Validity of Historical Land Patents
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case primarily concerns the validity of several land patents issued in the late 1800s and early 1900s, challenged by a later claimant asserting superior rights. The court examined the requirements for patent issuance, including proper surveying, compliance with various legislative acts governing land distribution, and the effect of prior claims or reservations. The reasoning emphasized strict adherence to statutory provisions governing land grants, concluding that where the government followed the necessary legal procedures for issuing the patents based on an approved survey, the patents were presumptively valid and effectively transferred title, despite subsequent equitable claims or challenges regarding the initial accuracy of the survey boundary lines or the status of the land at the time of patenting.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 93 LTF; Validity of Historical Land Patents: The court examined the requirements for patent issuance, including proper surveying, compliance with various legislative acts governing land distribution, and the effect of prior claims or reservations. The reasoning emphasized strict adherence to statutory provisions governing land grants, concluding that where the government followed the necessary legal procedures for issuing the patents based on an approved survey, the patents were presumptively valid and effectively transferred title, despite subsequent equitable claims or challenges regarding the initial accuracy of the survey boundary lines or the status of the land at the time of patenting.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in order 1 for imposing the costs of the federal procedure.
Cited in order 1 to declare the appeal inadmissible (procedural ground).
Testo completo
#$%&$#&''( "#)&$#&''%
"
* "*! +!" ! *!+ +
+,-. & )$ /0 &''%
!" #$#!%!$# ##% # &'%() %!%
%#
' ++ , # % ! -./$%01231334536
!"!
,1731,
! 1"
3: ##% % #! ! 3.2; % ## 5! + 3..;5<) =!3.;.%3.;8>%%(#(!#% ' :?%%%%#!)@ !18!?#1881:
1: #% ' $A @,) ' B %#5 ! %% $#) %#C# 3#5?#18811;)!5# #1886 ( %! '5# 4# C#@4# " $ %$ % 5 %! (' D %##$# " %$#?4%!:
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
#% 'CA$ % '#! % ! " J%# $# C#@ $# %# :
0: 32 # 1880 '#! $#!%! $#%% $#4 ')) % '#, 5 %! = > # E F:
2: #$$#% 0 1880 %# @!!# % %%%! ($% % 5 $#$ ) 1883))# %'!%%!$# )!54# $@ # %#5 @ 5C-$%C! %## % ##) ? %# %#,?@ C# (5$ % #%0,2 @@ ? %!# # #$%C )#,$% # % %% $#4 ! % @ # %: '#! $#!% % %# $JC%
76/1671889 ,6731, %#5 # " 388K #! !%# ! $ 6 # 1886 $ %! %#5 $5 % $ J%# ! #! $# # ! % # $#) '!% % $ (!: # !%% !$# ) % # % $ $% % $ % $ ' $ %! )% # # 4# % 5 %! $#) I % ))% # % $# #E F:
9: + ## # %# =G!%? % C$ % #G> 9 1880 '< !%#$C- @ ( 5 % %#! #% % )
5 % % #) # ( @@!# % %% % ! ( " 5: $# 5 '%# ?# $!# # (' < -@#$C ( !% ! '5 % $ $ J%# #! ! # ' #)$% %:
/: # %%# 1/ 1880 %# (! " ' ( 5 $-C%C!#$% ($# 5 %$#4%# :
;: ' %!+#5 ! #!@ =+>5'<$#% ? $ # =#C%@ ( % $-C %# (> '#! ( !%! < ! 1/ B5 # 1889: # #$$#% 2 1889 $$#5! $# ! , ' %# * =#$$#% 11 1889> %# L* =$! ! ! $C- ( % #!!% > % =E F> % @% (! #? %@ # ' %#? !@!!#% ) !?%% %!$%C #C ? # )) $%# % ! % % @?: + + $ %! %#5 ' %!#! !% % %% % 5 %! C? % #$% 5% % 5 %! $%! " %% )% =$#% C#@ )!# #"36M@>:
+# $ $-C %# ( $#% '5 % ?B% 5! %#? ! # %#% '%%% -$%A @! !$# 5)5#' @% !$# B# @)# @! $-C% ( -$%A )5# ' !%% %# $%, %#% ( ) % #?$# %!:'#!$#!% % !@##% %$-C%#:!% %!%#% 5$ ) %$ % @))#?B% 5?$%'%#% : -$%A )5#' @% -##<%)#$# %%'5 % !%! !5 :<$#%5 %%#%%! 5#@%# # !# % % $#%% ?#5! '!@% ' % # #%4# 5@ '? ) % ( $ % !%#% 5 5 % ! ? '< %# 5 #% $-C C@! $ '## 5! '#! + : %% # 4# '<$# % 5 #% )) %! )#N 5 % #)! $#! ' %#$#4% # '<$#% : +# ? '< ( '#!
76/1671889 ,0731, ))# % ' $%C@ $-C %# ( 5 % % $ %! %#5 < @ ?!% %% 4#%%% 5 %!:
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
+# $ % ( ! %#%# $#%% % '<$ (# #%C $!@!: < % %%#%% #%# $ %5%$%!%! (:'@ % %#4 #% % ' $ ) % -$%A 5 % @ $#%%<$ % )% '-5 % %% )% ?B% 5 '%! % %5!: # #!% %$%#!5# ?% # % % ?!!% %$% ?'@%#%!#"'))#%:
#$$#% + ) % !@% !%% ' %#% %!!$C ( 39 B5 # 1889 " %# ( %# 5 % )#! <$#% ( '#! ?!!) % ' 5 $#4 $-C@ #5 =$ $%?#1882>%('))# %'!%%!$# ) $#%%'<$!# %%#$C = > % $#?4 % (: 3../ $% % 5 % !%! $# !%%#%#! 5 %$$#!%!$ 5$-C %# = %#%C!#$ ?#45>3...:
.: #! 63 1889' #B%!$#%% :
38: # % 2 B % 1889 '#! )#! $$ % %# % ! % " '%# ' #% $#) ('" '% ' ,#%' 5 %!:?%%%!5#$#?%#$$#% + 2 1889 =( % '< % ' !%% !$# ) !54# #$% 5%'-#%#$%%#% (>% )$# (@#5 %!
76/1671889 ,2731, !%%'5 %$$J%# !5 #'<$#% # J ' $ ? %!$#'!5(#@#5!5 %5 %!%!5 % #! : '$$% '% $#!5 " % !@# ' %%%% ! ! %# %% %# C) ( " %% $# 5 % #%# % ## %! ! -@ % @#% G!%? %C$ % #G1; 1889:
$#% - %%% ( $% % % #!@ 4#% 5 %% %% $ B5 #3..;$#$#?4% (%$-C@ ( !<5 !54#? $-'# @ :$#! ($ $% % ?!!) % " 5 ' $-C%C!#$ #!@ 4# # '!%% < < % $C!4 #! : #$# %# %% 5 % !%! )) # !5!# %!%#% %' $#%!( $-C@ (:+ '#!$#!% %$#% #!%%!$# )!54# = 38*61,3>I-#%#$%,%#% (C# (!54#= 38 *06,3> 5# ) % #? $# %! $#4 <$!# %%#$C= 38*1,8>: #%#$$#%+2 1889%# %%!($#?4 !%#$%,%#% ('5 % $ !%! $# !#% 5# ??% # ! '!5 %%$#$#"-#:$% %!$#5 %))%!#!% )) %!"!5(#5 <%#J? $-:
# )) %! $#% % % %%% %#, (! #$# '% 5 %! J %-$ '% 5 %! =%#5 % < % # 'C#@# > # ( #C% '@@#5% %#? $-C@ ( !%% $#%% #$# % : % 5 %! #!@ 4# $# % ! $#%% # $ %C!#$% (: $#$ % !5% $!% # $# %# L $-C %# $! % %# $%,%#% ( $#4 !$#%% -C %# G!%? % C$ % #G ) '!5# @#! C $ $-C@ ( ! < !( $%,%#% (%%-$'% 5 %!($% %$## %#$##:
33: #! #$$ % 31$%?#1889' %! 63 1889 % % ( !!% !# % #% ) % %# 1; 1889 $#%% %$ ) #$ % #O'<$#%5 %!B"%%%!!$C (5$#% #'<'#!:
31: # % $%! 36 %?# 1889 '#! # ? % # = ,$#4P # ?> $# ' %#! # # &:"'%# $#%% '# 5 %!)# #%' 5 %!$#% %'#%$#) :#!?% ##%#( ' % %# %% %! %#,<$#% $-C %# (:
76/1671889 ,9731, ?%%%! '<$#% +2 1889 % ) ( ! %# %% %#% ? #! !% % F =! # ## $: 1 Q 2>: @#5 %! !%% %! '5 % $ $ J%# !5 # '<$#% # J ' $ ? %! $# '!5(# @#5 !5 ? : %% # '<$#% !% % $4%#(%# %!5 !% %E F =! # $: 6 Q 33>: + ##% $#% 5 % !@% !#! ( '<$#% $#!% % %% '$$#! % $%C@ ) % 38:) C % %$5 #%#5 #"%$$#% ) 'J%#$! %!5 %#$#?4E)C?MF!% )%#$%%#% (% !% % ))%!: %) ) '!5 %# '<# ' % 5 %! #!$!% % 5 % %="' %#'5# 4#C#@# ?# 45%<#!>( )# %('$ ##!%% ) % #5 5#4))#$! % %#%$#) :
36: $#!5 1 5?# 1889 ' #B% ## #$% 5% % ! #$$ % 31$%?#1889: '$$ $ % %)) #%(+'!% %!B"D%$#! # '$$#! % $-C %# %# %% ##% $ (' 5 % (! #$$#%2 1889# $#( @% #% $# %# $5 % J%# $# !#% : %# '#! '5 % $# % $ 4 ! 5 ( B% ) % %#% $!% #'$4:
30: ' %#% '%#% 4#' 5 %!$%5% # ? !#!5!!(%#'!% %$% % #' $A *L $! % $-C %# % (' 5 % $# # !%! %# ! " $#% (# ! !$% $#4 + $# % !$#%% 5 %!%'% 105?#1889:+! %5 %#( %!! !$% !% % !# C? %! " ))%# <$#% $-C %# ( 5 < (I %%) " 5 % 5 % J%# %# @! $# $-C %# #$? $# # $ 5# B# ( =): ## # %# 11 B5 # 188/ (! < $#% 1 )!5# # 188/>:
32: +#!%!@#!"B@#:
76/1671889 ,/731, ! "
3: @5 #'#@ % B #=>!%! ) !% % %!4 3#D%1886 # ?%# $!2B@ %$#! %%5 ,$#! %2$$!%%39B@#=#%:3%: #%29 >:
+ %"'% '!% 39B@#$# # ?)!!# 1/B5 #1880= *368389># @5 $%!36)!5# # $ % %# % ##@%$#%%% # ?%# !@##"%# B@% % #'%%%'!% 5<B@#: # ?)!!#B@!(%%% !% % $ #% % )# ##H% # % )!!# = * 368 166 : 6:0>:
# # '?B% ## ##% % " )!!# # R#, 5 %! 3. B 3.2. = > #% ( # ? ! % %!# % $!%%$#%%#'$4=):#%:29:3%:C:1>:
1: % %#! 5 @# 3# B5 # 1886 %#H% ) % !@ % 5 %% # % R#, 5 %!: $ % 5 %$#%$# $$$ ?#4@# %5 @#%O ) % B# (% !%# % % $# % % B@ # )$# $$#$$#! ##R!%%) %#! !" % !%# % ! # $$ % % @ = * 31. 0 : 3:1I 39. : 3 I 629 : 3 % ##J% %!>: $# $ # % %#%$# % '< # ? ,)! ! # $$ % 31 $%?# 1889 " 4# 5 $ % % = *3686601 :1:1%1:6>:
6: %#B%!)#%! ##%#5?5#%#%:29% :
0: % @$#%#R!5% R 5 %!##%%$#% ## # %"##%$#) #$% 5%" ,#% R#, 5 %!:
2: %#!$%! 5 %!R $ %!@ %%$#% $#!!$#% @ #! #!%% R ) # %! @! % R R % =#%: ; : 3 >: % #!$%! $ %! @ %% % R? R $#% $ ? %! @ R#! # #C! %#5 !( ?#!( %# !#% %% % #!%R%% %
76/1671889 ,;731, " %! $C- ( % % (R $# % $#4 %# %% % ##!$%% < @ ?=#%:/ >:
9: %% %"%!$-C ($5%%% %$C- (%#H# 5 %! R#%: 0 : 3 5 R#%:; : 4# $ !( R !%% $-C ( ) $ ))% " $## C#@ $# R#, 5 %! % $ %!@ (R#!$## %$JC#) %$#5 ? 5%!I # ( % < @ ? % J%# !%# ! ?B% 5% ( $ ? = * 381 392I + 1883 $: 110 : 1? % #!)!#I): *31/1.; :0 ) >:
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
+ %% ! " R<# R % 5 %! #!%% R <@!#% -$%A R %% ?? # #4@ # # "
76/1671889 ,.731, R?R%% %"%!5#%# %"$#%% R#: ?# %% 5 @!) @#% #%##!# % % $#%% ?#5! R!@% R % # % #%!# % ( #% 5@ R? @# 5#@ %# )#% )# $# $% % % ##%% R4) %($ %%#4!%#% 5 % ?R<$#% ( R!@% # C $ @#! 5 #% $-C %% =5 # U$$7V 7U $% #?# C TW C UX#$# -C T +CW # @M % P+CW T# C T CVCC# )%3../$: 3060 5 #!)!# " !% $$#) V M# % *#%#I 5 # # R?B% *3630. :3:1>:
/: #$5 ##@#!R 5 %!R %#% =B@R - ##> ? % ( ! !5%% R%# $! % 5% )# #:%YC! %"$#%#B@% #R!%%%!%" (#(#%$#(% 5 %!R#! % $?%#5 #:%#!! % %%!!% % $# !%# # ( %#5< $% # # ?% < @# R#!= *312193 :0>:
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
'%# %! %#% 5 %%%#')) ) %!%# %'%,", # %% #%%!$'$$ % #4@# %= *33/ 193 :6?$:196>: ' %#% %%'## %#% $!% # #( !@% $#% % !!% ##%%
76/1671889 ,38731, # #( 4#% % #: $#% # % %%# Z5# <$#% #(' $$#H%! ## ) #$%! <= *33/ 1;1 :0$:1;6>:
% B@ % $ ' #@ ?#%! C < $#5 (' % %##: %% ?#%! % # # '? @% " C#@ '!%? # ) % !%# % $# ' % @ =#%: 93 %: >: +'@ %'<$#% ! $# $$ ? %! %%%# ,J<$#% %#5-#"' %#% $#('%% Z5#<$#% = * /D%1886929781 :6:6I 3..6$:369>:
.: '?! '?#5# ( )#% #N ! %5 %#R!% %$C? %!" @##$$#% +1; 18895% %#G$-C %#*LG%(''!% %# $ 5%@ )#% %# ! " %#5 # ! !$% $#4+:'%%%) $! #'-# $#%!B# ( ##!@# %!,( $#!B@%$$!%$#) %% $#% ,4#(5#$#?%'<$#% %%% )NJ%#! !)#!%< !#% 5%:
'$4#$$#%+1; 1889%%# =C) ( " %% $# 5 % #%# % ## G!%? % C$ % #G $# # ! $! ! P ): # $# ##% 4#' 3../ [30$:311>%%# % #(%< @% %#$%,%#% ( %'!%%!$# )!54##$% 5%' $ %!%#5 $% % % #$ %% $#$$#! ## %<$#%% % @ :5 %!" !%# ##?B% )#4#($#?4 ! %# $%,%#% ( '5 % $ !%! $# !#% '<$#% % 5# ??% # ! '!5 %% $#$# " -# % )) %! !# !$#5! $# $% % " !5(#
5 <%#J? $-%#'% %!" )) ##%#<$ % (%!!%'!% %$$% ? ) # $ % +=):5 +0$%?#1889>:
# <$#% % ,J %%! ( $% % '<$# % 5 E ! F:$ 4#" ##%, % $ %%%# $#% # '? ! '!5 %% $#% '<$#% !: ##H% % '%#% %!!$C ( %# "%#% !'<$#% +=$: />'$!%! (!"##%5%! (#!63 18895 % # %'J%# % ( %%! ?% 5#$#?%=): * 36 D%1881 980783 :6>: 'B%
76/1671889 ,33731, (%#L*'%$$#%$$! !#C%@ ! $C- ( % #!!% # ( % ' $#% % !@%#<$#% #C%@ (
$$#H% %# ( ! + '% < ! ( %#4 $#) % # %4# B# $#% #% ) #%4# 5 % R %#? %)# #< =): , : 9>: <, % ))% !!#! $ $ !5$$% #% ?# R!!% ( $5 % % %# %% R $ % R <@!#% -$%A:) %$# # %# % #'$$ (## %4#!5$$! % 4# %#? %)# #< $# $$#! # #%4# 5 % $ % # $% % # ( <$#% % $#!?%"'?'%%#?'$4:
% )#%%%#(#$$#%+1; 1889 !%? $# # " ' ' %% ( % # % )) % % 5! ? (R % ) % $ < #!( % B# $#% $#%%% #H%#$ 5#$#?%= *312621 : 6311398 :3%#!)!#>:
$$#H% ( ) % % (R ##%% # ! % $%%(R $#%%%$$##5?%#(% # % % @ :R $#5-#"R)) % !$#(R $4%R %#% %# %5! :
%%) 5 #) #<$#% ? $ #"#C%@ %"$! %-#%#$%,%#% (=$#<$%# L $-C %# < G!%? % C$ % #G> ) '!5# $#% # @#! ' $ %! ##% ( %-$ '% 5 %! ( , $## %#<##!C!%$#4'%# #! %#!$%% $#) 5 %"! ##$ %!%#5 % 5 %!#!$!% % 5=): * 1;D%188331;783 :6I * ; B %18806;8786 :0:1>:
38: ##%( ?% %$#% %@ # %"!$=#%:93 %:@ >I) <!'$4"*#:3'888:,:
76/1671889 ,31731, + "1 "*! +!" ! *!+ +
/-
3: !##5?##I
/
1: '%$#% %I
6: ! ' 63 %31$%?#1889I
0: 5 % )) $# %#% $!% # !#%%5! I
2: %(' '%$$#N)# B% I
9: %(')) % !5##"##%*#:3'888:,"% %#!$I
/: )# $#% (' $5% )## ## %# $#!% ##J% ! 68 B# 4 % ) % $#4 # ? )!!# =+CW T#C)( 99880 >$#5 ##% 4## % $? )#!%<#%:;1 )!!## # ?)!!#3/ B 1882 = *>I ! # ## % (# % ) % -$#5%$#%# @%###%% #I % J%# #! # ? )!!# $# 5 $% $# 5 !%# ( < % R#%: 01 *: $#!% ##J% % $ 4 $ ##% 5(!-$#5 5%J%#B %"R5 : @#)) 4# #! %$$!% &\ ] , $ )#$#!%##J%%% ) !<$#% ('"')) )!!# # $#@#))
76/1671889