Statute of Limitations for Breach of Fiduciary Duty Accrual Upon Transaction Date
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAA party challenged the application of a specific statutory time limit to claims involving alleged breaches of fiduciary duties stemming from transactions occurring over several years, arguing that the limitations period should only commence upon the discovery of the breach, not upon the date of the transaction itself. The court reasoned that while fiduciary duties are ongoing, the relevant statutes of limitation, designed to provide finality, mandate that the limitations period begins to run when the transaction forming the basis of the claim is consummated, regardless of when the breach was actually discovered by the injured party; thus, the court affirmed the dismissal of claims deemed time-barred by the transaction date, absent evidence establishing a basis for equitable tolling or an exception to the general rule of accrual upon consummation.
Regesto Legislator
Ufficiale; AM ; LOI FÉDÉRALE SUR L'ASSURANCE-MALADIE ; MESURE DIAGNOSTIQUE ; ANALYSE ; TRAITEMENT À L'ÉTRANGER ; SÉJOUR À L'ÉTRANGER ; LISTE DES ANALYSES | LAMal52
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive for ordering the appellant to pay the costs of the appeal proceedings.
Testo completo
%&'&&%&(() "%)&%&(()
"
" +" + +
+,- & $ *' .- &(()
!"##$""$%!& "" ' (&(
"
) ' '' '' !'*+(,&(! "&$" -&( ./! ' ($0(
!" #$
5/1.65
/ "
.7 !$/8+".22.!00(9"&7 (""00" %$"!:$$0(#""(95*("$!;*(&5 &$((#.*&:.22<!(90&"#$(= /> ?" .226! (9 ":" @ 0 ( #$@ # &#" &A(#/B*&:.226!#%*(=.*&:/33.!"!5 0!(9"(9&#"%*#&(=.+*/33<7
/7 # ! 9$ " 00$ #= (9) ' ' C5 #= D ) ' E # 9 :%" ( * &#$&" 5 ("7
87 .2 ($&: /333! %$ : # ( A #$$;00"(:"#$$7
<7 /8 ($&: /333! 9$ 9" ( #= ( :" ) ' ; # #$( ; 9A ( ( %, ! ( #0 ( ( % ( &&: $A"-A"! ( "&""! ( (&$"(&,7
67 /+*/33.!(":"($;9$"(9-(9 &""(89<8>070F7
47 >*&:/338! $&*:#(5 A#$0,;00"(:"#$$7
B7 "0"&$((//($&:/338! """$, 9$00"((*00"&$":,",@&$ ;9$*"($""("$#",",9G7
>7 /B*&:/338!9$9"(#=(:"(:%&$(5 ( ;,#$($@A(:-&!(9(5 %"(&$":&!(#0((%(&&:$A"-A5 "!("@A("!(#0*"&,!(&$":&$%$",!( &$@!(##"(!(#"$!((%,5 "("&""7
27 .<+*/33<!(":"($;9$"(9-(9 &""(433H287
.37 .4+*/33<!9$"&;) ' :((&((9A5 ""(9-7
1/2//1/334 581.65 ..7 (/.*/33<!) ' 0&$9$,!<0$*/33<! *"(&($!(%&"&$(@; !* ##.3&/33<!",99*""+#F$#!(#: ""&"(("0"7 #$$,$%&""$%#5 *",#""#(#$;9$"%9$""#-% # 95&( ,9 (900" %I *" (" $+ ; 9$"%""&"#*"#J"(#$'7
./7 />*/33<!9$$#(,:"9$"";+ #&(900"A#"-#-A%#$(" #"!"-%$7#$$,A#&"5 ""*"-$#","0;(#"-%("$"""""!; *(":&&""$#-"$;A(&""5 ,7
.87 ##" ( < & /33<! ! &$(5 (9) ' 5 !(,$*""!(9#"!* ,#$5 $,*"%"0";$""((&(--!(9" #"!* ,@#,$*($A# (#:=&%"5""@!((&"""((-$-K0"&5 :"*(K$&"(%7 +"$,*"%"$"" "$"#9"&7 ($0"*! ($$, A0";$""&$(&""="$"&,9##" ,9$""#"0,&"7+"$,,,"" 00"$;"*"("(A7,A5 9$""#;-%(95&($"""*"%5 ""0:'7
.<7 ($0&(4&/33<!) ' 0$#-%( A($"!(9#"!,9#("#;(@& (" 9##" , $"" "0,&" ! (9" #"! , ,5 ,5 ( "" "*" ( " ( A " $"" #",$ (:"7
.67 &&"(.B&/33<!9GG 9 '' 5 C5#= D E 0$ (" ; ( & &$( 0&(9A#-A#"-%#&"0,@&;:"(%5 "9$""#;-%(95*("$7
.47 .3+*/336!9$(&($;) ' (&&,& (:","7
.B7 9$ A" &0"$ ($( * # ( #" ( 4 & /33<! ) ' 0&$#"#($(/>0$*/3367
1/2//1/334 5<1.65 .>7 /.&/336!9$0&$##""("($( %&"""0,*"7$&$"(A7"5 "$ 9##$" ( , #-$ (9* "&($ " (9* "":$ ; 5 ( ## &%7 ($$ , 9##" , ( A 5:%, $"" #&&"$"0,""(##$7(&5 ($,"0,0F!",*$%#"J""( ",9($:""("""$* 7 0!5 #-$ ; ) ' ( 9* # # ( %&" #= ( !#$"&$(""-&$#"-7
.27 ##"(//&/334! "&$,99$""#-5 :"(0""(9@&(:"(00$"(*"%"( 9"&7 @#,$ , " $ """ (9@#, 9"& # #:=&""(&:#"",&$("$#9$ $""((#"7#$$,""##-9$""#0&$#&$5 ("("7(,$,""##-&$(9$""# "0,&"!##A$#&+"$(#$"(9"&( ""$""0,@""7
/37 ($##"(//+/334!) ' +"$9##"7 (,$,"(A""#"*",A0%" #"""#*"#J"&:$!,9"00"$ ' ; 9$"%7 #$$ , A #",$ ; 9$"% 9$""&::,$""$#"$( "(A * &, (," ,9 $"" @$"$ ; 9$"%7 +"$ ,!((9$!%(&:(A#",$0" ##"("(A",,A$""$&$$ ""#&"(9@$";9$"%7 "!%$, A ( :" , #*" J" 00"$ ,9; 9$"% #*" J"(&"("(&(;9000$($("$#5 :,C5#=DG'E7
/.7 0@ ( 2 ?" /334! 9$ (&($ : " ( ((($(#$((*# $#(;($##"7#$$,9$""##:! #" :(0*0,9##"($&#"7
//7 (..?"/334! :0&$9$!(9#"!,9*" %"$!(9"#"!,9"((*"J"%$""5 (,9@#$"(&"0*,$7&#" ($ /> ?" /334 # "0 ; @% #$" ,9 (9:*"(##"!"($$*:7
1/2//1/334 561.65 /87 .B?"/334!) ' 0"#"(##@"$,"($,$"$ %0$# :#0#*$#$""($,""( 2?"/334#*"#J"($$&&7 $,! "&$,9#*"#$#(;(%&",9*"# $"$*$"""(9"""(9$*"&"*"(#"(9$7
/<7 /8?"/334! :0&$) ' ,9($*"$"$&#" #",("($#$""$*$7
/67 &J&+! :($;9$($4#"&:/334# &#$"7
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
/B7 $#(/2#"&:/334!9"&$;9*:"$(5 !:(&"!;+"7 ($$,(4#"&: /334$"$0&$"(*&"!"0+#=$-$!/>?"/3347 "&$, :*",0$;""((9$ (2?"/334,9$"",9(&((%&"7#!"5 ,(@=&#%"(($($/8?"/3349$""#(5 &:(=,#$*A"9",(9($#&:
1/2//1/334 541.65 ( 7 *$ , &(0" ( " ( A #*"#J":"( ((#$"#$(!&(*"0 9:+" (9 (&( #= ( 9G'7 #! " , " 9*" (" ; :" ($ """ ( "0, ( A "% #,9 ($ 0&" $"" #:7 #!0&$#""%$,,"(# -%(A#&#$&"@$("(("% (=,9$""*,$##&=07 M :""" ""(&(9%(9"""$((("" (9!#$",&#$&""#5 "#&"""##-%(#""!(" (9"(#""(9$+;9$"%9$""#$$7
/>7 .8":/334! :&&,$""$""7
/27 !/B*&:/334!%($;+%7
"
.7 %*N%"+(CE$"$&(0$"""$!(= .?"/338! :"(!&#$(6+%! (" #$(" " *5#$("! 6 ##$" " .4 +% C"7."7"64 E7
'";N"(N$"(.4+%!# :0$($ /B+*/33<C G.83.34E!( %*(#"$!.80$*! (#"""%"#&""" :"( ( $% ; " +% ""! ! ( N""" ( N$"(*@+%7
0&$&";9"7647."7-7<! :"(5 O"",("""#$*;N"64( 0$($#"%$$(("((4":/333 C E,""*;0$($N5&((.>&.22< C E7#!##"(9"7647."7!O"$%&" ",(""""*@&#$&"; ! " ; N5(" :%" #$* # 0$($ N5("(/3&.2>.C E7
' :(0"!(J"(/4?"/336C 661/336E! : " ( " ($& ( N&: ( ""@&"=(N&#$&"#*$!""((&
1/2//1/334 5B1.65 (N5&(,((N5("!,"" &#$&""00"""#&(,#"""(95 #*$"$#9000$($(7
/7 " "$ *% . +* /338 "O" &(0" ( &: (#" $% ( (& ( 7 ' #&"$!#"(*,("9##,("J""-$;&= (##,=%##:"*%&&"M 0"+(,&"($"&""#("C G.83/83(7.7.! 886(7.7/!./2<(7.7/!./B<4B(7.!./4.84(7<:" $0$E7
N#=!#$"#-%(9A00"$ ($&:/333"*&:/3387 ""($,0"($"&"" $$#"*""#=N"$*%( !(";# -%(A("J"@&$%((9("##$5 ( +,9 8. ($&: /33/ " 0"( * $%&"" $5 %#=""("C G.83<<6"$0$P07 G.838/2E7 &(0" $% " ( """! =% %$$! *0&$(!(+#("*@"5 #("*"9"$*%( P9($&(05 " ( #" ( * ( "! ( " , +#( ($*##$ ; ###"J"#"##,$C G.838<6(78E7
" @ =% ( #$(! 9##,"! 0 (#" "" "!;"(=9"$*%( C G.8. 8.<(7878!..B28(74:!../843(7<P .22>Q8B #78.4(78:E7
87 &"= ( ! (" J" 0&$ # $" ( ($ ( "" +C"7437. "4<7. E79@%(0&$"&#, $&"(9%"&"C07 G../.B8E7(5 ($"$!A(9@%,9"("&(%" % ( "P 9" , %" 0% ,9 #-"# 9"#*:7J&#*A""$$0@%9%#5 !,"(##";"&!9""$"(&""*(5 "$(9"+(("%"#*",9C"$$E#! (,(9:C G../.B8! G././6/(78E7
&$&(*A$#"$$#&#"!#($0"!,9 #(%"("!,""@@%$%7 $,",""$$##0#*"&$&" (9&:$ , " " *$7 " , ($# "! (" #" %9$%"$C:(%"E!&#""9"(9($#
1/2//1/334 5>1.65 $#*"9""(0";#%"(($(7 9"#+"0$(#"$%"&#"&",9##";9:(("! #,#"#J"($#$*:&"&A(9 "$$#C G././6/(7<:E7
9"74."7: #$,9"((*"+("" (" " @#$ " ( 0" " ( &"0 *,$! , !,*"(9&#"($*:"# &:!9*"",9(9:*"!$5 "$7'+%,"(9("#&""",9##$ 0& " " ( 9" ( ! 9"$$ (" $& &0" &" " # $" *"$ (9 :" &(0"P ; ($0"! 9$" ,9#("#"J"($$&&($"(C G..4 864 (7 /: " $0$P G #:$ ( /> +* /338! 63.13/ (7/7/P .22<R.2/#7.63(7<E7
<7 9#=!#0@(2?"/334!"(&($ :(5 (($#$#(;($##"(//+/3347 && 0"&,*9"&$!0@"""#"(! &(&((#%"(($!(9#"!(""! (9"#"!(9:(*("$(90&$#0@7=! 9";"",%000&$"!..?"/334!,9*"%5 "$";,9&#"($/>?"/334#"0 @@%$%0&"&"$!"(+(($#5 %$ ( 7 00"! #, ($ ##" $"$ @#$($ //+/334&&($!$"$F#"/4+/334!( " , ($ ( &&$ ; /B + /334 C"7 8> 7 . E!$"$#((.6+".6?"/334C"78>7<"7: E" " *$;$-$ (/>?"/334C"78>78 E7!/8?" /334!%00#%$;""($#&#$"#,95 9*"$"$0&$+,97 $,!(4#"&: /334(*"J"($$"(07
"0!(";#""(:0!($("(9"7< "7!"@#5 $&"$;9"72 "7'+#((9("!, ""+*:C G./B84(78!./48>B(78P /333 RQ./4#7//8E!9(&""("9:"(""&#"&"##; "	(&"$"""*"%($,(9 " 00 ( #"7 "A #" @% ( 9""$ ,9 0& @ #& ,9 0" " "&# # 0 ,9 $%"&&" #$ ( 57 &J& 0F! (" ; #"" ( : 0 #" J" *,$ #$!  &"!(9&#"&"(9(&""#":(9$*-K9(&"$ """#$$%"&C G./28>.(7B7."&:5
1/2//1/334 521.65 $0$"$E7!("&"**"(*"J" $D0",9""$""*(""=";9$%(( #($"&$!,9"%"$*%(&"( &#$"!,9(&"$9"#(&#"&&$("&"(9@5 ""( ( %&" :"! ,9 " 0($ 5 # #( ( (#",9"&(0:#$+(!0!,9" # -%$ (# &&" M %&" $"$ ($ C G ./. 44 (7/"$0$E7
9#=!"&0",%00($(0("5 ","($("(#"#0&7"# (#"#@#$((($&#"#%00#=* #$$,#%"(($9$""##:!-""J"5 0&$0(#*#"($$%7 0"@("($ #%00!:"#$+(!;*9&#:"$(0*"" +(,# :("(*"$(7 $,! ("J"#"$%$(0,9#$(("($# %00(",("J"($$*:7
67 "%#"("("&:&"(A00"$; /8($&:/333"/B*&:/3387#!"$%&" # ( ," ; # -% ( A "" ( N5&(&#$&"7
$%" 95&( , &#( 9 :%" ( " 0""* (9(&"$ += C"7 . 7 . E! , &#$&" #",$ # 5 &("&("#*$"$%#0$($""(95 (/*.23>C P"7./7/"8 E7 ""($,5 """,9(";(#""(#"(9"&$"":( 95&( :%" , ( "" (9 &#$5 &"!$"(4#"&:/334"!#"!&"=( "!#"!(&(#&"0($&#$5 &"*"( 7 $,!(#&"&#!A (9A(9$"*!#!" (&(#&"7
47 '9"7/6 !9:%"(#( -% ?" (#"",*";(%",;""&("$, C7.E7 #""&#""&&"A!&$(&"!&A "##(%","-$#",#"#&$(!( &"0@$# 0$($!#-#"C7/"7:E7#"5 "&"$;9"7/6 (*"J"00!###$"$&5 ,P900"$("J"($&"$(&$"-("0,C"78/7.
1/2//1/334 5.31.65 E7 900"$! 9($," " "= $&, ( #"" " $@&$ #$(,&" C"7 8/ 7 / E7 0&$&" ; 9"7 8< 7 . !#*"##(-%!""(9:5 %"(!(9"?",@(#""#$*@"7/6;887
B7 9#=9"76/7."7 !#=*"$ &&0$($( A! $#"&" $(" " ( A * "0 C-7 /E7 G" %(""&#$"!$#"&"$":"(AC !5 @8;9 'E7 59"##:$(00(("0$($ CE(A"$&",C'P"7/378 'E7 """(5 A"@-"*C /33/RQ.24#72E7 @"&(9"7B8 ! 9(& ( " #" J" " (9 &""P 5 #" "&5 &"##";,""$@("&$(7"&"" """("&"("S(9$&"$"#0&(5 "" ( #"" C /33. R Q .6> #7 .6> (7 /(P ' ! QT*-%! D '-UK- (*U"%-" V'W!'K'--"!#7.3.!7<84E7
& (#" (9@$" 0& " &"$ $("$ # 0$($@"743 !#"*&"#$#"&"C0($"7 4/"B6 E@"7/> '##"*"(A!9"74. #$*"("(9(&(9A("(A7
>7 '9"78<7/ ! 0$($ #"($((# -%! # 9 :%" ( ! ( ?" ( #"" #$* @ "7 /6 7/ /2 0 ; 9$"% # ( &$( C#&= #-E7'0("""($$%"(&#$"!9""$@$"*$("$ 9"784 !""$X"";9$"%Y7'9"7847. ! $#"&" ($%! #= * "$ && &#$""! #"5 "#$*@"7/6!7/!"/2(("?"$;9$"% "#-%#9:%"(,9#*"J" 0'7G!*"(&&("( && 0$($ ( #"" %$$! 9" :" (9$": "! #$" , 9$""#$:#",C* G./>B4(7<:E7
#(#"(.2($&:/338#("(A C*(.+*/334!#783"8.E!9G '#$$,9"(#5 ""&$(,0"#N:+"(N"#"*!A(:5 ""$%$#"("A#!,&%(&* @;(N""7'"N$""#!##(" #"* " ( " "$7 #("! ( A , "00"$,N;N$"%#*"J"(&("(5 A : (N (&( ($ ; NG ' CG' (# . +* /33<E7A(:",0%"#("(A
1/2//1/334 5..1.65 (*"#J"&:$!,N"00"$ ';N$"%7 (="&::,0%"("(A *&,(,",9"0";9$"%7
27 9"#"":,A#",$;#*"#J"5 ($$&&($"(9%(=,($#&";9$"% *(9A00"A@"#$$&""=7
""($,A,"00"$,9;9$"%#*"$%5 &"J"(&("(A:(9(&(($; 9G'! 0" (&"" ,9 9A # (9@&! && *" # ""&" 0 ,&" ; 9$"%! 9 9@" #:"$ ( ""5 &" ' ,9 & "-$#", 00"$ ' &#"" ##""(,&#"""":&"#$*$,9;9$"%C07 G.8./B.(787/P /338RQ/68#7/8.(7/E7*"! #$,"!(*$0A""$0%"("(5 A*&,(,",9"#",$;9$"%7 9#=! #= * @&$ #&" " ( A! : 9 "*$ &,"*;9@$"(9A#",$;9$"%(" ,90"($(,9;+!A00"$;9$"%9$"$5 #$ ( " ( A7 ! " #$"( # , ( A"*"("(A"##",$'7
$,! *" (9(&"" ,9 9$""! A 00"$ (:""#-%# 7=!"" , A"%(($&:/333" (*&:/338" $"$#"5 ,$;!9";+""",9"&$0$#-%7
"!"#-;9"&$(#*@&$(($ ##"("(900"$($&"$"0,&"(A #$$#0G (""&"(9"&#$%& &"%""$7
"%&""";&"*"(($##"7 "&"; , "" "! 9"&$ 9*" # ; #$( ; " @& (= ,A"$"$#",$G",A005 "$'";-%(9(( 7
!( $"!"(&(; &&&#$"" (9000$($(C"G'E(#$(;$* (*("$"0,("(A&:$7 :9$"" #&#$""#"""","!*"";("&" 9G'0&$&";9"74.7. 7
1/2//1/334 5./1.65 0!"#-;9"&$(#*&&,$&&" &(:"#":(#",A#"# ( :" ( " ; &:&"7 *"(#$,"","0"##"(9:+"("%#, 9""$(&""*&#$""9"##$;+"(($5 ##"7 00"!(#$( +("(&""*! #*" J" @&$ " +%$! ##! , ##" +(, ; ## (, 9""$ (&""* &#$"" 9" #$ #$:&" (9 &=,!0&(9($7""&!($($5 "&9:+"(""",#"J"($0$$+"#*(7 *-!(&M($9$"$(!"""9 # (9:+"! " +%&" 0( #" # J" ( C G ./6 <.< (7.!..2:84(7.:"$0$"$E7 (&"!"A#( %&" 9&: # ; 9"&$ (= , 9$ : -@ ( 0(#""&#"("("784;<3 C07"7 86 E",5&(9(#;9&&(""&"7 $,!##"""(%"","#=( &$(!#"*&"#=(9:"7
.37 " "% &"= (95&( &#$&"! 9"7 <4 #",0($0"(/<&/3330CGE(" 9"78"7:#$*",0"!#"(%$"#&5 !(=%7 9#=!9"&$=%;Z:(0(5 "([-7 "0!9"78/(("%$$(9# 5&(&#$&"C5#=D E#$*","&#$"" #"""+"(#$"""!-@!":@((& '(9$@(=%(97"$"(00*: ; 9$ " (& # 9"7 2 G " &#" (" ( *("$ ( " , : ( $ " $%&" &#$"" # O" ( #$5 "(&(7
0$($*("#(N(.B($&:/33< C' 5'24.73.E""#(=%#$0,"($, (*":*$,"("""($#&"= (9&#$&"!"(($9A"(O"#&J& , ( (& ( 9 :%"7 *-! 9"7<4 7.!.=#- !9$("("&"9""$+(#* (9",("J"""$((@;("(0"(9MO"9:%5 ",($*(""(N7""""*@5 &#$&" ; N5&( ( ! 5 "#$*"#$(&#"#((,+%$":"(N00 0""##$:&"#*C"7>67/' E7
1/2//1/334 5.81.65 9#=!0"0"O"9:%"($*"(""(9" 0""(A00"$;($&:/333"*&:/338! ; * 0"" ( / +* /33. # A ( /333 " ( .<+*/33<#A(/3387 "",(&( 5 :($4#"&:/334!%"(*&"(*"+("&5 #$"""(($(#((@(#-(0""!( ",(&("#"7
#!9#(";#-%:(&5 #$&"7 00"!9$""&&"*"#9&#$&5 "( ##""#$!;*#""#(&$(5 &":%"!#"";9$"%!"(#!0( "#"! ( *! &A " ##! ""&" (9"-#$( &@ #0",0&("-$##$C"7.(("#5 #$&"(9P5#=D ' E79"78( ' #"" ;9$"%"#",?"(""&"&:""-#"% "#-%($+"&#;9$"%+,9;(K&# "",99%(9%",9#"&""0"($"5 :&"-#"##J":&"@%$7
""#(=%(9"#$""(""7 &&* #"",9=%#5&J&C"7.33 E!+#( &"=("""##:79#=5!("%$$0" #" "$%" ( ""7 (#" "" #$0&$ " ##"#$"$&J&=%,""$(%$ (*(&" C G .// ..> (7 /P ..B 432 (7 4 #7 4/.E7 +%900!#&!(($"&&&"$""( #"!9J"@@#"($&"@"(""# *!"# !"#($%"*$":( *" C"7.>7. P G./B<<<(7.:E7
'9#*"#;$":*?"$""*"$00"*!9"", 9 ( """ 9 # &# *"$ $ @#&$ # 9"! 5 --,#"#*""(*"(!=%( :0!;&0""(*"$$#,C##"(##( 0P G.//..>(7/P..>8</(7.#78<<58<6P../ /<6(71.#7/685/6<E7##(0#&"(9&#"; #":+"0(&#"&"!&J&5#(#; *"$"&C G./B/B2(7/1#7/>B"$0$("5 7
9#=!("""C&&&E!$+" 0" ($+(!(#A!#(""" $5 ,!"($+&#,"($"&#",@"
1/2//1/334 5.<1.65 #% ( " ($ && ( ( (&( , 9" ( ; 9$"%(:"(#$(;(AC07 G (<+"/334#$* ##:"!2/136!(7478E7
0! (&( " $%&" *" # 9 &#$&" ( ' ##$*""&$(#=79"7/76 ' ' (5 &"#-%(""&"(&$(#=($+"&5 #;9$"%+,9;./&#"",#$( # ; 9$"% ( :" (9A J" ""$7 ! ( ( (&(! 9" #$$&"(;#A:(A(",!&J&(5 =(*"J"($$&&0"#"(9""&"(&$( #=!#"#J"#-%#""&#$5 &"7
..7 &#""(,#$=(!N*=&0($"(&(("J" +"$7
+ !" / " +" + +
$
0.1-- 2 3 45 *)& #6
1-
.7 $"(&(*:7
$ 1
/7 +""7
87 ",#$("%""7
<7 0& #" ,! 9%" ( 0$($ N5&( ( .> &.22<!#*"0&"#$"J"(($(83 +(="0"##&&($($ :0$($ (5 !'-UK-0,4!433< !"@($#" J"#%$7&$&("DE(,@"&",($"
1/2//1/334 5.61.65 ($:""#(($"",$P:E@##,&"0 "&#*(&("""($PE#"%"( #$""7'&$&""#"$$&"$&$$"" E:E"E5(! :0$($(##"&5 "= ,N (* ($ *:7 &$& ( &5 "&A(#*!,"+"!,($""5 ,$"N*##(,$"$@#$($"C"7.8/!.34" .3>E7
67 0& #" ,! 9%" ( 0$($ "" (9 ( /*.23>"(&"("<8"4>(0$($9%5 "+((.4($&:.2<8!#$"J"#"09:+"(95 :0$($(""+(="0"7&$&(5 ($"@&# :"(!.>! ("5!./3.=*7#$"J""#=#(5 "!*,$&&&A(#*!(*"J"+";9*7 %00= #$(" \I [ :' $"5+"D -## \
#0&(#$"J"""0$@#",N;N000$($ ("$#:,#%00
1/2//1/334