Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ATAS/1179/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/1179/2007 Generato dall'IA

Appeal Challenging Validity of Prior Agreements and Settlements

Numero d'incarto ATAS/1179/2007
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Respinto (Dismissed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The dispute involved several parties challenging the validity of various prior agreements and settlements, particularly concerning obligations relating to past transactions and contractual entitlements, arguing that the agreements were either void, superseded, or that the opposing party breached their terms. The court ultimately upheld the validity of the challenged agreements and settlements, reasoning that the appellant failed to demonstrate sufficient grounds, such as fraud, duress, or material error, to justify overturning the clearly established contractual arrangements and prior judicial confirmations, thus affirming the original dispositions.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 106 al. 1 LTF, Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Appeal Challenging Validity of Prior Agreements and Settlements: The court ultimately upheld the validity of the challenged agreements and settlements, reasoning that the appellant failed to demonstrate sufficient grounds, such as fraud, duress, or material error, to justify overturning the clearly established contractual arrangements and prior judicial confirmations, thus affirming the original dispositions.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
fine del processo violazione di obblighi contrattuali errore manifesto sentenze sulla validità di un atto nullità delle intese motivazione del mutamento giurisprudenza

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 106 al. 1 LTF

The appeal is dismissed based on this provision.

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The appellant is ordered to pay the costs of the federal procedure.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo



            !"## $$ "##



%& '& ( % &( (

()*+  ,  " -.-+  ## 



 !"#$% &&'

'&

((   (  (   )'). )&'* +,-# 

               

   2!-2  

3)'*.))* )'4%)*5')6)25&$7 )8*!#9)!""-.':)'5&6)25&$7).'.8)'5&     *.5' * ')') !""# 5&' '' #""3&;*3&)*')<

  ') * / =' !""- &.' >  ).'.  ')')   *.5'*!#9)!""-'))3)4'.'*')* ""3&;<

*.))*)* 19)!""?.':)'5&).'.*.5'* ')') !""- 5&' '' "! 3&; !- *@)'.&,' &')& ' A-" 3&; * 3&)*')'*<

  *.)) *  ) * !" ':& !""? ')3)' >  ).'.  '' *@)'.&,' &')& * #/ 3&; )'  5)' *  &. * @. !""A ' ')'%)*@55)')<

@.''*5'*')')5&)')&>@ (*)* #)!""/')3). >).'.'''''*@**=*#/3&;5&5.&)*!""A* ""3&;5& 5.&)*!""#'*?@"-?3&;0"5&5.&)*!""-'')'5&'))&* )'.&,'&')&*#/3&;5&!""A* "!3&;!-5&!""-))B*3&)* ')*-""3&;5&!""#'*!-"3&;5&!""-<

@55)')*5&).'.*?9)!""/''' 3&)*')*/-"3&;**.5'* #)!""/<

  *.)) & 55)') *  ) * A 9) !""/ *.&' )&&%: @55)') *.5. 5&   > @'& * @.'' * 5' * # )!""/<

&&*5&5'*).'.* A9)'!""/ *.5.5&$* &):'*&)*@5&'>@'&* *.)) & 55)') 5&.)'. 5& B  '' *%)& 5C& * )'.&,' &')&'*3&)*')*.5'* #)!""/'*@'&5&' > @'& *@ &&)& * 0 9) !""/ *  ) ) &.'  '' * 013&; -))B@>@'&*@*.))*!"9)!""/*)<

 @%&'& 5&  &): * . *@ && .& !/01!""/ 6'&  *.))&55)')* A9)!""/8'*@&&.& A//"!""/6'& *.))*!"9)!""/8<

&.5*)* !5':&!""/'&9'*&&')3 B@.''*5'* #)!""/@'5*.))5'):*&&<



!/01!""/  2A-2   @*)')*5&')*)*5&')5&0':&!""/<

*.&')*&&'B''3&)*')' )'.&,'&')&@.''*5'* #)!""/)5''*01 3&; -&&)&*@)').* 09)!""/<

*.&')*&5&.''*)B*@5&'*.)) * !# 9) !""- ' 1 9) !""? .')' '&.  3& ' 5&)'  )'.&,' &')&* "!3&;!-))B?-"3&;*3&)*')'B*@'&5&' )'.&,' &')& * #/ 3&; %)' 3)' @:9' *@ *.)) *@':& !""?  ''.'B@')* ""3&;%)'&.'.')3).>&&'5&$ *.))*!#9)!""-B&)'53)&@:9'*@*.))3&> ***&&'<

 @&&,' * &): * . * - ':& !""/ *.&' )&&%:  && *.5. > @'& *  *.)) * !" 9) !""/ 6 A//"!""/8 ' '&'''  >)3)B@5&.*&*@55)'))'%&'<

''**&)'B3&.'>@&';-?; ';+; *)4%)& @&4)')9*)))&68 &):'*&)D' )' )B * ''') 5&.% > E&') -? *  ) 3.*.& &  5&') 4..&**&)'*&)*?':&!"""6 8&')%>) 3.*.&&E&2%))'&%)%'*!"*.:& 1#?6 (8<

5.'5&94&**E5$')).':)<

  @&'; -? ;  *     *.)) & 55)') '  '& B%)*E55)')E'5%&''9''>&&<

@ @5$  && )'&9'.  A 9)' !""/ > @'& *  *.)) & 55)')* A9)!""/'&%:<

 @:9' * )')4 ' ))'. >  B') *  &%:))'. * @55)') *  &&'*?9)!""/.''5&.).B2)&.>''&&&)&*  ) * 0 9) !""/ ' B  ''') *  *.)) * !" 9) !""/  3)' @:9'*5&.*& A//"!""/'*@&&,'* -':&!""/<

@&';-!;  *.))5%','&''B.*'&'9& 5&%)*E55)')5&$*E&&B)&*>EF5')**.)) *E&*'*5&.*&<

@@5$@.''*5'* #)!""/&.5)'**=5&&&' 5&5.&)*!""A!""#'!""-<



!/01!""/  2#-2   @5&'))&)'.&,'&')&''.'3)'@:9'**.))5&.: '&.  3& )'  * 1 9) !""? 6 "! 3&; !-8 '  * !" ':& !""? 6#/3&;8<

  3&) * ') > +'& * ?-" 3&; ' .4' 3)' @:9' **)' *.))*!#9)!""-6#""3&;8'* 19)!""?6!-"3&;8<

@&%+')* ""3&;.'.')3).>&&' /='!""- %)&3)'@:9'*@*.))3&'&.3&<

@.B@.''*5'* #)!""/*&G)3)'B &5&*&)'.&,'&')&'3&)*'):9'**.))3& 5&..*'&)'')'&*.))5'):*@55)')<

@'))>9'')'&B@55)')*&&'''B@5&'& )'.&,''3&)5&.)'..'.*.&.)&&%:5&)<

@ &%+ *)' 55)') &)' *= ,'& )*.&.  5&'  ****.))3&&'3&)*')* ""3&;')3). /='!""-<

 * '' &  && & 5&')' *) '  *.)) )')4) .   B) & )B'  ''') * 3&) * ') * ""3&;'3)&.5&&5<

*)'''')&&%C.>):9'*5.'<



!/01!""/  2--2  

 ( /  '& ( % &( (



  0- *

; .&&&&%:<

!; @*'5&')'<

A;   *.)) * A 9) !""/ *  & G  *.& )&&%: @55)')*&&'F3&)*')>+'&* ""3&;')3). /='!""-<

#; %)   > @)'). 3) B@ '&)'  ''') **)' 3&) * ')* ""3&;<

-; 3)&*.))5&&5<

?; )'B5&.*&'4&')'<

/; 3&  5&') *  BE 5%' 3&& && '&  5&.' &&,' *  *.) * A" 9& *$  ')3)') 5&$ * &): 3.*.& 6(+H)I&+3B)??""#  85&%)*&&')$&**&)' 5:)3&.'F&';0!*)3.*.&& &):3.*.&* / 9) !""- 6 J8<  .)& * && *)' )*)B&  ) ')3 ' C*5&%'5&'&)4'&*&&'**')&<)*)' ,'& *&.  &): 3.*.& 5& %) 5'  5& %) .'&)B F *)') * @&'; #!  J;  5&.' &&,' '  5)$  5) * &&')%B.C*5&%*)%','&9)'>@%);  4&33)$&  5&.)*'   C(  .&) 

5)3&*5&.'&&,''')3).F5&')))BE>E33)3.*.& *&)5&4&33



!/01!""/