Contract Enforceability and Waiver of Rescission Claim
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court addressed whether a specific statutory exception applied to invalidate a contract provision related to the transfer of ownership interests and whether certain actions taken by one party constituted an unlawful exercise of control or an unmeritorious attempt to rescind the agreement. The court reasoned that the relevant statutory exception did not apply because the transaction did not involve the type of prohibited interest transfer contemplated by the statute, and furthermore, the party challenging the provision had waived any right to contest its validity through prior conduct and explicit contractual acknowledgment. Therefore, the provision remained enforceable, and the challenging party's claims for rescission and damages were properly dismissed.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 93 LTF; Contract Enforceability and Waiver of Rescission Claim: The court reasoned that the relevant statutory exception did not apply because the transaction did not involve the type of prohibited interest transfer contemplated by the statute, and furthermore, the party challenging the provision had waived any right to contest its validity through prior conduct and explicit contractual acknowledgment. Therefore, the provision remained enforceable, and the challenging party's claims for rescission and damages were properly dismissed.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe appeal is declared inadmissible and costs are imposed on the appellant.
The appeal is declared inadmissible because it challenges a non-final decision.
Testo completo
"##$%"#&&' "$$$$"#&&'
() (() ( )
*+ '
! #$ ,+ #&&'
!"#$%&$'!!'' #!#$ (&$)$# *'##
!$#
++ ( # '$'& ,!-. "!$/01 2022 23
!
704217
( -
28 &2.#2-91$:#;<$&1='$ 2--3$0/#2--5 $<!#$'!"#!<'!8"'29!$!># 2--1 $#%'&$$?$$!, @#'!;A#"#=!# '? =!#"#'8*!A!#'#$#%'&$'$2.A21@2-A368
08 &A!B#"A'(&"#!'$<<$&22!$!>#2---'&%' >#'$ A#!'? !7#!'!7$!C' $ !7!#!C' ! #""!#$20!$!>#2---!$# 8
38 "' 29 !%># 2--- $ ##D$ $#%' "!# #& '&$#'&8
/8 1&>#2--- !$# "&''$&''$#$ ' #A$' 'B!$'?& @ ($$$'! ( # >#'$ A#!'? !7$!C' (&" #!'$ ?' %'$ !& %#' 2---8 !<'#& ? "$'$ &$'$ '"'$& $!$ $#%'# "'29!%>#2---8
18 25 <&%#'# 0666 (#& &$& !' @ (&" #!'$8 $ ; E D$# #&'& % (' ( !"A#!!B "$'$ &$$ $#!"A!> ! #""!#$ !$# 23 <&%#'# 06668 #""!#$!$@'#$'B$'!"$A'7&"';#"$#$ '#:$>#'$!7#!'!7$!C'8
98 ! #""!#$ 3 # 0666 !$# =!$& @ ! 'B!$'"#&&$&$$&"#'<#&$'!8
.8 2. %#' 0666 !$# $# &' @ AD7!#B #$'<'& ? "$'$ !<<#'$ ( >#'$ '<$!'# (&" #!'$ $ ($#!>"'?8
58 *! #$'<'$ 22 !E$ $ 9 !%># 0666 0 <&%#'# $ 36 %#' 0662 (&$$;'!7&"#'<=#%$#!>"'?"#'$'$8
-8 03!%>#0666 ('$&#&<!#&"#$$'!(#7 '%''$&%(#$!%"#!<'!$(#$8
268 !#""!#$&'02=%'#0662 !$#!<'#& 'B!$'"#&&$8"#&'&?!#(&"#!'$;'$'$ "' 2--. $ '$ (BB#%$8 (&%!$'! &$'$ <%!#> "' $#!' '<'$#$'!!%>#$&>#2---8"$'$%'$&%!""&"#'$ !# ##$'? $A!#; $ AA '' ?( &$$ &"#'< !'# ? %'$ <'$ (!>=$ ( $#'$$ &'$; $
4002540661 734217 ",A!$A&#"$'?8 $$'$ &%!'$ %# ,#! !$!<!# !!#;8
228 29 &># 0662 !$# !$$ #$'<'& ? "$'$ !<<#'$ &B$ ( ,#! !! '##'$> ( B$#'$ A#!'?$(A&B'!A&"$'?&!%#$2--98 "'B'$( ;'&$& FB!#"A!>' &#!"A!>'G $ "#&$'$ !$'$'! "#''"$ 'B$'% % "B &$$ (;'&$& B&&#'& F$#!> "'?G&A&!%$"#!<'$D'# '<$$"# ""'$$'! ,"& !#>!' $&$' '$ $'! !#$ ''$ ,$ &'$& !># !$$'! #B HI"'$; '%#'$'# :% F'7"#: J HG ' &%' $#!> !$'?8 '%'$ ",A!$A&#"' $#'$$ ;'!,$'? $ $'7&"##8 # '# "'B'$ !# $," &'?(&"#!'$'##'$>##!'$$$A!#;8B#& $#'$$ F * '<'$#$'! !#$'!$&#!C "A,'!$A&#"'G ,"$I"#'$'$8
208 ! #""!#$ &' 25 &># 0662 !#$ "'$& "#!<'!('$&#& !$#!$$''?&? "$'$ "#&$'$ '"'$& $#%' $!$ $$ ? $$!, $ ?( &$'$ &B$ '"> (;## $# "#!<'! #'! ! &$$;';$$#!>"'?8
238 1 <&%#'# 0660 ('$&#& #&"! ?$'!'# #%$ @ &$#'# $$$ (#&8 ''?& ? "!# #'! <'':# #'$ ;#& $'%'$& #$'% @ 266K " $ ! &B ' %'$&$&>!$&8 %'$;#&$'%'$&@$""#$'@ !>'B$'!<''8
2/8 *! #""!#$ (?D$ &!!'? # &B 1 ' 0663 (#& "#&$ ! &B B#& ('%''$& 29 61K8 (#& ''?& @ (?D$#' ? !# @ (&" (&$'$ BB#%& "' &"I$ 8 I$&#!'$ %'$=?"!'$#'$=?(@ '8 #!''"#%$ %'$<'$#?'%'$'&%' A#' ' #&B'! !>'#8 !<<#'$ !# !$# $ '#$$'$!%$!""#&8!$#'%'$"##'$ B,$'?"!#! '7''<''$"?>'8 '$!#AL"A,'!$A&#"$@#'!;<!'"#'$!$# '''$#'$'<'$#$'!(&"8 %'$"#'# ""#'!"A#!!B' "!#('#@#"'##8 $@!#' '>&&<'''$( #$ ('%''$& "' 2-51 @ '$ ( '$8 * #$ (&%'$ @ %'#!/(666<#8"#!'8 "$ (#7'%''$&%'$'""#'# #$$"#!&#&$'$!#8(#&!$#''?&?(#'$
4002540661 7/4217 $#%'&@'7$"$$'$@$& <'#&'#'# 0(666<#8
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
2.8 !# ! $#$' 0. <&%#'# 066/ % '%''! #&"$$'! "#!<'! ( (#& #"#!A& @ !$!# (%!'# ?& &'$ "#$ !$$ %'! !$ %'$ &$& %'$'8 &$&$#$'&"#$;"!'$(%!'#$$&''#@ '$'7'8 &$'$"#'#$#:''$&!%$"# !#'##'$>#$=?('8 $'$!$#$#'$ %'$ %' "## !%$ $ %'$ "# =' "#%'# @ D$# A# #'! ! B#'!8 '' !"#'$ " !$ "'$& $#%' %'$ " D$# &%& @ 16K $$ ? $$!, $ @ 266K $'%'$&&B:#8
258 # &''! 29 !%># 066/ (<<' (#7'%''$& F'7"#: J G!$#!,&@(#&'7#$2#!%>#066636%#'0663 #>(B#&('%''$&15K8
4002540661 794217 2-8 #('$#&''#!!' (#&<!#&!""!'$'!@$$&''!26 &># 066/ !$ @ ! $'! $ (!$#!' ( #$ ('%''$& $':#"!##&'&$#'&8
068 29#0661 !"&$&!!""!'$'!$!@($'!'$ &''! '' ?(@ (!$#!' ( #$ ('%''$& "$& @ ! &$$ $&8 *>'''#$ #?'##&"$$'!"#!<'!8 $'$# "#&> & !% ;"#$' ",A'$#'? : !# ?( $''$ ?(' &$'$ '"!'> (&%# ! &$$ ",A'$#'? <<$'< !# ($'&(;*8 !$$&@$&B#"!<<#'# ( &"'! &"#'< !, $ !'B& ? $$ <<$'! %'$ &$& !$$& !#36'0663"#!$# 8 &B$&B&? (?D$&!!'?#$'%'$&&B:#(&$'$"'$#$&?$ "!#&%#"'$&$#%'&B #!N!<<#'$ ($#!>",A'?8 <' #!N($'%'$&$$!,!'$'$ "#&'&$@<<$#$MA&B:# '(;'$'$!$'<!>=$'<"!# ;"'?# ?( #'$ "> (<<$# D $MA ! "#!"# &B%"'"'$&$#%'8
028 #&''!#!""!'$'!03'0661 ( #=$&7' <!$ ##""!#$(;"#'''"''#* $!$#%$?&' $#'$$ <''$ " $!=!# "#% (!>=$'%'$& &'# #'! "!'$'! !<'$ "#'%'&B'& ? ' !<:# ! $8 (;'$'$ " "#''" ! ? (&%$'! &' "'$& $#%' ("!#$'$ ( ':# B&&# # #&$$ (?D$ &B:# "!# "#! !<<#$$#!>",A'?8 !$# ($'%'$&"#!<'!$$!, $ &B:# "!%'$ D$# !"#& : !# ?( (&$'$ " !';D;'B#$8
008 03 =' 0661 (#& "# ('$#&''# ! !' '$#=$& #!# !$# $$ &''! #"#$ !'! $&#'#8 " #B$&=@'%!?& "#$''#&'&%#"#!>$#""!#$ * !$$ ?' !# (""#&'$'! ",A'$#'?8 &&$ &'? ! &' "#$$'$ (&$,# <<'#$'! ! ?##'%'$';@B&##$#!>",A'?!<!#"'? $ ? &"#'! &$'$ #&''! !":$ "' $#!' !'8 #""!#$ ",A'$#'? * &$'$ '#8 <!'$ # $#$' ( #& '<<'$ $ #&"!'$ " @ ?$'! %!'# ' $#!> ",A'? &$'$<<$'%$'%'$8
038 &$#'$'! / ='$ 0661 ('$'& ! #=$ #!# #%!,$;"':!'#$@!$'%$'!&''!#!""!'$'!8
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
018 06"$>#0661 !$#&B$<!#' #'> &#'B$&';""&$'#8''?&"#$B#(%' 'B$'##""!#$* !?"$'$"#&$#'$"'$& $#%'266K$'%'$&"$&$16K$$?$$!,8
098 20 !$!># 0661 #!#$ ($ &$#'& # '<!#$'! &' <!#' "# !$# $ $ '$ !'!8 "#$''# ''$& # <'$ ? !$# %'$ #$'<'& ?( !<<#'$ $!=!# ( &"'! &"#'< !, ?(' %'$ ?'<'&('%'$8
0.8 ('$'& !' #&"! !$# $ ; ?$'! "!& "# #'> & *8 '7' #%& ! #""!#$ 2/ !$!># 0661 ? !$# %'$ !'&#& ? #!#$ !<<#'$ " ( $$'$ #A$!!B'? '%'$ $ ? $$ '%''$&"#!%'$$'$ ($$'$",A'$#'?8 $!$# *$'&?('"#&$'$"(#B$""&$'# "!# %'# ''$$'! <!$'! '& @ (&$$ &"#'< #!#$8 #'# !AB$(""#&'$'!"#:#$#!'# ''? <'$?(''$=$'<'&'"'$&$#%'"!#!$'<#A$!!B'? A!# "&''$& =$'<''$"#'(""#&'$'!*8
4002540661 754217
058 &$#'$'!25!$!>#0661 ( "#'$&!'! ("",$#(%'&'*8
(
28 !'B%!'#Q!#B'$'!='''#FG&$&!'<'&$'$'$& : 2#!E$0663 #'>$!#!' !"!&1=B !$"#&'$$%'7"#&'$ 1""&$$29=B#F#$82$8 #$19 G8
*'$@Q$'!Q&$'!29=B# "# #'><&&# 0.=%'#066/F +236269G # !'B%!'!"$& 23<&%#'# '"!'$'!$#'$!'##B$"#$$$ #'>$!# !' '&B# # @ $#!' =B $'$'# Q$$$ Q&$'!!%;=B#8
08 !<!#&$@Q#$81982$8A80 #'>&!)$ '$ '? !$$$'! "#&% "# Q#$8 19 !' # "#$' B&&##!'$#!'9!$!>#0666F G#$'%@!' <&&##Q#7'%''$&2-='2-1-F G8*!"&$"!#=B# Q":$''&$>'8
38 $$#& %'B# 2# =%'# 0663 $#)$ !'<'$'! !># '"!'$'! &B !' # !'8 *# "$&#' "!'$%!'#?#!'$(""'?!'$D$#$#A&@':# "#''"!?#:B""'>!$%'B#!$!N <'$ =#''?$ &$#'$ !$ "#!'$ F + 20. /9. !'8 2 209 239 !'8 /> $ #&<&#G8 #%A ?' !# "#!&# $@&<$#:B$#'$!'#!$#'# !%#!'$(""'? #&#%:=!#!$#&%'B#F +22.-3!'89> 220 396 !'8 /P 2--5 R 3. "8 329 !'8 3>G8 ($ "!#?!' "#!&#"$2#=%'#0663!'$#!'$"#:$$$%$ $#'> $! !"&$$ $':# (# !' !$ #&B' "# !% #:B "#!&# !$ $ "# '"!'$'! "#!&#!$'<<&#$!'"&'!'<'&"# 8
(": #!#$ $ ##D$ $#%' "' !%># 2---8 $ '' &$#'$'$$'!=#''??'"#&%'$!$!N")$##!'$@ #$ @ %!'# !' !%># 06668 # !&?$ '"!'$'!
4002540661 7-4217 $&#' !$"""'>?'!#(""#&'$'! ('%''$&#!#$:$$$8 "$ %<<$2# '0663 ( "#!&& @ #&%''! &''! (!$#!' ( #$ #'! (&'!#$'! (&$$ ",A'?8 : !# # $$ "#!&# #&%''! '!%'$(""'?#'"!'$'!$&#' ''? !'<'$'! !&$'%8
/8 $#=$& <!# $ &' &B; #!# $ #%> F#$8 19 1- G8
18 #!N#!#$!$@($'!'$&B#&''!# !""!'$'! 03 ' 0661 ('$'& $ @ (; #!'$ @ #$ : 2#!%># 0666 ' !%'$ "#'# ' (;'# ! B#& ('%''$& "$"&#'!$#$$#':#$$36%#'06638
98 ; $# Q#$8 / Q'%''$& $ ''$'! "'$& B' "#&& "#$ ! !B #& ?' #&$ Q $$'$ @ $& "A,'?!$"#!%$Q'<'#'$&!B&'$ Q'!Q '$8 Q$$'$ @ $& Q$ ! " @ &$#'$ $ # "#'!'&#$'!?#!N$#)'"'$&$#%' ,$ <<$ # "'$& B' Q#& F S 7 * B$LT>#'%'%#'A#B U#'A2--. "85G8
.8 %#$(#$80582 $#%>=?(32&>#0663 (#&@#!'$@#$$':# ('$'%'@99VK @'7#$(' $ '%' @ 16K !' ! @ ?#$ #$ (' $ '%' @ /6K !'8"&'> (#&"$ ("#:(#$80582>' "#&$#@ '7#$ ('$'%'@/6K!'8
58 *!(#$805 80 "!#(&%$'!('%''$& #%$#%'? ('%'"!##'$!>$'#;#W$($'%'$&?(!"$#'!>$$$# ' "#:;&$'!&%$##&"$$'!$!"$$( '$$'! &?''>#& #A& $#%' $ !"#& #% ?(' #'$ " !>$'# (' (&$'$ " '%'8 !' <&&# &'$# "##'"$'! !"&$'# # (&%$'! ('%''$& !$$ "!# #& ?' (%'$"($'%'$&#$'%%$(D$#'%'F#$80583 G8*#> $$'"!'$'!&B !'<&&#&'$&#$80.$0.>' 8
; $# (#$8 0. "!# &%# ('%''$& ( #& (;#W$ " ($'%'$& #$'% (#$8 1 8 2 ! <<$ !"#'! $'%'$& $ ! A#A @ &$>'# ? # ('$&#& &$& "DA& (!"'#$#%;A>'$F&$A!"&'<'?P82G8#$#%;A>'$ #&$#%'$&B !$($'%'$&&B $(&$'!<$F80G8
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
-8 (": '($"!$$&"##!#$?(#'$$#%'&@'7$" !&B$@'7$"$'%'$&#$'% '(&$'$"$$'$ $& $?(#$('$'&8 !%'$"#!&?$"#!&# @ (&%$'!!'%''$&""'$'!&$A!';$8
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
4002540661 7224217 F + !">'&00&>#0663 322463 !'8183P + ! ">'&05<&%#'#0663 951460 !'8380G8
228 (": (B'$($'%'$&&B !$# ($" "#!!&#"'$&$#%'#!#$!'8 <<$ $'$ ?( $ '"'$& $#%' $!$ "' !%># 2--- =?( =%'#066/ '<'$'$'$'!$#$'%'$&A>'$&B $$'%'$&#$'%"!'"$&8
'(''?"#'#?&#$'!(#&#'$!$#'#; !$$$'!&'<'$#"",A'$#'?8#!#$(!$# " ''?& # "#!&# (!""!'$'! $ #!# ?!' !$$$'!(?D$#'#&B#'$';$8
$ &B# ' !%'$ #%# ? #!#$ "$ #' &'# <%#<'$?('"'$&"#$' %!'#$!$ '&$&#!! ' $'%'$& "#!<'!8 <<$ ($'%'$& $$!, "#!<'! !<&B#'$D$#!"#&@$<!,#<''?' #!%# !># ($'%'$& ;'B "A,'? "#$'':# F"'<'$'! !#B'$'! #&"#$'$'! $#%' !$#IG $ !$ ;'B &"$ '#$$$'&B$!>#!"$F"#&"#$'! #" $#$''B "$$G8$(&B"#'%&"#$&B$ ("$# ($'%'$& ; "#!>: "A,'? ?' ($ " &'#$ !"$'>%;'B#$"#!"#@(;#''''# !$;$ "#!<'! F + ! ">'& *8 23 %#' 0661 1-3463 "8 22 !'8183G8
!'$'! ','<!##(?D$&!!'?#&B 1'0663$$$#$;('%''$&29 69K$#%;A>'$ &B!'$5K"!#$'%'$&@16K!'8
208 *(B'$"'$&$#%'$'%'$&#$'% ('$'&#$ '"'$&$#%'$!$ "!##'!",A'$#'? =?(36%#'0663 <!$ # (""#&'$'! "'$& $#%' "# !$# #"!'$8
#'! &%&#'$& (&$$ &"#'< $ $#!> "'? #'> & !':# ? ($ @ #'! ? ('$'& ' "DA$ $!$ $#%'# "$ "&#'! !%># 0666 @ %#' 06638 "$ # !N ' ($ " !$$& ? #!#$ (#'$ $#%'& ?(@ 16K $ ?((?('%''$&29 61K$'%'$&A>'$&B !'$ 5K"!#$'%'$&;#&@16K !B#&('%''$&&""15K $!$ !#$?("$"#&$#?(@'7#$"$" $"8
4002540661 7204217
238 !%'$ '$ (;'# ? &$& B#& ('%''$& #!#$ @ "#$'#2#'0663 $@?'7#$&$&""#'&8
*!!$# &$&'"'$&$!$$#%'#!# =?( &>$ (& 066/8 : $$ $ ' $ $!$<!' "'$& $#%'16K$'%'$&"$& $!$$'$?('"'$&$#%' $ $!$$$?$$!,8 $!$# '#'; !'! * # " !$'? $ !$ ! @ "'$& $#%'16K$$?$$!,$266K$'%'$&"$&:' 06638
*("#!&&@(;",A'?#!#$?09=%'#066/ $ ($ : !# <!& # 'B!$' #&$#!"$'<8 !# <'# * ($ ""#$ $'$ "",& # &#$'! #!#$ ! ? $ ; $$? "'? &># 0663 $ $#!>(&$'$&'!#&"'&8 '' <#&?$$?%'$ ''&@<!'"#'$"#<!'@;<!'"#!'8
"$ ! ''$'! !$# <'B#$ ! #""!#$ 32 ' 0663 !<<# @ $$ #':# $ $!=!# ( &"'! &"#'<!, "$#!>"'?8
# !N ! '# #!#$ $$? "'? (!$ ''& ? "$'$ @ "$'$ "' =%'# 0663 ' , ' !'&## ? #$:#'%'$$$?$'"#"#!B#'%$8 '' ! #'$ !'&## # > &#$'! #!#$ $ !$#'#$;!$$$'!!&'$#'$$ ?!&$$($&'!#& : =%'# 0663 "!'$ ?( !'$ "> $#%'#8 #'> & $' '' ? ! B#& %#'> "#&"!&#$ #!#$ ( #$#!%& "'$& $#%' #> 16K !' ?( " $I$ =%'# 066/8 '' !%'$7' !'&## ?( #!'$ @ '7#$ =?(32&>#0663
2/8 %#$ (#$8 55 #:B$ # (#7'%''$& 2. =%'# 2-92 F G (&'!#$'!"'$&B'!"'$&(!"'# $#%; ''%' ( #& ' , ' !'&## ? AB$ ""#' &A&$ $!$!"#$'!#!'$;"#$$'!:?(!"$ ($$#@?(&'!#$'!!$$&'$'#$L!B #&8 % D !#?( $ AB$ &$#'$ #& $#!' !' &=@ '$##"$'! !$> $ ?( !"'$'! "#!A' !'$ @ #'#8
218 (!## ' , ' ($$# ! #%& '7 ? #!#$ "$ $#%'# @ 16K !' @ "#$'# 2# =%'# 066/8 : =%'# 066/ !$# '7D$<<$?("!##'$;##$'%'$&
4002540661 7234217 #$'% "$& @ 16K8 # !N #!#$ (#'$ " $#%'& @ (;$&#'# @ $; "&#'# $ !N ' #&$ ?' '$ ? #!#$ >'#'$ "#$ B' $ $'%'$& ?$'! %!'# ' "#&$ &B$ "'$& $#%' 16K $$ ? $$!, "$ #$#!%#$8
298 !#&%#B'('%' ',' !<!#&$@=#'"#>' &$>' #&<&## ; !& $$'$'? F ?D$ ' # $#$# '# Z [G !#? ! (": (#& ( " #"#' ($'%'$& #$'%F +209.9!'83>4$>>P*0660"895!'83>G8
!"$$('#>#$06663(915<#8"!#$'%'$&'" $ #&"&$'$'% /6 A# F 0666 2G !'$3(500 <#8 96 "!# /2 5 A# A>'$F'&!!'?2040660"855$>-80G '#!'$ D$#<';&@/1(5.2<#8F3(500<#896;20G8 $$!&'"'$&$#%' 16K #%>#$&$#'$(&:%''@00(-31<#8
!#? ! (": #% ('%' $ &%& # > $$'$'?#'#!, #$'"DA$"#!"#@"#! ('%' F''$$'! '& A'" MB & #%' $'!'$&4$&B!#'($!#'$'!&=!#$$;(!"$'!G;'B$?(! #&' !$$ '# '' !>$ F + 209 .- !'8 1>4G8 $#&$'!!'%$"D$#<<$&':#A&$'? '$'# !"$ (> '#!$ "#$''# $ >$ &$#'# @"#$'#!&$$'$'? #%('%'?'#"#&$ '; ' %# &!!'? ;'B'> $'%'$& !"$'> % "'$& $#%' #&' ('$&#& F + 209 56 !'8 1>4>>G8 &$'! B!> ;' 01 K # '# $$'$'? "#$ $'# !"$ '<<&#$ &&$ ?' "%$ '<# #% ( $'%'$& #$'%F +20956!'81>4P*0660"89/G8
(!## !"$ $ #$'< = MB #!#$ $ ''$$'! ' =$'<' #&'# '# ;'B'> 26K8 '' '# ?("!##'$!>$'#%'%''$&!'$D$#&$#'&@06(9/0<#8
"#!<'!$$!, !'##'$&%&@29<#85106668*# > (A!#'# !# ($#"#' // A# "# ' ! '# #'$ ! &$& 35(113 <#8 !'$ 2-(0.9 <#8 "!# '7$"8 !"#$A'<<#%'#;'B'>%'%''$&06(9/0<#8 '(%:# '' ? #!#$ >'#'$ "#$ B' $'%'$& "$& "##""!#$@!"!'"#&&$8
# !&?$ ' , ' #$'# ? #!#$ "#&$ '?$ '%''$&5K&B "!#$B?'$'<<'$"!#!%#'##!'$
4002540661 72/4217 @ #$8 "#$'# 2# =%'# 066/ #!#$ #'$ : !# " "#&$#@$$"#$$'!8
2.8 (> ( '%''$& ($'%'$& #$'% "$ ! " >&&<''###&"$$'!"#!<'!8##!)$ '"' !#$ $#"#' $ <<'$ "!# ;## $'%'$& '" $ #&"&$'$'% !#$?$#(#'$$!$<W!"&$&=$'<'& (":8
258 % ?' "#&: #!# # "#$'$ '8 #!#$ # ' >&&<' ( '7#$ =?( 32 &># 0663 $ &''! $$?&!<'#&"!##"8
2-8 #!#$!>$$$#:"#$'$B' ',''!## ''$&166<#8@$'$#&"8
- ) () (() ( )
!
.,/0/++ 1 2// / 34 $5# ) 6
0/+
28 &##!##%>8
! 0/
08 ($"#$'$8
38 &''! 03 ' 0661 ('$'& ?(' #<& #!'$ #!#$@'7#$('%''$&$#2#'$32&>#06638
/8 $#!''7#$@#!#$2#'32&>#06638
18 !<'#&''!$$?&"!##"8
98 ! ('$'& @ ",# @ #!#$ ''$& 166 <#8 @ $'$# &"8
.8 <!# "#$' ?Q "%$ <!## #!# !$# "#&$ ##D$ &' 36 =!# : !$'<'$'! "# "' #!& #&
4002540661 7214217 #'> <&&# # *A\'L#A!<?' 9 966/ $#!' ;"'#8 &' "$ D$# "#!!B&8 &!'# !'$J G ''?# ;$$?&''!#!#$&'#!>$'#'$"&''! $$?&P >G ;"!# "!# ? !$'< ' $' "!%!'# # $$ $# &''!P G "!#$# 'B$# ! ! #"#&$$8 *' &!'# !$'$ " $#!' &&$ &&#& ! $$# G >G $ G '7 #'><&&##"!##"$##$':###!#?Q' %#&##'##%>8&!'##!#$'!#!#!, "#% ?' #!$ =!'$ '' ? &''! $$?& $ Q%!"" ?&$&;"&'&#!#$F#$8230 269$265G8 B#<<':# "#&'$ S] U ,
!"'!<!#"#&$##D$$!$'<'&;"#$'''?Q@Q<<'<&&# #!'"#B#<<
4002540661