Setting Aside Prior Marital Property and Support Judgments Due to Factual Flaws
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case addresses numerous challenges to the validity of several prior judgments concerning the division of marital property and spousal support obligations, primarily alleging that the foundational facts used in those earlier rulings were factually flawed or based on misrepresentations by the opposing party. The court reasoned that the initial judgments, which involved complex equitable distribution and support calculations spanning nearly two decades, were substantially based on factual findings that were later determined, through evidence in the current proceeding, to be inaccurate or deliberately distorted, thus compromising the fairness and legal basis of the original decrees, which necessitated setting aside those prior determinations for a de novo re-adjudication of the relevant financial issues.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Setting Aside Prior Marital Property and Support Judgments Due to Factual Flaws: The court reasoned that the initial judgments, which involved complex equitable distribution and support calculations spanning nearly two decades, were substantially based on factual findings that were later determined, through evidence in the current proceeding, to be inaccurate or deliberately distorted, thus compromising the fairness and legal basis of the original decrees, which necessitated setting aside those prior determinations for a de novo re-adjudication of the relevant financial issues.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThis article is cited in order 05 concerning the allocation of court costs to the appellant.
Testo completo
()*+,(,- #()).)(,-
#
#$ # $
"/0 )
' 1* 2 0 ,- !" !#$% $ "$ !&"$ '$ () $ & )) + $!" ,-.
! " #$#% ! &' '
+3/04+
3$#
05 $$ $ " 0-20 $ % #65 $$$ &! 7 "#" ! #$$ #8 &+% $" $ 9$:0-;<5
35 ##$ 03 %!: 0-;< !" $$$ #"$!" $$=$+$"= =$>"! 7"#"=?:8 6> $$" $ $ $7"! !5 &#$" "$$ $$ # 9 #$!:0-;<$&$$$@$"A$$ #0-.-5
45 # B% 0-;9 &" : !: #"$ C$$ #8 "$ " $ "$! :8 #"$ "$$ "$ =D "$! 6 6$ $"+$" 7",$$! :8 7+$ :8 #"+ E 65 ##$ !" $$$ B% 0-;9 @ !0--0F5#!0--0&"$$ $""$$$$5
<5 " 32 ! 0-;- &66 $ &+% $" C+#8 & F!&":""6 &$$8 &% $"%66$0 #$!:0-;.5
95 $ .!3110& $"#" "% $5
25 ##$ .B3110 >">&"$$ #$$"$$$$$>&&, %$# 7=!$ =$5 # & #$$ $%$" #6 3 7 # B "$$ %=:5
.5 04 $: 3114 &" $$ % ! :$ & 5A#">&%$#%6!!$$ 31105)$%$$@66$7$7G $ &##$>&@#"##$ B5#$#$@017$6$ %@047<956"%3114&"$$"#" "#$%$ H6 ##@ "$ $#%!&%$####$$$$$ 6$= $ %$ ! "$:!$ =" 0 #$!: 31145 # &AI$ # &$%$" $ #=$ & = 6$=:$"C65"=!$##$ 09 "!:311<F5
;5 ##$ 4 %!: 3114 6!" =$#"" $$ >">&"$$ $""$$$$5
-5 $ 32 6"% 311< &" "$" ! @ A#$ $ # #"$ !" $5 ##$ 2 #$!:311<$A#$ =$>"! 7!#>"
/0123/311. +4/04+ "$! "6$% 6 > $ >& $: "#65 &"%$: $8!:$%$7="$%A !#$> ! 7C6$:8F5 $!$ ! !:$ $: #$$ &,$ # : &$%$ 7= #0--25)&A#$#$$%@$A 91J $% "=>&$68% &"$!5
015 02 %!: 311< & ! " @ &" ! $ " #5
005 3 "!:311< >">#$$ #%$$%!$@91J#%$6>&%& 6!!#"$$ ,!#$K! @$$=D$"$6@ $$ #"$ $ "$$ # 7" %$ $'$ #6 "$7!$ #7 $!5 6$ " $A$>& &"$$##: &$# $%$"#6"=8@91J5
035 09 "!: 311< &" 6!" ##$ @ L "L 02%!:311<$!$ $ $8 &% $"5 6$ %>&%$$$" &A$%$"3110#$%6!! #$$$$5 # $%$ H$$>&#%$ >$8 #$!$ "# &A#$$ $$5 % 3114 &"$$ "#" 6!! $ %$ H # =" $$5 %$ ==" #!%$"">&&"$$#! $% !8 $5 &"$$ $%" "$$ 6$= %" > %$ "$"7#$$$$$ %$"$"% 5 #H$3114 &AI$#! $%$"$&"$$##:>6!$ !" $$$$!$@&% &A#$ $"= #"" &% # # # $$ A#$ > %$ $ &D$$ 5
045 31 "!:311<& 6!"&">& "$ 09 "!: 311< !! ##$ @ " > $ D$ "!#7!$$$!&A#$
0<5 " 9 B% 3119 & $," @ &" !+$ &% $"%66$0B%31195
095 -!3119&"!#"$"##$#"$>&"$$ $:$ !: 7"$ "$7!$6">$ #7> &:=$@ 7$7="=8!$56!"% H!$$ $$#:8! #7#!$$$# $$ $% !D!"$$ "5
/0123/311. +</04+
025 " 09%3119& !&##$$ " " &$# $$ !#"!$ $ 3 "!: 311<5 $$ &66$ #6 "$$ !$ $ $ $$5
0.5 " 40!3119$$!#I$ 9B%3119& 6!"&$@&" & !+$ &% $"%66$0B% 31195
0;5 3<B3119&"#8 : "> $! $ $ @ & !! :B$ !#"$5 LL &"@&$ &$$8 &% $"#$=!$ "%##" #!8##$5
0-5 32 H$ 3119 6!" & > #$$66$# #:8!#,7>$>&&%$B!$" #,7$5
315 $ 39 $: 3119 &" "$" ! @ A8! A#$ $ # #"$ ! =$% $ 65 ##$ &A#$ 39!3112&A#$ =$>"! 7!#>" #0-.-%, ! &$$$$"$! "6$% 6 > $5 #$$ #=$ ##!$ #:8!"@"$!>&% =$+!D!@ &%096 #B$4@<6#$5="$$$$$%$6">!!$> #7 "$7M$ #$"!$ > :$$ @ "!$ !$8 6" > $=$ @ 7= %D$!$5 &A#$" #=$ "=!$ &"$$ &$7"7>$ &$A"$" @$$ +"!>5 & #$ % !" & #%$ " > ! 7 "$$ $!$ $:" # 0--45 8 #:"!$> #$" $%"$$"A"# =$ &"$!5 &$7" 7> $ $: " @ $$ """#%$%=$% # 3@47#B$ $$ $% N &" #$ &:$ 6!$ @ $$ !!$5 &$%$" A" B>& &"$$ # A=:5 #$ #$"=" $ > ! #$ D$ %=:5 )&A#$#$B$6">&:""6M$ &$$8 &% $"5
305 ! 6!8 #"$ > $!$7"# "$" ! $"#"%$$ &"5$$">#$ $! "$$ 6!!" $,# :H5 $$ " "$$ $$ %#$!"$$#5 %&$$"$$@$$% # $$5 ! %$ =" &"5 !:$ # $> 66$" %% %$!"$$$B!#$$5
/0123/311. +9/04+ %">&"% $#7$01@416#B$$$3 7$ !56$#$+D$$>&$#:$" $ !" $$$ =$+$"= 6 ""% $$ $ #$+D$##$=!$C65##$ 04#$!:3112F5
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
345 ##$ 41B%311.$$">&% $ # % ! &=$ #:$" &$$!$$ &"=!5$!# % = #7&"%$ 9@01!$$7> A7 N% ="$$#$8!$# #"$$#$!# &: ! 01J5!$$!# $%@3@47#B #$ 8A#$7!#" &$7" $ #=$ &"5 "$$ 8 #: &"$ &"%$ #%$ ">L&$7"%$ %$= &"$$ =""$"$$ !A"%"#$$>#=$+$"= !D! @ &= "$$ $$L5 6$ !$$ !$ #$" $% 91J > # $ @ &%
3<5 " - 6"% 311. $6" 03 6"% 311. & B$" &##$ &"5A#">&"%$"$"!:""6 &$ $8 &% $" @ !#$ 0 #$!: 0-;.5 $6 %$ # # $%$" 8 6 B 0-;- $ $ %$ "$" ##!"5 &"
/0123/311. +2/04+ %$ #8 !! $ !$8 &+% $" > %$ ! $ " !$ $ "= $ "$$ $" 8 ! #$!: 0-;-5O&7$$!" "$$ 66"$566$ ! 7 "$$ $:" $ A#$ > %$ "$" !" @ #%$#$" $%@&"5!" ) %$ 6!$ $!" #$" $% @ 91J5 & %$ # ">$#" "@!# %%$% $" 90&02;65$ #8 % $" 33&-14 65 !#$ $ & " $ 31 J &% $ "$ $A &% $" 99J $ $ @ !+ $ &% $"5
395 0< ! 311. &" $ $$ " #8 : "$!$ $$8 &% $" # 0 #$!: 0-;.5 6$ % > &A#$ %$ #%#:$$> %$D$ #$"5$ :%$ )#%$D$% "!$ &!" =""$ $ & #"$ > &%$ '$ # A!" &"5 6 &=$ !# % %$ $ #8 % $" %$ &#" " $ !A! 39J $ "$ $A &% $" 2.J%$ $@$$8 &% $"5
325 "# 3-!311.&$!"&$"6""@ "##$ $B$ 5
3.5 ) 66"$ $ "$" $! A #$ $ = " @ B=5
$#
05 =% P=$ B 33 %!: 0-<0 CF "$" ! 6" $ $$" 8 0 H$ 3114 : $ $$$6!"!$@&$59250$5753$> $$$#"%@P$592 6" "#$="" $ 2$:3111C F>$$%@ P+% $" 0-B0-9-C F5
)!#"$#B= P#8$"$:5
05 $ $" %= 0 B% 3114 $'$ ! 6$ "=$% $!!$ $ &+% $"5 #$ % $!#$####:8= $%=!!$N 6$ B >!$ "$!$ $ # $ $ B= 6 #####"&"$$ 6$""@ $ "$!$ " ##$ $= C * 03- < 5
/0123/311. +./04+ 053E 02- 5 0 E 492 5 0 $ D$ $"F5 ## $ $$!#!! $&A! :+6 " " -6"% 311.@!8 #$ ##" &"$ $ B>&40 "!:3113$"7"$= % #$ ##" #$"C *041443 5353$354F5 > #" $ @ "6$ 8= $$ $ % $&##>"% 8B $" %=C * 00.-4 52:E003421 5<E 0--;Q4.#5402 54:F5
45 : " $$ > $B$" 6! $ " "=A#"%#P$521 $%:5
<5 %$ "$! " P$!"#%$D$%#% "%# "$# P"$:"7"$ =" P% $" $5
F%$ $5;50 $<50 $"#$"% $"&#$" =$$#$#"!"#!$ = "$"$$ & 6!$"="$ &! & $5 $@&#$" = $ "6@&$5. !! !$ &!: &#$ #:$" = &" !7" $% ">:" $$ !$"$ & $$$@$"#7,>!$$>&#$ #8$$!$$! " #$$A=:5, #" > B# $ P% $" $ $ $ "!> $ !" E $ "> "!>:B$% P#$"6$>P!#$ P"%C * 0013.9 5<E01931. 53F5
) &$5 0. $A &% $" :""6 $ :$ ! 6$$:$$ &66 ! "%"#&%@ % =!$" " $ "> ##!"5 %$ "=!$ # &$ #$$ : " %$ & " $" 6 > &"$$ 6$ "$!$ ! 6 $:!$ # $5 $ 7=!$ !#$$ $ ## @ 6 =" &% $" $ $ @ $ #$ !$% "% &$5 0. 5$#$D$"%"!$ ! 6$: &"$$ $" ! > + $ $" !D! ! > "> #$" = $ : 7=!$ !#$$ C * 041 4<- 5 459 E 004 3.9 5 0E 003 4.3 5 3: $ 4-1 50:F5#$ %$7=!$&$# $ $D$$7" !#$6$$>&#"$$!!$ "$ $ $ $ "=$ @ &"#> " $= C * 041490 5 45953 E 039 42- 5 3 $ "6" E 003 4.3 53: $ 4-1 5 0:F5 &, $$6 # !$8 @ "% + @
/0123/311. +;/04+ "$ + > $ $ !" 7=" $ > !$6 ## !$ $" >!$ %##"$ C * #:" 03$:3119;/1< 5 3E *0034.3 53:$4-1 50:F5!$6 "%&$50. $ !$ $ C * #:" 03 $: 3119 ;/1< 5 3E !$ $G= $% % %7=$78*:=3113##5044F5 "=!$$ "% $ $ 66$ $$ 6 !$ B > @ "A! $ $ @ $5 6 %$ #" > &$5 0. & # ##$" ! 6$ A ## B# $ "%##" "=! & $5 <0 %=B>&40 "!:3113C *0414<4 5459F5
:F B= $ A! !8 :B$% $ !, #%>>&$#%# " !$@ #$ #!$$$ #$ B=!$ %: $ $=A5 ) ##$ !" A $ $ $ #$ > &66 ##" &!: #%$ >#> 6 #!" $#$5##$ "%$$"" C# A!# ! & $ &#$" $% &% $" &$$$ @ &$"=$"#7,>!$F##$&$$ 6$ & !" 5 ##%"$: $ &"@ #$$& !$$B= : !$>!" $65&##"$ " !" %D$ !#$ &$$ # = $A$5 B# #""$M7 !" #A!# &"%$ &% $" &$$$@&$"=$" &A! $" $ $ &"%"!$ $ $ % !!= C * 03309; 50:$"6"E) #% $ R"=&7 (+:$) (S (+M3111 #532;F5
&+% $" &$$ 6$ & !" 6 ##$ !" $$$ $"@&66 &+% $"A#$ !" "# $ &$$$ &A!#$>"# $ &:%$ !" &+% $" C * 034 0.9F A#$# $##$>A#$!" "# B= #!8 8$C)0--.#540; 54:E #" !$$%+% $"$78*:=0---#50<3F5 &"%$ &% $" $M7 !" $ @ #$ B=!$ &"$$ $" $ @ > > ! $ # > $%$" &" $ #: $%5 $ " !" $$$ ""!$ $ # "$! > $%A #$ :!$A= &"C *039320 5<$"6"F5
/0123/311. +-/04+ ) ## : ##"$ #% #!$ %: #" B ! C65$520 $5 FB=&$#"# 8=6!! $A! !8:B$%$!, #%>>&$#%# " !$@ #$#!$$$ #$B=!$%: $ $=A5 ##$ !" A $ $ B= #$ $7&66##"&!: #%$ > # > 6 # !" $ # $5 &""!$ "$!$ # % #:$ & ##$ !" &$ = "=$!$5 $"= !#$>#$ $=A!#$$$6$&:B$ &"$ 6">##$6 A! !#$ >& # "=!$ "$ #$ A#!">&$"$""$:# C!8F> #$ $6" !" $ $ 6 > &A#$ $ : !$%"5 ) !$$ ## : ##"$ #% : 6" " #" = $>!8 &##"$$,# &A#$ ##$!" AC *039493 54F5
B= &"$ ## # !$6 !#"$6 & A#$ !" $M7 &A#$ "$$ #""!$ !$$ #"@ #$ B$6 &"#$ !" A &"$$ 6$ "5)B# #$$$ &"$ &A#$B 6$>+$$ $ $ >& A#$ " # $: 6! !8%$5$> &$#"$"!$$$ # $ #$ @ !$$ "!$ $ #$ " $ &A#$ #$ A $#"$$ %=$ #B=:$$!#"!$ 6! &%A#$!" C *039493 54:/$ "6"F5
95 & $%$ $!!$ A A#$ !" $# #"$ % !" $$$% ) >##$ &$$>$%& :$ & 5
$ &: %$ % > A A#$ !#$ A= B# $ # '$ # % #:$5 A#$&%$# $#A!D!&=$ #$" $%" $5&A#$$>&#"$ #$" 91J #6$&A#$ #$" 3@4 7 #$"="5 ) @ &% 6$%> &#!$%"#>
/0123/311. +01/04+ $$>&#$" 3@47#B>% = #7 # !A!! > 01J $!# &" # $ B"5 $ !" $$$$!>#$$#$$%>&!$@ 91J!# !8"=85
: "8%>$!# % = #7 ! #$" $% $ >& $7" 7>5 $ #6#% 7$7=>#7&$ "$7"5, %"=!$> #"0--1&"$$ $"$$:" $ !""###$@#" #"" $"0--1 > &" : $8 !: #"$5 $ "" %$%"%<7#B#$$# $3$% "$"#: #"#$ #$ B5 &$>>&&$$%" A !! 6" % & &"$ $ # >& 66$ & = 6$=5 # $ " !8 "=8 $ # $ 3 @ A #6 "%## 6$= A%5 &$> $$#$8!$$$> &$ %#: $$>&#"$" ="%8 &$7"5
% >#"8 $=8!$ "$ &" : "$! %$)>$ #$$%@!+$!# #6 %&8@ $ 6!$:5 $"= $#%D$#: "#$ $!# $%97>#!$ # $!#"@ % = #75
6$, $$>&"$$ $" $$:"$ !"" # &$ $ $ &% $" #!$ % $ "#% "%5
25 8> :$#$" $% 91J %$ #" @!# %%$$#8% $"5
A$! P$53;50 %= #0B%311<P" $@>$ $ $A &% $"$$$<1J!@ !+ $P$$$91J!@$+>$ $P$$$21J$@$ $8P$$$.1J!5
7G " $6 =" &% $" $ D$ "%" : & !# %5 % > &" $ # :$ & &"$$ # % $ !#" % >& #$ :$ AI$ &$%$" > #$ :!$ D$ A=" #8 $$!$ $ ! " #$$ !7" $% ">:"5 !# %&66$8= 766$A$!$>#: !$$ A%$ 6$$& %&$ 66"
/0123/311. +00/04+ #!$$$ $A &% $" C!"$7 ="" !# %E *0414<; 545<03;41 5001<042 53$ 3:E B>& 40 "!: 3113R $5 3; 5 3 E 0 B% 40 "!: 3114R$5050 "$%&$502 E #0B%311<R $5 3; 5 3 "$ % &$5 02 F5 #" @ !# % %$ # !!$ $ @ $E % % $ % $" %$ D$ "$!" # ##$ @ !D! !!$ $ ! 6$ % #$: &6 $ @ $ % B>& !!$ N " $ %$D$#!#$C *03-334 5<5003;0.<F5
% # % "$! "$:$ =" %!:#"# "$>&$66$%!$#"!!$ "$!$ "$$ : $" C * 03- 33< 5 <5450 $ "6"F5 $ D$ "%" !8 8$ > #: : >& %$ 8= ="" "6" > &" :$ %$&$$$@$"5
% &% $ D$ "%" %$ $$ 6$ $$ #6 8$ &$""5 &: & % 66$%!$ "", "6"A "$$$>$>&"$$ >D$$$ &666" " $$$>C *032 .2 5 4:/ $ ::F5 ! > $$ $$$> %$ D$ " $ "# &!: $ # $ #6 #$ C!$$ " 7 # M= " % $$"/$"= &$$ "B $ $A &#$F$"$ &"%$ !$ #% &##"$5 " $=:!A!! 39J$$$>#!$ $ !#$ 66"$ ""!$ > #%$ 6 % & $%$" $%C65 *032.; 59F5
!#$$ 6$>P"&AI$# &$%$"B%3119 $ " $ $ &% $"$ #"$ !%$ :$$$> P>D$$$ &" 311< # "$! % %$ % $"5 , # ">$ # % $$$> 311< 0 #= 94 $$ 7!! 7K$ $ $$ #"" + #> $ $ :""6 & $6$ 6$+$$ + > # @ % !, <&0;265#!$ 91&34365@#$!#5 !! :$ $ " $$ !#$ & 7 $% <1 7 $ " 7: ! 6" @ !, $# 311< C<027E"!>4+3112#5-1-53F!$$ $D$#$"@ 93&3<065415
/0123/311. +03/04+ % &% "6"$!D!!@91J> #"$ % 32&031 65 295 !#$ $ & " $ !A! 39J !$$ !#$$ @ % = #7 $ @ "$7!$ >& $% @ $!# #$ % &% &"8% @ 0-&9-165915
!# % "$!$%$$#8% $" $@ $ $A P% $" 2391J> % $ @ $+>$ $ &% $" @ #$ 0 B% 3119 CT93&3<0 65 41 + 0-&9-1 65 91U A 011 R 93&3<06541V2391F5
% > #"8 %$ $$ > $ :$$ #$!$= 5 6$ $@ "#6A"@0&11165
/0123/311. +04/04+
4#$3 #$ # $
'
5 /
05 "%:5
' 5
35 & !$#$!$ "$5
45 $ > $ $ @ $+>$ $ &% $" 8 0 B% 31195
<5 $"!!$ 31165@7= &$!"5
95 !&$!"@%$0&11165@$$ #$#$@6 &%$5
25 6! #$ >P #%$ 6! $ #"$ D$ " 41 B 8 $6$ #8 : 6" " C)7WG76>2211< F#% !$8 $ #:6!"!$A$5;3 6" " :6" " 0. B 3119 C *FE !"! $ > !$6 $ !, #%$#$=$ $ ! $E $ D$ " : 6" " # % #$ # % "$> A $ &$5 <3 *5 #"$ D$ $ #8 # $%>"!!!, #% %$D$B$@&%5 =668 " $ + X Y "$+B$R *" "> )
#6! #"$D$$$6"A#$>P@P666" " #=66
/0123/311.