "!6 % #$"%%! (%"'('%% D%%%A
;-</=;0..> /;<
• * ""!" 8 '5" % -7 '5" 0..> 2 + # D # " '%' ::!!' * :! %"6!%"' %"%7;-/-/C;8>.>; : 5?&# "
- &"!-C8C7- M%0../A*$"%%! !5"$6'%'%":'"'" $ !!5"$6 A.C-00C%('?&D-/(.C/:"A>./!0..>A
<A " ""!"0> &5"0..># "!5 !&!%'"D !:!" & !"(!%!%$ "'%5!#!!H(!$$"%B6%!& "#H IK '$ ( &"' %!%! D $"'& G $" :! # H " :!"'%0'5"0..>A
8A % !H' %'%'%"!I$"%!-7B&!"0..=% '%'6"'DB6"A
"-
-A ("%A 0> ! :''" " !5" $6 $"'& G $" :! #&!!#"&!&%%!&!!%'-<'5"-CC7E1F# %"'&!6"-"B&!"0...#"?6$" '"!& "A "H B !% %$N ""$"%%! "%!D$"%6"E"%A-00% -07 !&!K F#B6!!& " $'%%("%A<7A - !:''""$"'& G$" :! 0>B!-C80EF# !%D ?& "!5% " !$!-" M%0..7# !%# $"?H(::!"!'%'%"!E"%A-/0 F#I'%"( ::!$"%6" 5'"'$"%!%! '%"!'$"B6!& ".
0A * ("%A00 1E &%"&!6"$!-"B&!"0...F# !& "#$"%%! "%!H!"%"!6 %$"%6' : "'%I"%A-00#-07#-/-%-/0 4"%A7D>1($$!H% $" 6! %%D%":'""EA-FA ",H B !%#$"%%! "%!D$"%6" ""$ D!::'"%"$"%%! "%!#6%' & !" !5" $6 I!%% '&%% % !& "# % $"%%! "%!# 6%' & !" !5" $6 I!%% '&%% % ! "!6E:A"%A0/1FA " # B %D$"%%! "%!%D(& !"!5"$6I!%% % ! "!6!%'"O% %!& "E 1 -0807.4 1-0C///FA
7A N$?# B6 $"!?" !% " ' $"%6 $" !%!' $"%%! "%! H! "% "!6 $" " "% "!6# !% $ " $'"! -> B! -C87 / ! 0..># % D H B6%!& "%&I'% !"A
;-</=;0..> >;<
"(B!"'$ IH%! %!B %! "!5A "'%$%B6%!& "H(($&"' %!%! D $"'& G $" :! # H " I$"'% !A "$ $" !% $"'% $" '" $! % %%%%( &"%"$" IK'$ ( $%!5"$6$"? 1 %! !5"$6 11 * A
* % $" !%# " H! $% "!6 $"%%! !5"$6$ " %%% %/=(08-:"A<>/!0..># !%'"O% $"!E0(/-8#0>P8(878AKP-/(.C/#>.P0.(C7-FA $"%%! !5"$6(G%'%'H!$""D%"!6#! !%D IK'$ !%!'%% # !%07(-/.:"AC.A
$% % !&" : $"'& G '% $" "# "!5 " "%":"%% %!%': (%!%%! $$'%!&% *21 E0(/-8#0>P8(878Q--(0>=#0>F4 # !%--(88/:"A=>" &"' $" 2 + % * D"! >(C/0:"A7.,A
/A : "'% D B"!$"# $! B " '%"!% $ " $"%6 BH( % %":"% $"%%! "%! "# B !% !& "' 5'':!!!" %% $"%%! " !% D !%'"O% $% !" " %% K!A !%'"O% % ' %I !! '6 ("%A -0 ( " " $"'& G $" :! &!!# "&!&% % !&!!%' -8 &"! -C8/ E 0F %I "'6%!"# ! !K! % $'"!" E 1 $5!' 7=;.0 -8 B!% 0..7F
>A ' %"$"L#$" '"'%%6"%!%E"%A<7A0% 8C+A- !"$" '"!!%"%!&-0$%5"-C8>FA
RRR
;-</=;0..> =;<
/ "-2 -! /-" !/ "/
345 6 7 8$ &)* " 9
-A &!%1 * * 9 +D%":'""# $% !"# 0(/-8:"A0>D1 %! !5"$6 11 * :&" $% A00=7-/A88 &"% A
0A &!% *2 1 D %":'""# $% !" # 8(878:"AD1 %! !5"$6 11 * :&" $% A00=7-/A88 &"% A
7A &!% * D%":'""# $% !"# >(C/0:"A7.D1 %! !5"$6 11 * :&" $% A00=7-/A88 &"% "! A
/A &!% 2 + # D # D %":'""# $% !" # >(C/0 :"A 7. D 1 %! !5" $6 11 * :&" $% A 00=7-/A88 &"% A
>A &!% ':" D &""# $ %% $"'!%'# !%'"O% $% !" !'"%#?/!0..>BH( % %":"%A
=A G %%H5 !A
<A !%H$" '"%6"%!%A
8A : " $"%! H( $&% : "" " " %" $"'% ""O% '! 7. B " ? %!:!%! $" $! " ' "' "!5 :''" "# *,S!T", :H! =# =../ # %" ! I$!"A '! $% O%" $" 6'A ' !" !% J F !!H" I%% H '!! " "% '!" 5%!" ! % $ '!! %%H'45FI$ "$ "H %!:!%!$ & !""%% %"'!! 4F$ "%"!6%" "$"'%%A*!' !" %!% $ %" ! ''% ''"' %%" F 5F % F !K# "!5:''""$ ""$%""%!?""" "H(! &"'""!""&5A' !"" "%! " " G
;-</=;0..> <;<
$"&# H! " % B !%# !! H '!! %%H' % (& $$ H'%'I$'!'" "%E"%A-70#-.=%-.8FA 6"::!" "'!%J 2! !
$! : "$"'%""O%% %!:!'I$"%!!!HNDN::!:''" " !$"6"::
;-</=;0..>