Statutory Amendment Applicability to Retroactive Interest Rates
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAA dispute arose over the proper calculation of retroactive interest rates applicable to certain contractual obligations spanning several years, with the core issue being which statute governed the applicable rate following amendments to a controlling statute. The court reasoned that the statutory amendment, which altered the retroactive application provisions, did not govern the obligations in question because the parties' rights and obligations were fixed prior to the amendment's effective date; consequently, the interest rate calculations remained governed by the terms in effect at the time the obligations arose, as interpreted under the original statute.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Statutory Amendment Applicability to Retroactive Interest Rates: The court reasoned that the statutory amendment, which altered the retroactive application provisions, did not govern the obligations in question because the parties' rights and obligations were fixed prior to the amendment's effective date; consequently, the interest rate calculations remained governed by the terms in effect at the time the obligations arose, as interpreted under the original statute.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive regarding court costs.
Cited in the dispositive regarding legal aid.
Testo completo
"#$%&"$''( "))*"$''%
+, ++, + ,
- # ! . /0 $''%
!"#$%&' (
(
)) * !+$#(!( (#$ ",-.!+(/00!1/1123/0
!
8/%.8
+ 1
1& *( $ 9 *:: ( " *#+ ;8+2 </=(/66/&
/& 14 3 /66-! *$ "$+$ "#" " # ( + >?#:""(+2"3"#(;8+2@ <&
4& .A/66-!*$((32+!"# ! "B 8 ++$ +( +2 " "$+(#("+!A(($($&
-& 10A(/66-!@ $($:#$B""("*$*3(+ $($(&
7& /53#C/66-!"# D$D""*$ #(: B " *3( + #+ CE( " (? # " >>"*#+"+#"A(/66-&
5& $(B " 46 3#C /66-! *(( " *$ +2 " ( "*( ( " ($ ;8+2 @@< " B( " >#+! "#"$ "# B $(( +C($ " *$ " D$(3 "D& $($ $+" B* "3( #(( >> "*#+ #B( ( B "$ " $(3 " ++((9"("@ &
F& ((E("7A3/6679"# !*$ +"( >>"*#+"B(#+$$"(+$(B*" " (( " # "*=( /66-! "# *3( :#$ B*+"(((3+$(+:G3"H83: " G+B "$#> 9 (+" ( B* 3( $E#( $"* @@"B("2B*:"(+CC#( +#++& *$3$*3+"3" +("+#"+(#C/66-(3#E$((+3>> "*#+!B$(("($I(&
0& ".:$3/667!@ $+"9*$B*3(J(( ((B(9"(("3"(*((".A/66-(B ":("+3(I($(3$&
.& *$*($(+2"* 15#/667(+$($3 "#""*("#(+2"@ &
16& "$"/73/667!@ A($(("#"#(:B*$ 3( $+$ "( "#($ :$"$ 41A( /66-! B #
%4/5-%/667 84%.8 ($(("$""$"(#"2*$+#(""( G"#($:$"$(B"#""D143/66-D$(("("3&
11& " /- # /667! *$ :#$ ++( 9 (( "$ ++(3"$+$>>"*#++2" @@&
1/& /6A/667!*::"*#+"#"$ @@+">>" *$&
14& " /4 A /667! @@ (# + $#( >> "*#+ ::($ + *$ "( # " +(#C /66- 9 A3/667&
1-& "$++("/4=(/667!E+$#(:#$ "$ " /7 3 /667& B "#" " # ( "$+$+*$143/66-$(((3""$$E+B "(9*"#($:$"$+(:41A(/66-&((:(($B *+( " *$ (( B "#" "*#+ 3( $($ $ /53#C /66- #(: B* *3( + #+ CE( " (? #">>"*#+"+#"A(/66-!"2*,( $($#B* @@(@ &2!E+$#(*( B " +( 3 " *( "* # (! 15 # /667!("$$B(("2$((("3&
17& "1.+(#C/667!*$(A($((("$& :(3B"*,(+$($(+"$+(#("A(( +!3(##$"(#((($"# B3( "B$ B* +(( 3! B* "3( "$+ :> " "H83 " 3++ 9 $+( ( *" 9 *'+ E$$ (("( B* ((! +$( B (3 3 + +( +"C+"(#+&G+BB*(+B"$+$ >> @@&((3A#J"*(E&(( + *3 A# $($ 3B$ 9 BB $ "*:#( (3G#(B(+#"*E(#(& :!23 B((B$B*"#((:#("*$((# "* 3 " ( #(( + :( B* +3( $(3 ##3("+$2(!"# K&
15& 3($ 9 +! + $#(! " $+ " /F +(#C /667!+($"(#""$++(&
1F& ""#+(+*(("("17"$#C/667& ((!($::#$3##$"(#(+((3 2+2B+(B*3(++$($($:$&$+$($ B(("2*3(:#$B*+((3"(A(
%4/5-%/667 8-%.8 B* +"( (( 3 + (& (("(! $ "*9*'+E$$("B$B*:"(+CC#((("( 9 B( # + (3 3 +(& ( G+B *I( "9*>+E$$(3#>>"*#+!3B* "3($E#("9* & "(("((#+("! J *:#( B " $(( D$D& (( ( E$ 3 ($ >> "*#+ L> + +(:G"(+$+* #((#+#(++3 339($E"!406:&B$((3$(("*( ::($3"##(+&
10& ?($!"# !+$((+$#(!"# B**,3(+(8I(::(3#(+"$"*:#("# M :( #(( 9 /66-& 3$ B* 3>! +#( 3( + (( "*:# $& ( J(9*$B"3($($$!G+B$B**E( "* #+ ( "#((: ( "* "$! + B 3 " "( *$(( "B$& ::(! ! ( ( +( + 9 $B+B*$*"((#2+"(G"#($&
1.& "#"" C"$!*$+"((B 3($($$>E$3* N
8 " . :$3 /667! "# ! >:: "*E 3"#("* !"B$9*$B.A/66-! " +# (( 3 "# ! (( "2 3( G+B$ :(#( " 3 " # (! " *("(9*#+("#+(#+(3($E#( E:$B*$(("*CE("+3(? >B#! B* O3( + :(& ( 9 *::#( " *$ B "# "3( +" (( 3 + G+B B ((#(!$($(($&"# ::#$ B ( $(( +$$#( A( " +# ((! B* *(("+#(2+$(3(""& 3 ""(*$(("B$&
8 ##"$ " 7 A3 /667 "$ 9 "# ! *$ $+$($ B " *(( *3( :#$ B* +(( 3AB*9:"#"*=((B*"3(+"((3 + $( + :G "H83 : " G+B "$#> 9 (+"! E( B +3( +" + # + I( +$ ( B* (("( 3( $ "* 9 *'+ E$$& *$ (($ B "+ # " +(#C! "# *3( + + (( 3 ! "#"$ M +( #((
%4/5-%/667 87%.8 >>"*#+(3$B*$((#+C"3"H83 "A"+($$+>&"#"$$3("" (+"(>>"*#+"B("#&
8 #E$(B"17#/667!"#!"+# >?#E " 3 " E ( " E! :##( "#"$ 9 "# "$ $ : " # ( " $(3""*$#"3"P
/6& +2($($##B$9*(#$B#(+(&
+
1& E3OE(A";<$($#":$((($!"2 1=(/664! C("!#+$"7AE! "(+$"((38+$"(!7++$((15AE;(&1(& (75 <&
@(9O("O$("15AE!+ C:$"$ /FA3/66-; )146165<!" E3"+($!14:$3! "+(((E(+#((( C(" " $E 9 ( AE ((! ! " O((( " O$("3GAE&
/& :#$#( 9 *(& 75 & / (& C ! C ( " Q((B"(((+$39O(-.&4" ( " 11 3#C 1.04 #(2 " >?#E ; P / /6<& @ #+$(+AE""O+2($(C&
4& (A($(#+("3(O(($#+$((!(3C;(& -.&4 <&
-& (E +( B( " 3 *( 9 A( (( B @ :$ "*( #(2"#""*+( (#+"( #(: B8(("3&
7& #C " +(( #+$#( ( " >?#E :E (##(O#+(#+;(&F(&" <&
O(($#+$((++#+(#+N
< G >?# +> " OLE " (( ( ,( $+$ "( G "#($:$"$!
%4/5-%/667 85%.8 C< 9 (( C"! G >?# ,( $+$ "( G "#($ :$"$(BO(+(3$(3$"("(9O( "(#+!
< BOG + 9 >> "O #+ +2 3 G$ (3($"$+"(;(&4.&1 <&
O#+(#+(::(9(("3""""O+E## (: ( +" " # " +C G +((" +: ">?#;(&4.&/ <&"$"O"#(((! "O$(C#( ( :"( " "( +C! "O"#(( ## ( "O"#((($E:$"$;(&4.&4 <&
5& C$$:"O#+(#+!>?#"(N
< 3$+$"(G"#($:$"$P
C< ( 9 ( ( "# " OLE "( "( 9 ( " O83 + 3 + C$$: "O( " ( #+"O(&4.&1(&C P
< +3C$$:$"O(E+:"$(!"O( " ( #+ "O #+ (#+ " B( $ +$$"( "$+?( " "#"! $3 " M >?#! ##( " "#"! ( 9 # " ( ( "# " OLE "("(9("O839"$:("O( "(#+P
"< I(+(+#(P
< + 3 C +"( "$8" "O"#( :$"$ " + " "( 9 O"#($ " + " 41 A + 3 :$ #+ 3C E$ + O(($ #+$((! + 3 :( B +(I(C#(GE$"+(3#+3C!3 "$ " "( : #+2( 3 :( " BB #2 OCE( " : " E#( +($ "#" OCE( "O3! 3 C( (($ "OC( "=#( O"#($ ">?#EP
:< +3:(OCA("O"#(+$"#((3 "O:($+#$G(&167!165!16F (-F(-0 P
E< (#""$#G##"4#"2O$+#(""( G"#($:$"$!"E$(($3$;(&-/&1(/ <&
%4/5-%/667 8F%.8 3 "O( +: ++ #+ (#+ >?# B:("#"$((B#+("(:G$G(&-1!-/( -- ;(&--&1"2E#("OG$("#(2">?#E"4 "$#C1.0-!8+2N2E#("OG$(P//6&61<&
F& *+2! "( B :( "$:( *(($ (#$ ( $$ 9 *(& -/ (& E & + $#( ( @ E( B D"#"D"$+$+("("15#/667(("3+B "(G"#($:$"$$($$+$41A(/66-&
*( C B D3 "#"D "$+$ + *$ $(( $($ D"#""$(3(D""!B3($($+#((#+#( D$D+@ /53#C/66-!9((& *(+B((D(D * :( *CA( "* "$ +(C "*++(! #E$ *( " (!B"*(:#(3"*CE(""$+(8 "(3"#"&
*( 9 (( B *(($ (#$ B: *D( " "D 9 B 9 +$"$@ "#+("#((:& *("++B( " "$ ( "$: 9 *(& 7 " :$"$ +$" "#((3 ; P @ 1F/&6/1P R @ ! @ @8R##(! ( / " (& -.<! B +($E$$#(2"*;3+G#+ )1/6 4-."&/C<&@*(&7&1 !("$$##""$ # " *(($ " " "*+2! ,( + CA(N < " $! " #": "* " "( " CE(P C< " (( *G(! *G( *$(" " "( "*CE(P < " A( " "$ 3C""#"("(9$!#":!((""( (CE(&
"*+2"$#(+$$#(B*("""( " $B A"B + +B* * +3$ " "( " "#" 9 C$$: " +(( (& (( ( ( " "= : *CA( "*"$C(":#!# 9"3""(& +(! (D(D*(++$3+"+($E&
$B! @ ( "=! :#$#( 9 B "#"( (! " "$ :# ?(( "! ( B (+:#++(&@D3"#"D*("$($+ (*("#"(!"#"*3/66-B"(I(+#+(& :( B @ 8#I#! " "$ " /7 3 /667! + " "#""D143/66-D($3$(&
%4/5-%/667 80%.8 0& $((+$!(+C""#,!+(G#*G(( ""*DD""(&)("((B(*( +&
#( "#" " +(( "$+$ + ( "( " 14 3/66-*$($""$B8B*(+(($8#*(( +# "*$(C B* #+( $E#( ( "( "*( "* #(!B*(++(($&
+>"$(("+*I(+$($(?(" +3:>>"*#+&
+#!3("3BGE:E(+#C " "( $#$$ + (& -1 9 -4 + +3 C$$: "* #(&$:$B(:(9CE(+*$" : " >> "*#+ ( ( 9 *(& -. " 2E#( "*G$( ( ++C9+$""(B(3+$""*#+(#+& B* (! ( + +3 B* 3( ::($ " >> "*#+ ( 3( # @@! B (( "* + *(($ (#$&
" ! *(($ (#$ ! " " #+( +!B*$((:(+CB(*(::(3#(+3" $"*:#("#M:(#((9/66-&
:! C"$"$3+G+("(! B *( A# 3$ 3 (#+! B *( + J "($"2#+& ((::#(+("*(( + 3#CC B! " +# ( (( B* 3 (( "2!+(#C("*("$A9*::9&("2+CCB 2*(+AE$(":((G+(B*( "$(#+#&
$E"GG+(B+$2"(!"$"@ "*DD" "(239((#":##G:(((#I# $E($&
B*(!B$($3$+>(!"#""15#/667 "(I((+$($##"#""D$(3(D"+#2"#"! B3($($"$+$(#+(&
$B! C"$(#B(C:"$&
%4/5-%/667 8.%.8
1 , +, ++, + ,
!
234/4 5 644 4 78 )%$ , 9
/4
1& $3C&
! /4
/& *"#(&
4& "$"/73(/4=(/667&
-& ((B(G+((#+$#((">?#E :#"*#+(#+&
7& (B+$"(E((& E::2 $"(N )) R@ R
+:#"+$(I(((:$G+(+E::
%4/5-%/667