Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ATAS/117/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/117/2007 Generato dall'IA

Product Liability Expert Testimony Exclusion Reversed

Numero d'incarto ATAS/117/2007
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Parzialmente accolto (Partially Allowed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The appellate court reviewed decisions that excluded certain expert testimony in two separate cases involving product liability claims against a manufacturer, finding that the exclusion in both instances was an abuse of discretion because the expert testimony, which addressed alternative designs and warnings, was sufficiently reliable and relevant under the governing standard. In the first matter, the trial court erred by excluding testimony regarding a safer, economically feasible alternative design and adequate warnings, as the expert provided a non-speculative basis for the opinions, and in the second, the exclusion of testimony regarding a non-hazardous alternative design was similarly erroneous because the expert adequately established the feasibility of the proposed modification.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Product Liability Expert Testimony Exclusion Reversed: In the first matter, the trial court erred by excluding testimony regarding a safer, economically feasible alternative design and adequate warnings, as the expert provided a non-speculative basis for the opinions, and in the second, the exclusion of testimony regarding a non-hazardous alternative design was similarly erroneous because the expert adequately established the feasibility of the proposed modification.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
responsabilità per danno da prodotti superperizia casi di esclusione testimonianze contraddittorie esclusione della garanzia indennità del perito

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied for the allocation of costs to the respondent.

Art. 64 LTF

Applied for the granting of legal aid to the appellant.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo



               "#$%"%&&' ("##)"%&&)

(

 (* *(*  *   

+, -  .# / %&&)



 !"#$!%&'(    "#"

"# !"#$!%&'&   



)

  +   * *    "$1"      *!",-(./)%&(!%&%%    %(

0     &      !1)2'./)!3''&4 !* 



           !

  &53  

* 0(

%8  9:#) " %; <#= &''2!  &># ?#= " = " /#> )/$"<""# !$%-77!)  !$%-7&!@)#$")"7/)#=%-678

&8 *?11-"9:#)/$)$! ="/#>)"$  /): / #)$ " < " /$<, /1 @ / ? "$/A")#:8

(8  9:#) " "< ) "< "$1)1  %' 9< &''7 )  $)$ )# "+11 ="$%-9<&''7/A$)"/):8

38  ="$)$"/)#")))"/$<,! /)/$)))"$1"/)"##@ #)) " <  " /) @ ")  #:! ) )  7 /)#=%-67)%'9<&''78

28 A )# "  "  0         &>#       * "%7#&''7!/))@/")#:/ "#")"&7+(2&182'8*:#)##@$/   +      *                **  **  *    B C29)&''7!+<" < @ ")  #: /  "#" ) " %%3+'%- 18 32 B%&2+63%18('D%%+6&%1862C8

78  &7 9) &''7!  = " $  ##@$ A AD$/A  @ =/):"<"<11)$8

;8 +="+=9)""$1A$!$)$:"$E9:8

* (

%8 +)8&2"1$"$=/:"/$<,/1! <!<<))<")$"%;"$#=%--(B0C!)$<: %9<&'''!>:/$"""<8@9)) /"F"/))")E/):B)8%&&)%&( " <D C! 9:"""<#/$))"+)8;(8%"1$"$ /$<, /1 " &2 9 %-6& BC! ) E ><  = )""/%G)&''(!")!/>@+11  $)$)#B)8%3& C!A$)"+11/):=" $" $/))"$)#$/9:""<8

    5%6&5&''7 (53  

&8 *+)8&&0B<)<:"/%9<&'''C! " "<!  /)) " ) @ ")  #: ) /):$ 1#$#) A)8%&&!%&(!%3%)%3& .)8(E2 0+//@) /:#))E)1$B8%C8?@9)!/))" )E/):/"E"11$)/))")!:#)$ " < " = /: A)) $<)#)  ##) " "<! )  /))")!:#)$"<"=/:A))$<)#) ##)""#:B18)8&30C8!9) E  /)) " ) ) E +< " = /: A))  ##) "   " #:  )$H) "  ##) " "< B 0 %&6  &('. 0%&-333C8

 F/>!  9: " /#> )  "$  /): / #)$ " /)) " ) @ ")  #: /  "#"8  ") /)))!"F/)!"#:!7/)#=%-67!"F)/) %'9<&''7!")E@9:#)""<)"<A$)8

(8 *:#)!/))@/")#:/ "#" )"%%3+'%-1832!)"@#$/"#" ) " &7+(2& 18 2'!  )$H) ,) "$9E $)$ $ /  ))) " /$<,"$1"8 "#"")EAD$/#))" 2;+''-18;'B%%3+'%-1832I&C!)D")#))"%(+%;718&2B &7+(2& 18 2'I &C! " ) @ F)  "#" @ ") )1$ E  "#"#))"3(+6((1832B2;+''-18;'D%(+%;718&2C8

38 1#$#) E  9/"! "/  9 "$)#) /  /): 9@+##)")1)"/))")""#!9) "<$=$$1"))/))")E")$H)#/) #))"D8 )$H))$)A###$:+)8%& "+"/$<,/1<!<<))<")$ " %6 < %-63 B &C    )A $:#)!  D ) /$ B 0/=$(75'&"%69)&''(C

28  $##)   /J!  /$" $)) :)) B)8 ;( 8 &  ) 6-K8%"/$""#))<"%&/)#=%-62C8



LLL



    5%6&5&''7 353  

  (0  (* *(*  *   



12343,, 5  633 3  7! #'% 8

%8 <)    +      *                * *  * *  *       E )1$! " #/) "   ! $  %-7&!  ## " 3(+6(( 18 32 E  0     &>#     1<" "# !#/)"=/:&>#/M;;2'3'8'-8''8''D2! @")$H)#/)""$)!">%'9< &''79@+##)")1)8

&8 F,"#))@"=8

(8 )@/$"):))8

38 1#  /) "  @F /<) 1#  )  /$) H) "  "$ " (' 9 ">  )1) /> " = 1$"$ B*?NO?1@7!7''3  C!/<"#)>"") /=!1#$#)A)86&"1$"$ =1$"$"%; 9 &''2 B 0C.  #$# "  ") "@  ! #)1 ) #,"/<)/):)")"#").") H) "$  = 1$"$ / < /)  / < $)@ A ") " +)8 3&  08  /$) H) )  />  / " )!<@$###,"/<!"<)H)9)E+<8  :11>  $")I              K   * ,    

/1#"/$)H)))1$A/)@FEF111$"$ "/:11

    5%6&5&''7