Easement Validity and Enforceability Dispute
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAA litigant sued a group of entities concerning a property dispute originating from a transaction related to a right-of-way easement, with issues centering on whether certain contractual agreements regarding the easement were valid, enforceable, and correctly interpreted, particularly in light of subsequent property sales and surrounding circumstances. The court reasoned that the relevant instruments, when read in context and considering the parties' conduct and the physical reality of the property, supported the finding that the challenged agreements were clear and enforceable, thereby upholding the lower court's determination regarding the scope and application of the easement rights as described in the controlling documents.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Easement Validity and Enforceability Dispute: The court reasoned that the relevant instruments, when read in context and considering the parties' conduct and the physical reality of the property, supported the finding that the challenged agreements were clear and enforceable, thereby upholding the lower court's determination regarding the scope and application of the easement rights as described in the controlling documents.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAImposed the costs of the proceedings on the appellant.
Testo completo
!"#$%%# &$'$$%%(
)* +* , ) *, ,
,-./ # &$ 01./ $%%(
!"#$"%%% !!" &$"'"!( )
"!
& ++ %! %"%$ ,-.
64/736
2
78 9%6 !:;&!$<$=%7-33!%$"%%"$ $%:!>?"$=%"7--0"@"4555"!!%#$ A:#05#B!7--48>!$?$CDE !%#$F"!$!$8
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
08 72 #!% 7--- ! D? %%G %%G D%!!C% %C"%# %C"%G$ $"" !: "% !? "% $"" !: "% ?!"! & D, "!#! B%! $"" !: $#"% D$"B%!CD$"" !:%?!"!$ !"%CD8
28 75 =% 7--- &!$ &" % A "%"$"!% >% "$!%$"A$DC! D%&B8
J8 7!"B!7---! $%%"*)!D"C% """$ G&"" %" "!%" ! #!"$B! !#%"!B%!8B%!%C! D%G !""%"&>!$%6 ?!"!%!8 "%" !$"%" ,! !> D!%G "6 "% # !C% A !$% CD " ! B?%:! B%"$! # !BB ""%" "6"!"%G &!"%"% !6%%G !%"8 ?%" $C" "! ,?"% !%:! !"%"% D!6"! CD8 $"%" "!%"$ ! B%%"% "%6%?"%!""%$ !!A "%"8
/0123/4553 60/736
38 2 "B! 7--- ! "$ $#"% "" ?#!B # %C"% !#%C% BC% D!%G ! !6%%G !%" " "! CD8 &$"" !> D!%G ="%?%%" &% %"$"!#%8
.8 &!! ! B%%"$ %#% % &%" L%"!"D! !#!$A&!$ ! $!%71=#%!7---07$B! 7---""J&255?!8!! "A !""%"!&"%#%"$ $C:!&!$$C$ !6%8
18 71 ?$#!%! " 0 ! 4555 ! $%%" *) $% C$$! !#$ !%" & ,! !> D!%G " !C%6BC%8
-8 4-?$#!%!4555&??%" "%"""$G&!$%% G $ > ?%%" &B=" & $%% !#% "" >$"%!!%&!! ""2"B!4555%%?!$&??% "&!6%#%%"$9%6 !:;& <G$ > B$$?%%%"& !% %4.=%45558
758 7!!4555&!$!G% !""%&!6%#%%"$8
778 77%4555! !! !"$% """"G &!$ $%"%" % 71 =#%! 7--- "!%"" $% G % %"$"!#%$"%""" %""""G& !$"%"K,! !> D!%G " "% # !C% CD ! B?%:! B%"$! # ""%" "6"!"%G !BB &!"%"% !6%%G!%"8,?"%! !%:!!"%"%D!6 "!CDK8
748 72$B!4555! $%%"*)D%!!C%! > !"%$%A&!6%"8!G%%! !%C%G $"%!74"B!45558
#%">%$ "%"43%4555G$"%"%"%>% % "$!%!"A&D"75"B!45558 %C%"! !#% !B%! "D!%G D! # CF ! %!"%! C% &%" BC &" CF %# *8 B="%#" &> !" ""%" "" B% !H %??$!" !$"%"""A?%"!!"H!#% "%!H "% ! !6#!"$B! !%" %# I" 3 A 1H "% " !% ! B%! " "% ! > !6%%GH %" %C"6 5 C!" >!B"% ! B%! " !6%%GH !%C%G" %?!"!%$& D,"!#!2A!%"8&$""
/0123/4553 62/736 "%" #%" ! $#!8 "" $"%" """ % B "!#%!" #%">!!?$C8 #%"!#D ??"!"MD$C:!A%%%&$"%" %A"!%B"%8 "!%"" %%G$ $"%" !" % %> N% D,%"D$! % "!%"" ! $% ! " ,?"%" !6 %%G" !%&"%6%?"%!"&"C%G842=#%!4557! !$%$ G &!$ "" G $C:! A %% " B &??"! "MD !" A #%! ?%! %% & ! ?" " ?%! "!#> "",C $C!8 %" $#%"! " ??!" """A"!%B"% !> DC!%"!% !& %!"! ! !"!!D!C8!!%:!"MD"%$ ! !%" !?% !O!8""G?$CCC$ !"%!% "%!G& "%%"!>"MD$C:!"G&""" !!F" "!#% "8 !"!%"% " $G ""%" !B%!C!$ !"!"%71=#%!7---8
708 0 % 4554 &!$ %%G$ A & G % $"%" B "$ >!!%""%#%"$A755P!"!"%8
728 70 ?$#!%! 4550 ! """$ & ,! !> D!%G "6"% !D% "!%" % %"$ "!#% "" ? $C8 &"! "%#%"$ $"%" %??%%" >%C%B !%"""%"!%C%"%G"&B?!"%8 "%" %C%"!D%C%D!%GC"$A&??!""D!, D" !!6%%G"&$"">%>8&$"""$$"%"""%%!8
7J8 07=#%!455J!#%$%!$C% 9%6 !:;+ < ! > %%G B%%% %%! ! ! G %C$ ! !" K ,D%"! *)K " ! ! * KD%!!C% !"D $%G*)K8
! !" "% G &!$ "!#%$ ,$ % & !"!" "> %B??">!"!"9 "%<"%"?$CDE !%#$8&!$ %" BC% B "% &%"%"$ #!%B ! C B! %?$!%! CD ! " "D!%G # %??%"$ ! %!"%!8 +&C%" "" ,D%"!%G % " !#$ G &!$ !$" %?%"% %""%G%C??!B="%#B " &"!"%8> !"&" B="%#$, "I?#!&,! !>"?! !%""8+ %"$=C""!%" !! "A%"%C%%"!8&!$ !$" "!B !%"$ !B%8 B "" ,D%"!%G"%%"!8
/0123/4553 6J/736 %C"% $">BC%D!%G"!"D!%G "6"!"%G !%""8 & !$%"% $% !:#" G &!$ ??! & % ,D%"!%G %#%"" %"$"!#%>%C%B""%:!8
&B & #$!%"B "%" $"! G% ?%" !"% ,! !> "?! !%"" % &" !" %C"%8 + %?%"% "!"% !B "> " !B !"" %C"% ,! !> "?! !%"" ! ! !$ & ! %" " !%"" & C" & "%"$"!> %G$"%:!" ! ! D,%C%G "!B D,%G " !#" ">" ?%" $"% " !B: ,D%> ??%" % !"" ! F"! %$!$ "%"!B8"!!$!""! !C%G8 &!$ " $"!"%# " %! C!!D$%G "#" %""%G%C??!B="%#B " &"!"% " ""%!! "! "D%8 !$" !B%%"$ ,D%"!%G B$$?%% & !% D!C !D"C%G " ?"%"%"!8
!%BC% !%""""!$%"#%!"!#%$"%! %6$"%!K !"!B="!& %%?$!%!A%GN%K8 %"#%!"!#%G %"!! %"%%# %"% B"8 %" $#%"! "!#> "?>% "!8 !" $ "A "" !%8
+! "%G""G?$C %"$"!#%"" !$"5PA !"%!71=#%!7---8"!#% "$! "" %%""%?"% %"$"!#%>%C%B" :"A !"%!7! =#%!4555&"6A6%! !:&%"8
738 41?$#!%!455J!+ G !%" &% %"$ "!#% "" "%#%"$ &$"%" $%" ="%?%$ 6 A7!=#%!45558
7.8 44 ! 455J & !$$ A GF" $%G ! $C8 &GF"!% !:# G&% % " %??%% !! %"% ! % %"$ ??"%#G&!$!"!$C!"??$"&> !% "&""%"!%G% !$!"&"!"%8& !:%! %6%% %"$$C$ """G% !'" !BB ""%??$!"! !"$%>?%"G&%" %%,%>"G&C! F"!%!""!" 8
718 - @" 455J !$ ""% !?% & !#$ G &D, "D: G&!$!%"B"$!"!#%$A755P%
/0123/4553 63/736 !"!"% #%"F"!!""G6%#%"%%"""&"%#A 755P8$"%" !% "C!$&%#%%"$!# %#%%"$""%"%GA755P27&25.?!845559++45556 .<%" ?$C ,$ !"!"%"!##%#%%"$ 4555"B++4555 72J&1.7?!84J"%#%"$%! 45 P !% %%""% ?"% &!$ B"%" A !# 03&3-. ?!8 C!$ &%#%%"$ $"%" %% 770. P "> G% &#!%" !%" A ! !?%8 &!$ #%" ! % "8
7-8 ! !="$%%-@"4553& !="$ !""% &!$8
458 1 "B!4553&!$! !$"$ !#" $!%"A& G &%% & %"$ "!#% :" % 7! =#%! 4555 $"%" "!%"% :" # > " > !"% !$$" !"%%!&> !"%!72$B!45558
478 !$%%44 "B!4553& %"!?!#"G !#%""""$G&!$$"%"% B""G$C:! &??"!"MD!"8
448 45 "B! 4553 &!$ !! A &"! "" !%:! $%% !: !%B"!%"A"% "A&"!%&!"&%#%%"$:7!?$#!%!45558
!:#G&"&%"!$%%"%!-55?!8 !% ?$C8 #%" ??"!!"%"!#>$C! "$"%"%$ !!%"B6O!8+&%""!#%!%"A15P ?$C"",C8#%"%#%""!%"" ! $8 %&%""=G&70?$#!%!4550"! !"$%> """%"&% %"$"!#%A755P"&$"""B%%$8$"%" %>" %! G& #%" "!#%! : 7! =#%! 45558 & !$%"% !$"!"%# $% + $"%" DG"8 + !# %#%%"$ " " ?%" G& !%" C"$ " "!#% " G&B" !%$=!!%"#!%BB"$"$25&555?!8" !# &%#% $"%" 8 !!%" %> "!#%! A 05 P ! !#7&555?!8 !%G%B"%%"A">&%#%%"$.5P8
408 45#B!4553& !="!!8
428 7. #!% 455. !%B $ ?%$ > !"% A ! ) "" G&% >%"%" "!%"% "! #% $%> + " ! " G" A %"$"!#%!!"8
/0123/4553 6./736 4J8 41 "B! 455. ! ) ! ! !" &> !"% ?$!&>!!"B%"!"%"%!6 %%G%%G&,C4-%455.8&!$ %C%" % %" "=! ! !$C% B%! B!! %% G !$C% !6%%G > I"$ # %!!%"% % B! %?$!%! CD8 ! " "" !$%" %" " "%#!%!"%&#%!"!%6G!"&D!6D!8 %"$C"!!$C%"! :EA!%""C!%"!%"8 % GG =! ! " $C" ! !$C% "D!%G"$!%!CD8 !"D!%G"$C" !$" %"""%8!%!& %"%"C%G " !"!C" F %"%%B"%%C" 8
!%!", %?"%!B%B%C%G%%G& !6%%G"$"$$8 >"!>8&, &!C" ! % %?"%! D!%G ", ,!"D! "D%8 ! &> !"% $% 455J !%C! D% " !D% ??"$ "B! 4555 " $"$ #%%$ " $!%" !$% ""!"%G#%%BD!%% "D%$!$ 26J" !BB%?!"!%$& D,"!#! 2A!%"8 $%$!%""B!"%#!8&, &$$" B="%? !!$"% # , "I "%"8 %"#?"%!%! " ??"! "!#> ! " !$ $"$8 " !%B" ??"! % "%#%"$ !?% "", ? $C8 !#D " ??"! "%#%"$ $C:! "I" % # %B%%"$ DC!!$C%:!" %"%8 "!D! !B:8
& %"#!D"C%G "%"??!%"BC%D!%G" ! "D!%G !%" D!%G # $%!"% !BB8 !!%" ??"! "%#%"$ $C:! !" D!C ! "!#> ! D$#"# %B%%"$DC!!$C%:!" %"%8 %"% %"$"!#%"755P8
#%" !!%:! !$% !"A !"%!G "%" ">!!"%#%"$ "$A755P8??"! # "%" !%:! ?% % 45558 "%" $"" %" A " % & !# "B! 4555 !: &D"8 "%$ G %"$"%"!"%%!"#&%"G&$"" "%"&$"%" "B%%$"% ! %"!#%!%>6D%"% "!G%& $"$?%"8 =#%!4557! !$%%"G "%" #%"??"!G "MD$C:!"%#%"$$C:!8 !$%%" "> %"$ "!#%8 &# &"!$#"%=G&A&> !"%455JD!% ! !" $% ! % ! $% "!%"" ?$#!%! 4550 G% $!%#%"
/0123/4553 61/736 %""%%DC$8 #""G% !$:#%! !$%% !" &$#"% " "%! G "%" " >!! "%#%"$?$C %&%""G& ">!!"%#%"$ $C:! "$ %47=#%!455JA#%!A !"%!"&> !"% &"%"% %"$"!#%>%C%BA755PA !"%!7!=#%!4555 ! "!$#"%B="%#8
438 73 "B! 455. !!" !G% #!" & !" "%:! &%#%%"$ " $!% " =G&A &"!% ! !$ ""% %% G& ! !" % " " %%"$ =!%:! ! $!% "$!%!A!"8
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
""%$G%!$"$%!*8
418 +!G%$"$C!$A=C!8
)
78 ! ! 7. #!% 455. !%B $ $!$ !! !#B8
48 &B="%"%C !"!!%"!!"A!"&%#%%"$"A !!$ ""% !?%8
/0123/4553 6-/736
08 " !$ "$ % %"$ "!#% "" !" "" !"% Q "%" Q!$A %! !?%%Q"%#%"$"!#%G% " !%B" F"! >%C$ % % "" !" !$" Q ""%" A "$ D,%G " ,D%G8 Q% %"$ "!#% C !$ Q"%#%"$ G% " F"! >%C$ % " % !#! Q "! !?% Q "! % Q"%#%"$ 9!"8 3 <8 " !$ "$ % %"$ C% "" %%"%QBQ !"% %B%%"$C%Q!$! !D$"!#%$G%%B!$%Q"%#%"$%""%%"%!$" Q""%"A"$ D,%G" ,D%G"GQ !%" !: "!%"" " ! !$ ""% >%C%B 9!"8 . <8 " !$ "$ %#%%"$Q% %"$C%"" !"%G%" !$$ !" C!$9!"8187 <8
28 < % &"!$ #%C! 7! =#%! 4552 # 47 ! 4550 %?%" 92:!$#%%<"!&!"84187 "%#";R78 &!$ !%" A !" &% " %#% A 25 P %8 !" " $D$%"">&%#%%"$;25P%G!"J5P %%35P%"!%6G!".5P%!""%:!8S8
+ ""! ? % %"% ?% %?%"% 47 ! 4550 !" "%:! ! !T "%"! & "> &%#%%"$ $C $!%! A 334/0P "%" &F"! #!$ !: &"!$ #%C! # % %"% $C A " !"%! G% A " A " ""%" &MC J58 ""!!""%:! !T"%"!&%#%%"$%?$!%!A .5 P ?" &B=" & !$#%% $% & : &"!$ #%C! #% %"%8
B< + &!"8 4- 8 7 !%" A !" &!"8 41 ! % "I"A"A !"%!G&!$ !$"% %"$ C% !B 25 P % 9"8 < A !"%! G % !$"$ , % %"$ "!#% 25 P % " $ %"!! "%"B9"8B<8
Q>%" Q % %"$ C% !B 9!"8 4- 8 7 "8 < %" F"! % !G Q""%" A "$ " !C" "B%%$ " "%" %!!$#!%B"GQ??"!""#!%B!B" %"$ C% Q!$ ! ??%" C!# ! ="%?%! Q"!% Q !" 9!"8 4- !:C" ! &!6%#%%"$ 7. =#%! 7-37 6 <8 ""%" !%C%" B% " F"! %$!$ !"%#" "B%%$"!G!":!%!"$#$%:!GQ % !$#%!G !"%G"DC""BQ%"!#%! #%! !$#%%B 9 * 77- 754 %8 2 " !$?$!H + 7--- 8 17 %87<8
/0123/4553 675/736 J8 DE !$ "%? C!$ &%#%%"$ %" F"! $#$ ! B & !% !#8 ! !# G &!$ !%" B"%! &% &$"%" %#% " !$ # % G&% !!%" B"%! >!T" &"%#%"$ G% " !%B" F"! >%C$ % !: "!%"" " ! !$ ""% ! !D$ "!#% $G%%B!$8 !% !#&??"!:C!%%!D%??!"%>""G %B "">!#" ?!""& #&"!%??$! !""" ! "> &%#%%"$ 9$"D C$$! !% !#H *705021%808274105%87752703%84" 4BH=G&07$B!4554;!"84184 H7!=#%!07 $B! 4550;!"8787 !!$"%#&!"873 H %7!=#%!4552; !"8 41 8 4 !!$"% # &!"8 73 <8 ! !$! A !% !# % #%" ! " % !%" A !"H !# # " %#%%"$ %#" F"! $"!%$ ! ! !" A F " " %?%"% !# "%B &%?! !%" A !" !# =G& " U $%% " !%#"F"! !% "9 *74-440%82877417.2<8
!# &%#% %" F"! $#$ #" "" ?"% %""% !?% !:" &%"$!$8 &B & !# ??"%#" !$%$%,%!$?$!!>$""%"%G"G&!$"" GF"!"!"!%!9++<&??%?$$!""%"%G9 * 743 .3%80B/"BB<8 !G%!!!"" ""%"%G %#" F"! !$%" $ &B %!" ! " !?% !"%%! 9%%""% %$ D% MC $ !#% "%%"$/"$C!% &"!%"% $=! " "> & "%<"!$"&$#"%%%" #%!& !$%"%8 $"%CB>%4JP!%!""%"%G !""%! " %??$!" $$" G% #" %?! !# & "%#%"$ !"%#9?8 *743.1%8J<8
!# ! #% $"!% $"B%" C!$ #!%B !$ $!"G&!%"??"%#" !$%!" $"!%" % $"%" B "$ 9 * 74- 442 %8 28087 " !$?$!<8 %" F"! $#$ %:! % !:" G %B % B% G&% #%" !:C C$$! !$?$!! !%! %! G &!$ B" #" &""%" A "$ "" " &$#"% %! %"!# =G&" !$$%%8!%"&$!"!&"!# !"%?G&!$% %"#"!#%#%%"$ %! %B%%"$ C% G G&% ""%" #! " G% % !""%" &B"%! !# " 9 * 74J 7J. %8 J/BB " !!F" %"$<H % #%" ""?% !! A &, !$?$!! !G&% !!" &B %!" G &!$ %#%%"$ !%"
/0123/4553 677/736 ""$ & " !$$!"% %:! !B 9?8 4554 721.H 7--4 8-3%82<8
38 <G%! !#=C!%?$%% ?% %"%"!%!%!?%"G%?"&F"!$"B%%:! %!!$?"B !%" #!%BB&"6A6%!G% !$"" C!$#!%B !$ $!"8??%" G&?%" %F"! %$!$"D, "D: %B8!%"$$"?%" $C$ #%CB =C %" $D$" !"%! > G% % !%" !BB9 *743035%8JB74J7-J%84" !$?$!H?8 *705042%8084"080<8 %&>%"6"6% !%" !% !%% G&%%"!"%=C#!%" ""!"?#!&!$9 *743044%8J<8
+ !%% %B! !$%"% !# %" #B !$!=%%%!!!%!%9?8!"837 "8 <=C&" %$ !!:C?!%%">%! %:!B="%#", !#GG&%" !# % $%!%"A% %"% !""" !"!=C"#B! !%" %"%C%>8 ! !" $%> "!%"%! =C " "!D!&??%! !$%!&B !#"%%G!!% ! G % ? ! %% $% " ! "!8 &$$" $"!%" ! #! !B" & ! !" $% &" % !%C%%$%C"%%"8 "$C!%% !"G %" %"%C%>% !""%"?%"&B="&$"?%$G! !"?! > " G&% ! $C" %$!"% %" > !%$G&%%"$"$$"B% %%%!9:<G !% "% %"!?$! $% %" %! " ?% G % &> !" %" B% "%#$8 + !""! !%% %B! !$%"% !# !%B ?$$! ! $ %C %!"!%G%!%:!& !$%!!"%", &> !"% ! !"$%>9 *74J0J4%80<8
B< !G " !$! %%"!"%# > !"% ?%$ A $% %$ " " $"B% ! $%%" ! ! B &B!#"% !?% " &%#"%C"% :" %% G& % %%!"G&> !"B"%"A!$""#%"=C !%"$!"!%C" G&%%!" !""! !B%6?$9 *74J0J0%80B/BB<8
< =C " !! % #! !B" > ! !" " > !"% $"B% ! $% !! % C" G >6% B"%" A !$""#%"G!%%"$!%""%#$G #%"%" "!%"%"G&%%!" !"" ""! ! B%6?$8 % ?%" G $% "$ " %$ A
/0123/4553 674/736 &!! !! !""!#% !" !"!&B="%#%"$ !$%"%% T! !$#"%A&$C!&!$8 &" G& !$%!" !"%%:!G"="&% !"%%"$ & !$%"% #" F"! %$!$ B="%#" ?$8 "" $ &% !" ?$!$ > ! !" $%> !%" ! %%,%""?% !>%C$#:!G"A&% !"%%"$ &> !" 9 * 74J 0J0 %8 0B/ * B%$ 70 ! 4555 J-4/--%8B/<8
<=C&$!" !%% "%?% $!"%?%& > !"% $% =%%%! "MD &> !" $"" !$%$" ""! % $%A% %"%="%?%&$%!!! " $%>&$""?%"$8+=!% ! ""%"!!% &$!"!&> !"%=%%%!?%"G6%"%""!%"% G& !> !"% !$ ! "!%B %?%! % %:!#%"8"!!G&"! $%%"$""" %% "!%! " A ""! $!%" " !"% $"% &> !" " >! %"! !$""% %#!C" %!%! !=CB%%"!"% $"%! ?!&#> !"%$%9 *74J0J4%80B/" !$?$!<8
<G%!! !"$"B% !$%"!%""=C "" %" "%! " ?%" G &> $!% $% "!%"" " C$$!"%"A !! !"% ! "%"!% !"%?%G%&%"A!%!9 *74J0J7%80B/BB"<8
?<+%&%%"!"%=C?"! !$%"%%% !#?!% !%#"%C"%>G%%#" !$!&??%" #%G!"%?%" !$""C!$#!%B !$ $!" "G&"!! !B"%! !!%" %?%!"" !$%"%% " !? &%%"!! &"! !# 9 !$%"% "%% $ !#H (+ !V"C#!?D! % ! +E%#!%D!C 8 474 W 2J5H (XY/)Z !V"C#!?D! !V"C!D" ?C 4$8 80-W777" 877.W045H[#!V"C!D" ?C4 $8 84.2H?8% *74423-%82744440%80745B44- %84B77-022%80"!$?$!<8"%:! !$! #% !%"&F"!"&!"84-84 "89+4557W75 841 %8 2B< =!% ! ! & %! &!"8 2 "8 $"" "=! #B9 *742-2%82B744734%87"&!!F"%"$<8
.8 <!!F"07@"455.93J/5.< !%B?$$!=C$G ! !" + 70 "B! 4552 ! &$"%" !$# "%"! ,D%"!*)G #%" !$"!:!G"%"! "6 C! $%%"%#%" $"$$%#!$ !*)!% %"
/0123/4553 670/736 & % I ?$$! $% & % I $% $"!C! ! +%8 " > !"% % %" & "!%"% &>!! "%#%"$ A "%"! $% $ " %G 6% % #%" $"$ $%#!$42#B!4553 !$ !""#%"$"&"% %8 !%B ?$$! "%$ G&%$ " $" !?% ! !!%!!$C!%"$&!!?! %$ A ! " A &>!% "%#%"$ % + "D%" ?%B%%"$ ! !" $% $"B% ! " &%%"!"%8 : ! #%" !! % #! !B" A & !$%"% $% 70 "B!4552% !"""%!!%B!&$#"%&$"" "$ !!" % &"!% %%"% !"8 % =!%%"% " &$"%"6 !%" ?! !$%"% ! #% $%&#! !B"??%B%8
B<& :!!! !"$%07 =#%!455J%C$K ,D%"!*)K!G&&#%" "%"!"G& &$"%" "!%$ A"!#%!""G$%$ "8 %""%$"" %%%! !$%"$ % #%" & ! G #! !B" & !$%"% ?%" ! ! * # ! "??%B%8
18 !%B$""G&> !"%!)!$ A " !%":! ! G&% % %" ! % #! !B"8 &%"%$ &" $C"8 !!" %" %% F"! %$!$ """ B "!#%! "%#%"$ $C:! !" D!C ! "!#> ! D$ #" # %B%%"$ DC! !$C%:!" %"%8
&%"%$"" ""AG"">%C%B%%"$&"%#%"$ "$ >%"%"&> !":47=#%!455J8 "$C!&> !"!:#G &"%"% & %"$ "!#% >%C%B A 755P % 7! =#%! 4555 %" !:&%"! !$#"%B="%#8
+&C%" $!%"$!%!47=#%!455J$%,">%$ !!"" !$%";
6 2 "B! 7--- ! "$ $#"% "" ?#!B " """$ & % %"$ "!#% "" A $"" !> D!%G8 %6%$"$!#$ !! ?$#!%!"!4555" 77 % 4555 $% "%$ G&% >%"%" % %"$ "!#% "" %&%"?%!$70?$#!%!4550&"%#%"$?$C ! !$%"A"""G&"!"%#%"$$"%"%??%%" >%C%B!%"""%"!%C%"%G"&B?!"% !!"8
/0123/4553 672/736 6 72 $B! 4555 ! ! &> !"% !G% ! &!6%" ?%!$ % %"$ "" "!#% &"%#%"$ ?$C8&$"""$&$"%" !"B%%$8&"?$! >!!"43%"75"B!45558
6 42 =#%! 4557 ! !$%$ G& #%" $#%"! " ??!" """ A "!%B"% % G& $"%" B &??"! "MD !" $C ?%! %% & ! ?" " ?%! "!#>"",C$C!8
# #% $%> % , % ! G !!" $"$ %$!$ """ % B "!#%! ? $C %=!%" !"$%&,">%$8!#D 42 =#%! 4557 ! > !" %$ " "% G& " B&??"!"MD$C:!!""$C:!$#%""??!" """ A "!%B"% !"! ! D!C8 "" !$%"% G" > %%""% ?"% " ??! !!" !=%" ?%" ""$ !!)!G&$!%""%#%"$ %B $C:! !"D!C!"!#>! D$#"# %B%%"$ DC! !$C%:!" %"%8 !!" %" %% F"! %$!$ " A >!! "%#%"$ "$ : 42 =#%! 45578 "$!%!"42=#%!4557%,%%$!!%C"% $ ! ! " !"%%! &$"" !> D!%G G !!" $"%" """ % B "!#%! "" "%#%"$8 ?%" G& %" D$ @" 4555 &" "! A %?%! "" !$%"%8
""%" !%!?!"$ !?%"G70?$#!%!4550! > "" "! "%#%"$ >%C%B ?%" #%! G ?"!%"!G%" !!"&!6%#%%"$9G ?!"% !B: C """ %"!<8 &, %% % &""!G&?$#!%!4550%>%"%"""%"A"$>""""%#%"$ "$8 ?% F % ! !" ! & #! !B"%&, %&!!#$#"% ,D%"!%G:! G!!"&:C""%"A"$%#%"& %"# ,D%"!%G " G % %C"% ?%B!,C% % % "!B "?!!>&$"$$#G$ !&> !"8
% !%B $ !"%! G !!" " B "!#%! "%#%"$ "$ : 42 =#%! 4557 " $" &> !"% ! G %%""% ?"% !!" " !$%$ " %%G$ A 6%8 " ! %" %G"%&$!"&#%!)8
/0123/4553 67J/736 -8 #G% !$:!!"% %"$"""!#% %71 =#%! 7--- =G& 42 =#%! 4557 !%" A !" "%:! &!6 %#%%"$7!=#%!455505#!%45579!"84- "11 <8
+&C%" !#D $!% B$G" %" : 7! % 4557 !%B$ "G?%!!C!$&%#%%"$??"$ ! &%"%$8??"%??!$"A&$C"%!!"! "%#%"$%#%%"$?$C ,$!"!"%A755 PG%?%$8+&++4555"B .%C0.%#2"!# #! $% %! 0&054 ?!8 "$ A D!%! "!#% 271D!4555G%B"%"A!#0&2J5?!835" 27&25.?!8458!!!!""&%!G&!%"!$%$ &%" %! 25&555 ?!8 ! 8 " %! &%#% % $"$ !!F"$A=""%"!A2J&1.7?!89"B 7%#2<G$"% ="%?%$45P$"$ $!$%"%!03&3-.?!8
" $C! !%B?$$!! =C$G%!""%"%G ++ "%#%"$ % " !$ $"%"%# !" !C $#"% &"%#%"$% "! !"%"!#%G" $C:! " !""" &"! #" 9 * 4J #!% 455J 6 43-/50< !" G&% #%" &""! G& " "$ & : > %%""%!!"8
%! %#%%"$ !$ %! &%#% B"%" A C!$ &%#%%"$772PG !%"A!"%A! !$ ""% !?%8
758 !! ! %% !"%" % $%% 44 "B! 4553 $"%!%"G!!"A!%"A!""%:!&%#%%"$7! =#%! 4555 05 #!% 45578 %%"$ 7&155 ?!8 ! $ A !!"AD!C&%"%$8
% ?$$! 73 $B! 455J %?%" % ?$$! ! &!6 %#%%"$ " "!$ #%C! 7! =%" 4553 94553 4550< !" %?%"%G%!""" !$!%"#" !%B "!9!"8J4J1"37"8 <8 !"%%! !$! !!"%:!"""% !""!&"!%!? !""% & #" !%B$"$!%%A?!%="%G% %#" %"! "! 455 ?!8 " 7&555 ?!8 9!"8 3- 8 7 B% <8 & : !$" " % # !%" 9D8 "8 % %"% "!%"%! !"%# A %?%"% 73 $B! 455J< !" G& $" 455?!8!%AD!C&%"%$8
/0123/4553 673/736
, 2 +* , ) *, ,
34050 .. 6 700 0 8 &#$ 9
50
78 " !"%"!!8
48 $%%44 "B!45538
08 %"G!!"!%"A!""%:!&%#%%"$7!=#%!4555 05#!%45578
28 A!!"%%"$7&155?!8AD!C&%"%$8
J8 "$"455?!8AD!C&%"%$8
38 ?! !"% GQ #" ?!! !! "! !$" !!F" $% 05 =! : "%?%"% !: !%B ?$$! 9+DV%E!D?G%33552 < !#%!!"%:!!%" B%?!$">!"814%?$$!! !%B?$$!7. =% 455J 9 *<H $%! !! %" %%G! % "%? " , !#" !"!%C"!!!""%!H%%" F"! !$ !%B ?$$! ! #% " ! #% $"!%G > %"% &!"8 24 *8 !$" !!F" " %: % !!"%#G$, !#%#"F"!=%"A&#%8 C!??%:! !$%" ,+ $!%
%?! !$"!!F"""%?%$> !"%%%GQAQ??%?$$! !% !C!??
/0123/4553