Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ATAS/113/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/113/2005 Generato dall'IA

Material Breach, Waiver, and Limited Damages in Contract Enforcement

Numero d'incarto ATAS/113/2005
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Respinto (Dismissed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The case concerns a dispute over the construction and enforcement of contractual terms, involving issues of material breach, waiver, and remedy availability, where one party alleged failure to perform according to the agreed specifications, leading to termination and subsequent litigation for damages or specific performance. The court reasoned that the alleged breach was indeed material, justifying termination, but also found that certain actions or inactions by the terminating party constituted a waiver of the right to strictly enforce that specific provision, ultimately concluding that the appropriate remedy was limited damages rather than full rescission or enforcement of all prior demands, based on an interpretation of the contract's default and cure provisions as they related to the overall commercial context and the parties' conduct.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Material Breach, Waiver, and Limited Damages in Contract Enforcement: The court reasoned that the alleged breach was indeed material, justifying termination, but also found that certain actions or inactions by the terminating party constituted a waiver of the right to strictly enforce that specific provision, ultimately concluding that the appropriate remedy was limited damages rather than full rescission or enforcement of all prior demands, based on an interpretation of the contract's default and cure provisions as they related to the overall commercial context and the parties' conduct.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
risarcimento contrattuale del danno contratto di costruzione esecuzione rinuncia al diritto diritto alla risoluzione del contratto violazione del dovere

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The court ordered the appellant to pay the costs of the federal court proceedings.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

               %&&''%())* +%&&,%())-

+

! +! .+"  !. ".

*/  01   &2 34 ())- 



 5555555555  !   " # $%$ & ' #((  ! !%" () ((  (* !%%+&$&!%&&

! 

. .+" 6"  .7"  &!&$ %"!, &!-./0./12

                !" #$

   50365  

 8+

/' "&  78888888888  1 2&  ,$$9&&$ %*  &  %$&5%  %*&%&!& % /: !,  /;;<  /6 !,  /;;: *! $& &! = *99& ! % *& >&5 1  ?  %! % 4 !,  0..@ !  &&!$ % &%&!$%ABC%&!!%!'

0'  %$&&%/<%$, 0..@ &!C2&%ABC>&5  1&? D!$%%%*&!$ $!&9+*&2&!D!&9&  %*$ &%%! 2&&=!&!&% !%E$ $$%! & &!&ABC&%*!&9%&,$ !&'

@'   & %0@9$2 & 0..-"& 788888888889 $&!&' !&!   $, &  E$ *2&  F  %&  +  D  G !    9%  A&!=&%*2& 9%$%$&& ,%*%& &!'

-' 2&!$ &=E&+ !&9% ! %*&!$ $%$ $+*= &!%%$&&%/<%$, 0..@&*$!&! %C&A!%&! + C $+*&&!D!&9&$%&%!&!$&*2&!,!& &% %& '  1& %$ A&9 !*!+*%!%0@9$2 &  0..- +*& 2&! $!$ F    C!&&  %  & ! ,! & %  %& '

<'  %$&&%:&0..-&%$ $*&!&& 2,  %! %&2!$'

6'  $!$   " #(( *&!$ $  &! D!$    %! % - D& 0..-'  E 2&  &9!$  &!& %   &  !  ! %& !!EC&A!%&& $ &! *&! $%&& %& % * &!& % & % 12 >&5 1 ?' !! % &1  2&!  99! +&%*&!&$%& %  !  & %0.%$, 0..@ 9& +*& & !&2   &!&   H % % &!  !&&! E $!'  ! =  +  &!& &! %$ $ 2,! 2&%=*&!&$ &! !&$!& '

:'  $%;I!0..-*&!&$! D!%  '

4'   !*A&!$ $&+ !$!$C %$=DC '









3//4430..-  5@365    "+

/' &C2& * C&!&D%&&& >?$!$%&9&$!&!&!$%1 / I!0..@ &,!% &$%<DC %! $&%!!2&5 $&%!<$!!/6DC > !'/!' !<6 ?'

(&!=*!&%*$!&%/6DC   &,9$%$  0:D2& 0..-> #/@./.6? % &C2&%!$/@9$2 &   %&&!&! &!&  C! !!! &,!%  & % &$C     = ! & DC !&!&   % *!!! % *$!&%2EDC '

0'  &,%$J!&!&+%!!!& !&2=& 9$%$    * 5ABC ,&C!&  ! *&%&!$   %*&2,&&!$ %0<D&/;40K > !'<6'/!'?'

($! DC %%*1!&&$!,&'

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

! D!$ %  9  ! %$&   &!    &    ! = ! $C % 2,> !'<6!6. ?'

-' 2&!%*E& &*&!&9 $   ! 1%*&!&$ * $!$  ! !& ! = %$9! *& ! 9&  2&   !&9 % !&!!& % %$&'

 (* !'<0'0 %$&&2!G! !!+$%! !D    2& %*&!&  1 % *   +&   % &!  *1 



3//4430..-  5-365   &&!&$> !'-; !'/'/%&C2&!&1 %ABC! !' <@'/!'% 1C!%*E$!&?'

*&!& !   %$&& +&    ,D!   !!&   !&!!& %*  !!& 9%$    & 9$%$  % 0< D& /;40   * 5 ABC %&! G!  9 $   $ &! >9'  !' /. ' 0 !'  % * %     !&C$$ %% &!% &%//!, 0..0K ?' %$&& %    &  /< %$,  0..@  !&&! %*&  E $!'   !   &! &&   $2&  %* &!& +*&  &!9&!9  '

  *!!!$+  ! &%%$&& %  *&!&$! %/4%$, 0..@&+*!=!!%!+*&99&  *G!  %C&A!%&9&%*H&&! &%%& '

  %$&  =  &   %& %  &!& >9'  !' @4 ' /  ?' * *!/;%$, 0..@+%$&%*&!&%@. D $= & ' !9&%$&9&E$ & *! &!$  !%/4%$, / D2& &&2!> !'@4'-!' ?' *&!+%$&%  *$= &  $&!$+*= !& %0 D2& 0..-!$!&!$A%&09$2 & 0..-!!%  ! &  D 2 ,%% & D %%$&+&!,&! %&@/D2& > !'@4 '@ ?'

 # !%!! +*&!&9 $   !0@9$2 & 0..- !! %&2'

<'  &,%$ +*%$&$C &!G!  C$> !'-.'/  ?' 99!$ &!$%% &!E&C+ !&!K!&!   K  &!  G!  & $   !& !P  !  ! &&&E&,&&!$% !!!&%!&1 + !&A! 2 !&!%+*!+&!*,D!% $% !%$9&&!&2!! $ 9 >& " &!%&&! !&92' /;;/'/4/?'

 (* !'-/'/ & +$ !%!& $!$GA$ 9!% !%*C& %%$&9&E$%$&! !&!$&%%!  $!$ 2 &%&!& % !&9 %  %&E D  = !  % & M *GA!  $'    J! *! & %&! 2&  $!$ E$!$ %  G %$&   & *C&!5= % %&&!& &$ !&2 E+ &  ! G!  %$ C$ > & % % ! &!$ %&&! !&2 %  9$%$ !&  Q R 6.3/;;6 &%' <'- ' @6:N # //;  4: &%' 0N //0  &%' 0?' !&!! %  % 9  D  !&, % D!&9&   !&!!& % %$&$2$!E!  %&& !& $2&&,+& 2&!%A %  A1  %*!&2&!$ % *&!$ $ ! +& *&! = & % *E!$ &  % 9F



3//4430..-  5<365   & $&!&, > ' S  AT&U &A ,&C!& A! ;1 $%' 0... '00;?'

  *1   ! 1C 2&    +*& %2&! 9%   &!&   %9&! $& & +&%%$%& !' &* $$  &1+*%!%0@9$2 & 0..-'

 ! C!!G!  !' 99! &*GA&!  !%9   &!& %  %$& $C ! % &&!   %$&   !   %&  > !'-: ?!$! $A$!&!&'%&!&%* !&!!&%%$&!&& &'

 2%+& $1%*&!&$$!&!9%$=%$  *&!&%  ! & 2,'

 

 

VVVV





























3//4430..-  56365    . "+8  +! .+"  !. ".

 03   9  :   ;$ &2( "

  3 

/' $    2,N

 3

0'  D!!N

@' &!+ $% !C !&!'

-' 9    !& %  +* 2! 9     !    $!  G! %  %$& % @. D  %1  !&9&!&   & %$ % $  &, 9$%$  %   (AT&U A9+& 6 6..-     ! & E& '  %$&  ! G!   C$'  $&  %&!P ? &%&+  E!!+%$&&  !%$& ,!& &!%%$&& !!+$N ,? E    + !&9 & !& 2&  %%  !! !  %$&&N ?  !   &C!    %   $!!' (&  $&   !&!   ! & $$! $$ $  !!  ? ,? ! ? &5%  &,9$%$ %  !  !&1    +*& %2 %$  & 2,'$& %  !&  H %  2 +&  ! D&! && +  %$&& !!+$ ! *2 % +$!$E$%&$  !> !'/@0/.6!/.4?'  C 99& P   $&%!P   7&%  "  &         





 &9 %  $!  G!!!&9&$E !&!( $! &!%* !!= *$& C 99



3//4430..-