Insurer Successful in Maritime Damage Exclusion Case
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe appellant sought recovery for losses allegedly caused by the appellee's failure to properly secure an insured vessel, leading to damage while moored; the court reasoned that the policy's clear language excluded coverage for damage occurring while the vessel was tied up or moored, as this specific exclusion governed the situation where the vessel was not underway, and therefore, the trial court was correct in granting summary judgment for the insurer based on the express terms of the exclusion clause.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Insurer Successful in Maritime Damage Exclusion Case: The appellant sought recovery for losses allegedly caused by the appellee's failure to properly secure an insured vessel, leading to damage while moored; the court reasoned that the policy's clear language excluded coverage for damage occurring while the vessel was tied up or moored, as this specific exclusion governed the situation where the vessel was not underway, and therefore, the trial court was correct in granting summary judgment for the insurer based on the express terms of the exclusion clause.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThis provision was cited in the dispositive orders regarding the allocation of procedural costs.
Testo completo
&'()*&'+ ,&-'.*&'+
,
,/ , /
01" - % ( 1" '+ !"#$#% &!'() ( "( !*"( +( , -. ( // , , , 01, ( (!" 2345
! " ! # $% %
:$69:
2/,
#; " #<48 =""> * !:( *) (" *() '*// ,, ,?:'@ A '(( !'"!( B * ,: >" " ( ( B !'( #C)$888;* (!'(' !(( D *E *()("'((B48F;
$; *("" "'" ! % (= $88$; >!" * <C)$88%;
%; * @'" "B) '((GH')( '"( *("" ((>" " 5)!= (# "!= $88% ( % ( $# C) $884; 2H " *("" >!" ''( ((( (!!( ' !'( * E *()(" '(( ' "' @#)!=$88%;
5; " 4C($884* ""H*''(BH *"' *(""()' !(!':"((IE" %4 = (" E !( >J =""> ' G'" '> ( K( ) ) @ >!( * ; ((> ((" H* *"(( ( '@ *>> ( *!' ? A ! $885 ( H* )( ' ! L) (( "!2 "'()();=(2E B* B("E ((("H*M ( 'M;* @''!" ' !'( * E *()(" '(( ' @ # ! $885 ((>(("*((( *("">(H @#'(!=$884 *(' !3!;
4; " $8 "!=$884* ) " '((((!'( *E *()("'(( *"';
7; *("" >!" ''( $5 C) $887; @) H E "'("("G((;"E!(>!* H*('= ()B94F '(=$885(H* "'"B("E ! ") ;
9; " 7C$889* C("*''(;
N; *(""'"("'+(. , -(C("4C( $889 ( ( "; E H "' = H 22( ()!(!'*'()"; H'H'" ") ( *) (" ( ' ( ' )( = "; (B*( " 7C$889((H*'!'(
6$7486$889 :%69: E '(( *()(" ' "' ( E" (G *'(" ()" 94F;
<; "' 9'(!=$889* C( ;
#8; 3( ##'(!=$889 = "C("(C("' *("" ( " *// * ,, :
?:'@ A>( *E!( !:( *) (";
##; ,"("E "BCE;
/,
#; >!"!(B*(;47;#(;2;% E)OE( C ?A = ( +( ( H ((('")BO(;47 >" "'(E"" ( 7(=$888? AH(()B >" "'((!'"!(BO:)))( ( ) (" #< ! #<74 ? A; +( "E!( ''( *(;47;$(; ((('")BO(5% ( '(((!'"!(BO:)())( (BO:) (" $4(=#<7N? A;
,!'"('CE O'@("(=;
$; >" "'(E"" ( 7(= $888? A((")E#C)$88%(+(! >( != '( ! ; , C' "E( ''= 2E!( @E ( ( H "(( )E "( *"(( >( H ( 3( ''"" C H!( H "H C H ? / #$9 579 ;##$7#77 ;5=A>(H = "'(3( !" B ' * '" "(( ' GH(' (CH*!!( " !(()(E ? /#$#%77 ;#=A; *'@(:"E' (( H'((!'"!( >" "H(?(;# A;
%; (C(" >! ( " '( ' ( )= ?>;(;47(78 P(;5%;# A;
5; (E'('!'( *E'(('*"' *("" ) "(!( (> G '(( !'"!( >" " ( ( H * E '(( ' :
!3!B48F;
6$7486$889 :569: 4; (;$($(; '")(HO( (G'((!'"!( >" " ' H ( ( B !:( B ( (@ *) (" "' ' ( '" G ) "(!(; !3! (: ' '(( !'"!( ( *(; # ; !(( '(( !'"!( ' B '( "' H G@ ) "(!(?(;%;# A;
G (! O(; % ; 5 "' ( ) "(!( C(>(!"E!! )(3( (";
,*(;%;#(;E ) "(!(!'( ( '( >( ( K( ( *( ; ( ( ( ''= (!!( H* ' " =E( C H B ""!( >('('"( B(""!( )( >(( >(') (' (B!(()'(" EH*'(GE *H*G()("()? /#$# $84 ;5##9$N< ;$A;!3!@E('")' (?(;4;#7(9 A;
7; ,C' *(""'()(('"!'(''(( ')H*(''= ")'!'(H* '(*GE ;G!(H( )*"'(G ()("()(( ( *(( H*>)( ( !'( >!"!( =( '(( !'"!( (( ( =C() ( =C() H ()( !'H( "( * ( ) ( (" *IE >!( E(H *()(" (" *= ) '> (@ != * ()(" ( ' ( !2" () ? /##9#47 ;$##4<% ;%P #<N<';78N ;%P>; "E!( EQRE(E R -6 '; #%#P 6 . -''"!( ()E';#85A;
!3!K (!'((( (K( (*( * ) 2K'(2"(H *"' *" H ( '(( !'"!( *=(( *G ()(" () H * ( ( *GE * *"( ( ()(" ? / ##9 $<# ; ;%=P,$88#';#$9; ;#=A;>>('(" E O"'G ( 3( (" ! S ( ( O(; #78 ; $ (=BO(()= >!?(;#7% A;
''((B* !(( CE *G!*'(GE *(""H*G()("()( "2"( >G H* '( ( >( ')
6$7486$889 :469: =)(";>K *''HB(('"='' ( >!!'(( ( *'@? /##9$<$ ;%A;(@ ">((!!(((B*IE 'B "(( (" B E(H B >!( '> B *()("G"CH*!2" *!'("2"((!'' !E' (H"(""E" )'>? / ##9$<8 ;%P,$88#';#$N ;#=A;) *()("() '(( )>!"!(B*(;%;#(;> 3(' !'( B G ( !( ? / ##9 $<$ ; % ( ">"A;( )2K'(2"(H('O"' H"( '@ " ( #*488>;>>"(G')( O(; %;#(; "(('!'(B G(; )2K'(2"(H(')"E" !@ (HG)"!( 'J?,$88#';#$<A;
H (@ ! ) '(" E !2" *!' / "" H* !'( ) ( B H ( *("" ( ! () (); ( "E >( ' "( * '( *>> !' )( '''" ( *('(!= '22(()?3('="T; < "!=#<<<$6<<A;K *G!@(!((( !2" ()?3(U; <C($88$#N68$P / '=" N(=$88$ NN68#;A; (( C' (( "(" ''" "!!( / '="7#68% $$!$885;
( C' >" "HE'(( (3("= '*("";'((!(">"BC' !(@ ((' / H'C ( "; (( OG!'( CE"' =>" "? #<<$';%5NA HO"' ( OE "(E@ O)( >!( '> '( ' >J('"((K!'(!(E "')G"(B '((,; =>" " ""H!'(( IE ?$$ A ( >( H "'G O)( B (( "'H ' O>( ( (!( ' OH(( =E( (= G 2E !"E ' '(( '" '( B (!' '( ()("@('B((!3()E";C ( " 'G((E'(('"'*K(>!( '('(H!('>J(K('>(=IE? , 9486$885A;)2>G"B48F(G *()("()'=' "'K(B2EH(>(H"((:!3!C(H'" ( = >!( ? , 57N6$885A ( B 48F "E!( * "' K("E!( >(B2E()( "CB!!'( ! B $$ 2 ' ! !( ( ( *"(( (" '!((( *G ()G ((KE B G 2 ' C ? ,
6$7486$889 :769: %9$6$885A; !3! = " :(: ( '(" () '( ' "' 5N '2=@( *K( C! G" *()(" () ="") ) >( ( ( ( (" >E ((( >=!KE ( ' H * *)( ' ( (= ) (; "(" CE" H* ')( ' () !"( ((KE ! '( (= B *(( >! *()(" '( (( () '( G *'2="(!? ,$576$887A;
9; *'@*"@E)= !( '(" (); ( "'" ! ") '@ * ;/( ((> (( H * ' " 7 )!= $887 C(" ! ( !( *( * !:( *) (" ( H (( " "(">!"' = "##'(!=$889? 6547%6$887A;
* "(( @ > " B ( ' *" E 2K'(2"(H ' (B!'B48F;
N; *"(("E!(H*E'(((' "(' "';
!( ' >( H ! B '>( '(" () ( GE= ! E H !E" 22 ( '( B * !$885*'()" ();
!'(B("E >G( *)2K'(2"(H (!'( >( H ' : *G( : * ()(" () GE '" * '(( ( H*'@ E = ) '> ' ("E( !2" *!' *( ' '= B '( * ( IE; ,EB*( *'" * '((!= @) =H '!((B'" (( ();
K((> )H* )( "CB(!'( (E!( " 4C($884'H*)('""!( " " H(!''"!('H*"' *(""((!' *>>( 22 *!';
/ @( "H*)2K'(2"(H'*"' (3( ")( ' !'( ' '(( H = !3! '2 '( 3( " 2( H* 22 ()!( B G()("();
<; (:C(";
6$7486$889 :969:
3,/2 ,/ , /
%
4 1
#; ")=;
% 4
$; C((;
%; (H'" (E((;
5; (H'H((G'((!'"!(>" "'( HO')(>!('"(3( " %8C @ (>( '@ = >" " ?,2VR2>H 7 7885 A') !(@ ('=>!"!(G (; N$ >" " = >" " #9 C $884 ? /AP !"! ( H !(> ( !K ') ( '( E( ( ! (P ( 3( " =>" "')'(')"(HG ( *(;5$ /; '"( 3( ( '@ ' ( )H" !! !K ') )(3(C(B*); E>>@ " ( : T W
'>! '"(3(((>"G'(HOBO>>>" " 'E>>
6$7486$889