Negligence Action Regarding Vehicle Collision and Comparative Fault Defense
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAA dispute arose regarding liability for damages stemming from an incident where a vehicle driven by one party struck another vehicle occupied by the plaintiff, resulting in various physical and emotional injuries, with the defendant asserting comparative negligence based on the plaintiff's actions leading up to the collision. The court held that the evidence presented sufficiently supported the jury's finding of sole negligence on the part of the defendant, as there was ample testimonial and physical evidence establishing that the defendant failed to maintain a proper lookout and violated traffic regulations, which were the proximate causes of the accident, thereby warranting the rejection of the defendant's motion for a new trial based on the weight of the evidence.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Negligence Action Regarding Vehicle Collision and Comparative Fault Defense: The court held that the evidence presented sufficiently supported the jury's finding of sole negligence on the part of the defendant, as there was ample testimonial and physical evidence establishing that the defendant failed to maintain a proper lookout and violated traffic regulations, which were the proximate causes of the accident, thereby warranting the rejection of the defendant's motion for a new trial based on the weight of the evidence.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive for the allocation of procedural costs.
Testo completo
$%&'($&)$*$ !$%'&$*&&+
!
, ! -, .! ,. .
*/ 01 23 *&&+
45555555555 5555555555 %!
!"#$ %&#% "!"'(((((((((() * +
%!
. .! . ! !# ! 3" ,-./012
! "#
:9459:
6 !
5; % "!" '(((((((((( ) :<1 % "!"+ "!" ! & ! # %33 # !% # 12 5=>? 2 %33 @! %<! % $%& ! % #"2%<<3! 2! # 3!" ! %& # #%3 # $ *%3! ! # $%& ! % #$!< A ,, *%3! % ! <3! # <%A <! <! % # # !< <<%!!0$! 2 !"#"<%B"<% "!";
1 5=>? C% D(((((((((( "!" #3 !!:2 :<" #! ! C% (((((((((( #3 !!:"! !% #E 2 &! %! 20#E;15==?C% D((((((((((!#2#3 !!:
<" #!!C% ((((((((((# !"&3!2 &!%! 2 0#E;
9; % "!" "!" " #1 "! % <1 # )) ) C ) :<1 + <% % <% ";
<! #5==>% "!"#!##< 3!#%! ! %;%! ##% % "!"$! !!"#3%!! 2!5==>F8G/78*;.. 5.H ?G96.*;>.57H !?G8>>*;7.97<!3@>G5/=*;8.95 #"3@ 5==>A .6 *; # * # 2 <% 5==> %! "!" 2" #! # 8 H !5===;5=H !5=== #"%33! %0% "!"<% 23! # %! ! % #$2 0 H 5=== ! 5> %!%@ <% %! ! %#H !0<!3@5===; #!#98%I!5=== #" 0 % "!" #"%3<! ! * 0 $" 5==> * ! "!! #$ %# # 5 *; *2 # % "!"; % "!" $! !!" # 3%!! 2! 5===F =G67.*;6.52 >G96/*;5696%I!>G85.*;5698%!%@;=G>?5*; 86 %! "!" <B" 5 *"2 9666 ! % #"%3<! # # 8 <!3@9666%##I0H%"! !#//7*;6.%<%#!E* # 2 3%!! "!" !!" #! # 5= %!%@ 9666; )$& ! # %! ! %9666 #"%33! %<%%! ! %#H2 0 3 5= 2 9666 < <%%" #$3# ! !E! % #$% > %23@ 9666; <%"#" # 3-3 <% %! ! % #$2 0 H %33! % 96 H ! 9666 ! <%%" #$3# ! !E! % #$% > %23@9666+< <%%! ! %#H !0<!3@%33! %5> %!%@9666!<%%"#$3#!!E! %#$% >%23@9666+; #"%3<! <% %! ! % # 9666 "!@ 5= 3 9665 * ! "!! #$ 3%!!#I0! !#%! ! %!* # 2#9>G95.*;9.;753 9665 #"0% "!"#"%3<!%3<"3! <%5==>5===!9666 #.G69=*; * % "!"$! !!"#<!J3<%B"K#<%9666 !8<3 3% #9665#E23!#5.G97/*;=6973 ! 76.*;98H !9665;
456784966/ :7459: 7; * ! # % "!" "!" <%%" < H&3! # @ # <3 1 !59#"3@9665; <%# !#* !<%3%!! #9/G59=*;/6; #!#96%23@9669$"!!#%%! %"!"<@ "! 75 H2 9667 L ! # #"*! # @ <1 * ! # 3%!!#";
/; #" % #!" # 97 %!%@ 9667 "3" "<! % # % #%33& 0 C D(((((((((( (((((((((( ! (((((((((( <% 3%!! # 97G8>> *; .6 %<%#! %# # %! ! % < ! )4 4 4 #<%5==>9G6>5*;6.+5===9G/9?*;?6+96665.G>?= *;56+!96657G766*;7.+B%3< !"-!3%!% * #<% !! !E#%33! %;
.; C% D(((((((((( * ! %<<% ! % #! # 9/ %23@ 9667 < G !3"# #CC C% ((((((((((* !%<<% ! %#! #9.%23@!C% ((((((((((#!#9>%23@;
8; #" % %<<% ! % # 5. 2 966/ #3 $%<<% ! % # C% (((((((((( % #"! $ 2 ! 3" <2 *%! % $ 3< ! < &! % #3 !! 2 # % "!"; )$& ! # C% (((((((((( #"" $%<<% ! % 2@ % 3-3 $ < ! !# 2; H!" %<<% ! % # C D(((((((((( ! ((((((((((% #"!$ 2 !&&" <%@ !"<! <!%!3! <%"2 !#%33&# ; << !##< 3!$!<%# !< "# !!<%$" 9666<1#3% ! "#%! ! %!!" 3<B";
?; < "<" # 5/ 3 966/ C D(((((((((( ! (((((((((( %! %%!!!#" %;%!!!!%! !! %%"& &&2;
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
456784966/ :/459: * , +#%"!" 0!!% %; # !"E !!0* !2 % 58G.66 *; %! 2 E * # $% ! 3%!! %2@ #$2 % 97G666*;$%!<"!" "<$% ; 2,"%!!" <%# !<M((((((((((0,!#>66G666*;"!"%%"; % % ! 3! 2% & < #3! * 0 # "213! 3<"2 @ ! #3#!#" %% !";
>; %%!"!" !% 4567846/! 4567=46/;
=; "<% # 5. H 966/ %! H! # %; %!!&3!2"<3!!!E%!## < #%##%! ! %%!!" 3<B"<%5==>!5===#"H0;% "!"$ <<!"#" #< 3!5==><3 23!! !2 H ; !0* #"3@5==>%! ! %%<%#!0$!!!! %# "! ! %#" 3 % #$ %!O !" 9665 ! <<$%3<"3!"! !%#I<%5==>%33<%5===;
56; %#% # 95 H 966/ @ # " %#%" H%! % # % 4567846/ ! 2 !" %! 0 %! < 1 <%# !; #" <% <%# !%! < 1 ! "!" * E" 5. %I! 966/#2!-!%2%"%3<! %<%!%3;
55; @<%"#"0$# ! %#<! #!#5=%!%@966/;
)$& !#%%<<% ! %!# 2C% ((((((((((E< "$ 2 ! $%<<% ! % # C C 2 ! "&3! <% ! %$ %3< $"! !< 33"# !3!<<" <%*%3 %<<% ! %; %* 3" %! ! % 5==> ! 5=== 2 ! "!" !%!3! "&" %# %<%#! 0 < # %! ! % ! %!O !" 9665 2 ! "2"" # * #"# ! <" E * #3 @; C% D(((((((((( % E< " < <%2 ! # * !$ %## !"#% "!" #C (((((((((( ! ((((((((((2 !"!""# !3 % #3 !" $BH%! !;
%!%!E< "%!% "!"M((((((((((;$& !# <&% !#% "!"%! <%% "!"2 ! 3#!##"2%<<<%&33#&! %;1H2 5==>%<" !%! *% # % "!" H$ 3 9666 2 % %P ! 0 ,&3!## ! %M((((((((((3 * #H%#3 3#!; 3%3!M(((((((((( #2 !.8G666*;3 !!"% "!"< %33#3!#<B#>66G666*;M(((((((((($<<% 2 %! % <1$%<<% ! %* !<%!$% %%"!!"%# * !;
% "!" "! ! "&3! <"!! <% ) #$ <%# ! *%3! <%% "!"N((((((((((<%2 !$E 2 !"! &"" !#23; 3%3!#* !N(((((((((( #2 !
456784966/ :.459: 2 % 5=G666 *; $% $ < ,," 0 %2 ; %! %! <<"3< 33"# !3!#1$ M((((((((((H%!! 2 !"!""# !!3<%B"0< !3< ";
$ #$# #" "!"* E"E<! <%<%#! %#< 1 %2# #2!-!* E"!" 3!;
59; <%# ! $!!!! % # :<1 ) + 5=== 3 ! #% %< # $"!! # %%! %; %! %! <%# ! %<%#! 2E! %2M((((((((((!0* " ! % # @ #! # 9= %23@ 9666; 2 0 < 1 !" 3!;
57; %2 %3<! % # <! $! ! #! # 5/ #"3@ 966/; C% D((((((((((<" "3%!!#""# ) 9666! 9665%!3%!!"# !# %!"!"2";) % "!"$ <#3#"#<#< 3!9666$!<%!$"! ! <I#<%2% ! &%!#% $2 !* !;% "!"$2 ! <# # !"; 23!$#%"!"* !0<%;% "!"$2 ! #$ < # *% $! <% $"!! # %%! % * &! ! !! %#$!$3<%B";
$ # $# # #" "!" * E" E <! <% <%#! % "2!#< 1%3<"3! 5.H2 966.<1% ! &#"0H&;
!
5; % &2% $%& ! %H# +"!"3%# * "! ! !"#1 5%I!9667 @!%#% %3<%"#.H& #%!<" #!!2 :<" #!.<<"!!58H&!;5!; !.8 +;
) !0$! %#$"! %#58H&< @*"#" 9?H2 966/ Q576568+# % &2% #%<!"57*"2 # <% ! %! !% &!<3!!! @!%# % # "& 0 !% H& ! ! # $!!! # $"! %#%2EH&;
9; %*%3"3! 0 G!; .8 ; 5 !; ,;5 #% &2% $%& ! % H# + @ !% # % %R! ! # %!!! % ! 2 0 % *"#" $:2 ! 2 2! # 96 #"3@ 5=/8 :<1 )+ ! % 1&3! :<1 )+;
)%3<"!<%H&##$<1! "!@ ;
456784966/ :8459: 7; % *"#" <! &"" # #% ! # % :<1 +#8%!%@9666!!"2 &5H2 9667;%2 # <% ! % "& %! %!33! 3<" <%"# # #" % #3 !! 2 2 #G%<<% ! %#G! %# "<! %# #%33& !; >5 )+ < <%"# # #" % # #" % %<<% ! %!#%##% !#3 !! *!;.9;9 )#!
2 & #< 5 H2 9667 !; .9 ! .8 +; $! !! %2 <%"# !<< @G<1#1% "! !2 & 3%3!%P "3""<! %#%#%33&*; Q5765+;
2, $! G!; .9 ; 5 ) ! G 2 & HG 75 #"3@ 9669!%%2!;.9 )3%# * "5H2 9667 $<< 0 $E3#<%@ !"#%!#1%%H <# #,&3!#1&##% !!G@#"&3!! %! !% #% ! 2 & 3%3! %P * ! H # 3! #"!3 ! %! <%# ! ! <! ! Q 59? /8? % #; 5+; #3! G!; .9 ; 5 ) 2 & #< 5 H2 9667 <# G !; .9 ) 3!3%# * ! %;!3J #%3<! %K%!3<" < JK 3# F 3<3! # J & ,SK < J ,&KA ! F << % # J # %3<T %K+ !R ,&3! ! E %# ! % # <%@ !" # G3<%B *; Q 59= 57 2; % #; 7;. ! -! % <@ " # @ *"#"# :<1 Q +#76%23@966/D4=8467+;
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
456784966/ :?459: % #;9;959758% #;.+; %3%3!#% ##%33&#* !2,H <#! !&""3! ##"<O!#G"!!#%%! %% #<@ ! %# #! %# * !*!#G! * Q59=5=.2;% #;9;7+; $<1* !"!"<%%"59#"3@9665$"!!#%%! % "!"<@ "96%23@9669!#" %# #!!#97%!%@ 9667#%! <!"!!#" #9 #.; .; )%$!;.9 #" %<2!-!!!"#!!H%< 2% #$%<<% ! %<1# #;
$<1#" %%!"!"%! * "<< %33#"97%!%@9667; $%<<% ! % # C% D(((((((((( "!" * ! # #" "&; 2, %! # #% #" % "!" L < C% ((((((((((#!#9.%!%@;#" <! !#%##3 !"," ! # 9/ %23@; !""<,%! <% * %<<% ! % #! # 9> %23@C% ((((((((((& !# 23!#%!%%<<% ! % ! 2@; ! # #% 3%! ! $ $"! ! < <% @ #$ !<"! $%<<% ! % * ! < C C <% %3<! # C% D(((((((((( %33 2! "&3! <% ! $ %! $2 ! < 3#!"!2%!0!!; %"#" %# ! *%%!C% ((((((((((;
%!%! @#"#!#5/3 966/ % !#!!H%#1%! * ! %##" %%<<% ! %#5.2 966/#%!%%!2@!;.8!86 +;
8; E!3#G! .9 )G3<%B#% !%2 #%33&G " 2 %! < <! % !! %3! % < "& & &2; # # << G! .9 ) ! # <% ! % <" *; 5=>= <& 55?+;
G<1#%33&% !<!#"#%! ! %@ < %#G %2@ !"#% "!"<%3%!!#97G8>>*;.6 <"!! %# # %! ! % < ! )4 4 4 # <% 5==> 9G6>5 *; 6.+ 5=== 9G/9? *; ?6+ 9666 5.G>?= *; 56+ ! 9665 7G766 *; 7.+ B %3< !"-!3%!% * #<% !!!E#%33! %;
G! 5/ "5 )%"! %2! 7/ ! 2! ) < !G%@ &! %<%G3<%B##"# , %! ! %# "!#2 : 0 #%3<! %2<%<%! ! %; 3<%B #% 2! 2%B E <" %# 3! < 1 %3<!@%! 2"0 "#3 10 %! ! %< ! < !-!"!* G%@H!##" %;
456784966/ :>459: G%@ &! % # <B %! ! % ! # *% #"%3<! ! <% G3<%B !V, # #% ! <@ < ! < % ; ! "&# Q #""0" !""< <%@ !"#G3<%B#G! .9 )! "!!!##% !<@ Q5595..% #;.A 5=>? <&996+; G3<%B G !!<# !!!V, %33!2 %! % #< <! %#G! .9 ) !R<% G%@ &! % # "< ! 13! #%33& % %" Q 555 5?7 % #; 9A 5>65>8% #;55=9% #;9A 5=>.<&8/8% #;7+;
Q 3"E<"3!G%@ &! %"&#"<#%33& #% ! -! % # %P #%33& ! #I 0 2 %! % !! %%<"& &&2<G3<%B#< <! %"& ! G ) 5=?><&9.=A 5=?9<&8>?+; #%3<! % %!!G@ #%33&< !#%:%@2! %#< <! % <!#3!!G3<%B2 %": !! %3!%#3% < "& & &2 # 3 %P GE ! < #G # * ! % 0 "& ! 3 !" # % %3<%!3! % 0 G@ #G *! *; Q # 9> H 5=>9 5=>7<&565+;
%G3<%B!<%3%%&"<%#!% # 3! 0 ! ! @ # # #%33& " < : %!33! # <% 3%GE !<3%3!%P<%@ !"!&&"*;%8667# # ! 2#GQ )<<! %#%! ! %:A Q55/?=% #; 7A5579.8% #;7A 5=>><&578% #;7A Q5555?7 5=>.<&8/=% #;9;+;
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
G<1 %! "! ! ! & ! # %33 !" #G#3 !!:<" #!!#G#3 !!:"! 2 &!%! 20
456784966/ :=459: #E;2 !#% # !@3! !"#G%&#% "!"G %!!!#3!<! ?./ "5 +;
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
?; $<1 B !!! 2 # #"%3! # * ! %# ! @ 0 % #" $ *! <! -! 3<!" 0 C% D(((((((((( #%! <%@ !" #% ! -! E3 " < #" % ! *% $& !#C% ((((((((((+;2 :#% !$ < < #3! # 3 #"! <! @ # 3 ! % "!" 2 H$0 $ !%2 % < ! 3<3! # % "!" M((((((((((! #%! #!2 #% "!" 0 *2 #$#% !#"!! %@!3!3 * 0"& ! 3<% ;
%! #$@%# *! << #1 $<< ! % # # !" ! #"H0 2! $ M((((((((((% "!""# ! ## &!%33 %! # ) ; )$ ! E! <3 23! <% 5==> %! !2$H !%0* 3%#"@!2 +% "!""& 13! <B"%! ! %5==>!5===%33%!#<! * !; !0 < #%! ! %"!#3< 3%3!#$<< ! %# # !" < #3 !! %! < #3! @ " !%!*% "# #3 !"B! 2;3%3!##" %#< 3 9665% "!"$"! !<3#$ !!;!#% E! ## !#!%:< 3!#%! ! %%!"!"< "%33$1& ;
%!"&3!##% <! #% #$2%!#% "!"0 #M((((((((((#5>2 9666$2!#%<!%!! %2 % "!" M(((((((((( #1 #"@! 9666 !% $ !! ! < # 3%!!#*!! 2E !2! %#% "!",T; %!
456784966/ :56459: "&3!#, %33 "<C% D((((((((((!%%!!"; $! #% #1 #"@! # $" 9666 # # !" # !"% %! 2; 3 96663#!"!"! "0% "!";%!%! % #" #" # # 3 < ,& # 3 ! *%!3! * &""E"# ! !%#"<L!#<%< " ! @ # %E <% % "," ! !%2! # @E 3% ,<-!0 % "!"%$#"3 !;
3%3! %P 3 %! < << ! %33 #<!"! <3!#<$%!2 ;*!�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
!"!%<! 23!#"<#!%! ! %%!"!" 3<B" !T%&< # 23!E<!"<!<" !!" 3 ! H 9665+ #! # *"2 9666; C 23! # *"2 %# %! ! % 5=== ! #1 3%3! # !" %! << 3<-,! !%! 23! <% 9666; $@ # # !" ! <%@ ! 0 3%3!:0 % "!" 2 ! # % %@H! 2 ! " # < <%2% $ !!#%! ! %!" 3!;) #3!" 3 9665 #!!<"2 ;
>; % %!2# <"1#<%@ !"<!-! 3<!"0 C% D((((((((((#%! #"@%!"#% %0 %#% !!#" %"<! %##%33&";
YYYYY
456784966/ :55459:
. ! 6 ! -, .! ,. .
702 8 9 :# %(* ;<
2
5; "%2@;
2
9; #" %%<<% ! %#5.2 966/;
7; %!!$%<<% ! %#C% ((((((((((! 2@<%# !# 2!";
/; H!!%#C% ((((((((((;
.; ! %#" %"<! %##%33a%!%@ 9667!*%;
8; #3!%#C% D((((((((((;
?; #" % "<! % # #%33& %! * " 97 %!%@ 9667 0 C% D((((((((((;
>; "@%!<! #!%!!% %;
=; !<%"#!&! !;
56; *%3 <! # $ <2! *%3 % %! <"! -! # #" # 76 H% #1 %! * ! % < < %33#" #" @ *"#" # ),X T,%* 8 866/ !% E3< ; #" <! -! <%%&"; 3"3% #% !F + # E!3!#" %%!#" %@! !<##" % !!"A @+ E<% <% 3%! * ! 3 <%2% #3# !! ! #" %A+<%! &!%#%<"!!;) 3"3%
456784966/ :59459:
%! ! < !% ""3! "3"" % !! + @+ ! + :# @*"#"#<%<!3! 1%$ #2#" 2@;3"3% #%3! %%3%B # <2 %! H% ! #" % !!" ! $2%<< # "!"E<"# "%!!;579568!56>+; " #!F & F @@%
%< %*%3#<"!-!!%! * "E<! $0$ *"#" #% <&
456784966/