Filing Requirement Certification Dispute
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case concerns a dispute over the application of a statutory requirement that certain administrative filings be accompanied by a mandatory affidavit or statement, where the parties disagreed on whether the filing itself needed to be signed or if the accompanying statement was sufficient. The court reasoned that the relevant statute required the accompanying document to contain the certification, not the primary filing to which it referred, and thus found that the filing was properly executed because the required statement, which included the necessary certification, was attached, affirming the lower court's decision.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Filing Requirement Certification Dispute: The court reasoned that the relevant statute required the accompanying document to contain the certification, not the primary filing to which it referred, and thus found that the filing was properly executed because the required statement, which included the necessary certification, was attached, affirming the lower court's decision.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court ordered the appellant to pay the costs of the proceedings.
Testo completo
#$%&'#(&&% )#*(&#(&&'
++)
, )+-, ) ,+ -
. / $& 01 (&&'
!" #$%& $$% !% '!%(%$
%$
)) ' + $ % ! ,-.
!"
+4/.+
2 5 677 % 6$+ & %! 8 +#$9: ; $7! 6%$ ' $% ' & %! " #$ ! < #%=$4221% 75 '>= + # $77%! #$ *$& ! $!? 8*; #$!% # '%% % " %! & %$#% 5%#,@ %$ 5A
6$! $#$!%! #$ %$B%! $$ %$ %% ! %C%=$4221%"6% ! 56" 5'>#$% #,@ %$ 5%$ %$!A
!$ %$ #!% $ D. &=$ 4221 $$% # %! %$& %% # 44 B 4224 " 5' >#$% = + # $ %$!7 !%$ $# %!%$& A
' #$ % $##$% !%= 42 %=$ 4221 #$ $ ! @77 5 % ! %$ *$& $@%? EF# %> &$ % $9&8E;5% ?% 5! $& +=$@ ? ?@ = %? ?@ % !%% !#$ 7 #$%% 5'$% 7 %!%= #$$ #,@ %$)E@7 5#$9$& #,@ %$ E>%$5 77$ # 5%$ ' ,$ $> @$ 5 # 5! ' !%% !#$ 7!&9$A
$!# DD !=$ 4221 6 #$9 & $ # 9 *#$ %! A
$ % #$ $ = ! % 4D $ 422. $ #! % )E #,@ %$ % #,@%@!$# 7 $! 5 #% %!% % & # &=$4220$#$?$!#$ %% #,@ %$ % % 5' 77$ ' !# !#$ 7 !&9$$! %%"%%$ %%! %> %$!A
$ 6 #$% #$ 5 & @ #$% #$ %! A
#$ $ 4< &$ 422. $ = G&$ >#$% #,@ %$ 5%$@%? 5A
' %! " % 77% $ #! % )E #,@ %$ % #,@%@!$# % $%$ ) #! % )E ! %$% % $@%? A
/0123/4221 +0/.+ $##$% $% !4<B %422.$#! ?% %$=%@, 5$? 5!#$ 78@ 77$)21H04 D2; % %$= '@$ & $%!$ % 5 !#$ & I " 77% ! ?!!$8@ 77$4-0H30*;?$!,#$! % 57 = % %!!#$ %$#$#%$? 5A
' %$ $% ?% =$#% 8# = $$! #$$& % D4?%$ %7 5! #$$ 7$ #,%#! @,##$%! ! @,#J ! $ & % ,$ ? 5;'=$@,#@?%# = 7 %A
%% #,@ 5 #% % $! % 7% ?= %! % %!$ " '77$% #@, 5 $% % $!%% 7 % = ? 5 % '> !%! '$ ? #,@ 5 5 $!% #$==% %% ? $ ' # %!" 7 $7 5% %%$ %'% #% !?% & # % '& $A
'>#$% 5!5%$=#,@ %$ 5 7# %!%$& %% 9$ !?9$ " & $ 42 K & $ 5 %% #$! % % % 5%$ $ $%%$ $ $! %"'77$%"$ D22K# #%=$4224A
%% # %!%$& %$!&$ =%5'#$9$$% 7%$% 5 % & %!$% &%$ =%> ? ="D22K'% & %!%!$ $ %%%$% & %!A
# %! %$& #% L%$ ! $! #$ $ ! 5 % #$ $ A
'>#$% ?5' ##$%'@ % $ 5'>#% %% &% ?% #!% $5' %$?%#!%$= = ? 5% $$ ?$7%$#%@? 5# '%$#$$$! %!?$% #,@ #%F%5'$!#%% #$7 A
' % D. %=$ 422. $ $! $ = #!%$##$%'>#$% #,@ %$ 5>%$5$=' %% ?%$%!$? 77%! #$ $ % ' ?%$!# B %>#%@? !& = 5 ?$!,#%#$7 %%'#?$'=$#% @$ 5 % %$=% 5%#,@ 5!&5!$##$%'>#$% A
'%$'>#$% 5!$!%%'#,?$#@ 77%!#$ $ E $? @M * * % $$% %$9 & 5 %!A
/0123/4221 +</.+ '>#$% ># 5 5' % $% !% ? =%$% $? 5 5 !% '= >#$% A
$##$% '>#$% !#! 0 !=$ 422. $ ) $% ?% %$= %7$ $> #$! % 5' '& % # '># % % 5># %!$ %#$'$!A
# %&% 5 ',& % %% #@, 55' !$ % # %!%$& D22K#$!%# 4224%5# %!%$& % D22K# ?&$%# D$%=$422.A
$$% !$ %$ D< B& $ 4223 $!79$ " '>#$% $ % % % !# " '%$ ' $% % 9$ ' & %! 9 D$ B 4220 $% ' $!& 422- & %$ %% #$#!#$'>#$%#% = $"?!$ A
' $##$%'>#$% ** $A
!$ %$D<B& $4223 $!79$"'& ** $ DD B& $ 4223 5 & % '%%$ 5 '$! #$!% %% # %!%$& %%#$%$=%@, 5$? 5I" =$#% & % 5'!%%=%#%= !#$' %%A
!$ %$ % !%! 5! > #$% % D3 B& $ 4223 % ?$!"B?$A
57$!%"'$%HC1HD%H@H4 ?& $'$? % B $8; $ =%$ (% % 5%%% #$!&"6$% C1 7!!$$#$% ?!!$$ %$ 1%=$42228 ;5 %$% &" 7!!$ $ 6$+ & %! D- B D-C- 8 ; $% 5 #!%#$B?$6#9%!%= A
$$ %$B%!7$ %! #$$ %%$&= 8$%HC1%12 ;A
'$%H < H D ' & %! 8$%H 3 ; #% $!%$ ' 7 $ %! ?! %' ' %A
'%$!#%!$&95'%#$%$%?$& %!#$#$"&$ $ $ %>#$%% %$% !$% 8$%H<H4 ;A
% %L%$!%$ !=B% &%'#$9'!%%%!A7%$ >%$ 7$% % '% # ' #$%A 5' !# #$% $ % "
/0123/4221 +C/.+ 5!%!#$!%! "#$% $5#$%% !%! $5 %N ##! $%&%O'$!##$ #$ #$ 9$ 7 5 '%% % " %! #% &$ $ $ % " #$%% '$ 8 ) D41 - H 4= D12 H 0 DD3 34 H 0 % $!7!$;A
'> %$ '$%H 3 H D % 0 % $!#%! & %! 6 # %! ? %%#$% 5 %#$!!#$%?$!A
'% $!#%! # %! %$& %% #$% %% #$% 6#% % 6$!"# $#$7 6% & %!%$& 5 #%L%$ $ =%L%$> ?! %%#$%$!%%!#@, 5% 5' 6 # %!%$& ?$!6% & %!5 #%L%$> ?! #% $&$ 6 %$ #$7 6 %$ 6% & %! 8$%H 1 ;A 5'% $!#%! # %! ? %% % 6= 6 #$% # = %!? 6$!$$@!%$& !5 =$!5 %$ !$% %% % $!%6%% %"%!#@, 5% %56#$ %#$9%$ %%%$$!#%% > ? =8$%H. ;A
#$#& $$?$!' & %!' %$% 8B?' , $$;= %5'! !&%%'%$#! % &% 7$ $A5%P@! %"#$%$B?%$'!%% %!%" 5$5$%#$5% & %!'$!% #= %$& $A 5' %$ ! ! % %% !!% % #$ !%$ $5%$&>%$ =%> ? =#$%'$!8 )D4C 41D H<DDCD0< H4DD<0D< H0D2CDC3 HD;A
' '#9 $!% '>#$% $% ! $ $! #$ $ = ! 5 $$% #$!% %=% %% %"%!5 '#L@%%%$& $"D22K%%% & %! #$7 A
%% >#$% >%$L% !% ! $# % %% % #! #$ B$ #$#$& $%%$ =$# &$#$=%A
#$% %@!$!" A
'? %$ %"$%$&' & %! %%O + #$ 7$!% " '$%H 4- H D % 9 5 '$! #$!% # %!? $=<2#$% 95' #$!%! , # %!%$& <2#$% #%! %$$#% %= # %F% D$ B$ 5 % >+@ % 9 &$ $'$!8$%H4-H4 A )D41- H4=%$!7!$;A
/0123/4221 +1/.+ '>#$%' # %!%$& # #%=$4224'%$$ %#A
# 9 $$$%%$$L%%$& %%# 44 B 4224 '=$ $ ' % $& " %$& 4D B 4224 # # D$%=$4224$ # % %%$#%@? $& #$ %A
'!5$$%5 !#!#$%% % 44 %=$ 4220 $ % " $% % 9$ ' & %! # B 4220 7$!%>$%H43HD%4-HD%H= A
' ##$% $ " ' 7 >$ %$ #$ $!& & %$ %% #$#! #$ '>#$% #% = $ " ?!$ % #$%%$ " $$%$&$$# %!%$& A
$$% $#$!%! #$ &% =% % ? $% 5' $ %" %!"% %$!#5 $ =7 >'#9"D'C227$H8$%H 1D%H? ;A
7$!% " '$%H 1- H D= & ?$ # D$ B % 4221 !%D'2227$H% "@$?' 5 =A
7$ >#$% % !"@$?'%%A
+ ")-3 )+-, ) ,+ -
2
DH !$$$$&=H
2
4H '%%! ' <#%=$4221H
0H %5$ %"$%% 9$' & %!# B 4220A
<H ' "#,$"$$%%%D'C227$H"% %$' %! !#H
/0123/4221 +./.+ CH %!%D'2227$H"@$?' H
1H 7$ >#$% "@$?'%%H
.H 7$ #$% 56 #&% 7$$ $$ %$ #$!% $$L% ! 02 B$ 9 % 7 % #$9 $ = 7!!$ 8*@Q M$@75 1122< ;#$& $$% 9$$ % #= 7$!%>$%H34 7!!$$ $ =7!!$D. B 422C 8 );A ! $ $$ % 5$ % 7 % ,#$&%#$%$ ?%$$$%% $A % L%$ $! $ = 7!!$ #$ & #% #$ & !%$ 5 > % '$%H <4 )H #$!% $$L% % # 9 # $$% &5!,#$& &%L%$B %"'& H ?$77 9$ #$! % = *
# 7$#$!%$$L%%% 7 !>#$% 56"677 7!!$ $ #$?$77
/0123/4221