Buyer v. Seller: Breach of Contract for Defective Goods
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe dispute arose from a breach of contract concerning the sale of goods, where the buyer alleged the delivered items failed to meet specified standards, leading to a claim for damages and return of payment, while the seller counterclaimed for the unpaid balance. The court reasoned that the contract's terms regarding quality specifications were not met, finding that the seller's tender of performance was defective and constituted a material breach, thus justifying the buyer's rejection of the goods and granting the buyer the relief sought, including the refund of prior payments and dismissal of the seller's counterclaim.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Buyer v. Seller: Breach of Contract for Defective Goods: The court reasoned that the contract's terms regarding quality specifications were not met, finding that the seller's tender of performance was defective and constituted a material breach, thus justifying the buyer's rejection of the goods and granting the buyer the relief sought, including the refund of prior payments and dismissal of the seller's counterclaim.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited for the decision on court costs imposed on the appellant.
Testo completo
&'()&*((+ "&)),'&*((+
"
" #" # #
#- * % )* . *((+
!"###$% &"&'
"'&
(( ( )* !& #'#$ "'+&#',-%
! "#! $%
20.32 "" /"
4#25&6 &"&'7 8' #&#' 5&6 8 8 4#25&6 7! ' 98 $#2& $'$ ":&';5'+&0--/<5'+&0--3=
&' $#2&! &"&' "5$ 5"# '5"&#&! &' > "#=
&"&' 8' #&#' % ": ' "##'$ 8"'&"# 8##'$ ?"&5#;5'+&0--3=
5&$##"0-"'"+&0--3!8 &?'$!"'#@9 "#'#""'#'#"8$'#'5&5#!'98#8A:#'5#+$&'#" 8"+#B'#""'#&=
&"&'@#'"55"#'#"0":+&0--3=
$##"&"55"#'#"C>?:#&0--1!8 "@#&5"#'#"! "#'#" 5&$: 5& &'D C/ ' C, "# & 8&2EFB ' 8#":+##'$4#25&6 78$''5&5#=
"&"&1@$:&#&0--1!&"&'G5#99"#6&# @#'#B&"'"'85"5&#'&!'98"##'"#' 8"'&"#8##'$?"&!"#'&5&#""5'#"'5"&#&=
&$5" 0< @$:&#& 0--1! 8 "' &?' &"&! "'''9&"&'"''55&5#&"#'#"&'#:% 5$&#""'#'#"!'98'&5&'#B$"&&#&&$&:# & '" ##9' 98 $#$ &"5& " "'&' 85"# '5"&#&!5"&&#"5&"=
&#+"&"$"5&'#"5&"5&'#!9#8'' 0<&0--1=
8%''"#"&"&'G5#9$:"#&$'$5$ ( ( 6"#?#'0--,!"H'&##':I'' 988 5 "# "' "&&#& 9 # @#' #B& !'8"5&5'&=
&#+ 5&"$$ % 8#'#" ! 9#'$ '$"#! C0 5'+& 0--1D 2# $&$ &"J'& 5&@#'' &"&'!"'8"5"#&D 8'"6B9#@#'#B& "&&#&9'#"%&"&'D(8B#'#&"'&5'& "'&'! G5#9$ 9 &"&' $'#' : :"#& % @# 8$ 0--,.$+'0--3##'98"E#'#'&&I'&"'&:#!98'#'
.//.0--1 2/.32 5+#'98$'#'@'#B$D("'#'$'$98"E#'#'''&@#% " "'&'D 5&$#$ 98 &E&E#' '"?"& '#:' 5"# '5"&#& 5"& &"&'! 9# &#' "& 5"& &$ C0 "# % '5 5#=
8%8#8#!&"&'$&$9#"5'#"'5"&#& 5":#'#I'&5&"5"$$#&#"+!5"&&$C0"#!9# ":&#'&"#'G##'$EFB!&"&&#'&'#&$=#"! &$&:#'&"#'@#&'&"#6&#A'@#'#B&"&&#&=
5&"&&#&0,"'"+&0--1!8 #@"&$ &#+$9 &"&' $'#' # +$$@# 8 5"# '5"&#& '" 5# C, 5'+& 0--1! % C-- K! 5"& C0 "#! 9#'$ 85"A$ #" &#&$=
&#+ @#G$$# % &"&'0-":+&0--1!5"&&'#&& G5&$'"&"&!$''5&$#$98%$@'&&I'"'''9&"& $'#':"+?'&#'&=
8 8+ 8$&#'& &"&' % ' @#G$! 5&'# "' $'$ #@"&$5&5#0>":+&0--1!9$'#'B&$%?B&D
LLL
#0 " "
"#B:"#&M"&B#'#"?###&47$'$"#@#$'#'#'$! 6 C& "N' 0--/! &#+ '" & "#! "5"$ 3 ?B! "' 5&$#' ' :#25&$#'! 3 55$' ' C1 ?B & 4&'DC'D&'31 7=
#'%M'#"M$'#"C1?B&!5& &#+@$$& 0> ?:#& 0--, 4 C/- C-17! & "# B:"# "5'$! C/ @$:&#&! #5"#'#" '&#'"#& &B' 5&''' &#+ '" & "# #$B& & % '&"# ?B '#'#&! ! M'''M$'#"":G?B&=
"@"&$' % 8&'D 31 D C 'D ED < ! &#+ '" &"#"J'#'#9"'''#"5&$:%M&'# 31 9#"'&'#:%"#@$$&&M&2EFB"+#B'"#&' M##'$M#":+##'$03?#C;<0D
8 "'&! "@"&$' % 8&'D 31 D 0 'D + ! &#+ '" &"#"J'#'#9"'''#"5&$:%M&'#
.//.0--1 2,.32 ,; #$ '&"# "# '" '#6& EFB 4#25&6 7! CC ":+&C;</!'#6&5&''#"'""5$'#&=
"5$'5"&?B&M56'##$'+#=
8#'&?'$@"&'$#5&$:5&"#!&"&'&:+4&',; D/ '3>' 7=
8G'&&'D<!C/'C, !8&$&"#'%8##'$EFB! "''8#&5#'"#'#"&'#:%5$&#""'#'#"!"' #+$&$=
8 856 # @#' 5 "'! # 8' "''$! 9 &"&' 8 5 G&$8'#:#'$"#%"'#'#"&'C0 "#"#$#2& ":&'@:&!5#9'#:#'$G&$$#2&$'#' $5"A$ % '#'& 8"5'#" '5"&#& 5&6 ( ( !9#8&$5'"#=
8#'&'#"5& &#+5$'+#&9!8@O""8'&! &"&':#'@#':"#&$''@'#B5"&''&@#"'&'8"5'#" '5"&#&!"&'98"&&#&8#'&&"5'#$'$"#5"&#B'&5& "#6&=
&"#' '" 5&$:"#'! "''! " & "5$'#& '"EFB85"#'5"&#&4&'D>'D 7D:'"'' +$$@##& EF& A' $5#$ & &"#' G ##'$ @$$& 9# 8"' 5'&":$'&:#&#$"'&"#'%8"'#"&'"&5"#4&'D/; D C ' +7 7D M5"# '5"&#& ' "@@&' % '#'& ##:# " & M 5&"B& "'#@ ' "&&5" & 5"#+ G 5'#' 5&"@#" EF& 4&'D /; D 0 7D $&" # M##'&'#" '"! M$'+#' ' @"'#" &"#' 5+#! M##'&'#""'M##'&'#"'&$B#@$$&4&'D/;D/ 7D8&'D,,DC 5&$:"#'9&:#8#&'#"5&"@#"5&"5" 5"# '5"&#& EF& 9# @#' $&#' ' 9# &5#' "#'#"@#G$G&'#,C!,0',,"#'"=
"#'#" "' &5# 856! ' "' 5& #& 5 #'#B#!":5"#'5"&#&A'$'$5&"5"$%&"&'5# C,5'+&0--1=
8#$"9#5&$69&"&"#'I'&&?'$''98#5"&'& 5#'8##'$?"&6;5'+&0--3!"#'#"8 $'' 5 &5#! ' $&$ "+?' 5"& 9# "& 8"5'#"'5"&#&!9#$'$"&$%&"&'D
.//.0--1 23.32 # "/ " #" # #
%
2.3 4 5 67 )+* $8
3
CD $&&"&&:+D
% 3
0D &?'' '' 98# 5"&' & 8##'$ ?"& 6 ; 5'+&0--3D
/D $&"+?'5"&&5D
,D #'95&"$&'B&'#'D
3D @"& 5&'# 9M 5:' @"&& &"& "'& 5&$' &&I' $# /- ?"& 6 "'#@#'#" 5& 5# &"$ &$ &#+ @$$& &! (EP#Q&E"@9# 1! 1--, ! '&"# G5#&D $# 5' I'& 5&""B$D $"#& "#'R 7 ##9& G''9$##"&"&'$#&"+'#&#'5$##" ''9$= +7 G5"& 5"& 9 "'#@ # '# 5":"#& & '' '& $##"= 7 5"&'& #B'& " " &5&$''D (# $"#& "'#' 5 '&"# $$' $$&$ " ''& 7 +7 ' 7 #2! &#+@$$&&5"&&5'&&'#6&&&"&9M# :&$&&#&&:+D$"#&&"&'#"&"&"A 5&:! 9# &"' ?"#'! ## 9 $##" ''9$ ' M:"55 9$'$G5$#$&"&'4&'DC/0!C-1'C-<7D B&@@#6&R &$#'R STQ ++"#
"5#"@"& 5&$' &&I''"'#@#$G5&'#'(&$'&#'M ''% M$""#5&B&@@
.//.0--1