Contractual Liability Cap Enforcement
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case involved a dispute over the validity of certain contractual provisions concerning a pre-established liability cap for damages. The court reasoned that the language used in the agreements, when interpreted in the context of the entire agreement and relevant commercial understanding, clearly and unambiguously demonstrated a mutual intent to limit liability to the specified cap across all claims, including those arising from a breach of the specific contested provision, thereby affirming the enforceability of the liability limitation clause.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contractual Liability Cap Enforcement: The court reasoned that the language used in the agreements, when interpreted in the context of the entire agreement and relevant commercial understanding, clearly and unambiguously demonstrated a mutual intent to limit liability to the specified cap across all claims, including those arising from a breach of the specific contested provision, thereby affirming the enforceability of the liability limitation clause.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court ordered the losing party to pay the costs of the proceedings.
Testo completo
&'()*&+,,- .&''/,&+,,-
.
.0 . 0
12" '
% 3 4 " +,,- !!!"#$#$ % & ' '( (' ) '*!+'!!,!'(! ! !(!"
- (../0 '!*#$#$## .
! " ! # $% %
%$1##%
50.
#5 " #6/7 8( "-!" ' !( 9 -'((! :'%;<= >""' ( ( "- " -'? '*! '* !!( :! !@ A"B'$002*!( C : (' ! -'((! 5 !!," ,: "(!( ?' "!B(!' , >! #"$4*'!$00#*!*!(*;D-'('('!(" '%85
$5 :!("'" "(" ! B"">! -'((! ( '" 9 ;<'>!' !(?#'*'!$0035
.5 $ *B' $003 " C !?' - ! * =' ( -'"!" ,: :(!( D B! * ! ;D , *!*!((-(-5 !?'- ! '((!'" (((! ' >!(,:*'!(";"(!=' ;=( !!'!%! '!( !! ' ' !( 9 -'((! 5 7 "B' !*( :!("'" 9-!," , '(! * ! :"(!( "("'! '" ,:! :*!( ,$.,:!--'(!(C('(' '(,:'!=!(,:! *!E-' F(':>(5
25 '-- '( :,E( "(" "(B! $2 ' $00/5 :!("'" "'" , -?'>!"(!(-'(!*(!,:"(!( *!( '*!( ('!B(! -'(5-'!' >!'",:((!( 9!?>(- '>!*'!(,>('-?'"(!( !' *!*(C!=8@G'A5 !=",:'!(;D!HI%! ,: ;!(!(-:!('G'5
:,E('!( '!"C!=8-!:( $0035 "("' -' !'#/!$00#5 !%!"$2+!( #6/$ (! !(" ! ,!((" ?* #' -(B' $002 - ' !=8% G 95 8 ( -' -'!"(!' : B! ! B!!'5 *!!( !!!!' ;D -'(:!("'"-'! ((',:--'(( - '(!(9 ;B' -'(( * !(-'- "5 :!("'"C ( "=' -'"!" ,: '!( !( B ( >! ! ;(5 , *E(( --'(( C :!("'" ( C >! "(!( '=" ' !'5
:!("'" !- -( B!' !*( J -( '( ( -("-'=-(!=' ( -("-'=5 -("-'= +!=' "("-'!' *'( 5
-(+( -(:*!(-"(" " 5
1#/231$004 %.1##% 35 :!("'" ;":-(!(>!!$$*'!$00/5
/5 '"!! $/*'!$00/ !> '":!("'",:((!(>!C ' !(9-'((! ( *>>(.0*'!$00/5
45 ' ''!'/+!$00/:!("'"!!,",J K "- ( -'((! + * ! >>(!*( "'" *!*' ;D-'( * >!# ,! "(!('!= '(9(5 >! "(!( :!' !'!( C =''! :>( (! ! C %% ( "(B!( ,: >'",(" -( '" 9 '-(!*(-(B'$00.C+!($0035
! +! !(" ;D !' E ! + ='! :- !',>(,!'- !(;=!(!((! -!, !:;B!((! '(!(!;="5
-9 >>!'' :* !' +! 'L -! !(!' !' 5 '!'(' *!(!((! >!!?'!>>!!*-!' "- '!(C (!>5>!!("("-' " ('"B( $00#('"-(' !K5
! C ! >! # $00# :!("'" *!(% "!"-' ('!B(! -?':>(5
-'!'!,:*!( *'( -(B!'-'?:C !!>>!'",::"(!(+! -"(,: :*!(+!>>(" !'-'"?*(,!9-!,,:*!( ! (! '5
"'",!:*!(- -!!,":9!( -(B!' #:(-',:-!(:* !'' !( '' -( !(" -' -' *( >! C : ! !*'!':>( >E( M5
>! + (" , J K !( !' -! '(! B' :" + !! '(!*( B! *!= !=8 +:*! ('?B "; ' " ('(+:!"!"* (9!? (-'--' ;'>! -?' '!'G'K5
75 ' ' #6-(B'$00/ '!B(("!' (((('!B"C :!("'"(C !':( '!("-'( + !(''9 >! # ( ! '" =' # C -?' ( !C?''(!>!": '>!!' -'-'(C* !' -'! ;'= >!!?' ( ( ; :>( ( ! ( =' ((5
1#/231$004 %21##%
65 . ( B' $00/ '"" C :!("'" 'B '( .#:.6.>'533'-'"(( ((-'((! *'"C( '(5 :( > " ' >!( , :!("'" *!( ;" -!' !> '(! (!'(!*C-('!(" !''# (C9 -(B!'5
#05 :!("'" > '" -- !(! #' *B' $00/5 ?= , ! :*!( - "'" , # *!( "(" ' -' -?' ( *!( ' " C ' !( C -! !(!' - ' >! :( -' , : -'( *!( , !%! - ''!( - *'' -! * !((! >!!?' ( :(' -'( -' ,: ('(!( * ! '(! ('? !>>!!5 >>!' ,: ( ( + ' '(" !!!" '%85 -'"!,( *(' -( ("("9!*(>!(-' !' , -( + !=' ( !(" -' -'((,!'('!( ("(">>("' -(:(!,(C '!'5
##5 '"!! $/'$004'"!( !:!!('(! :) -! =""' '+(" : -- !(! !! , '! !"'( , !(! B > !:"(!(-'"!"5
#$5 :!("'"!('+("' '$2*'!$004 ('!("!! 5 ( -'!!-(C:(! "!! $/'$004(B!!!'(C , (('(!((! !('"!(K ((,!:"(" " '! >!,!(' *!(C;'=-(-"'! !'!!"K>! C'!: B!=(! '(!('5
#.5 '"- $$ ! $004 '"!( ! :!!('(! :) -!=""' '+(' '5
#25 !'"("(-' '!B".+!($004( "'"J K:! ;(" ! , + *! #66$5 :! - - :8 "(B!' !"!(( -' , + ('*!! @( 8 ('*! 'A - ' '*! ('!?*5:!!("("!B"">!:"' =(! 5:"(! >!!(-' -!+*!'$000>'''5
',+!'(' *">!!( -( ("("B ,"5 -( "-'= "(" *!"5 :! '"-"'" -( !' ,, + ' -'?5 >!!( -( !(!( - ' "-'=' >! :,!((' !("'E( ( : '(!( ! 5 :*! -' , :>>! >!!( '-' ; :"-'='5 :( !! , -(" : *'!' -(
- ' !C 5:+!(!!"5:8- *(' -( -! "B' $0025 -'"! , B, (!(%8 (
1#/231$004 %31##% ,!(--' ; !('*!5! :-"("!! '>!!(:>>!>!!(8( !"'",((;8- (;"!' "(!((' -!- '((5:! -'E(! B!!'#66$- '#7C(9 #$3.$N5:!';("( B(-'E(*!#664- '$05
('+( !! C ! ('*! -' *!' 20 !( +,:C#;#05-'('4;#3(4;23! (+:''!*('7;.0(6 ;5 -'!!- ('*!C7;.05(!B'( !>!'20;' -'!59C(' !+ '-'!+:''!*-('('*!-', +:?#C:" 5 ;>-(! ;!('!(,+(' * (' (! 5('+ '!:(,!: - *( '%85 ('+( !=8 % '%8 -' C - -'? 23 !((!C:;'- !(5(:*!' .0!(:('5 8 # '( 2 !( '%8 ( . C !=85 #-' -';B'C!=85!!((';B' !(-C!=85
! : (' ('? !"-( ( + - -B *!*' * ,,:5'(! ('?> '(*-'(5
*( :('" *!=' *(! + -8! - -! - ' # +:!('*! '*; - (( - ' !*' ;( C 5==!4:$00>'5B'($00.5==C -'"(/:.00>'5('#. !"=(K5
' -'(! -' -'(! "' ( E + ' :!("'",(C"'",J
K!(( !!!"'%8;D-'(-!( + ' * !5 * * , -?' >( !( =' # -! -(B' $00/5 (!?'( ('(! -! E (5 -'*( ! B '!( C -8' *E(( ;'-'9-5
#( '!"C!=8%G 95 :(-'!!- !,!*! ;';'C:" ('?;D !'%85 --,!('*! != '"-?''('(5:!-'">"'",: !(!'!(C:" !=8 -' , +:! ( *! "; ,( C :" '%85 *(! , * ,(' !(=':"("' :) -! =""'5 *( (( *(! -?' :>( ( !%E (! ('?B!- '(''=' ;!(#5
:--'(('%8(>>!(='- ' ='>! ( !%E!B !--'(5
1#/231$004 %/1##% *!(-(-C!=8-',,+ '5
:!'! B - - * !' *!*' * !' C !=85 :( ( (> !--'E(- '5
', + ! !'!( '*! !' !!( :!- '(( -' B? >!!' ( ( ">( B! *!( "(" "!*'" (' !5 !! ', B '(' : !( ,-?' >(*'!(-8'-! +:!,, '(-!," * ( - =='*' !((! !' 5 !( + *!- ( '(!' =5
*( "-'(- '!=8 !';B!(!(--'(( C95- ?! -!#66$>'''5
$00# C $002 !' "(!( >!!( ' - ' ! '' '*! +:! *'( - ' ! ! C -( 5 *!( B !
- ' -8' -'E( ! B!!' '"!( ='! 5 :! +! >>(" '('!(' -(+:*!E B!"'! - ',+:*!- !=" '*! 5 :=!( -( *'( # + ! !' , ( -'( -''! ''! ,! :--' *!! (5 -?' !( -'> ! '(!'' (( - ' ! ,:!,!(-'B ''-'> !-!'*'(5
(! !' : - # ( :? C :"
- ' 7 ; .0 *!' 5 :! -( - -' ,:! :--:''='* ;>C6;.0:( !,!*!C!=8- ':'C:" @('+('% 8C!=8-'*!' O;5A5'> !# '(;D !- ' !-!>!'5 ! '( ( + ' '%85 ( -'( ,! : -( ',+*!C!=85
:! +! *!=" -'' --'(( !"-( - ' >! ( !%E:B '-',+!('?B!;D-'(!(- ' '! >!!?'5'--,+('*!--!7C65
#>'",(!(+'!:>((!( ''!(! 7;5C!!K5
#35 ' ''!'$4 P($004:!("'"-'!(" ! (-' !( ,(' -!? !( ( !(' #7 +*!' $004 :) -! =""' ((' '" C :!!('(! >! ( ## P( $004 ' !((!="-'%E>*':) -!=""'#$ +!( $004 ( '-- '( :,E( #7 "B' $00/ "(B! -' :) -! =""'5
1#/231$004 %41##% #/5 "'!(' $7 P( $004 '"!( ! :!!('(! :) -!=""'"=(!(- !(! 5
#45 ' '!B " :) -! =""' -' !( "(! -'((! *'"5
#75 "'!(' -'? ,E( ( '!' ''!' :) -! =""' ( "(" !,"9-'(!("("='"C+='5
0.
#5 > '"( C :'(5 3/ 5 $ (5 B ! =* ! ' : '=!(! +!!!' @A '!B ( ' ! F( (((! -'"* C Q'(! 26 !" . ! ( (!?' ;<= ## *B' #67. (!?' -'((! ( -"(!'@ A5
$5 > '"( C :'(5 3/ 5 $ (5 '!B ( ' ! F( (((! -'"* C Q'(5 .7 ! ( ' -'((! ( '" 9 ;<' >! ' !( #7 *B' #662@ A5
-"(- '+='Q-?(!!"(B!5
.5 ' '!('+("(-(!('*B@'(5.7 A5
25 !(!= - '( ' '(!((! .#:.6.>'533 '-'"((-'((! ,!'!("("!P(*'"C:!("'" :*'!$003C*'!$00/5
35 ! =* ! ' -'((! ( '" 9 ;<' >! ' !( #7 *B' #662 ('" *!=' #' +*!' #663 @!%-'? A ' 9 -' ,! ( ;<= ( ,! ( "-!" ' ' !(9-'((! Q'%;<=@'"=!>""'('"=!( A ' !( C '* !! ( Q! ! @ A *'" -' Q) -!""'>!Q"*!(',Q !*(' '!'CQ!(-B!, @>5'(5# A5
/5 9(':'(5$ J (' !('*!!( :! !(-*(B"">!!': (! :!'(! -' J
A,! (' !!(''"!>>(!*'(''!( !'"-B!, (( ?*R
1#/231$004 %71##% BA,! (;<=(,! ("-!"'' !(9-'((! :'% ;<=R A,!: (-((!(:S=:'%*!!>""'R A(,!'"- (9(' !(! -'"( !5
455:=!'!("('!'-'!'(-!:!("'"( !!!" C?*5
45B,(! * !'!-' ( !!!"! CQ"('=' !( E(''" '=''(5$.(5 !*!!5Q'(!$. !- , !!Q-' !(! T%!'*Q!((! Q8"(B!''B(5Q!((! '"''"!'B !(" ' Q B !' ( B+(!*R * (" -' !("'" Q("!!*,' T-(E('*"'!>!" (' 5 "-<( --!' Q B((! Q -'! "+ ' Q9'! ' !( - !(!, -' *( - (!((! Q !! ! (!(( 9!*( !!5 ! Q!(!( - -'" -(! ;=( !!R ! ,!!* ,(;=( !(Q"(B!'C(!>(! 5+'!-'!! !, !!Q-' !(C T(' 9!( ( '(! @ #6/7 5 30$A5 ! !!*! '(! 'B C -!'' !( !!(' *! T!* -'(' 9!('-- '(-' !("'E( '9(("'! *! ( =""'( (!*!(" -' >! ! @ #67$ -5 #4#R 14#4102#2-(B'$002A5
45 ,! '-'*+=' !> "!! > !- !(! ('!' ! ' >!( ,! >( :E(' "(B! !?' !''">(B--'!( -*'!BB:(%C%!',!-'"(( ='"*'!B-'"- "'(5>>!( -,:>!(-!E(' !"'"( ;8- (;?- !B5'!( ""(>!( "=" *!=B += !( ";"( '(!' 9 ,! ! -'!(--' BB@ G#$/./0 !53B#$3#63 !5$( '">"'R>5 G#.0.$2 !5.5$(.5.A5 !:9!(%(%!-' !( ' !-'!!- ,:!!('(! +=*'!( ((' (>*':'"@ G#$/.$$ !53A5
455:-?,(! -(E('!" *'(' '*(, !,:! !( E(''+("- ' (!>,!!*(5
75 :'(5 ## B"">!!!' '* !! ( Q! ! !( "'' C Q) -! =""' ( ( >!( (' C ('F' !>!(! ((-'((! ,!! ( "5 ">(Q) -! =""' -( -' --'!' *'( -'((! ',
1#/231$004 %61##% B"">!!!' '> > '!' (' C '((' '!=( "5 @>"=( 1$271$002 1$/.1$00/A
Q B!=(! !,' ( ( !> '(! (! C Q) -! =""' ( (( ( ( !>!(! '* Q"(( > '( (!( > ( E ' !( 9 -'((! 5 Q!> '(! ( " B"">!!!'-'Q) -!=""' (-' ''!'!"=( -'!=('Q(Q==(,!-'"* !(9-'"((( B!=(! (9-!,'! >!-''!(9( !-' -'(!(@ 33#1$003A5
! >! '*' , "=!(' -'"* 8( C :'(5 ## , :!!('(! K-(K -' --'!' *'( -'((! ' C %! - * !' !B' --'"!(! 5 @> ! U '"! ' !(!!('(!>2?"!(! -5.3A5
75B5 Q-? ! --'F( !'( , :!("'" *! " ( B!=(! Q!> '' Q) -! =""' (!( :9!( 9 -( B!'!"=(>!(>"'(! (C-!''-'! :!,B(: B(!' -'((! !5
(''-,:"=(=! '(>!:"*!('>!'* !' (' !' ' !( C -! !(!' - ' >! #5 ' :'(5 3 ((' ; -'"* !( 9-'"( , B! (B"">!!!':(!! !*(E('-'! !"'(! ( -'! '* "('!(5 (( !- !(! ( !'(( --!B ', B"">!!!' ' :-? *'( : -! !(!' - ' >(5 :--'(!( >>( - C :) -! =""' -'' - -?'R ! :( - ,(! ,:! !( " -' ( B!! C >!'!!'((-' '"-':!9;<'>! ' !(5 ' '( -' !' -!? >!='( !' , -?' #('*!!("+C'(-"'! !"'"9'*!('! ?*('"!!('*,!!'!('=(-'!:' '- B!!("-""(!'5
755 :( ",C+((!(',-'"!! $/'$00/'"!( ! :!!('(! :) -! =""' >!'" "!! --'!(' !(:!("'"9-'((! (!'"('B '( .#:.6.>'5335 !' ' !(%!E(''+("5
65 E "!! '"!( ! :!!('(! :) -! =""' "=( 9!" - !B!!(" : '' C :!("'" '! : B!=(! 'B ''!( (:"'(" (!>, !(! B > !:"(!(-'-!5
1#/231$004 %#01##% 65B5 ('Q'(5$05$ B"">!!!',!"(!(B > !:(( C'(!((! ( ( -'(!,' T!'!(-!>!( !((! !>>!!5
+'!-' '!B >""' ' B > ! B"">!!!' -'((! ( 9 QB" ', >!( ,! !( C Q B!=(! '(!(' @*! (! * !' Q ' '!='A ( !-(BC - '(( !> C"=!=='*@ #666.72 !5.('">"'!("A !(,8(' !( > '-C ,!-(E('9!="Q-' -B!'( !((! !(!,(E!' (@ G#$#23 !5.B##7.0/( !*( !5$('">"'R 1./310.#4"B'$00.A5
655:-?( -((-' - ('!( !'(-':!("'"( '"!("'""'(! =?'!* !, !(! B > ! '!(E(''(5(!!-'>"(( !':9!' !(! >!!?' '>: ''C:!("'"'!-(E(', >!'"5
1#/231$004 %##1##%
6.05 .0 . 0
%
7 2
#5 "'' ''*B5
% 7
$5 '+((5
.5 +(("=('!5
25 !(,-' "'(='(!(5 ='>>!?' '"!( '!% ! V '!W
-! > '-'"(''E(( (!>!"9-'(!-'='>>
1#/231$004