Statutory Toll on Inter Vivos Trust Transfer Timing
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAA party challenged the application of a statutory toll on property transferred via an inter vivos trust, arguing that the transfer was not subject to the toll because the beneficiaries possessed a vested remainder interest, which they contended triggered an exemption for interests vesting prior to the statute's enactment. The court reasoned that the relevant statutory language focused on the timing of the *transfer* of the property interest, not the vesting of the remainder, and determined that since the settlor retained a life estate, the transfer of the remainder interest was not fully effected until the settlor's death, which occurred after the statute's effective date, thus affirming the applicability of the toll.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Statutory Toll on Inter Vivos Trust Transfer Timing: The court reasoned that the relevant statutory language focused on the timing of the *transfer* of the property interest, not the vesting of the remainder, and determined that since the settlor retained a life estate, the transfer of the remainder interest was not fully effected until the settlor's death, which occurred after the statute's effective date, thus affirming the applicability of the toll.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in dispositive sections 5 and 6 for imposing court costs.
Cited in dispositive section 8 for granting legal aid.
Testo completo
$%&'($)' $%)+$)+
, !-, , !
. / % # 0 12 )+
! "#$ % &$ ' '" '"' (&$' ' )$ * +
$
, ! '" ! '&-' "#$ % &$ ' '" (&$' ' )$ #
,! . ! /$ 01 ##& 2#$3 45! 6778 +
! "# * 8947 *
3!
4; ($# , <*#0 ($#= $ $# '%' $% ' '" ' ">! ' ?&$ "& $ ' 1&*%! $ $$ @ $ 1$ ' "" ' 0% '# #$"? 4::A;
($# $ --& # #&%/ -% ' # #0 ' ,! .'$ $% <*#0 ($$$ ' #&%/= '# 4 '&"? 4::B;
8; <*#0 '"'= $%& ' $$ $# '($? 4::6 C - '&"? 4::D; & 4::B C 4::D! ' $ $ &$& --$& $$ ' #&%/ #- # "$$ $$ ' 5(:85 -; :A;
5; ' D %"? 8777! ($$$ ' #&%/ -"& ($# @( (/ %$ # ' #&% ' $$ '"' # & 4::B! 4::E $ 4::D! ' ' /$ $F &$& -& """ C #$ '@ (--$ C $ ?1$; # ' &$& '& '"';
6; * " '" ($# E #$"? 8774! ' "? "" ' 5(:85 -; :A #&$$ $$ $ '$; + % ' ($#! -$ $- ""'"$ ' #/ B %"? 8774! @ &$& -##& '(##$;
A; : F% 8778! ($# ""'& '"' ' (' '$"$ C ($$$ ' #&%/ # ?$ %"$ ' "$$ &"&;
B; ($$$ ' #&%/ ' G$& & @ $ C ($ ' ( ' #&%/ ' '"' '0 4 '&"? 4::B! #" %& %$ &$& &'$& C ($# <-; ' 8E %"? 8778=;
E; 0"$ '"' %$ '1& 48 #$"? 8778 $ ($# $ #"$ # '%$ ? ' #"0 $ < =; F1"$ ' 6 #$"? 8775! 60" 2"? ' ($ '&& "#&$$ $ "$;
'"'! #&$& # )$ * + ? ' & : $? 8775 - '(?$ "?"$ ' "" ' 5(:85 -; :A! '&"#& "" $H * .; 4(7E5;D7 % $&I$ C AJ '0 4 F% 4::E * .; 4(7:B;4A % $&I$ C AJ '0 4 F% 4::D * .; 4(EA6;77 % $&I$ C AJ '0 4 F% 4:::
94:5698775 * 5947 *
D; "&" ' &# ' 47 %"? 8775! ($#! #&$& # )$ # ! 01 @ '"' $ #$ ##$ ' ($; BE ; ## --$ @ ($ " 4::D @ '"' @( %$ &$& & C $$ #0 ' ,! @( (%$ #'$ @ #$ $ ($# @ D $? 8774; $ ##$ '(1 # $'
6 " 4:::;
($# #& # @( @( $%$ C %! ' "0 &#'@! '"' #%$ #0"$ ' '"$& F0 ' ; * $ "% ' &" F'(2 "?"$ ' #" #&%& @( %$ "I" $"# @ ' '"$& F0 ' ;
:; &#@ ' 4: F% 8776! '"' $$ @ & # I$ #$! %@$ $; 48E $ 64 ' -&'& ' 8A F 4:D8 #&%/ #- %! %%$ $ %'$& <=! $ #$ ' ;
47; '#@ ' 8E -&% 8776! ($# '0 @ ($; 64 $ (##@ ' '(#0! #@ ' #&%/ ($ # #$ C #&'; + ($#! '(#0 ( # $$ C $1 C $$"$ # %$ ' #&%/ #-! " C @$ ' % $ 'K"$ %& #*'% $$ ' #&%/ $ ' '"' $ @ $ $ &$& "?& # ($$$ ' #&%/ @( % '"'; "I" '0*$* @ ($; 48E (##@ #! #@( (1$ # '( $1 '&$ ' '$ ' $%; $$ -"$ @ '"' ( # ##$ #% ' @ ($# %$ --$%"$ &$& "?& # ($$$ ' #&%/! @ @' ? "I" $! $$ ' @- & ' '"'H -'$* (2"$ &1$" $$ ' $% L #"0 2/#$20! ($ ' $$ $ ($# $ ($$$ ' #&%/ "#@ @ * "? --&! $ ($#; 'M0" 2/#$20! ? ' & $ # "#&$$;
44; ' ' 8D #$"? 8776! ? ' & ##& ($$$ ' #&%/;
48; ' 46 $? 8776! * -"& @( $$ ( F" &$& ' # '"'! /$ &$& -& """ # #&' "&;
94:5698775 * 6947 *
# %& 'H
* # ' $$ @( %$ '& C ($# D %"? 8777! M $" ' @ %$ '& &#$$- ' @ %$ &$& $ '"' '# 4::B! N$ @ # &@$ % '%3 $$N! $
* # ' &#@ '& 84 '&"? 8777 ? '"$$- < = ' ' '( #&' '1& # ($$$ ' #&%/ $ ($#; ' I$ 8D K$ 8774 #>$ "%& ' (##$ -"& # ($#; +(1$ ' "$$ @ ($# %$ % #$ '&'$ ' '$$! $""$ '&& @ N "$$ ' 5(:85 -; 8A ##$$ & $ ($# '$ $$; ($ ' # #? ' '&' ' "$$ ' #" ' 54 '&"? 4:::N;
$ ' &#@ #'$ @ N% -? %! ($ # " C ( ?1$ $ # C*"I" F$$ M $$! , .'$ $% ( # '"'& ' #" '&?$ # &; @ & $ # " C ( ?1$! '&?$ '&'$ ' # & 4::B!
4::E $ 4::D! "$$ $$ ' #" (&%$ C 5(:85 -; :A; '&?$! C ? '$! # %& $$ ""; @ #&0'! "$$ ' 5(:85 -; :A $$ % ' & $ ' ("#/; "" ' 5(:85 -; :A ( ' -$ ?"$ C % % & ' # '"' $ #$ ' # I$ # "#$N;
45; %$& C '&$"! ($# 0% @ ($$$ ' #&%/ $ %"$ # $20 @$ ' % %$ &"$ "?& $$ #&%& ' '"';
($$$ ' #&%/ $$G$ & % > $$ $ '"' $ $$G$ --"& % "?&; ($# '0 @ M#$ ##$& # ($$$ ' #&%/ (##$$ &1 % $$;
46; $1& # ? ' &! ($$$ ' #&%/ ! # '
48 % 877A! #&& @ $H
N #&' ' 4;48;4::B 54;48;4::B! % '&?$& #" # -$ 4::E97E:B6 ' 8A;78;:E # "$$ ' O. 66A;BA <"$$ "# ' $$ ' O. 8(885;5A=; #0 4;
#&' ' 4;4;4::E 54;48;4::E! % '&?$& "$$ ' O.
A(8B8;47 # <"$$ "# -$ 4::E97:ED: ' 4E;75;4::E=; #0 8;
94:5698775 * A947 *
'$ ' B;75;4::D! $ -$ 4::D97D5B8! % &'$& "#$ #" ' ($# , ' "$$ ' O. A(E7E;EA #'$ $$ ' #" '&?$& ' 4;48;4::B 54;48;4::E # ; #0 5;
#" ( &$& -$& # C #$ ' 4;4;4::DN;
4A; &$& $" M #$ $ 1'& C F1; &1& ' #$ $ #! $$ @ ' ?! ' #$ P '$ Q @ $;
!
4; 1% R1$ F' <= &$& "'-& $ $$&!
'0 4 K$ 8775! ? $ ' ! "#& ' A F1! '$ #&'$ $ %*#&'$! A ##&$ $ 4B F1 <$; 4 $; $ AB =;
8; +$ C R$ ' R&$ ' 4B F1 ! # ? -&'& 8E F% 8776 < . 457 47B=! ' 1% '#$&! 45 -&%! '#$ $$ 1$ #"$$$ ? $ ' ' &1 C $ F1 $$! ! ' R$$$ ' R&$ ' %M F1 ;
5; -"&"$ C ($; AB ; 4 $; ? ! ? $ ' )$ $ @ ' $$$ $% C #&%/ #- ##$ $$$ ' #&%/! "#/ $ /$ '$! / "# ' '%! @RM #&$$ #?$& <$; 554 C 554 ' ' ' ?1$ S $; A8! AB! & 4! $ $; E5 ' S $; 468 ' %=;
6; M $" ' R$; E5 ; 4 ! 2@ $ '&1 $? @ )$!
'0 $ $! ' $$$ ##$ $$$ ' #&%/! "#/ $ /$ '$; '& ' $?M $M #%$ I$ '&-&& ? -&'& ' < . = # % ' ' '$ '"$$- <$; E5 ; 6 =;
$$ '#$ R##@ 'R #$ M $$$ ' #&%/ 1$& ' '$ #%& ' '$ #? T ? @ #$$ "" ?1$ @R @ #$$ R&$'$ *'C <$; 6: ; 8 = T $! 'R$ #$! M -'$ ' #&%/ -% ' # 1$&! ' '" ' #$$ @ '&#$ """ ?1$ <$; D: ? ; B S . 488 585 '; 8=;
94:5698775 * B947 *
"#&$ ' $$& %& # ($; E5 $ '?"$ '&-;
($! $$ '(?'! @$ C $ ' $1H -$ @ $$$ $ #$ #$ ' @$ #&-@ ' #&%/ #-! &$$ 1 < . 488 A: '; 8S 487 4D '; 4S 44E A7 '; 4S 44B 887 '; 4S U + ! 2$2$3 ' 2$ ? 2$#V2 ?-2 1! &1 # EA0" % ' . ! #; 6EE =; $ ' ##"$ ' $1 @ #$$ ' #$$ '(! ' #$$ ' ? #1 <$"$ #$$ '($& ' $= $ ' $$ < + !
## '( I$ ' ? -&'& ' $- C "#&$ ' $?M 1%! + 4:DD #; 446S ! 2$ ' ?-2 1 ' +2W3! X B! #; 48E! $ 5=; %2! % ' '$ ' ($; E5 $ # %$ @ $$$ -'"$ F'@ $ @ '$ ' #&%/ #-! "I" '%$ % ' --$ %$ ' '$ ' '$ #&%/ < . 488 A: '; 8S Y * + ! 2$#21 % '1Z2" 2112$ ' '12$ 3" ! + + 4::A #; 47A S 48A 4BD '; 8!
488 585 '; 8? $ &-&S + 4:DD! 448=;
$$ "#&$ $ &1"$ "$& # -$ @ '&1 ' "0 &@%@ #$ #%$ I$ & C $$$! % $$$ ' #&%/! "#/ $ /$ '$ < Y ! 2$W1 2 '" ! + [47B\ 4:DE #; B47 S + OU ] O* O O ! 2$#-1 2 '" S + + 4:D5 #; 4E6=;
? -&'& ' I$ #?& . 488 AE F1& @ ($; E5 (&$$ # ##? ' '( $1 ##$ $% C "#/; $% &"$ #"$ '( "$$ 'K $#$ ' (##$ ' $0; -$ @ $$ ' $%! "$$ '%$ I$ $& # 2$ ' ' # --$ # # '"$$ "#&$ ' ($$& %& # ($; E5 ; . '&$ @ $$ $$ (&$$ # (M# '( ?1$ ' ( ' ($ ' #$ % ($$$ ' #&%/; $ $ $ '(#0;
#&$ $1 #$ --$ #&$$ ' '"' "?"$ ' "" ' 5(:85 -; :A $ C $$ # ("#/ $$ ' $$ ; '0 ' '" #&-@ ' '$ ' #&%/ #- < . 488 AE=; +% #$ $1M! $ (#0! '"' ' "?"$! $ (?F$ '( &1"$$ M# ' ' '#$ '(M&$ ($ # '&$"$ @ "#&$ < . 44E A7S . 446 47A=;
94:5698775 * E947 *
"#&$ $ "$ ' ? ' & # F1 ' 'R#0 $ &$?;
A; R$; E5 $$ &1"$$ #&! '&1$ C R! ' " ^ ##" "#$"$ ' '$ ' ' %?$& ' ' '$ '"$$-! C % RM$ 'R '& -'& '$ #? -&'& <I$ #?& ' 8A F% 8777! 5E9:: _$ S . 446 47A '; 4?=;
B; (%$ ' ($ #&% C ($; E5 ; 4 ($ " "" $ C (?%$ '( '& <+ ! $$M ' -&'& $ #&' $! ' F#' 2`$ 4:D6!
# 4:=; @I$ '&#& # '"' $ '0 %?;
E; -&'& ' B $? 8777 #$ 1&& ' '$ ' < = $& %1 4 F% 8775 ($ # ##? M $1 "$0 ' #&%/ #-;
% ' 5 $? 8775 "'-$ <#"0 &%= $ $& %1 4 F% 877A < &% ' $ '#$ '$ ($& %1 &$& -M& 4 % 8776 $ 4 F% 877B [ 8776;4E77\=!
$)$ "'-$ ' "? '#$ &1 ' '" ' #&%/ #-; + # "$&! #$ ' % @ '$ (##@ '$ I$ $2& C "0 ' ## 01 ##? $ %1 ""$ ^ -$ F'@"$ '&$"$ $ #'$ < . 48B 45B! '; 6?=;
(#0! #&$ $1 #$ "?"$ ' $$ #&%& C $$ ' '"' ' 4::B C 4::D! $ # #&' $& C ($& %1 ' %! @ (##@ ' #;
D; $$ &1" '( ?1$ ' & <$; 8 ; 4 =;
+ ($; 44 ; 4 ! $$ "#/ #$ ' & " C ( ?1$ '$ I$ --& C $$$ ' #&%/ $ ' 1$ ' #&%/ #-;
($; 5 ; 4 ' (' '$ ' ($$$ ##&$% "$0 ' #&%/ #- <+ D54;656= #&%$ @ ("#/ '$ % C ($$$ ##&$% $$ ' # ("? ' & " C ! % --$ '0 ""$ ^ $ 'K I$ --& C $$$ ' #&%/;
94:5698775 * D947 *
+ ($; 8 ; 4 ! (--$ C $ ?1$ @ %& # "I" "#/ '&# "$$ ' 85(DD7 -; <&$$ 4::: * ' ('#$$ ' "$$=;
(#0! ($ # $$& @ '"' && '$ #&' & -& C "$$ $ @! #$$! ' $$ C 2$ ' 5(:85 -; :A (&$$ # ';
:; ($# 01 @! %$ ' ($; BE ! ($ '1& # '"' $ *"I" $ #$; '0 --$ @ '"' ## 44 " 4::D '&FC @( '%$ # I$ & #0 ' ($$$ ' #&%/ $ $ @( $ 'K 1 # $' 6 " 4::: # &" $$$ ' #" '&FC $ $ 57 #$"? 4::: # #" $ ' 4::D;
+ F#'! (?1$ ' $$ (' -' #" '#$ #& @ #&%$ $! C '&-$! 01 1&& ' (2"$ &1$" ' $; B8 C BE < . 44A 44D '; 5?
$ &-&=;
! @ ##$ # ($ ' '#$ C #&%/ #- ?1$ <$; 6: ; 8 =! -" # ' " $% C $$$ ' $$ #/& C $$;
'&-$ ' " $$$ &1"$! '"' ' "?"$ -' &@ $; B8 ! $""$ ($; B5 ; 4 < .
48D A8 '; 5=;
%$ ' ($; BE ; 4 ! ($ # '(2"$ &1$" #$ # C "#$ ' F ^ #$ && ' '$ ' &#&$$! $! ' $ ! # 'M '0 ' '$;
($# '0 @ '& '%$ C "#$ ' 44 " 4::D! '$ C @ ($$$ ' #&%/ &$ $"H N($ #$! % "$$ '&"#$ '($ ' #" -$& 4::B $ 4::E # ! ' ' A(E7E -; EA $ &'$& %$ "#$ ' #"N;
($ # (% ' ? ' &; $ '&' ' @ "" ' 5(:85 -; :A ($ # 'K I$ #&%& ' '"';
* @ @R $ ( # &$& -"& ' ;
($ @ D %"? 8777 @ '"' ## @ ' $$ %$ &$& #&%& C $$ ! %$ # ' '& # ($$$ ' #&%/ C ($#; "$$$ '"
94:5698775 * :947 *
($# E #$"? 8774 $ -$ $- ""'"$ ' #/ B %"? 8774! 1 ' '& '( & #&% # ($; BE ;
+ $ %$ C ?$ "?"$ ' $$ @ %$ &$& 'K"$ #&%& '$ '0 I$ '" # "$$ ' 5(:85 -; :A; ##$' C ($# ' $! &2&$! $ ($$$ ' #&%/ * --$%"$ 1'& # '% '$ "$$;
@ - $ '&# ' ! ($; E5 ; 8 #& @ $ '%$ #&% #&' "#! #' $! ##! 1$$; ($; D:O ; 4 ' #&' '"$$% ' 48 #$"? 4:DA < = #&%$ @$ C @ #&' $ 1$$ # #$;
94:5698775 * 47947 *
!3 !-, , !
#
451 6 7 89 %+) ":
1
4; & '"' %?;
# 1
8; ('"$;
5; '" ($# C "? '"' "" ' 5(:85 -; :A!
'&"#& "" $H *.; 4(7E5;D7 % $&I$ C AJ '0 4 F% 4::E * .; 4(7:B;4A % $&I$ C AJ '0 4 F% 4::D * .; 4(EA6;77 % $&I$ C AJ '0 4 F% 4:::
6; '" C % '"' '"$& ' 4(777 -; C $$ ' #$#$ C - $ '&#;
A; -" #$ ' @R #%$ -" $ #&$ I$ ' '& ' 57 F '0 $-$ # # ""'& '& ? -&'& ' ! +2W32-@ B! B776 ! $ M"#; '& #$ I$ #1&; "&" '$ H = '@ M$"$ @ '& $ '& ?$ $ # ' '& $$@&S ?= M# # @ "$- $" #% '"' $$ $ '&S = #$ 1$ ' #&$$; + "&" $$ # $ &&"$ &"&& $$ = ?= $ = *'! ? -&'& ' # # $ "$0 @R '% '& %?; "&" ' "$ "/ ' #%! @ $ F$! @ '& $$@& $ R%## ' @ &$& M#&'& $ <$; 458! 47B $ 47D =;
1--0 &'$ H
* ] U
# -" ' #&$ I$ $ $-& M #$ @RC R-- -&'& ' # 1--
94:5698775