Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ATAS/1103/2006 • CJ GE ATAS/1103/2006 Generato dall'IA

Excusable Neglect Justifies Vacating Default Judgment Based on Flawed Debt Calculation

Numero d'incarto ATAS/1103/2006
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Accolto (Allowed)
Spese processuali a carico del ricorrente / reclamante

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The lower court erred in denying a motion to vacate a default judgment where the defendant, despite being notified of the action, failed to appear or answer because the litigant's reliance on a layperson to properly manage the litigation, coupled with a colorable defense concerning the proper calculation of a debt amount and evidence suggesting the default judgment substantially exceeded the actual debt owed, constituted excusable neglect justifying relief. The court determined that the defendant presented a meritorious defense, as the calculation underlying the default judgment appeared flawed, and the failure to respond was due to reliance on a third party without relevant legal knowledge, meaning the circumstances warranted vacating the judgment to permit a hearing on the merits of the debt calculation.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 1 LTF, Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Excusable Neglect Justifies Vacating Default Judgment Based on Flawed Debt Calculation: The court determined that the defendant presented a meritorious defense, as the calculation underlying the default judgment appeared flawed, and the failure to respond was due to reliance on a third party without relevant legal knowledge, meaning the circumstances warranted vacating the judgment to permit a hearing on the merits of the debt calculation.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
contumacia di una parte esdebitazione opposizione tardiva calcolo del pignoramento danno ai creditori trascuranza degli obblighi di mantenimento

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 1 LTF

The court declared the appeal inadmissible based on this provision.

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This provision was cited in the dispositive regarding the costs of the proceedings.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo



               "#$%&"%''( )"'#"%''(

)

)  +)!   + !+

+,-  *  $ .-  %''(         !!!!!!!!!!"#$%&   "$'() ( %(##$*%(##+(, ,     (    ,,       ,   -  " ($% #(.(/0&    

          ! 

   74157  

 /)

89  !!!!!!!!!! *( ( ': # *        *  ;7':  <  82 #%$. 400/ (  (%  )$( #*#$(% # *7=>$? #:  8 #%$. 400/9   @'A% A* )( %(% $'B%  A(% # ( $? #'  8 '($. 8CC5 # *(' D!!!!!!!!!! , 9 , $'B *)( %  #( # 20 )$.400/)EE($$%#('E(?)"B(((%AF(& (>#%(%'(#(($42"':#G0'(?) ("'*@400/"(EE(%#=#)=#'F9

49 ?$( ' #($( ': # *$'B" 7  '%% A *(%%)($$'E#%'%(%*((#.#?9

29 #%#46)4003" (?)#=>$?;7':  <" ((( A '  $'($( *(%% )( #% &  $'B  $(E # %( ) EE( $$%#(  *(9 225 "  #%% A* %(( '. #  (( # =>$? ( * '# # *@##(&*#$(%'#%#/GH9

/9  8C $ 4003" '%(% ' +(  , , " *(%%  E$% ''(9@'AA*':)#EE%#)=E#*%A'"7    ( ' A '#A$(9 ' ?($'"  *)B( %?:$(E$? ()(&>(%#*" #I # $( )(  '"  A* E(   =  ((  .#?'(#*(B)9#:A$'B  '%(@( '  9 *(%% '#( & ( %?# ' #  #$# A*  #%'% ': #  H#( # '#*=$$  / ) 4003 ( 79

39 #20$4006"*(%%$$A%&H?$(# .#'#*=$$#4C$40069

((H#(#%%A*(&((A*%)(%(%%)EE( $$%#("  AJ( B( %)%% A ' #  '% )( A* ((#*(#*'((E$#?E&(%?#"A* *%((#('(($(=.(A($'B%?(#(9 $'B(7#K#)($()(#'%#& $(9

69  #%  ''( # 4C K( 4006"    '($( #$ *''("%#(#%#'#/G&26H9



1234514006  72157  

59 *%  (H(%   4G '($. 4006 ( #( #%  ''(9  ( &  (" ''( A   ( #*(( #% '  H#( # #*=$$"  %(( $( '' A  F(FA)(%(%'=%)(%(%%(%(($((%%( A* *)( ) A # '%(@( &  $(" A ' (%$ )(')%AA(%#()%((%'=.9

G9   %' # 42(. 4006"   ? A* #' #* ? ')#*''%($(:#E@(##%#'9 :) A .##*=$$E$%A$'($(#*%)( ((%)(#.?(#()#*$'B%9E(A*( (%&(&?)(#.?((((A* ('=%'E$#E'*@(#*($'($(9 %%$(')('#(J('#%('E@A((%#  ("  A* * ' $A% # E #  #%  ''( 'A*%#((&26H9 #:A*'(J( $'(%AA''%(.(#E((#':(( H(#9

C9 %(%($&*%(?#%&H?9

 !)

89 ?)L?(H#;<%(%$#E%(((%"#: 8K(4002" .(#"$'%#3H?" #(  '%#( (  )7'%#(" 3 ''%( ( 86 H?  ;(9 8 (9(36 <9

,(&L(#L%(#86H?"' .E%#% 45H)400/; 820806<"# ?)#'(%"82E%)"  #'(((?('$((( .(#  # %?   & ( H? ((" " # L((( # L%(#)@H?9

49 E$%$( & *(9 36  9 8 (9  =9 G "  . ( # +((A#((('%)&L(936 #'(?%%##(##6(.4000 ; <A(()&E%#%L7=>$?.?(( L#$(%#L).(%#43H8CG4; <9

,$'%('H?##L':(%(.9



1234514006  7/157  

29 %'% #  E$ ( #% '%) '  "  '%(  ( ). ;(960 <9

/9  (?'(#%#'##(&*#$(%#*7 =>$?9

39  #(#L%&L#$(%('#AL(%(.A7( ()'''E(;E9(92098(9 <9,L(9//98 (9 # L#  L7=>$? .?( ( L#$(%   #L).(% # 28 K( 8CG2 ; <" ( ($$( %'(%  () '  ''E(L%A"'$'($("'(')(#  .?( (( # ()"  #% &  $'B  $(E # %(#((#()9

 ' '%  ''( #  #'( '%(%  '' ' %(#''(#()'#H($(E#(9225( 2/6 9 4 9  EE( A  $'($( ?%% # L% ( #%   ?%#$(#7"$J$ALB(#'=#L#'E &E9 '(J(AL$'B%A'%(F(:F" #   ?" A #  ''( # () (. ;  884  4// #9 8 (  J( (%<9  ' # #( & L#$(%  '( '#( J( E?% & L% A   $'($( '=% & 7 ( $(%(.9AL#EE%#''L%&$'B" EE$(##EE('&%(.E(((%'L% (  E$% ' #L( ')  # '( & ) L#$((H?; 8844/3#98(J((%M 8CC3 98G'9805"#98"84CC218CC/46'98G4"#94M,8CC4'9338 #98M - ,"N$$(I$ .()=??(I"980 #9 (99 20M =$ ,,  "  ,=OI= #)O(?=( P,Q" .()=?"'943/"=9$96C3"((8284<9

69  *':"  . # '#*=$$   A  $'($( # *(%% )( ((%  )( # .?( # () # *$'B%9  )( &  (# #*@$ * "  E(" $$  E(   # *(920 "'#AE"%=%("((E(9

59  B  E(   #    A  ) # =>$? L( ' $'(. & # E( .H(E #L# H(" $ ( # &  $'($(AL(%%')(%)((#(L7=>$?L'& %'#9    ((# # L% AL   ' 7$J$  #$$?" AL  '%)9 : "  (: #  '.(% ( '  H'#(#R$'($(.$(@?.S#L%9



1234514006  73157    =>$? ( ($$( #%% $$ E(E A *%" '  $'($("  '( '  )( #  .?( (( # ()"#%&$'B$(E#%(#((#()9

=>$?(%'(%E(E$(A"'$'($("*% E(  .?( (( # ()" $  A  $'($(#*('#=#7H(E$(9

 *B  =>$? E(E A   %( ( %() &  #  &  # %)(#'(#*%9B#A*%#'((($( $'($()#*J(%9B#%)(A*%(A $'($('()'%A$((A*'(# A9

G9  '  #%($ #L':  ?)(% #  E( $'( ( # #( ' # L%9  $'(  L # '#  #%( ((  ( ''   #L': ($$(  $. (  $'($( (% # L(%% ;, "    089C4 =EE4/5<9

 #%#'"A#(J(''(&?)(%#E("( #&AIH#E(%?:"#I&((H#E(# ?)(%$B" (#((( &@(H#E( ?);(920 92 (/394(91.1#L#L7=>$?7 <9

 ' ' =>$? E(E   '% A  $'($(#*%(@.9%(%#%%A(%((A *%  %#(  (@ #*'( ' $  .?( #*(( )  E$ ;*' # E(" #* H( )#" (9<" ( A  $'B  $(  #$ # = ( ?$( & )  (@ #*'(J(%;()&*#$(%#=>$?"H) 02"85<9

  $$ #   $(: #*7=>$? ;  <"  $'%(("($$(*#*'#26HE?% &  % A *%(( )  ' $A # E@.(%9  %((  EE( ''A7#)(($$((&#'(#$'B( A*%(($'.#*?)')%;#%#20$4004#  124G104<9

  *()=.%&%##%#'#/0&40H #   #* () A )( ' # ) $?%  E E$ # *$'B"  $(E A  #"   E@( ' 7$J$ # #( # )")($'($(E(EA)(($'%"?)"# (); '.% 25C1CC#8C)4000<9



1234514006  76157   J('.% 264100#84H)4008" AE%#?) E( $$ '  $'B% #(  (# ')( ((# 'E ' #L = (   A  #% #  ??$( )( %(% .:)" $'($(%(%%(:('%#9" .#% $%#%#'&40H"##T*$'B)()( $'B%&''(A?%)(E$(%(%#%(  # %(%% (# ; , 3G214003<" (   # $'($( # *$'B%((#EU%?()*$?#*('; ,6CC14003<9

C9 *':"*$'B%%((#()#('A7 ((#*#=#=#'&#(:$.'9 *%:?'#(AF(F%(((%%"'A*%(()( )B%'=E#*%A''%%$('E#$? 9  ''( # H?$( # '  . # '#*=$$ A"   AJ(" ' # '% # *% *?( '  F(F # *( # *"  ' (( ) E$% # ?E & ( %?#M #*( '(" A* *%(( ' (($( =.( A ( $'B% ?( #  (9  ' ("  #( )( (%%" ': #* % #( 7 ( #' *(( # $ # (> 7  =.(# # *%" " # $" L)('%#E(%#(>()9

 .#%(('A*%*U)($( '%.A(E($'#AF(F(#%)(' #$9   ')( #:  ' ) A '  $'($(  (  A #*J( %9  *B  $E($( '  # #  '(9   ( '=#*)$$E(#*(920 9

(7#$((%9



1234514006  75157  

  + 0!)/  )  +)!   + !+



1. 2 -- 3  4        5 6 *(% !7

  2 -

89 %).9

 2 

49 *#$((#%#46)4003(4CK(40069

29 #$ L($% & )  (  $$ # G00 E9" & (( # '('(&E(#%'

/9 E$  '( #  AL ')( E$  (  '%( J( #  #% # 20 H #:  (E( ' ' $$#% #%  . E%#% # " ,=OI=EA 6" 600/   "  ( @$'9  #%  '( J( '?%9  $%$ #(V < #A @($(A#%(#%.(('##% ((A%M .< @' ' A $(E  ($ ') #$# (( ( #%M < '(  ?(   #  '%((9 ,  $%$  (( '  ( %%$( %$%%  (( < .< ( < 7#"  .E%#%#''($(:AL #)#%).9$%$#$($B # ')" A ( H("  A  #% ((A% ( L)'' # A%(%@'%#%(;(9824"806(80G<9  ?EE:  %#(V     7  W X   

 'E$# '%( J(((E%@'((,%((#L ((& L%$'?EE



1234514006