Contractual Assignment of Future Work Upon Termination vs. Public Policy Against Restraint of Trade
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case addresses whether a specific type of contractual provision, which purports to assign rights to future work to a party upon the termination of an existing agreement, is enforceable when the termination occurs without cause. The court reasoned that while the language of the contract was broad enough to cover the assignment of rights to future projects, the provision violated public policy because its enforcement would unlawfully restrict the ability of the departing party to secure future employment and compete in the relevant market, thus creating an unreasonable restraint on trade, leading the court to invalidate that specific assignment clause.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contractual Assignment of Future Work Upon Termination vs. Public Policy Against Restraint of Trade: The court reasoned that while the language of the contract was broad enough to cover the assignment of rights to future projects, the provision violated public policy because its enforcement would unlawfully restrict the ability of the departing party to secure future employment and compete in the relevant market, thus creating an unreasonable restraint on trade, leading the court to invalidate that specific assignment clause.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAProvision cited for ordering the payment of court costs.
Testo completo
"#$%%"#&&' "%#()"#&&(
* +,* * +
-. / ! %0 1-. #&&(
!" # $
$
%% % & ' $!"
! !
.)(*.
2+
+/ " +0*1 $ " 23 %% % 4.23 5 6 2 + 78 ),,, 2 9 :;$ < $42)=*6/
)/ 9""$= $ 0!),,-2 ! !:!$ 2$ 2! $ <9 8$ 8" 2 + 2$!: ),,,/ >2<" < 2 $$ $ . 2 $ = $" ?$ = @ <$" 922$ 2 9!2A" . 8$ "$" 8$ :;$!$ $ < $/ 2 $ = 922 $$$$ !2A ?!$ <9 "$" 8$ 2 $ 2? $ 2? 22$ ?" " B. $4 6 2)*C$),,,42*$06/
1/ +D ! ),,- ?!" 9" <9 28$ $ ?8:= ! ."$$$ 8/>2<"<8$ < $28$E$2 <22!7 !< $ ! $ 923 + 8 ),,- 42 +, 6/ 8 $?$ 9"$""$:=!2$ $$ $/
F/ 8$ = G; 9" $ < 28$ E$ $ $$ 2? 2<9 9 8$ 2 ?!" 9$ ? "9: 9:;$ 9$8 9 $8 8$ >$$ 2 7$? ! !:!$/ !$"<922$922<$2 $$;4 )0!),,-H2++6/
&/ 2"" 2$ 8 $$ +) 7 ),,-/ !$" < ";$ 22: $$ !$ = 2 8$ $ ?I "$$8 2!$ = 9" 2"$ !:!$ 2! A $8/ $=22$ 8"< !:!$ 2!"$$$$$2$ & 23? 9"8 <2!8$"$"2A"/ 7$" < 9" 98$ 7! 2$$" < G< " $?$ 98$"$" "<!$8$ < $/ 8 9!: ""!$< 22 9";$" $$!$ $ $ " ?" 9" = ! 9"/ -/ %$=8 ! 9"42+16 " ?! ? !:!$ 2$ 2!$8=8$ < $ 2 2" + 2$!: ),,, 1+ ! ),,-/ "!"22"<9"98$2?!"8$ 0 ! ),,- ?$ <9 "$$ 8$ 2 < $ 2
()*++(),,- .1(*. / 8$ 2 2 " ! "$ 2 8$ < $<928$A82 $8$8$+8),,-42+F6/
D/ %$$$22$?!" "2$ )*7$),,- 42+&6/
*/ 9" $7$$ $ $$ " $ <$ !2$!$ 9$/ !$8!!";;;$2= ??$ 23 9 >I$ 9. $ /J$<"$$";$!"=2 $= ! !:!$ ! 7$ <9 2"$ < $$ 3 ?$ K;$K ?! 9!:!$!:9;$ 97"< 2 = 2A 2! 9 !/ "$$ !$$ < 2! $ "$" " C!$ 2 28 9>$ 9 8$ $A$"$"22$"2$/
0/ "2$7$ .$=?!$ " 22$ !$? < ! 2 8$ < $$$ 8/9GA2$G3!2::L9" $ $ = << !:!$ 7$ < $ 2$ " &$<9"2$2"8 :?2<9 I G<" $?$ 9!$$8$ $ 2< 2!$"$"2"8"/
+,/ $ 9 !2$ 2 1+ ! ),,D 2$ 9 $ $ = / 9" 2 ";" 8 $""2G" = 8 > ! 23 ":$ $8$" $$ < "29?!<9"$$ "!"2< $2 !2A/$<$$?!$"$$??$$"= ?! 2 "$/ $ = ?$ 8 <9 8 A$"!$<!$ = " !!$ L >. $$;$ !7$" ?!< 8$8A!2"$"?$ <?G "$22<"$8$ < $!$/
++/ %$ = 9 ??$" GG $ ?!" : " <9 9"$$ 2 ! ? 28 98 ?! 2 " A$ $$$ !7$" $ ?! I $A$"$"G8"/$$ !E!2 $$$$?!$A2 8A" C$ ),,+ " < 9" !2 +*3! "/2?!"48 +F7),,D6/
+)/ 2 $ >"$"$!=9"< "$"; "=7;/
()*++(),,- .F(*. +
+/ ?!"!$ = 9$/ &- / + $/ G/ F ;8 9;$ 7 46 : $ J$ $ < $$$ 2"8 = B$ &- ?" " 2$ ;"" $ -$:),,,4 6$8= ?" "B.! +*!+00F4 6/%!2"$2 7; B23$"$:/
)/ $7$"$!2$$ ?!2$24$/&-=-, 6 $8:/
1/ ?" "2$;"" $ -$: ),,,4 6$$"8;+78),,1$J$! ?$ !: 2$"; ! /% 2!$"2$ 8< $922< $E$$G"=!3 22<3;22:$8;!!$L ?$ 7 <!$ "$!$ $ 2 $ 4 M+)D F-D / + +)- +1- / F: $ "?"6/ 8G < 2" $= "?$ 3;$$$8 $922< "8 37 $"8;4 M++D01 /-:++) 1-, / FH +00* N 1D 2/ 1+- / 1:6/ 9$ 2< 2" $ $ 23 + 78 ),,1 8$ $: $ !2"$$!$3 9$";28 3; 2" $ $2 2$ 2" $ ??"$2"! ?"2 /
F/ $$;923<$ 82 8$ < $ 2$8??$"$$?$"G"$9" 2$2"$ !:!$ 2!A$8/
&/ %9$/+ 9.! !2 9:;$ $?$$8 9 !$"734/+6/ $!!$ 2$$ 9 $ !L.
$9!2G;4/)$/:6/
9$/ + / ) $/ : $ 3; $ < $ ?$ : 9.! . 28$ E$ !" = 2 G; ?8$2. $4; ?" "$"8 9.! -8!:+00+OMM+00) FDP$?=9$/+/)$/: 6/ .2$E$9:;$ . $ 28" 4/ % NQ8G; 5 %GRSG 8R$;G$ %S %GG$/+-)6/
()*++(),,- .&(*. -/ >$! 9$/*/+ 8$ $2$E$2 $$<9"$$3!$8$2<=$$:;$8$ ?" " 9. $ ), ! +0*+ 4 6/ 9 23 =2<9"?$ ! $22$28 <9 $ $3!$ " ?!"!$ = / " $ 2! "</ $ $ 8$ 8$ 3 < 8$ $$!$2$4$/*/) 6/
2 8$ $2"8=9$/* ! "$ 9"$ "2??$2$T$2!7 ! <$$$ ! 4$/++/+ 6/
D/ 923 $ $$ < 9" ! " 2 "$ = 9 $!" 2 8$ $0!),,-!$/
! = 2 2 8 ! 9?! . << ?! < $ . ?$ <9 "$$ " :;$!$ 8$ 2)*C$),,,/??$$ 2! "= 0 ! ),,- 2 K;$K < $ 9 2 ?!" <9";!$ $ / "$ 9$"" !2$2$8=$""2G < $2$"= 9$!".8>!232 9!2 .?$<9"$$ "!":;$!$2< $ $ = 22 9 $$"/ $ "$ . < 28$ $ "$ 923 "; ?$ <9 8$ 2"?">2!3 "$ 9"?$<9;$2$.
E$ "< 7 < $ < >2$ $" 28$ 8"$"!!$?$ "?>$"4 M+)+FD /)++&+F1 /*6.$<<9$2??$2 2!$$=9 2 8$ < $2<9$/ ++ >; !$ "$ "$ 9" < 2 $ 2 28 9??$ !23$ = 2$<$ / $ 9A$ "$" !2 8$ 0 ! ),,-9$!"9"$$2 $ 2 8$ 9$; 8$$$ $/ */ 6$$22"8 2"$ ?!$ <9 $ " = 9 $!" 2 ? :;$ $$ 3 ; ";!$$$822 :?/
:622 :?.< " $!$ 9$/0 $$$ ?" " $ 8$ 2 9!: 9$8$" "$$< . 2$3; $A ? ";$! <9 !$ I $$" <9 ";" $ 923 " "$ !2$!$ "$!" 9 !$$/ % 72 ;!$
()*++(),,- .-(*. " " 9 !$$ 28$ :; . = $ = !$"8$;$=";!$$8;= $<46 9$$" $ $8 $$ 3$ = 9"; 2 "$!" 4:6 <9 $ ; $ " 8 ; !$ !2"$46<9 !$"9$22 !2$!!" $!$ 9>$$ ;!$:$4 6<9$? " !2$!$ $2"8$22 2$>< $: 2"7 $46<";!$$9$2G;" 2!!$L9"$" "4 M+1+-)D /-/+2/-1- $"?"6/
6 9$ 2 28" ;" 8!: 2"2 "$ 8: $ < 9" $ ??$8!$ 22" 9$!" 2 <9 "$$ 8$ 2 .
$ 2$<$ H $$ ! 9 "$" = !:2/9$ 92!E!";"<9$!"$=$$ "?!$"$ <$ " = ! 2 "$ 2 8$ < $/ <9 $ $ $ 2 !!" $!$ !2$ $3" 9?!$=22 3<9"$$2 $;"" 9 9$!"<2$!$$>$ $/*/+ $++ /
"< !2$!$ $ 22 : ? 9$ 2 2G:=9$!"/
0/ ?$89;!$<!2$2? !2$ <9$ ! "2 8$ < $2$T$ . $ E$ 2 "$$8!$ 3 < 28 "$" 22$"<9"$$" 2)*C$),,,/
%8 $ !$ 8 $ = !"J$ $>$ < " < 8$ 9 $ $ 2 < 9" ?$ ! 2"$$22$28 ??$!23$ / 8:K<K!2A"2";$$"<8<$?? $2"$$/9;$ 9AA! K!!$LKK< KK 3 <K/8! 9$/*/+ ?!2<9 !$KRK/%";$8$8??2:$"=9" <" 28??$"$$?9$>2"!$!$" <992?$/
+,/ $ $$<2"3 <9""!$2!$ $ 9$!"= 2" = 2 8$ < $ 8$ + 8
()*++(),,- .D(*. ),,- + 7 ! < 8 <E$ "$ !2;" 28 < 2 9/
$ " 9$!" ?!"/ 2 $$ $=;!$K!:K9$28: 7 $ "22<$ $ 9??/
7$" !L$8:/
()*++(),,- .*(*.
3 +2 +,* * +
!
4 -
+/ "8:/
! 4
)/ 7$$/
1/ $<2" $;$$/
F/ ?! 2$ <B 28$ ?! $ 2"$ E$ " 1, 7 3 $?$ 23 : ?" " 4%GRSG?<--,,F 628 !$3 $ 2:?!"!$>$/*) ?" " :?" " +D 7 ),,& 4 M6H !"! $ < !$? $ !A 28$2$;$ $ ! $H $ E$ " : ?" " 2 8 2$ 2 8 "$< > $ 9$/ F) M/ 2"$ E$ $ 23 2 $8<"!!!A 28 8$E$7$=98/ ;??3 2" $ MM N% N "$.7$5 % #. U
2?! 2"$E$$$?">2$<B=B???" " $"2:<2;??
()*++(),,-