Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ATAS/1233/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/1233/2007 Generato dall'IA

Property Tax Valuation Appeals and Assessment Challenges

Numero d'incarto ATAS/1233/2007
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Parzialmente accolto (Partially Allowed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The case involves numerous challenges to decisions spanning several years, concerning various property valuations used for taxation. The court addressed multiple appeals, cross-appeals, and motions to reargue regarding the assessments, with the core dispute revolving around the proper determination of fair market value for the subject properties across different assessment years, resulting in a complex history of adjustments and statutory interpretations applied to the valuation methodologies. The court generally upheld the initial factual findings and the application of appropriate appraisal methods as determined by the administrative tribunals and lower courts, finding no reversible error in the established valuations, while clarifying or reaffirming certain procedural or substantive aspects of the tax assessment process relevant to the specific years in dispute.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 68 LTF; Property Tax Valuation Appeals and Assessment Challenges: The court addressed multiple appeals, cross-appeals, and motions to reargue regarding the assessments, with the core dispute revolving around the proper determination of fair market value for the subject properties across different assessment years, resulting in a complex history of adjustments and statutory interpretations applied to the valuation methodologies. The court generally upheld the initial factual findings and the application of appropriate appraisal methods as determined by the administrative tribunals and lower courts, finding no reversible error in the established valuations, while clarifying or reaffirming certain procedural or substantive aspects of the tax assessment process relevant to the specific years in dispute.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
stima fiscale immobiliare valore venale dell'immobile valore litigioso rettifica del valore determinazione del mercato di cui trattasi revisione d'imposta

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in order 16 to rule on the costs of the federal appeal.

Art. 68 LTF

Cited in order 16 to rule on the allocation of costs concerning the respondent.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo



           '())*')++, "'()--')++,

"

 " "#    # 

./ 0 ! , 1./ )++, 



 !" !#$% $ "$  !&"$  '$(  ) *





$

++     & )) ,      $!" -./ 

           ! "# $%  &! !

   ,2015,  

 $"

16 "1.78 &9#$9:") #;  !< #  2/ ! 1.=/6  "$$ !#-" # &$# > #1?$1..=6

26   #$  1..= @"  !!" A  #    !B C %$#;"C$;1...$$'$ D$ $%$"$;6 $ 12$B2441&"@$$%"#$"$$ $%$@ ## @$%$"#; #6

86   B"";" @ !$" ?E  @,!  #$  9 #!#-6

36  $ 84F$2442 "#" !  #$$#E &;; $ &,% $"G,#EH I6

76 $;$ 2.!1=?$12#$!B2442  !" ,$$$ $  !"  "# $ $ 9$C"  !B9 JC # C   # -$J !B 7 $  - ! "#; "$ $'$  #$"  $% $E E  12$B2441 $%JB$$ $$$$%$"6 !"  $  C" C  #$$ #%$ $!!$ $  #$ B$ $  J#?!D!#$# $$$!$&"$$##B  $  #$ A 9:  #    B$   B6  !$%$###;!$!B$;B %B$"!#"%B!#$$6

56  !D! !"  $ #""   ##$ $!"   11 ? 2448 C& - %$ :B$   !B % 9!$$  # &$9C #  "B$ 24486  $$!$ $$  #  )# ; %!:$$;9$$$!$##J-$J"#C "$$  ;;$6  ! # $ $  "9E !"$ # !,%24486$$C#$$J$$#% #-J$$ C# &$ "#!B$K!$K6

/6 ) ! $  &     J!$9  #" " A  :#$  $  8 F$ 24436 @:! C  #! A @:#$  $$- !%$"B! ""!$$9;$% !B$"6 @:! 9C  !!B ;" @ # !$" @$$    @$$$ 9C B?$%B6  $   !B #$C"1/?2443@!"% C " ! ""  :  9!$ !B A %  #$$ #$J 7,)1 $ : #$$J !" 3,7$7,)1$$ 



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

=6 @ ;":#$#-J$CA"" 27?%24476#$B?$% @"$$$B  !! % "% ;"C$ $ J! @ $ 9$$ % B @9 ##$$ "J   BJ $ "#   #  6 @"@# "$ @ " 6)$$C  #"$ #  $B   9" #-J$C !  "$$ !"C6 @:#$  #"  9$ @"$$ "#; "%E $  #$"  $-# "%$$ #BB!$ #"$ #  "E  ;E $ # 1./.6    "" C  #$"  $% "$$ :$$ $ C@ @- %$ #   !$#B? @:#$6

.6 @    "" C $$ :#$ "$$ $# # 9!$" $  $" @%  )% !"  "9  @,% $" G,#EH ) JMI6  &%       %  2 ! 2447 $$ :#$#"$!E$E$$$C$EB;$ #$  -!#$M! "#;  $ C@ % :#$ $ "6

146    . ? 2447  !"   @" $  C"  C$ ;!" # @  !! #$ ##   #$$  !B9 JC #$J3,7,)1$- !:, "#;"$  "$$  $ A $$  9$6  $ $"  :B$   !B # 2448 $  "$"$ # ##$ A @:! #"" $6 $%@"$$#BC@;$$#$ $%



012230244/  ,3015,   C@ :$  $$  $!# $ C@ ;$ $ !J $$ B$$#$$$ %$C#$$#%$: A #$!#$%$" !<$% #$"6 %@% $"# @$%$" :"    "$$ $$ $  !"$  @"$$  $" @"@"$$#B6

116  :#$#-J$C"$";"+#-J$6   ##$  25 #$!B 2447  !"   ;!" &:$ & "#  "#;!?%9B #!B 6%"C&"%$  B $!  ,!D!  $$ #  $!$  #B$" #$   $!$  &9$$ $  !"$  ;;$"  $$ &%$ ?!  & "  !$ &%$ #  $B !! #BE! # 6&B -!#$M! "#; "9!$"$";!"#"$$ &"J &*!$$ C$  N, #$C" # &:#$6 ,   # %"  #  $, "#"$JO&" C$C&"$$#  B !#$$  !" $ " A  "#6 &:#$ & # $$" JO&" &9#$E;;"$%A!C ;;$;$A$!$#$ $ 6"$"#" &$B  & #$$ &-$ "%$  ;$  $ #$B &:#C  $B C $$  %$  !  #- $  ;; "$% A &"9!$ ;!#$M$C $B &J!$" #  !B"6&%"9#%$ 9"#-J$C  -!#$M!  !$$6 $$$   $ $ #$$ C$ !$ # #  : !  :#$ ;;$  % #J-9C#J-C&:#$#" 9$ - !!$;! :#"$ #1..=G+3763I6 $"9  C"C$  &" "$!! !B9 ;"C$$ ;B ?!B !#"9E$##-JC !#  %  C !B$ # K$B!$K &$ # $'"  # !#$$  &"  ,!D!6   $ "$ !! $" &! !#$$C&%$"9E!$%C# !!$ "$!! 9"B$ $$$""#JCC$ %;!6##$ $ &D$ # #$E!$ 9D" #     $%$" C$ G!"9I$$B ;#?&#E, ! !! $ !" 6;&:#$ EC&:$   $  #$ $  B 9C C ?$$  $   % $"  ;!$ " #  #$$6  $ &% C  $B !$;! :$"##$" $% &" C $ $E  % #-JC $$  !$$ &!#$  ;;"$!A#  $#"9E &$ "#B J-9E  % $  9$    #   !$ !"  !$ #6  ;;! C& $ B!$ :9B  &" C&



012230244/  ,7015,   ; # ,!D!  ;;$ " # "$"9  #  $% !$$$  :9  # "9E  $ "# $  % #-J$C "$ $ # !#$$ G " A COI6  ! "%$ " #$$$C#$#J-C6&:#$E% C &" $ $%     #;   ! $ #  9 $!$$:;6

126 )"$B##$;7 "!B2447$A !B9  $B "9""$; G736=I #!$$$  #$"  74L  &$%$" JB$$##$" $%$" #$" E12$B24416 !$$$$"$#$ J9&:" $#17N9&: $%: $&"%$!$ $$ $#$,A,;:6

186  " 1. "!B2447&  ;"$A&" !$; C  #$  % #-J$C  $B !$;! : #$$ &!#9$# &!B $"#-J$C &$"$ & " !#$$!#$$E#$$!$$$"% $$$ A$"% $$ #$ %#J-C$##$"   $%$"  #$" C  9""$ C& #$  9  =&142 ;6 /7 # $A ;;"$%% $"#2442G7.&314;6I $  % % $" G7/&44= ;6 47  &CD$    $$  G))I% C;$3% " $ 14L#$%$" "9EI6  $: &% $"  "  13L "$$ # "C$ ;;$ #% $A$G34L!!!I6

136  "  24 "!B 2447 &   ;" A &" $$ $  !$  C &   #!$  "$ C  #$"  $% "$$$E $%$" #$"$C&!$$"A&"$$ $" &$%$&" JJ &!#6

176 15?%2445!"  $$ C" C#$$#"$$$$$A%$"BC#!$$$ # &;;$  $%:   $ C&  & "$$ "#; ?$"  %$  !$$  P%  % :#$ J!$9C $ #-J$C6

156  84?%2445!#"$"21!2445&";$##$ : : " #"$" $ #"B!$ A  !  P% @:#$ J!$9C $ #-J$C $  ;  A @$  "$A@$ @$ @% $"$EB !$A@$  ! !$6$$B$C@:#$#-J$C  +@# %#B$ !Q@%E$E 9""#!$$$ ;;!$ @ $;$B $;;$$



012230244/  ,5015,   $ $ $$ %  ##$  !"  $$$ C@%  #!E :#$#-J$C ! "#@ 6

1/6  "  ##$  1. ;"% 244/ @   ;!"  " $ $$ $  ;  $ C  !  !$  "$C:#$ +$@C ; $  ##"$ #"$$  # % #B$ $!$ A @:#$     $ : ##$  !" ,$$$ C @##$$ # @""!$ B?$; #!$$$ @"B @##"$  :#$6   !D! "   "" A &"  $ A &$? C6

1=6  $  25 ! 244/ &"  $?$"  $ $$ " $ A & !$ & :#$ # A &$   " C"C; $$! & #;  !D!CC$ &$? C6B$$ $$ C &:#$   + & #  % #B$   C& $ $ $ $$ #  !"  $$$ C # &:#$ 6

1.6  "#  22 ! 244/ @$!"   C" @%  A ?$ A  !$%$  "##$$?$ 6

246 $9#$$; &$? C;$&B?$ &#"  "#" G 012810244/I C  "  A  D$  B  "  $  1. ? 244/ # C &$ ? C  "$" $-"  $ ##" ##$6

216 14$B244/ B "#" "A!#$ #$6 $ ""C$H

K ! "% % 5,/ J  !$6  .*84 ?  # ! #!6;?# ;"A&:$"$$ !6) ?&CC!!A;?;A!!$6! ? $A!$!#"#A!96&#E,! ?9  $""% $   ?:6  15 J ?  # %  ! A &:$"6  $ A  ! % 1=*846 #E !&% #"#"A!9$!9"?$A%6$? ! "% # ; A     6 $;  &!B!!!$B6

 9  #;   ?:  ;; &!#6 # $ ? &?!%;;C$#!%!#$$ ! !$$;$K6



012230244/  ,/015,   $ A &$!"  &$ "" &  &;;  $     #!$6 $"9  ":#$%$H

K - : $ &   #!$ H &   #!$ !# $ &   #!$ %  $$ #; $ $9  $#6& #!$!#&  &"C!$ A$%!#  ;;"$$#6& #!$ %$$#;!# #$#$A $ #;% !$###"# $5A/!6 $$ !B$$9""!$A$9$## $8!6

#$#JA&%C$-# & #!$! #6- "B$$$%#$$:C " $C$!####"K6

 ! $  $  "" A $$   C , #$$   #!$%$$#;$$9$#6

226 )"$"9 "A?96



 #"

16 ;!"!$ A &$6 75 6 1 $6  J6 2    9%  &9$ ?  GI  B $    '$  $ C $$$#"%A@$675 ;" "#$9""  $  5$B2444G IC$$%A ;" "@,% $" 1.?1.7.G I6

)!#"$#?9  @#E$"$B6

26   -$ "$" "#"   ;! $ " #$ #    $ %B%$ $675 6

86  #"$    $ : #$$ E @" 24426  ;$ #$$"$$#$$"A@$"%9  #"$ $ "9 #  #$ #$$       $ ?C@ 81 "!B2448#;$C$ ""?C@A$$ $#  $1?%2443G3E!"%I#;$B"C$ !D!C #  E1?%24486! ;$  %9 E1 ?$2445$"9!$##B#C#"$"$";!"25 !244/6

36 $9#$ $ $A$ @,% $"$  ! &  #; $ 9E!$   % #B$ 



012230244/  ,=015,   :#$ 9$" # @$!" $ # #$E!$    +#-J$6

76 %$ @$62=61 @" $A$$E@$% A 55208L!A !,$@$% A74L!AC$ $@$% A34L!6#1?%2443G3E!"%  I$: @% $"C##$$ /4L! $: 54L!%$ $A$,C$ $6

56 ) @$6 3      $ @% $" $  !$   #$"  9 #"!" #!$   9 " C "$ @ $$$A$"#J-C!$#%$ @;!$"9"$ @ !   @  $6 @$$$ A  $" @$  # A   "$!$$# "$C !Q$'  #$"  $% -$  ;;$   #$"  9  @" GR, ) 9$OSB % %J9TJ1../#6 =I6

%$ ?# $ @% $"  $   $  $ "!C $  !" U  $  "C "!CB?$% @#$";$C@!#$ @"%G + 114  2/7  6 3 147  24/  6 2I6 C@   @$%$"  @"  " "!C ;$ ";$  -     ;    " @ !"  !Q#!$$$ @"%#$"  $%  @$""   $%$" B!$ :9B G + 117  188 6214717= 61I6

$ &% $"$ &#$" 9$C ";      $ $ # ? &J #  $6 5 A =    ! ;$ $6  &$6 = 6 1 $ 8   # C&$ "#$" % $"@#$" 9$$#$C$#"!"#!$  9 "6 $ "#$" #$"  $% $$ #$ $$  #$  @#$$  @"A !# #; ! @$%$" $% C #$ D$ B!$ D$ :9"    $$ #$ "$   $"#J-C!$6 @#$" $% 9 "@$%$" C#$D$:9" #$% @$#; @$ ! @$%$"G$65 I6$"#$"#$" 9$$ !$ @!B @#$ #B$" 9 @"!J"  $%"CB"C$ "$$$ !$"$ @$$$ A  $" #J-C  !$ $ C@ #$ #E  $$!$ $  ! " #$$:9BG$6/ I6

/6 !  $$$ A  $" #-JC C #%$ !!  $$$ #J-C#%C% $" &$6361 %&$6



012230244/  ,.015,   =   $!$,A#$! !$##!$ $, !#-JCC"C%$A ! 6  E#!!  "C & "$$ #-JC ! ;  # !!  ;;$ A # J9#&,% $" !$ #$" 9 C&"#$!#DJ;$#% B%$"U!  C$:9B $D$ "$!"B?$%!$C#B6;$  "$B  $  C !  " #$ !9"  ;!$" !$ :$%$"C!J" $%;;!#$$ #$$ 6 #$ "$!$$ %C$%$"#$B!$D$:9"   6   !$$ &:$ & #$"  9 " #  $$$A$"!$&$ # ";C&":$%$" $%;;$U;$B#$M$ ! &- & !$$C ! A #;$   #$"  $%  #$ #$C!$ # D$ B!$:9" C&$!D!##$B#"$" G +142157U)2441#6223 62B$";"U;6 +12/ 2.= 63;I6

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



012230244/  ,14015,   GR, )J$B9;;  B$;VJ9N$  $9   )O%J9  H )J!O   B$;VJ9N$ )$6  2448 #6 //I6

)  !$$ " A &: & $%$" "$$ & :9"$  -!#$M!  & $$ !BB    E9   A &B &$$$A$"%$ $A #$$ &6  !B $$%9";9$  $  "$ $  !#$!$ B%" &"9$ &$  $  $"$C !$ %9 &B  !     9  %9 $  ;!$ ; #  #$$ $  $$  &!E;$C #$$E "!$$%$B&:#$  C &"9$    J # !9"  %!$ #-J $$ G% (0W0()   ! BJ OXJ (Y# -J   O )JX9N$  H )JXOJ  OJ WJJ;$ 1../ #6 1383 % ";" A  "$  ##;   W ( $ +) U%&!B ?$ +1813.I6

  &9$  $B "#;  -   &B% C   $ !"  G;6 $!!$  00) *  Z*96[ $$ (;N$ #-JJ )$Y9  ,14 (#$  Z+[ 3E! " $ #6 1.1I  C &##  B ;" "    "$$ "#;  $$$  ## #  !B $" #-J$C 9% $ B A  $B !$;! :   ! Q   $  E9 9"" C& !;$$ "$%  %$ # ; &B?$ & 9$"#"G +184875 686861;UR0 )#6$6 #6=1$187I6

=6 #% 9" &% $"& !$$G?9&- IB  !$C&!" "%$!$ &$#"$ %$;6$\J !" $A#$?9!$&"$$  $" $ A  C  C ! $ # C $%$" &" $ A  !$; #B  $%6  $  " !"  $$$  ""!$ $ # "$! C $%:  #$  B!$ :9  &" G + 127  251  6 3 117  183  6 2 113  813  6814717= 61I6  "!" #!$$$9""!$  ##"$ B?$%  6  &!#$$   $$$ C #%$D$;$A& &$9 &B%$#;C $ #$B &D$ ;" #  ""!$ B?$; "  !#$!$  &" # $  $9 G +   #B"  5 ! 2448  /52042I6

 %$  ## "" #  ?#  $ @##"$  #%?9 $$$;$ @:!:#$#%" $##A



012230244/  ,11015,   !$$ $#$$9:!#$$@#$  @:#$ ! $" #  $B    @ :#$ !"9" # @, $  #  ;;  G + 127  871U +   2. $B 2448821048 6861I6

  C   ##$ "$B #  !"  $$$  ?9 #$ $ $ $ !#$  ;$ C  &:#"  !"  $$$ $ 9""!$  $A# #$##$$  $ ;C&$A G +127871 68B0BB$I6

.6  @#E$;; @;;$#J-C$#-JC C?$;" #$ @$!"!P% @:#$J!$9C$ #-J$C6

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

116 %#-JC@$!"@$; "@:#$ + C $C #""!$  $6 $$ :#$ ;" A  #"$ #$D$"$"9$!#C& $#!$  $   B,; "   ?#  G + 127  878  6 8B0BBI #$$C@;  B%$##;  %$9$



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

126 ;; $ $@:$@$#! $ %$D$ :!"   $E "%##" #  B ;" "  !$E  $B !$;! :6  @B  !B $" #-J$C !#$$ #  9%$"  $" $  "  !#$    @#E @:!$$E "$!$#"%$E% $  $B $ ;;  $6  - ! %$"B ! ""  !$$ %D$ A @"%   $E JC  "! B6 # $  $'$##$ @$"9$ !Q!$$  $$ ? %  !6  $$$ "9!$  $ % 



012230244/  ,18015,   ;! @ ;<  #  B  $""#J6 ;$  $$!$ #-J$J"#$C $  %$ #  !E 9  $$!$ !" !$:@:#$@"$$#-JC $#$D$ "" !! $"  "%$ #B  # $J"#$C6   $ $ !$$&:9B$" &;;$ %$" $$ $E% $ $B!$;! :6  "$$ @$!" B#$C;!6

186 $A:!$: @% $"$#@$!" 13L$?$;" 9   #$"9#$$6

) % $"  $ $ ""   ;!$    !#-#2442"  "B$  $A$% 3&7/4;6# ! #  $OE!  $ 7.&314 ;6 #  J;; $ "9!$ # @$!"6

  C   % @%   $  $% # # # "6  %$      ?#   "$!  %   ";"$ :  B$ $  " $$  $$$C  @CD$    $$   G))I G + 125  /5I6   $\J !# $ "#"$$%   $ #%" G% @:9 3I # $A#$""  $2442"$$ 3&77/ ;6 # ! $  73&5=3 #  #  "  $%  34 J # !6 !#$$ ;$C@2442!- $$ ""$$ 31/ J% "$!$$ 7/&44=;6 !$$$ " $ 17L !$$$ &\9 $% $D$D$" A3=&375;6=46

 !#  %  $ % % $"  ##'$  #$  9 1=33L$:C$;;$#% $A$6

136 )#C$ ! & #;6

;!"!$A&$6=61 "% !" &% $" !!$$ $:! " #$$C$"$ $A "$B  #$"  9 A &!" A  %9   A  ;% &9  $ "$$ "$!"  ;$  $$  " &$%$" #BB6  %$ &$6=68$6B ! " #$$!#$ ! &  #; $  $$ #;  ;!$ #;$!$#;$ #!$6 %$ &;;$#$J E ! ! " ;  "$!!$ $A"$B!"%9  A;%&9 #$" 9 &"G +114141 62I6  ;;$  !  " #$$ &$ # "   $ %" A &"J  $$ %!B "  C  $ !  $ A  J9 



012230244/  ,13015,   &,% $" C & :$  ##$ B $  F$ $ $$"#"%B6

176 I :$! @$61/ @" $!$ % #;% $" "$#$" 9#$ $$%!BD$%9 "!"" !E$B6$  "" !!%  $$ #$CB$ ;$  $$$A$"#$ 9 @%24LG +12314=114I6

BI&#E "# !!$ ;$C#$ 9 $$ ,   24L  %$  $$ C  #$" & #$$ $ &##$9$$$%!B!$" $C!  $ #$C  $# $ A  #$"6  ;;$  $ !'$ !#;$!$  ;< !! & %"   +   ##$ &:#$ G#6 17   ##$I6    &  ;!$ #;$;" !Q"$";!"C!$$#6

!#$ $   ""!$  %$ & !$$ C  J  E &! !$#;$;;$6  $$ $A&$ &$!$#"C$?$"6

156  %$ # $ &:!   $ #$ #"$  A  !  P% &$$#;6

I %$ &$634 &" $A&$$#;C  % $"  ;;J: &#;&: $%$" $"6 &% $"    $$ #$ "9 $   !#DJ!$   J: & #; #    $"   &: &$%$"$" &"###B $%6$   "$ $$ J # #J-C  #-JC C $$    #; $ $%$" #B C @" #$ :  ;$   #$$ $ !$%$C !#B&: $%#"" $6 )$ $$; :  J #  # &!#$ C &$'$ #  !#DJ!$  $B $  ?$;$ E  #  #$$  &, % $"G +1132.661I6

BI &$:"# $$$% $%: ;6  !B9JC$  #$J$? &J  &!#B$" A &\9  #  74  &:"$  $ $%:6  "$$  %$ & !$$ C  J:  #; C  $  %$ $  $B!$ $$   & $$$ A  $"6 $ J # $ "9!$D$ ""!!$B EC&!#DJ&" #$ J9! ""A $!$#$ B$#9" # & J $  !J  #  24 !$      6



012230244/  ,17015,   ##$C $#$$#;$" $C$#$#"$ A&$ &$!6

1/6 )&9$ &    #!$    #$ $  $ EC&$!"$ #"A;;$$!$$C,- "9!$ &  !#$# #$ 14 $B244/6"C$%$ &# $6

1=6  %   C #"E     #$!$  !  "  ##$ 1. ;"% 244/ ;!"   C   ;  $ $ "C&;$$$! & #;6 , #!B""; &! &$$#; C & $#$ & #!$6

1.6 $B$$#$!$9  !$" 1&444;6$  "A$$  "#6

246 &"!!$ 244;6$!AJ9 #$A#$"96



^^^



  #"$  " "#    # 

!

 2 3.

16 "%B6

! 3

16 & !$#$!$6

26  " 1.;"%244/ &$!"C&;"$ $$ $A! & #;6

86 ;!##6

36 $$$$#;6



012230244/  ,15015,  

76  $ &99!$ &$!" !$$$B""; &  #!$6

56 &- !$$CB6

/6  ! &$!" A %  $   !$"  1&444 ;6 A $$  #$#$A "#6

=6 &"!!$;:"A244;6$!AJ9 $A 144;6$ &$!"A !D!!$$6

.6 ;!  #$   C@ #%$ ;!  $  #"$ D$   "  84 ? E  $;$ #E  B ;" " G)JXOJ;C55443  I#% !$E  $ #B;!"!$:$6=2 ;" " B;" " 1/ ? 2447 G +IU  !"!   $  C   !$; $ !- #%$#$9$ $ ! $U $ D$  "  B ;" " # % #$  # % "$C :  $  &$6 32  +6  #"$ D$ $  #E  #  $%C"!!!- #% %$D$?$A&%6  9;;E  #" $        *  ) -        "$,?$H   )     

#;! #"$D$$$;":#$C@A@;;;" " #9;;



012230244/