Contractual Damages Multiplier Appeal
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case concerns an appeal challenging the calculation of damages awarded to the appellant following a judgment concerning a contractual dispute, where the appellant argued the lower court failed to properly apply a specific statutory multiplier to the awarded base amount derived from the contract claim. The reviewing court affirmed the lower court's decision, reasoning that the statute mandating the multiplier was inapplicable because the underlying claim upon which the base damages were calculated was rooted in contract law, not in a tort or statutory violation that would trigger the application of the statutory penalty or treble damages provision cited by the appellant.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contractual Damages Multiplier Appeal: The reviewing court affirmed the lower court's decision, reasoning that the statute mandating the multiplier was inapplicable because the underlying claim upon which the base damages were calculated was rooted in contract law, not in a tort or statutory violation that would trigger the application of the statutory penalty or treble damages provision cited by the appellant.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court ordered the appellant to pay the costs of the federal court proceedings.
Testo completo
"#$%#"&''( )"%%'("&''(
)
) *)! * !*
*+, % - ., &''( !"###$% !&'&$($'&)(& &"&( *# &+&##*&,&- #.#(- /0&1*$#("## "(& / // - !#&(#"2$$&!#& #(#$ 3#245% -
!
-8.:-
/ 0 #2$ '&; , / <#-'&; ,#(#$=,>>##(#"8?"("0&8556@
,>$3&#&855?!"#*$%,#(#$"'#"'&#$+"&@
'& "&&#& 47 >$3&#& 855?! ,#(#$! "((( * ,#($&$ &$##( /#'#4Ⅼ!,#>"&$*,,>>##(#"(!'&((#" ,&0'3('A(&"&$3(+"(&!"#( ,';8?"("0&8556@
,#($&$! &'&$($ '& & +&##* & ,&- #.#(- /!!'&"&&#&?+#(8559&$%,#(#$!"#2$ *, ,$(#( B( &$ $# $2 (&"# "#! * "3&(& ,&$0(#(;"&&$(&"(#3(4&'(0&8556!(," "(&C,D0#((("@
47+#(8559!,#(#$$&$'(#""&&#&@
88'(0&8559!,#($&$(&3&""&&#&?+#(8559&($ #(("$,#(#$#"(#>#&$##"@*,##'&(#'"& >#&$##1+"&@
85 "("0& 8559! "3 '&( ,#(#$! ,#($&$ ## �$,&"&'"&$#+(#@
,#3#($ % $(&#&! ,#(#$ #>"&$ � *, $##" 3#( $($ &@
86"30&8559!&1'& �!"#*$"'# $##"! ($ 85 "30& 8559! 1 (& * ">#& * ,#($&$(>>##$'&;#-#;8?"("0&8556@
,#(#$"('&#&&+(&"&'"&$#+(#!"#$&( *$#%#'&(#'&,#($&$"(#(*,3&##(#3$# '"&&&$##"@*,,*"#*,#"#(2#*,3"#&(&@
&$'",#(#$$($(&#%,#($&$(2&$%+2&E
* 0 "# 23"# & F"&2#(#" +###& <= $($ "#>#$(#(#($!;4&"B(8556! �("&"#! "'"$ : +2! "( '&$#( ( 3#-'&$#(! : ''$( ( 49 +2 &<&(E4(E&(:9 =@
.6746.8559 -6.:- #(%F(#"F$(#"49+2&!'& �>$$& 8G+3#&855?< H465459=!& "#23"#"'($!46>$3&#&! #'"#(#"(&#("#&&2('&((( �("&"# #$2& & % (&"# +2 (#(#&! ! F((( F$(#" "31+2&@
">"&$( % ,&(E :9 E 4 (E DE ? ! � (" &"#")(#(#*"(((#"'&$3%F&(E:9 "#&'&(#2$$&&"#(&"#9"("0&8555< =*# "(&(#3%"#>$$&&F&-#47&4II?< =@
"'$('"&+2&F';(##$(0#@
F&(E8IE4 (E-*#$$%,&(E?E4 (E'#4&+3#&8555- #'"*("('&"&"#(!'&"$&+###&"##(&(#3!% *"#((&#($$*#(0((+2$$#&#"0@*,%,#(& ,&(E 9 '&E 4 J - *# ,">>&! % ( $2&! ' '&"((#" ' $( < 4IG7'E68:"#E8=-!((#'"#(#""&'&##'$$&#($!(&( #( '&"D#0 &(& #+(#>#$ % ((&@ * ,("&#($ 3#" (( 2&(# "(#((#""&*,&'$##"*,###"0'&& $#'&&#('&"#"$#*(&,>>#&##*("((& #&"( >"( ''&)(& " &#"0 < H 48I ?49 "#E 4! 489 8?I "#E ?! 48? 46I! 44I 4! 44G 44G "#E 6! 4IG "#E 4@ 3"#& # . .J ! &"#( "(#((#" #! 3"E ! &"#( >"(1!'E:I?E"48??E=@
,1(&,&(E?IE4 !,&&"#(&&'&$&#($##"*# '"&(( & '&((#"! &$ " #+"(#" #'"&(( " 3 * ,#($&$ ,( ' ,"&@ * # &*$&( & 3� #($&A( #2 ,A(&'&"($2$!,&&&$##""(((#"<&(E?IE8 =@* '&((#"!&$(#+"(#"*#"('3#$'&,&(E?IE4'3(A(& (&#($"'&"$&#'#>#$@,#($&$'('(1#2&*,$##" "#(&<&(E:4E4(8 =@*$##"'3(A(&((*$ (&( +"& '& 3"# ,"''"#(#" '&; ,&& *# & <&(E :8 E 4 = ( $##" & "''"#(#" '3( >#& ,"0+( , &"& 3( (�("&"'$((<&(E:9E4&(#"3&(E:GE4 (:7E4 =@*,%"(&*$##"&"''"#(#""#3(A(&& $#''&"'&#$!"#3(A(&"(#3$(##*&3"#&"&<&(E:8E8 =@
" ,&(E :9 E 8 ! &"& '( # A(& >"&$ "&* ,&&! 2&$,#($&$!&'$##""$##"&"''"#(#"@ *!&>((&"&(&%((&"(#((,"0+(#(#2
.6746.8559 -?.:- "#(�&("&"#(""0#2(#"&"#(>"! &*,#($&$$1'&$(%,&&'&""&< H " '0#$86"("0&8556687.56(::.56=@*,'&"$&>$$& 0$*( <&(E 98 E 4 =! ,"0+( #(#2 ( $2( ##($ &> ((& " &(& % ((& ,&&! % ,1#" &"#( " "0#2(#" &"#(>"@
,&(E96E9"#&'&"$&##(&(#3< =!(&$3#2&84 +3#&855:!'&$#*,K L'&(#'(&"&#&("((''"&$#+(#"&(&"+(#>#$# ,("&#($"&$"'#(&'#(%#&'&$3% ,&(E?E?L@ #(#2'"&(&'"#(3"#&#,#(#$"#""$#+(# &('$##"'#?+#(8559!"&*,$($"$ >#&88'(0&8559@
>"& ( ("(>"# "((& * ,#(#$ "(#>#$ 85 "30& 8559 $##"%,&$@
&"&'"&$#+(#(##3"0+(E
.6746.8559 -:.:-
* 1!)2 ) *)! * !*
3. / ,, 4 5 6 7 %(& !8
/ ,
4E $&&"&'"&$#+(#&30E
/
8E &($##"&'&,#(#$85"30&8559E
6E #(*&"&(3"0+(E
?E #(*'&"$&(2&(#(E 2&>>#;& &$#(K &#-"# M "&#N
"'#">"&'&$(&&A(("(#>#$1'&(#'&2&>>
.6746.8559