Indemnity Agreement Scope in Product Liability Dispute
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case concerned a dispute over the scope of an indemnity agreement related to product liability claims, where one party sought coverage for a judgment and related expenses stemming from defects in products manufactured by the other. The court reasoned that the indemnity clause, which broadly covered all claims arising out of the manufacturing and sale of the products, was intended to protect the indemnitee from liability flowing from the indemnitor's operational activities, including the resulting judgments and associated costs, regardless of whether specific fault was determined outside the scope of the indemnity's initial triggers.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Indemnity Agreement Scope in Product Liability Dispute: The court reasoned that the indemnity clause, which broadly covered all claims arising out of the manufacturing and sale of the products, was intended to protect the indemnitee from liability flowing from the indemnitor's operational activities, including the resulting judgments and associated costs, regardless of whether specific fault was determined outside the scope of the indemnity's initial triggers.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe costs of the federal appeal are imposed on the appellant because the appeal was unsuccessful.
Testo completo
&'()*&+))( &'+&+)),
! "! # ! #
'- ./ % ( 01 +)),
2 3333333333 ! """""""""" #!$%%% # &% '( ) *+ $% !$ &, &! - # #. % % #!$%%
!
# 4 #!$%%% /$% # % %$ !% '( )
!"# $%
4 (03 4
5
'5 6 7 """""""""" 8 +% '338 % # %!$% ('5 * # %4$#% 9 ! - !:%; !% # !% %% . ! #%+ !$$ %5
(5 """""""""" $% :7% # $ $#% # -4 %+%#% <%4* = </>%! /%= ) !$ # ' ! !: '3385 !!; %! 7 4#) # # ) . """""""""" % -?; # #@ !% +% '3335 - ;$ A #$# +% ) % /; # $ #-;! /%5
B5 7 # />%! /% # &#$ """""""""" #-;! /% # &#$ &"""""""""" ! # ) %4$#%5
15 ! ! """""""""" $#%4 % .% +% % #@ % $ % !; 4%5
C5 +% ) # $% ! """""""""" $#%4!% # %4 $#% !%# . D """""""""" +! %! !$ ! ! #%;! % %$ %! # />%! /% ! % .- % E %! ) /; # %4$#%5 !;!#% # % %! % - % /; ! %4$#% ! -!#! %! # - # !% < 9=5 $!;!%$ !%# F !$$ D !$ G % # % $ !% G5
H5 %4$#% #* ! 7 # # /; 7 # />%! /% #-;! /%5 - !7%$ #%%! # '3 #$: (22B % #%%! !!% %! # ' A% (2215
%4$#% - 7!# !%! # ! $#%4!% ! """""""""" .% %$ #- .- % $ />%! / %. -%$! /I 7 #- .- % $ #-;! /% !% E % /; . # #- /!!;% $%!: ) $!> $ .% - %% %% . ! :% # $#% >/!!; # $ # #% % # JF% @ %+% % # *+ # # 'C A% (222 ! . />%! /% !% $%! ) ! ?; ! D $% ! # . 4% % 7% # :% %$% !%+ G5
%4$#% ;$ . . %! # -!:%; %! # % /; # />%! /% 7% -!:A #- @$ !$$%%! % % < !% %! % # />%! /% K 9 %=5 $$: # !$$%%! ! %+ ) !%! .-% -> +% % # !%+
0'1230(221
4 B03 4
% /; # /%5 9! @ D % % !:*$ %@ +% ) , % $ % ! ) 7% %#%.5 !$$%%! % % . % * A %7% -% %! # /%77 8B'' ! $%5 !. #!%+ E $:! - %+ !% %! %7% 8B2' G <75 #%%! # !$$%%! % % # 8 ! !: (22(=5
85 """""""""" % A ! ! #%%! !!% %! C A% (2215 9-;% # % /; # % $ # />%! /% #* ' A+% (22( @4% !%; . ! $% # """""""""" * #%77 !.- % # />%! /% ! !.- %+5 %% 7% . - %; # !#%% # +% ;#$ $%! #-;! /%5 ! #* ! ) . !% !#! @ % $#% 7% # # $% -%%# # # />%! /% #-;! /% # """"""""""5
L5 ! # 8 $: (221 %4$#% . ! - 5 B( # !% 7# -4$#% <%4* &= %! #!%+ E 77% !% !!$%.5 9 7 @ ! # ! """""""""" # $#% # JF% @ %+% % ;+!% ! A # !5
35 +% ) # $% !% ! @ !% ! % # !%! #$# -#% %! # $#% % <75 % # L ! !: (221=5
'25 # 'H !+$: (221 ! ! """""""""" # M
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
0'1230(221
4 103 4
'B5 ! # -#% # !$ %! ! # % # 'H !+$: (221 ! ) !+ 77%$ . 7 +% :!% # % $ . #% .- +% E -+% !;5
'15 9 .!% ;# ) A;5
#
'5 !% ;+!% -!;% %! A#%%% <= $!#%7% % % #* ' !N (22B %: ! # !% !$! # C A; #! %# +%4%# C 'H A; < 5 ' 5 CH =5
9% ) - %! # - %! # 'H A; %: 7# (8 A+% (221 < P 'B2 '2H= # !% ;+!% #! 'B 7+% #%!% %! % !% ; $ %: ! # !% # %; ) !% A; % % # - # - %! # !+@ A; 5
(5 !7!$$ ) 6 5 CH 5 ' 5 /5 1 %: ! # !% !, % %. # ! %! + ) - % CH .% ! %+ ) !% 7# -4$#% # 'L $ '3315 9 !$ ! A; # #-* %% :%5
B5 !% 7# % ; # #!% # !% # H ! !: (222 < = +%; ' A+% (22B , $!#%7% %! # !$: #%!% %! ; # #!$% # !%5 9 $ % !% # +!% . #!% 6%. #!% E / ) $%* # %% ! . *; %: ! +%; $!$ !Q 7% A%#%.$ # $% ! !#% < P '(8 1H8 !%#5 ' '(H 'BH !%#5 1: 7=5 +/ .% ! !# ) #7 # *; % !% ! % !+ #!% 6%. + #* A! # ! +%; < P ''8 3B !%#5 H: ''( BH2 !%#5 1R & '33L S B8 5 B'H !%#5 B:=5 6 !.!% !# # ' A+% (22B ! % !#% * # #+ %: ! !$ $ %* #6 !% ! ;% !+ *; # !# ! # #%!% %! # !# ! # #%77 !% % $!#%7% 5
15 ! % A $ % +: < % CH H2 =5
0'1230(221
4 C03 4
C5 %4$#% 7 # # /; % $ # />%! /% )
!$ # ' A+% (22( % $ #-;! /%5
9! - 5 C # -!#! %! # - !:%; !% # !% # $#% # (C $: '33C <%4* 9= %! %+ # />%! / # 5 1H 18 # -!#! -4$#% < &= ! % /; !.- ! 7!% % %! $#% <T=5
- # /; % %! $#% !N # 7 # %!# # !% $!% #% % %!5 !+ % %! $#% % ! % /; #- ;# !$: # 5 ! . * % $ .%+ ) BH %4% ! % ) E % /; $#% % #!% # ! $#%4!% # - % $ !!% %! #N$ $! %+5 $#%4!% !! # !%+ ! ! /% @ 7% # - %#%. # . $55 9! - 5 H 9 %! 7!% % %! $#% ;! / !;% %! #-;! /% # 5 1H 1L C( & ! % /; # $ !QM
5 ! ) - #-77 %! !$ %. ;? ) $%! %! # 7! %! !! - !!$% # -!$%$ # !#%% # +% !
:5 ! 77 # # #- % $ >/% %.5
- # /; % %! $#% !N # 7 # %!# # !% $!% #% % %!5 !+ % %! $#% % ! % /; #- ;# !$: # 5 ! . * % $ .%+ ) BH %4% ! % ) E % /; $#% % #!% # ! $#%4!% # - % $ !!% %! #N$ $! %+5 $#%4!% !! # !%+ ! ! /% @ 7% # - %#%. # . $5
+ # - 5 (1 & - !:%; !% # !% # /; !N # %! #7%% @ 5 (C ) B' !$ # !#% %! # 5 B( ) B15
@ $ # - 5 B( 5 ' & %! $ %! @ 5 (C ) B'
& #!%+ E 77% !% !!$%.5 !% % * ! % !#% %! ; # % /; # !%5 *
0'1230(221
4 H03 4
!% #- $ #%;! %. ! / %. ! #- %! *+ %% # % * $#%@5 !. -%#% %! $#% %$ :% % % % # 7% # #+!$ %% ! #$ . -@%; # * !% # $ % < P '(C 33 !%#5 1 R & (222 S U '22 5 L !%#5 (=5
H5 -* ! !+ #-+% $#%@ #%+; . %! # % /; # % $ # />%! /%5
! """""""""" $#%4!% # -% %$ !%#* . % % $ # />%! /% - # %5 9! % #+!$ # """""""""" % +! %! !$ % % $ 5 $#% # %%. # #% % .- />%! /% % $%! !5 ! ! """""""""" +/ %$ . % $ # />%! /% % 77% # # 6 7 5 $#% % # 7! $ !! ! # ! #% %! # 'H !+$: (221 # . % $ # />%! /% % % % %$! .-% - % D ;! #% A+% (22( G5 77 @%. ) ;# . % $ #-;! /% % *+ # % $ # />%! /% M D % -;% )
! #-;! /% .% $ #-.% 7% %%! -/$!% # $!+$ G5 > %% % # ! . $#% % %4$E$ !%#* . % $ # />%! /% !% 77% !%5
P! #* ! # ! . % $ # />%! /% !# #* A+% (22( @ % * # % /; # - 5 B( &5 ! $ 7!# !% 5
85 ) # $% .-% # % $ #-;! /%5
#@ E # % ) :% %! % !77%% <V5 # (3 $ (221 S BCWBH02( J5 # 8 $% (221 S '2B02(= %: 7# # @$% . %! # % /; 64$#% # % $ #6;! /% !#%; # !:*$ # #+!$ # !: # $! %% <PL( &4'2=5 !%! P . # 77 %! ! I 7. /I 7 . !: # #+!$ # 7%: %$! + E % # $ #6!# #;!;%. 6 4)4#% # %! 7+!% !$! $ #+! !%:%% %#%+%# # """""""""" < ; SX4 +%/; #+Y ;/ Z9[ 9!I% 9%//% /5 L1 ! '8H=5 $% $ 7%; ! $$ # ! # ! % % ;! # %+% # !%% %: <! $$ %. # A#! ! # X = ! 7. %! # # %!5 ! %$ @ $ / %. $ #6!# #;!;%. 7! % # %!
0'1230(221
4 803 4
!:%; !%$ ) /; # 64$#% <) !! # !: # #+!$ 77 7!$ !% +!% PL' &4'2 ; !5 % 5 /5 L1=5
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
9! ! """""""""" % $ #-;! /% -$%! /!!;% ) $!> $5 9! ! ! """""""""" ! % % # % $ #-;! /% !7%$5
!.6% % # ! :% $#% % A; 4% #!% 4% % !$ # 7% . ! 6@% $#% % ;$ % # #! ) # % ! ! % %! # %! # !7% .% 6% ) #%5 %% A%# !# # !%# @ ! %! 7% %% .6) 6% %! # 6%% # +% $#% # 7$% < P '(C BCB !%#5 B:0 7 R '33C 5 11 R '3LL 5 C21 !%#5 (=5
P! ! 7!% # ! . #% . ) @ # $% ) !$ :%47!# # -;! /% $% -+%; !$$ $ / %. ) %! #- 7!% $% !$$ %5
L5 - .!% .-% !% ! . % $ #-;! /% $ )
"""""""""" #-.% ;# %## ! !$% # +% .! %#%5
0'1230(221
4 L03 4
%: # !%#* !. + # A%# $ %! . % /; # % $ #-;! /% A %7%5
0'1230(221
4 303 4
#5 "! # ! #
% 6.2 7 8 9: ';+ #$<
2
'5 ! +:5
% 2
(5 -#$ -;% # % /; # % $ #-;! /%5
B5 A ! 5
15 !#$ -% %$ ) + ) ! !$$ # '6(C2 75 ) % # %% %! ) 7% #5
C5 % . !# ; % 5
H5 7!$ % # .- + 7!$ ! ! E # #% # B2 A! #* ! %7% %! % !$$# # %: 7# # 9/Y%I/!7.% H H221 !% @$%5 #% E !!;5 $$!% #!% M = %#%. @ $ . #%%! ! #% !: % % # #%%! .R := @! ! . $! %7 % %$ !+!% #$# #%%!R = ! %; ! # ! 5 9% $$!% ! % !% $ $ ! = := = %4# %: 7# # ! $ %* ! .-% #+ # %+:5 $$!% # ! $ %! ! $!> # + .% ! A!% %% . #%%! . -+! # . @#% ! < 5 'B( '2H '2L =5
;77%*M %# M
&%4!% ] !% V
!% !7!$ # E ! %7% @ % %% .-) -77% 7# # :%. ;77
0'1230(221