Attorney-Client Privilege and Work Product Doctrine in Adversarial Context
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court considered whether certain communications, related to a legal dispute, were protected by attorney-client privilege or the work-product doctrine, after a party sought to compel their production. The court reasoned that the communications, even if between employees or agents of the client, were protected if they were made for the dominant purpose of rendering legal advice or preparing for litigation, as the focus shifts from business advice to legal assistance when an attorney is involved in the communication's creation or review. The court found that the adversarial context and the involvement of counsel in generating the materials were sufficient to establish the required legal purpose for protection.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Attorney-Client Privilege and Work Product Doctrine in Adversarial Context: The court reasoned that the communications, even if between employees or agents of the client, were protected if they were made for the dominant purpose of rendering legal advice or preparing for litigation, as the focus shifts from business advice to legal assistance when an attorney is involved in the communication's creation or review. The court found that the adversarial context and the involvement of counsel in generating the materials were sufficient to establish the required legal purpose for protection.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court applies this provision for the allocation of the procedural costs.
Testo completo
"#$%&"'%%# ("##)"'%%$
*(
( + +(+ +
) '%%$
', -
. ////////// ! !"# ! $% &' (()"'" ("" 0.
+(+ 1+2 +( + ( #*+,%-./
! 012340
+ 3 (
35 !" 6666666666% ("""' - ./% 7' &"/" - (8" ("("" "9": );("3+;'/" 3<<15& ;;""'.( " 8/"( "="0 . "> )"'(&7"- " "5
15 &'"- "</"1443 "("&' 1444()""(")" '"/? (@1ABC1;53+ ) ;-&"/" '("5;"(& )&" " ("3D 3<<<&'/" -E53@AC1F%#8-+A434;53+% (" ) :(/"' " (E5B,+ )(' ("" 8/" " ( /" ' " (' ( E5 3@AC+35 . ('( "(;"%/ &'/" -E51C&F+,5
B5 "('-&'(' ( " " G0 ( '(3BD 1443% ;": " " &' 1444 - +AB+C ;5 ++% " ' " (&((3AF4C;5++%('( "(/ ('H-''5
,5 &';'33 ?1443%' '3B ?14435 :')&"/" '"'( &'1444"? (@1ABC1;53+ ) " /" % " " "% / (' " "- " "(,@A41+;5C4%" ( (E5 1C&F+,)&"/" ")'( "(/&'14445 &' '8' ) " /" "% " - ('"" ( " " G0 &'3<<<%(('("(/? ;"( (' & "&'/ -E53@AC+3 )&"'" (.- 3AF4C ;5 ++ ' " " ( " " G0 11@ ;5 14 ' " " ( " 8/" " ;""5 -);"((' " " " - )(' ( " " G0 &'1444" ' (&/(' " (E51CAF+,5
+5 '/"(3B('?1443% ":') " /" "((' '")"H ";" ;""/)' )"" "(/"('""(3BD 14435 ":")');"( (' (7/" * ("( "%" :( ''# (" ''/"% - (('""( " " ( 3<<<5 G "% &" '' /" ) &" '8" ' ( #8&/" ' '" (( " "(' 0B2340
'"5 " ((' ( " ". H ";" "/ "/-;"('3<<< 14445
@5 '")(3,H/"1441% (&?( ') " "" H"(('(";"/"(' (' "'(;" &' 1444 / (& '/ ";" " ( ('"" ( " " G0 &'14445
" % ;" (& % " '"' /" 3 D 3<<< (?" -"= "I/"G#"/("> 7( <44A444 3+4A444(#8"5 ;"%7 ' " ;;"" '(";;' %" 7( F44A444 1+4A444(#8"5:")') '(' " (&8" "' " (&"? " ( " (&"" " ;"5 ( (3"1444%&'/" (''8'( ":% ( "' " (/"' " )&"/" (D ' 5 '/7 ( /( & - ": " '8 - " 7' ( 'H;" "%" " '"'"" (& 75 ;" ( (' " (' & % &' /" ' " (&8 '# ('(& (" "?' (' ( " ' '"( ( ") 5 :0" &'/" -3BABF1;5,4% (")#8' " ,A44F;5,45 :(/"&'/" ) --1C@;5,45
G&8" ( ;" ( (' % ;" /" )&" /" ;; ' " ( /78 0 ./0" ( &' 1444% ( " "' 7 ( /" % ' (' ( E5 34A+44% - " ( E5 4%C4 J". % 3+A444 J". 5 K/78/" ' ';; ' " (E5BA+C@ &'/" "&/"-")""5 " " ":(&? ( ?"8/"%(& (E5C44% "(?("&'/ -E5++15;" )') ( ;" ( ' " '" : E5 3@AC+3 ;"8 ( & " ( " &' 1444 )&" /" " - "</"14435
"% "(")'&- ";" "(('""( " "&'3<<<%" " (( ( " ) ("." ("('('( "?;"( ''/"" ( ''#5
&' H" - " " (' "' ( (' &' 1444%" L 0,2340
E"(& L 3@AC1FA444%"
"(& /"G#"/("L ,A144&444
( /" " =" " '* % ;" ?"% "M ?"8 "' "('(& (")>L @&4+4
#"("' '"?"".L 3A3,<&444
;" ( " ' =" - ( " " ' ")% - 8K " ">L +A@C<&444
#8L +A434A+44%"
#8(&"?/" " L +B1A444=N>
(''8 /"G#"/("0/" " L 1A334A444=N>
L BC,&+44
' "" 'L 3A1B<&444
8KL C++&444
:0/"L B,+&444
8" ( "L 314&444
:L 11+&444
' LE53@&C+3
"L=+1:E51<F>LE53+&,<@
?./LE5C44
"L @<4&444
C5 (") ( + ;'/" 144B% " ' ?" / / (' " &'1444?(".;" - &" ( " ( 3, H/" 14415 " "" ) /" '"'( &'1444/? (@1ABC1;53+%() ";" ('(""M -" "&'/ -3CA@@1;5F+%"") ;"(&)"" "(/=/"7 ' ';; ' : (#8;;""(&E G(E54%4F13+344 >%" L
& L 0+2340
317- F44A444%" <A@44A444%" CAFF@;5,4I ":' )&" ('"'-&)"" "(&8 ":%)&"('" " ""'(" / &)"" "(/5
( #8 (& ( 31 : 344A444 ( ?"% " 314A444%')"/ -E5<F+5F45
;"(&%8K ' "" '% " " ""'(:% 3ACB@A<+1%" 3A,1@;5<45
;"((' L
H 0 ./0" = (' ? (&?" ("0 ";%(:".%/# (&? ("0 ";>%" B4:E53+@OE53+4%' E5,AFB4 ? (? -"(&/( @<4A444%')"/ -+@@;5F+5 "'"' )& " (&? (?8/"%"&' " "'- /"-"5
" "" ' ?" ) ;" : (&)"" " ( / ( &' &'/" -3+A@<+;5<+ )/(' " ' " ((B4AB1<;5 C+5 % " /' ) " ( /" " " ;" ( &' "' " "#875
F5 '( " ( 1C 144B5 /' )&" ;" ('(" ( " (' " ( E5 1CAF1, ( 3CA@@1 ;5 F+ ( : "M - " "5 ;" )' ) " &' " /" "( ";"('""( " " G0 &' 3<<< )&" ;" "(' ) " 5 G&8" (;"(& %"'8') "(/" " ;;"":(7%( - ")" "% )&(/" " " (&# ( (;"("' % )"' " - (&'" (' "5 ;"(&%8K ' "" '%" '(((' ( "% ' (3A<,+;5B4 (3A,1@;5<45 /') "/" "( " ((")(+;'/"144B ( :0/"(& (1FB;5F45G&8" (;"((' % &' :' ) ( E5 ,AFB4 " &' " '" )&" :"8(")&"#" #( " /"" ;" PJ0( - ./ #" 88 " ( /"-"5 0@2340
+ (
35 " 8/" A8" " H(""" ( 11 /? 3<,3 ="0. >' '(";"' "? ("' '" " ' (.3D 144B = 53 5>5 ;' -A 5B 5B(("" " " "("(3,/?1441(";" %" (" / A ' /"8 ( " '" ' ( (/ "" ( ". (A0/"" /"/ ' ' " (A;;" "? ( "5 ' ( "?(' (.' ?" #(' " "85
15 ";'(' "8''((" ("(@ ? 1444 ="0. > ' /"8 3 H/" 144B% Q ( ? (";" " ( (" ( "5 (&. ( ;" '8" ("" " /"8 H)& B3 ('?1441%'8("")H8(" &-("(' "(";" "((" (&' (;" '" - ( (' " ( ('"" " "8" = E 31C ,@C% "(53% 313 BF@% "(5 3?I ;5 '8 ("" " " "% 5 F1 5 3 >5 ' " "8 ') :"' - ". ( ("" " ( " ;'(' &0/"" /"/ ( 14 ('? 3<,@ ="0. G> ( .8 &0/"" /"/ ( B3 ? 3<,C ="0. G> /"8 H)& B3 ('?14415
B5 ''(; ('""'"%' /? = 5F, G>5
,5 G% & 5 , ( / " ( 3, ('? 3<@1 ;'(' " G" '?") " "/ - '" ' "% " "("""'G" :N "/" ' "/" " "7 .('" '"" "5
(&.% #" ' '.( "" & ;;""'.( "%"")&7 "& 535 , 5 G5 " % " "('' "' (& 7 "- " "" "(& 5@ G%' (') 77 ' ?" G" (7( " " = 53151 G ">5
&. & 5 @ G% " " ( ' ( &7 & "- " " '; "(")&"N"/ 5 0C2340
'8(% " C 5 G (';"" )&" ; ( "(' " "- " "5
: (& 5< G%;"8'': ('' "'(A:' "( /:5; "(;"8'': "(" ' (' '8". (' ( ("" " ( /" #?" " ("" " ( /" #?" I "(" ' ; "" " ( " (' " 5 ;" 8'':/ * ('(" ("(' " A" /')A"A'./ - " 34 ( " /'5 ;" (' ' '' ( "/ ( * ('(" 5
"%;"8'':); /""'("/ * /' (/"??= 3<FB5B34> "("/ * ('(" - ( ;; "; =" "/ " (' " R G SB44+>I-9" ' ?")(;"8'': ' '"9( " '" *# / " ( ;"% :0" ("/ * "' " ( " = 3<<4 5 ,3>5 " ( " " ;" ) &7 2 "' ( /"?? )" (;""(''I;"8'': (' ' "' ( &:' " ( /:5 ('"? "'(;"(& " 5 &8" (;"(/78(/"%" %" 8 %;" ( ' " ( (' " .% ;" ( '" ( /* ( /"% ;" (& "" " ( : ;; ' - &:" ( & "/" ' "/% ;" ( (''8 " ;"% ;"(; "(; " ;")&" / "' " /& "/" ';"("'=GSB44+>5
/#%;"(& " )" ("."( ") 8 '8 :" (& "/" ' "/ "(''(('"0(= 3<F15B+,>5
% &7 "' (" / ( " ( /"?? ) ;" )&" .8 ?" '5 :" ( &" / " )" '" '( ("" "/ " " ".('" '":"8( )&("" "H8 ( " "8 ? - ) ( 7 ( " " & '" - / - ( ;;" /"?? &:" ( ;" 5 (" ?" M )'" (&;;" (' '" /% " "? (";;" ' :"/I'#' %";;" (&"/" (" -;"0* )& :"8(& -;"( "= 3<C<5CC>5 0F2340
+5 &.% '8' 3, H/" 1441 )&" /" ;; ' " ( /78 0 ./0" ( &' 1444 ( "; ;"% ( " "' 7 ( /" % (K "% ") /" ) (" (/" * (' ' ( " (' " 5
% E %") "" "'%H8');" ( (' ": ( ("" ( /" " " """(" (;"8'':('( "?( ""- " "5 " ")("" "/("0 0) ;" ' " ( ( " ( ("" " ( /" " (;"8'':)"": ? '"8'&( & 5 (&.% E "('' ) ;" ( (' ":(("" ( /"(" "/ (++ ,CJ " (;"8'':('( "?(""- " "=;5 3<<, 5 F,>5 : " % ) (" ": ( ("" ( /" " '8 - " ( J". % &" :" '#' (& "; (&" % " / % . :( ""%( "(&"(" '((' " (;"%""'&#"""((""( ";T( /U=;5G3<<,53<C>5
""% ;" ( (' ( ( ("" - " ( /" ("/ * " "(' " ( "(' " (& 5< G%(" ./0" '8 - F44 V% ) H '" - &)"" " ( / )&" % ( &?% (D ' ?"5 ( % " &' " ;('- " %(("(' " %)( ;"((' #'")) " ;; ' "%" (;"((' ;; "/ 5
G&8" (;"(&? :? (./%"; " ( ;" 8'': " * ('(" ( " (' " ( & 5 < 5 3 G% "' ("""' - ./ " '8 - D ( H (""0"( /"5
@5 "/')&";" ('("("(' " ;" ( 8 " ( &# (& /" " - "5 % " /'' ) ;" ( 8 '" - &)"" " ( / ( ""% ( ;" ( &'"8 ( (""8/"( ("( /"5 '8(%( E5 3A344 ('' 8 ( ? ") ' ( & ;; ' &# ( & & ":"/%" "%"')"/ -7 0<2340
# ( 7 E5 @+C " ( &)" " " ( & /" G#"/(" H)&-;" /" 14445 %&# ( & /" " '( - 8") '")% ") /( ( "/" ' - " ''"";(5
.%; (Q );"(8 /" " " (;";"'"-&)"" "(/ )&"("/ %- " %* ('(" ("(' " ( %" "(& 5< G5 / "" '8 ( ;" ( " ' ( & % '"(#?" ?5
C5 "(/("(' " ( &' 1444 '( : ('( " '" :" ( (' '" " " ' "% : ( (' "' : (' % /"% ( " ( ". &# (& /" " %"");"(& "% ( :0/" ( " ( ( " (' " 5 "(/"(' ""7 ""'- ;"( &'1444%) "" "* ('(" ("(' " 5
F5 / ( )" '.(% ("% ('"" ( '% (" /7' - " / ( " " G0 ( &'1444%("(' 5
' ('(%"H ";"(&(('(';(%)" ;":'&.-3A+44;5
( 3 ( + +(+ +
4.
35 '/?5
4.
15 &( 5 0342340
B5 ('""( "(3BD 1443;": " " G0 ( &'14445
,5 /"- "' (&" " /('"" ("(' 5
+5 "(" '(3A+44E5- " ( "" "-;" ('"")&-:(( "5
@5 ; " ( )A / ; ' * ( ('" ( B4 H (. ";" " " (' (' "? ;'(' ( % G#P"K#;)" @% @44, % " :"5 ('" * 8'5 '" (" L > "(") : )A ('"" ('" ? " " ( ('"" )'I?>:) ";" "/"(( ('""I> "8 (' 5G"'" " " '' ''' > ?> > "0(% "?;'('( ".)A" (/('"/?5'"( "7 ( /% )" H" % "" ) ('"" )' A/ ( )' ':'("' = 53B1%34@ 34F>5
8;;"L '"( L " G ?G
' "0H" L " W
";(' * ";"': """)A-A;;";'(' ("8;;