Statutory Interpretation of Property Forfeiture Criteria
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case addresses an appeal concerning the proper interpretation of a statute regarding the forfeiture of property used in criminal activity. The court reasoned that the statutory language, when read in context with related provisions, clearly indicated that the forfeiture provision applied only to property seized under specific enumerated circumstances, which were not present in the appellant's situation. Therefore, the lower court erred in ordering forfeiture because the seizure did not meet the requisite statutory criteria, leading to the reversal of the forfeiture order.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Statutory Interpretation of Property Forfeiture Criteria: The court reasoned that the statutory language, when read in context with related provisions, clearly indicated that the forfeiture provision applied only to property seized under specific enumerated circumstances, which were not present in the appellant's situation. Therefore, the lower court erred in ordering forfeiture because the seizure did not meet the requisite statutory criteria, leading to the reversal of the forfeiture order.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAApplied for the order regarding court costs.
Applied for the order regarding legal aid.
Testo completo
!"#$"!%&&" !""'!%&&(
)
* +,* - * -+
"" %&&(
#. / 0
1111111111
+ - 2-+ - +- ! " #$! %&'( )* ++,-
. &/.
3+
%2 3", 4444444444 - "-,5 %1&2 6-*+ %11'! "+*- " 3+ 4444444444! 7 "--"- *+ %1182 9 + : 7 9- -- ,+ 5--6+ "9 " ** ;
,: " % ,+ %1182
&2 ( 6-*+ &'''! + <*+ " ,:+ =+.:) > "? 6- "+ ; + + " ,:+ 6 " 9-! ",+++- ; 9-<! *+ :+ -"2 9 7 9 :@ 7 " " 6! "A! *+ + 9B< " "+C.#+ ( 5 %118 79 -7! " ** + "? $ ::+,- * 66 % *,5 %1182
02 "-++ " ( 6-*+ &'''! " -,- ; 9- ++ " , *- : :-+" " *,5 %118 ; 6-*+ &'''! + %&D 8 62
2 9-! : " 5 6+! -<- 7 ++ " ,, -,- ,+ " ++ 6++) "+66++ 6,, ","- ,+ " 95+<+ " +2
2 "-++ " &% , &''%! E- "," ,+6 7 * " 9- "-:+ +,+ 6+C- : + 7 ") ! :*+ +"- 7 ,5, " ,, -,- ,+ " ++ "+66++2
F2 + " *+ &''% . "- ; ,+ : "+) ;
,,++ " ,+) "9 G ,, 5E " ,:- .! 9- +E- "-++2 6+ ,7 7 ":+ 0% , &''%! 9C : "9+*+- +* 79+ + ") +,:+5 " ,5 ,, -,-2
82 *+- ; :! ! " :-*+ " %0 E+ &''%! E " 2 : 7 :,+) "++ ; ,+ -+- :+7 9- ,+6, " 5 6+ ,+ 7 *! *#! :-+ " &'D''' 6 C "-: ",+ : *+ 79 ,5, ,+ " ++ "+66++2
/%01%/&''% . 0/.
(2 + " %' E+ &''%! 7 * +< +,+ 6+C- : +2 6+ ,7 79 - +*+- +* ":+ 0% , &''% "," 7 "+ 6 95E "9 -C, 5 " "-+ 6+ &''%2
12 :+ :+! ","- ; 9+-- :+ " "-+ 6+ &''% 6+ " :*+ -C,+ "+2 9- 9 6+, C-- : + " && *+ &''&2
%'2 7 ++ " 9-+ : ,"+6+- 79 :! 9-+ ,+- " " % , &''%! + :+- " +! 6+ ,7 79 :-"+ +6,+ * "-: " E+ " 9-2
%%2 + " %' 5 &''0! 9- -7- 7 -:C *+ :+ -" "+:+ " "9 *2 9::+ " "+! :"+ + " 9",+++ 6+ 79+ 9-+ : C5 &''&2
%&2 + " %8 *,5 &''0! +! * " * --,! ",+ 7 ++ 6++) " :*+ $ +"-- ,, "+66++2 ) 7 "++ " 5 6+ " #< : " -+ ,:+! 9+- ++,- " ::- "9: "," " ,+ "95+<+ " + " 2
/%01%/&''% . /.
-+
%2 + " % *,5 &''& ,"+6+ + <*+ 9<++ E"+++ = H & '>! - *+< % ? &''0! ++- +5 " + + +7!
,, + +* ; + 6-"- 9.
*++ =+.:) G IG (0%2%'J H 62 + %! F +- %!
#+66 % >2
6,-, ; 9+ 0 +- 0 " "+:++ ++ " + " % *,5 &''& ,"+6+ ! +"+ * 9- *+< " + :-+- :" "* ,,++ " ,+) "9.*++ -- ,+ "966+ +5 " +2 ,:- " +5 " - ") -5+ : K " :- ++<2
&2 + :! 7D 5 " --, " 7 "-++ 7- - :+! ,"+6+ : " E7D;
D*+ " -: 2 * "-++ "+ $ +6+- :- ; + " D+- " =62 L&'%1 " ++ +C>2
02 9:)! 9++,- 9 : : " " * "-++ :+79 9-+ "-E; C:+,- 2 9 " - " 6, ::++ M 7 ":+ "-++ ++<+! ++ -,+7 " 9- 9-+ ,"+6+- 7 ,5, " , -,- ,+ "-,+ " ++ 6++) "+66++! + ", 7 "++ "9 ,+ -+2 *+ "9 :" " " "-++ 2
/%01%/&''% . /.
-+3 +,* - * -+
45 6 7 8 79: ";% -<
7 5
%2 - *5 H
5
&2 9", H
02 "-++ " : + <*+ " ,:+ " " &% , &''% : "," " ,+ 6,- : H
2 6, :+ " 7D :* 6, :- E<, " "-+ " 0' E ") +6++ : :+ ,,"- "- +5 6-"- " ! G#N+O#67+ F! F'' ! + C,:+2 ,-,+ "+ M > +"+7 C, 7 "-++ "-+ 5+ + : " "-++ 7-H 5> C: : 7 ,+6 +, :*+ "," "-++H > : +< " " :-2 G+ ,-,+ + : + --, -,-- > 5> > +."! +5 6-"- " : : ,+) 7D+ "* "- +*52 ,-,+ " ,+ ,A " :*! 7+ E+ ,-,+ D+ D<+ " :+) :+ " 2 G -<, E+ ,-,+ "-++ 7- D*:: " 7 -- C:-"+- =2 %0&! %'F %'( >2
<66+) M -+" M
+ PP Q+ G Q
:+ 6, " :- $ +6+- C :+ ++ 7D; D66+ 6-"- " + : <66
/%01%/&''%