Property Division and Alimony Appeal Regarding Asset Valuation and Imputed Income
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case addresses several errors claimed by the appellant in connection with a judgment regarding property division and alimony following a marital dissolution, primarily challenging the division of marital assets, including the valuation of certain business interests and the imputation of income to the appellant. The court affirmed the trial court's property division, finding no abuse of discretion in its valuation methods for the assets, including expert testimony relied upon, and upheld the imputation of income to the appellant based on demonstrated earning capacity and the need to achieve an equitable result, despite the appellant's voluntary underemployment in a lower-paying role.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Property Division and Alimony Appeal Regarding Asset Valuation and Imputed Income: The court affirmed the trial court's property division, finding no abuse of discretion in its valuation methods for the assets, including expert testimony relied upon, and upheld the imputation of income to the appellant based on demonstrated earning capacity and the need to achieve an equitable result, despite the appellant's voluntary underemployment in a lower-paying role.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAImposed court costs for the appeal.
Testo completo
!"#$%!"%%# !&"#'!"%%#
( )*( ( )
+, - &$ .+, "%%#
!!!"#$$ % %& #%&'"&! !!("& )&%*!%%
&%
+ ( +, +! !&!" % & -./0 1
*326*
/)
7$ 38 '9% 3556 "# " ( &! :!!%"&% &!'# %&% !:&"%#&!'&37 #&9%7;<;70 & 9%7;;5&7<='!%7;;8 !!!">-!!##!$
3$ % %%!%38 '9%3556 ++( +, + + + + + ? @!*#%A , B "C(%"!:!%#%'!% &%!D&! :& & &&&&! %"! &-&!:!" #% & -!!##!A'$
8$ % %%!% 4 ! 3554 (%" !!&" #% D&! "! # % #% !%(&-&!:!&! &#% &-!!##!CA' &%E!9"":!(!&=%!!E#%&!# % '%!%:%!&& &-&!:!&! & "D" E( ("'!& C 0/ :%$ #% & & &!&!&# %-%D%&!'& %$
0$ % "!! 30 ! 3554 , %:" (&%% &!A% % (!& =%!!E &!: E( "!! ('!& % "&" % !&! !!#9 C ( &% ! ( & !&$ && "!! &! !&*#%%%%*' !( ## !&! $
/$ & 3< =! 3554 (%" : %" ## !&! :!& ' !% E !&! ( &% !(!&=%!!E"&!&%"!"&E !#%"' !& &E(!&=%!!E#&.&% %"E%( #% "% ( ## !&! $ + ! (!& =%!!E #& '%!% (!&%'&! ( !#&: %&! %!#%%-%D:%!D%" #%#% "%&E:%!(&-&!:!&! $
6$ &77=!&3554 , &%!!& ## !&! %!9 " 9=& #"&$
4$ #%A0#&9%3554 , %"!! % ## !&! %& : !&!D * C ' !% % !& (%" C &! :!!$ , !% !&(!&"%"C#%&&! :'% :& # % #"%! 7% ! 3550 85 '%! 3556 & ! &% F" &&;(055:%$ %%# &C>( &! %%!"%"$
<$ "&%!&! 4 #&9% 3554 %& % % !&%=&" #% (%"&!A%(!&=%!!E(!&!":!&' !%E% !&C* ! #% "% !!&%&!' (>!& #%!!# # &G& E(#%A &!:!&! "!! !&C( '%&%#% "%( ## !&! $(!&!"
234/523554 *826* !A%E&&!&%!&.&% %"& '&E( "!! %: !&%&E( ## !&! !&: %"$
%A' E % %& !!&" 9"":! (!& =%!!E # % '%!% :%! (&-&!:!&! & ("&& !'! "!% C ( '%&%(#% "%%&!'C( &! :!!&E(C & !&! (>% !&C(!&=%!!ED%&!&("&!& # % "$ #% "% ("&& #& (!&!" &! E( # '!&E &&%E%E.&(!&=%!!E"&!& 9=&$
= &E#%!%( !&! &!'%E!# %( &% ! (!&=%!!EC' !% #>!&"(::!%(%!&& &:H #"&"%#!& &%=&% %$
;$ #! && "%!&% "&" !E" C % %& & D%" C =D%$
)
7$ &% %&$ 34 $ 7 ! %&!' C I ::! & % !@ +B&8< !% &! :!!@ ,BI!& D%&!&I !=%!!E& %"%# %#% "%'& ! I ::! %E!% &I>!D&$
: %"&CI%&$7;$8%AD&I>"&! !%&!'CI ::! & % !@ +B&33$8%AD&(>"&! !% &! :!!@ ,B%:I!&=%!!E#& .&% &&E" #% ' ! % % #%A %!9 & % !$
%!9 " & A % #"&& # % &&% % % % !&%=&" &% "!! (!&!" %:& I!& =%!!E D%&!& # % #% "%%&!'C( &! :!!$
3$ &%=&": %&"!#%%!&#%"&% %&%'9@%&$8< $7 ,B$
8$ >&%%&$34$7 +&8<$7 ,(!&D%&!&( ! =%!!E & %" % # % #% "% '& ! %E !% & (>!D&$ & &% F" : %"& > #%%!#&! :""% &!A% &&!> I%*'!! & %'!'&(%*!'!!&" &! #%&D!& #%&&! #"&!%$ #& .&% %" E ! "%- #%)&#' "CI"-! #>!&"I::!%I>!D&!I!&"%"&
234/523554 *026* 9 !J !&! &&!'@%&$7;$7&3 +&33 $7&3 ,B$
!# !&! & & "&" #&" !& C (&%" '!D% ! :""% % #%&! D""% % !& % ! 6 & 9% 3555 @ BE#%"' !& %&$84$0E(!&D%&!&( ! =%!!E& %"% %E!% &(>!D&$
0$ B + =%!#% !&! ( &% ! (!& =!!!% D%&!& &#%!!#%#!! ! #%!&#' "C("-! %E"%&&9 !&!(!&(' &&"!% ! !!E"@ ,73/847 !$/9#$843&%":"%B$
!&! ( &% ! (!& =!!!% # " #% =%!#% (#!% (%&$ 0 &$ & ##!9 C ( &% ! (!& D%&!& ( !=%!!E#% "%( ## !&! @%%.&$3; '9%3550 //4250 !$3$7#9!"C'(' &355/$8#$738B$ &: ! # !& ' !% ! & %"!" !& .&% >!" C ( %!&A% # "'A%#% "%!!&%&!'@K+ #$!&$$35%&$84B$
9B# !&' !%!(!&(' &&"!% !!!E" !& .&% &%-" (#%A !% & %A& 9=&!' & 9=&!'$ %&!E& ! :& % # % -E #%&!!% ! !% & 99 & (-F# &-A L %E"%& %!& # 9 !(!&(' &%!&=!! #&&:!&E(!&"%" ( # !*. ! =%!!E ::!& & E (!&"%.& #% "(=D&=&!:!%!&-%D:%!E!" @ ,758 04 ;<77<J:$! ,785 7<3 !$ 3$373< 383 !$3$/$3& %":"%B$
(!&#%' &(!# !E&C&!&%>#&! L ! & :!& ## C ' & #% E E&! % !& :!& !::!! %& !& ##%& "!% & E( !& #% %#%"&&( !&! #%!&& ! (&%#% :! #% :! (!&!&&! ! (&% # !"%&! @ , #9!" 76 M& 3554 2773256 !$ 4$7J , 783 355 !$ 0$7 #$357&%%.&!&"B$
/$ (#A (!&!" &!'" %: (!& =%!!E &!& #%:!&E("!! ('!& %"&"% &"#G& $
#& E&! ' !% ! &!& (!&!" (!& =%!!E&!!&"C#% "%( ## !&! #&%&% '%&(#A % %'&.&%%=&"# %(&% &!:># "!* $
234/523554 */26* 6$ %!9 " %A' #% !% E % %& #%A (.&% &&" !!&! !!&%!&=%!!E#%&!# % '%!% :%!(&-&!:!&! *E("'!&C0/:%$#% &* " !% ( ## !&! @%& N % %B C "!! %: (!& =%!!E"&C#%!-%D- %!%(' &$
+(D!& %!% # !& ! ! %'% E #% "% =%!!&! !!&%&!'#'&.&%>!"&=D"#%!!#E %## %&=%!!EC #% # E(& %!&"!!&%&!' #"&&(& #% " #%"9& ( !A% E! ! : % ( "!! $ && % "!! "&%! ( 9=& &&&! E! #& .&% ":"%" =&! #% ' ! % %$ %'- % L "!! ("&"% &&&! (#( 9=&&=D&%: #& # .&% #% " @ , 73/ 070 !$ 7 77; 9 86 !$ 79 & %":"%!&"B$
&: !C % # !&' !%! %!9"#&"&%!% %D%!:!' E"# %#%!A%: !'&!(# #C.&%&%-" #%"&( &% !(!&=%!!E'&.&%%=&"# %(&% &!:$
4$ ##%)&::&E((#A(::!%("&!&#( #>!&"&E( "!&!&(!&%'&! (' &$
% %& ( %!D! #-!!##! !!&" &! :!! # % &% ! :& %&" > -!!##! ' % #A%$ :!& E( #% E (D!&E(!&!"!&>!D"(&-&!:!&! (&%!D&& ! =&!:! # % (!&%'&! ( ' &$ (!& #% %#%"&&( !&! #%!&& ! (&%#% :! #% :! (!&!&&! ! %!& "&" ::!& & ( &% ! ( &! :!! && # % "# % ( &! :!! & ::&% "%- !" C (&-&!:!&! &$
(!&=%!!E !&.&%%:"# % &!:"=C$
%# (D!& '%&% :%! (&-&!:!&! ! '!& &&%C&% !%E% %&(&:!&' &% F% &! :!! %%!"%" # % && ;(055 :%$ # '!& A % %! 9& >!D% ( E( % #%&! !*! #!& :%!(&-&!:!&! E!("'!&C7<5:%$
"D%> !"%&! E!#%"A&% %%%=&"$
234/523554 *626*
0 )/ )*( ( ) N
12 ++ 3 4 5 $6( 5 "
2 +
7$ "%% %%'9$
2
3$ %=&&$
8$ : % #%&! EI #'& : %% % % &% #%"& %%.& "! 85 = % A &!:!&! #%A %!9 :""% @+-O!P%- :E!66550 B#%' !% %&!A%% !& #9! : %"&>%&$<3 !:""%% %!9:""%74 =! 355/ @ ,BJ " !% % % !& !!E% ! &!: & F#%'&# %&%!D&%% %& &!%J! !& .&% %" %!9 :""% #% ' ! # & #% ' ! "&% !E > !&! (%&$ 03 ,$ #%"& %%.& & #!A # ! % %&!' E" F#%' !'&.&%= !&C(' !$ D%::!A% #%"!& !,, K%!+ K D%::!A%*=%!&N &-%!
#! : %#%"&%%.&& &!:!">#%D%::
234/523554